Adam Voges went from captaining the Perth Scorchers to coaching them in the space of a season.
It was an odd – and perhaps an absent-minded – move by the Scorchers hierarchy. There’s no doubting Voges’ pedigree. He was an elite cricketer and leader. And he’s been part of the furniture in Western Australian cricket for more than 15 years.
But coaching? Voges had no experience as a coach – let alone as a senior coach – prior to his appointment as Justin Langer’s replacement.
Curious indeed.
So, what have the Scorchers lost?
Batting strength and depth, in a nutshell.
Shaun Marsh will pull on the Melbourne Renegades colours after the east coast club offered him a three-year contract. The financial security proved too enticing for the 36-year-old, who was offered a single-year deal by his home club.
Hilton Cartwright is shipping off to the Melbourne Stars. Although not a prolific scorer, he was a stable presence in the Scorchers’ middle order. Also, he offered a great pair of hands, handy medium-pacers and the ability to lead.
Cartwright feels his development has stunted in Perth and he’s keen to link up with current and ex-WA players.
“I’ve heard great things about the club’s environment from past and present players, including Michael Beer and Marcus Stoinis, and already know a few of the other guys through various teams I’ve been involved with,” Cartwright said.
The Zimbabwean-born Cartwright will be joined at the Stars by a known talent in Nathan Coulter-Nile, as well unknown entities in Lance Morris and Clint Hinchliffe.
The dynamic Coulter-Nile adds firepower with both bat – he scored 92 in the recent World Cup against the West Indies – and ball.
Morris has been dubbed the Wild Thing, such are his similarities in pace and bowling style to the ex-South Australian speedster Shaun Tait. And Hinchliffe is a left-arm leg-spinning all-rounder who debuted for the Scorchers last season.
These are the outs for the Perth-based franchise. What about the ins?
(Photo: Will Russell/CA/Getty Images)
Fawad Ahmed spins into the squad to complement an already potent bowling line-up. Ahmed, from the Sydney Thunder, joins fellow spinner Ashton Agar as well as a strong pace line-up led by Jason Behrendorff, Jhye Richardson and AJ Tye.
And the batting?
Cameron White was discussed as a good fit. But the Adelaide Strikers have since got their hands on him.
The only other link is South African captain Faf du Plessis.
Does Voges hope to rely (again) on homegrown talent to bring success back to the Perth Scorchers, in spite of the recent coup?
This could prove a risky ploy. The Scorchers’ batting depth is dangerously thin and will rely heavily on captain Mitchell Marsh and his deputy Ashton Turner.
Are the Scorchers finding it difficult to recruit?
Cartwright mentioned that he’s looking forward to the environment at the Melbourne Stars.
What about the environment in Perth? Is it stale? Or lacking in expertise?
The Scorchers will be hoping for a change in fortunes this season after collecting their first wooden spoon last season.
Silverware is what the fans in the West have grown used to, not woodwork.
James
Roar Rookie
Coulter Nile and S Marsh are nearing the end of their careers and looking for a payday. Hilton Cartwright is playing ordinary cricket and needs a change. Perhaps he saw what Maddinson did when he moved to Victoria! Don't know the youngsters.
Simoc
Guest
Seems the Scorchers have offloaded the deadwood. Plenty of time to bring in a match-winning batsman like Gayle, Azam, Stokes, Bairstow or someone that the Bangladesh big spenders don't want.
Rob
Guest
Don't think they've really lost anyone that big. Their bowling is stacked so losing NCN isn't a major issue. Turner and Mitch Marsh are their two best batsman so as long as they hold onto them they will be able to build a good batting unit around them. Especially if they sign ball tampering Faf.
Insult_2_Injury
Roar Rookie
Stoinis been recruiting?
Gee
Roar Rookie
Cartwright going is no loss, I can't understand why the Stars wanted the plodder.
Peter Warrington
Guest
gmaxi32 is a big magnet
Bunney
Roar Rookie
I too believe it was risky putting Voges into coaching straight from captaining the side, but seeing who they are losing, I don't think it's cause for panic. NCN is overrated - he is a great fielder, and can occasionally hit a few late 6's, but he has no change-ups with his bowling - a T20 necessity. Is expensive and has lost his primary weapon - pace. SMarsh is 36 and very injury prone. At his best, a great T20 batsman, but not worth more than a 1yr contract. Bravo Scorchers for standing firm. Cartwright had a great first 1.5 Shield seasons but has done nothing since, especially in T20's... his loss is not worth crying over. And two relative unknowns have left - none of this points to poor coaching from Voges. One has to remember that last year was a stinker for the Scorchers, so they're not exactly breaking up a winning unit. Voges got off to a poor start last season, but I'll wait to see what happens this season before judging his coaching ability.
AREH
Roar Guru
Odd how so many have already diverted to the Stars specifically. Particularly concerning as the Scorchers have been long regarded as a close unit, keeping the same core group together through successes.