The Newcastle talking points following the big gamble of Adam O'Brien

By The King of the World / Roar Guru

With all 2020 pre-season drawing near, a lot of questions are being asked about the Newcastle Knights and whether or not they can crack the eight. Don’t write them off yet.

Many say the Knights took a big gamble signing Adam O’Brien – I’m 50/50 here. He may have no first grade coaching experience, but he came from the two best systems in the game with a wealth of knowledge from arguably the two best coaches of the modern age. Here are a few things to think about.

The challenge
An unproven first grade coach is challenged to push the Knights into the finals. What I like about it is he chose to take it on, whereas he could have easily said no. The knowledge he gained can pay off for the Knights and whether or not it does next year, it will given due time. It wouldn’t be the first time Knights gambled big time – they hired Nathan Brown to rebuild the club and history tells that tale.

The leadership
Leadership is one of the most important things needed to any team of any sport. Mitchell Pearce is the captain, and you have other leaders such as David Klemmer, Tim Glasby, Mitchell Barnett, Lachlan Fitzgibbon and Sione Mata’utia. As leaders, they need to lay the law with the players for both their on and off field behaviours.

(Photo by Ashley Feder/Getty Images)

The players
The players need to put pride and hard work into the effort they show on the field – if they lose any games, I’d prefer they take it down the wire. We suffered record losses to the Titans, Roosters, Tigers and Panthers. We shot ourselves in the foot too many times against the Titans, but at least we returned serve on Old Boys Day.

The fans
This is to my fellow Knights fans – give O’Brien a chance to prove himself. He’s got three years to give us the finals berth we have been missing since 2013. I know it’s hard to be patient but that’s what we have to be. I don’t know how it will go next year but the action of our players will tell the story. Let’s just do what we always do and show up in massive numbers to cheer our team on.

The consistency
Having ten different spines sadly was unfortunate. So that means that ten different combinations had to be made and with so much adjustments, no wonder why our season turned sour. From winning seven of our first 12 – including a six match winning streak – to winning just three of our last 12 is pathetic. That loss to the Tigers in which it was finals or bust really was a shocker – it was like our players were physically there but mentally on the bus, and the same goes for our loss to Penrith two weeks later.

Next year, what I can predict is a different story to this year. With Jayden Brailey coming to Newcastle, we can consistently have a dummy half. The five-eighth spot is a bit of a battle and I know some are talking about those to hire, but why? We have decent players who can own that spot. Connor Watson with his top running and passing game, Kurt Mann with arguably the best torpedo in the game and gun junior Phoenix Crossland with his good kicking game – plus the speed to outrun Road Runner – are all potential options.

The early stages of next season will be important, but the final stages when the finals draws closer are when the stage is set. Remember – you don’t win premierships in May.

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2019-10-27T06:21:32+00:00

The King of the World

Roar Guru


157 ????????????????

2019-10-27T03:01:55+00:00

Zavjalova

Roar Rookie


Knights will finish 10th next year. 9th in 2021. Maybe finals in 2022. 147 more articles from Adrian telling us the Knights can turn it around.

2019-10-20T22:05:09+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


Did they have a top 4 lineup? That gets bandied about so often it's close to meaningless, feels like the Newtown Jets have top 4 NRL line up.

2019-10-20T22:03:18+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


I'd say fit is important too with regards to culture of the club, age/development of players, current roster capabilities, and boardroom strategy.

2019-10-16T03:03:08+00:00

paulie

Guest


I think anyone considered for a NRL coaching job can obviously coach. It all seems to come down to man management. Which until put in that position you will never know.

2019-10-16T01:56:50+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


hi Adrian, You've made a number of interesting comments. First of all, you suggested O'Brien could have knocked back the offer to coach the Knights. There's no way he would have done that, unless they made an insulting offer for his services. There's not a coach in the game who doesn't want to have a crack at first grade and O'Brien now has the chance to show what he can do. A key issue is the squad he inherited from Brown. It may take him the full 3 years to get the squad HE thinks can make the finals. On paper he has plenty of guys who should be able to get the team into the 8 this year, but again, the Knights may need to shop around for a season or two, until they get the right combination, similar to what Ricky's done in Canberra over the past 2 or 3 years. You suggest the side has plenty of leaders but I'm not so sure the side does. Klemmer leads by example and is a great role model for the side with his work ethic and energy but I question whether he's an onfield leader. Ponga & Pearce can both be great at what they do, but can equally go MIA when the pressure's on, which is the last thing you want from a leader. IMO, the two best leaders in the NRL at present are Hodgson and Cam Smith. Interestingly, both play at dummy half so can control the game to a large degree, but both have a real presence which demands others in their respective sides to listen to them. This is the sort of leadership the Knights need and a top notch dummy half might go a long way to fixing your spine issues. I hope O'Brien is given a real chance to show what he can do and isn't shown the door if the Knights don't immediately challenge for a top 8 spot in 2020.

AUTHOR

2019-10-16T00:19:42+00:00

The King of the World

Roar Guru


I understand what you mean but Wayne Bennett (alongside Don Furner) was co-coach of Canberra in 1987, in which they fell 18-8 against Manly in the grand final. Sometimes the coaches with the right mindset and the right team will make the difference. Newcastle in 2019 had a top four lineup but not the mindset. Nathan Brown wasn’t a bad coach but he was aiming to be everyone’s friend. That’s not a bad thing but your boss is your boss before being your friend. Coaches like Michael Hagan in 2001 and Trent Robinson had the squad that could get the job done. Granted, Andrew Johns pretty much coached Newcastle in 2001.

2019-10-15T20:43:25+00:00

Forty Twenty

Roar Rookie


I don't subscribe to the big gamble tag that's tossed around whenever a club signs a coach with no NRL experience. Bellamy, Robinson ,Hasler , Green , Maguire, Flannagan , Ricky Stuart , Bennett and Hagan among others were devoid of NRL experience when they were signed and all won titles at the 1st club they signed with. The greater gamble seems to come from signing an experienced coach. If The Eels can finish well up the ladder after finishing last then so can any other team. The comp is as open as it's ever been and a great chance for a playing group to get going over the next couple of years without running in to Smith, Cronk and co at the pointy end of the season.

Read more at The Roar