Blake Austin playing for England is a disgrace

By Tim Gore / Expert

The idea of Parramatta born and western suburbs-bred Blake Austin representing England devalues and disrespects the jersey.

It is wrong, plain and simple.

Austin isn’t English and he shouldn’t be playing for England.

There are plenty of good players from England, players who dream of representing their country, who Wayne Bennett should have picked instead.

I myself am a tri-national. Born in Australia to a New Yorker mother and a Lancastrian father, I have citizenship of all three nations. While I am very proud of my heritage and my citizenship of Great Britain and the United States of America, this country is my home.

While I can, have and will again sing both God save the Queen and The Star Spangled Banner (although I really prefer Jerusalem and America the Beautiful) with pride, it is when I sing our ridiculous anthem – even with its girts and unused verses – that I know where my heart truly belongs.

This is not an unfamiliar story for the multitudes of Australians who still have passion and allegiance for the nations their heritage derives from.

Whether Mediterranean, Scandinavian, south east Asian, Balkan, Baltic, etc, there are multitudes of us who have strong links to their heritage. However, for the most part, it is their allegiance to this nation that is paramount.

There is no question that I support English and USA national teams when they compete. I have been known to stay up to stupid hours to do so. However, when they play Australia I always want the Australian teams to win. Always.

If I had been gifted with any sporting ability whatsoever, it would be my dream to wear the Green and Gold. I wouldn’t dream of robbing an Englishman or American of a chance to represent their nation by taking their jersey.

You know who your mob are. You know where you belong. You know what feels right. You just do.

You can’t fake pride for a jersey. You can’t fake pride for a nation.

You shouldn’t try. You shouldn’t have to. It should be involuntary.

When the Viet Minh communist revolutionaries had the French Far East Expeditionary Corps besieged at Dien Bien Phu in 1954, one of the ways they tried to get the defenders to surrender was by playing La Marseillaise (the French National Anthem).

While many of the French soldiers openly wept at the sound, it did not encourage them to surrender at that point (they eventually did). It did the reverse. It encouraged them to dig in and fight harder.

I can’t imagine Blake Austin will either swell with pride of tear up when he hears God Save the Queen. I can’t imagine it will spur him to greater efforts.

Blake Austin during his time with the Raiders. (AAP Image/Dan Himbrechts)

Napoleon Bonaparte remarked something along the lines that a man will not lay down his life for any amount of gold, but he’ll do it willingly for a piece of ribbon.

Real, passionate allegiance is that ribbon.

Former English rugby league international Gary Schofield is disgusted by Austin’s selection:

“I don’t want Australians in the dressing room… He’s Australian … I want GB to be full of British lads, as simple as that.”

You’ve got to wonder how many of the English team agree with Schofield’s sentiments too – and whether it will impact the mood and morale.

I’ve talked to Raiders co-captain Josh Hodgson before about his national allegiances now that he’s settled in Canberra. When I enquired if he would ever consider donning the Green and Gold, he was unequivocal: he was, is and will always be an Englishman.

He looked quite disturbed when I raised the concept that his son George – who at the age of three can already punt a ball better than kids aged ten – would be eligible to play for Australia and might choose to.

Hodgson is a fiercely proud Englishman. As are Elliott Whitehead, John Bateman and Ryan Sutton. They dream of representing their national side, wearing the jersey, belting out the anthem and then showing their opponents just how tough the English are.

Blake Austin was born in Parramatta and raised in Sydney’s Western Suburbs. The image the world has of ‘peak Australia’ may be Bondi Beach, or the Red Centre, or the outback, or the Great Barrier Reef, or even Sydney Harbour. However, peak Australia is Sydney’s west. It is the biggest concentration of people in Australia. It is what most of us are.

Blake Austin is peak Australia.

He is Australian to his core. From his Doonside and Mount Druitt roots, to his sleeve tatts and goatee, to his coaching of the uncoachable Doonside Roos, to his appearance on The Footy Show as a kid to playing for the Australian Schoolboys In 2009.

Yet this weekend he will return to Western Sydney and represent another nation.

How can that possibly be right?

It is the same type of rubbish eligibility rules that saw Semi Radradra able to represent Australia that will allow Austin to play for England.

However, it is not just wrong that he has been selected. It is wrong that he accepted the selection.

When Austin played for the Raiders we found him to be a lovely bloke. We liked him. We like him still. But I don’t like that he’s doing this.

Blake Austin.
(Photo: NRL images)

A national team is no place for mercenaries. The whole point is for people to represent their nation, their people. That pride and passion can unite the players to lift to new levels of effort and achievement.

This is not like during World Cups where minnow nations are necessarily boosted by players with tenuous connections. England is not a minnow nation. However, this selection disrespects them like they are.

The very idea of “Queenslander” being yelled by anyone else is outrageous.

Wayne Bennett is a proud Queenslander and he should know that better than most. The guy who wrote Don’t Die With the Music in You” is the master of motivating players to get the best out of them. He would know to his core the value of passionate allegiance in getting the very best out of players.

How can he possibly hope to fabricate that passionate allegiance with Austin?

How can Bennett see it as acceptable to select players who don’t hold England as their primary and passionate allegiance? How can Austin possibly try to justify linking arms with his teammate s for the anthem? Will his teammate s even want him to try?

Even if Austin does brilliantly and England wins the competition, the selection will still not be proved right.

Blake Austin is an Australian. He is not an Englishman.

His selection demeans the jersey. It demeans the team. It demeans the competition.

The Crowd Says:

2019-10-22T07:17:52+00:00

qwetzen

Roar Rookie


Yes, 'we' know how the rort works Tim. The fact remains that, unlike sayyy Inglis, Clyde & Stuart *never* lived in the State that they were rorted into playing for.

AUTHOR

2019-10-22T04:43:23+00:00

Tim Gore

Expert


Well, while the ACT is not NSW, the CDRL is part of the NSWRL. So that's how those players qualify.

2019-10-21T13:57:51+00:00

Get Your Hand Off It

Guest


'This is not an unfamiliar story for the multitudes of Australians who still have passion and allegiance for the nations their heritage derives from. Whether Mediterranean, Scandinavian, south east Asian, Balkan, Baltic, etc, there are multitudes of us who have strong links to their heritage. However, for the most part, it is their allegiance to this nation that is paramount.' This is a ridiculous over-generalisation. It is their allegiance to this nation that is paramount?' From what data do you draw that conclusion? I work with immigrant populations and with the children of immigrants. Some, as you say, are very proud to be Australian and consider themselves to be Australian in every respect. Many others do not. I've worked with hundreds of young adults who have grown up here and lived here all their lives but who, if asked 'where are you from?' will tell you they come from elsewhere. I had a third generation Australian, who only spoke English, and who had two white grandparents, tell me last week that he was from the Philippines and wanted to go to live and work there when he finished University because he couldn't stand Australians, their culture, attitudes, and sport. The flipside is also true. I work with migrants who've only been here a year or two, who don't even have permanent residency and are struggling for work visas, who are passionately and ardently Australian. It is patently and obviously ridiculous to insist that the first category of immigrant constitutes a 'real Australian' - that they alone can represent this country with unfeigned passion and pride - and that the latter does not. Obviously, international competition requires eligibility laws, but complaining about their strictness on the basis that you have ('but he couldn't possibly feel English!') is to make uninformed assumptions about a stranger's personal feelings and motivations based on his upbringing.

2019-10-21T09:01:39+00:00

Terry Miles

Guest


The Melbourne born Mark Viduka? It's a Rugby League issue mate always will be

2019-10-21T07:47:42+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


Also you're just jealous because you don't even have a state, territory boy!

2019-10-21T07:46:57+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


Yep and it's bloody irrational. I enjoy the irrationality of it but also wont die in a ditch over the contrary.

2019-10-20T09:36:54+00:00

Superspud

Roar Rookie


Yeah you can but why is this more of a problem than David Pocock, Manus Laubasheine, Marika Korobeiti hell why not Kepler Wessels, Tony Greig and Graham Hick. Also something about Mark Viduka but can't remember exactly. Been happening for years in plenty of sports.

2019-10-20T09:24:58+00:00

Superspud

Roar Rookie


Yes you can but why are we picking on Blake Austin to make this point? David Pocock, Manus Laubasheign, Kepler Wessels, Tony Greig, Graham Hick. There are hundreds of examples and has been for years

AUTHOR

2019-10-20T08:43:48+00:00

Tim Gore

Expert


I can do whatever the hell I like dude.

2019-10-20T02:53:42+00:00

qwetzen

Roar Rookie


"Inglis = yes disgrace" And some think that ACT players pulling on blue jumpers in a *State* of Origin is a "disgraceful" rort...

2019-10-19T04:50:18+00:00

Chris

Guest


You can’t pick and choose when to get on your high horse about players playing for different countries when the wallabies, kangaroos, Socceroos all have many players in the same boat. Harry Souttar for example. Born in Scotland, he had never been to Australia before his selection for the Socceroos. His brother plays for Scotland. Did you write the same about him when he scored 2 goals on his debut last week??? You can’t have it both ways.

2019-10-19T03:01:59+00:00

Superspud

Roar Rookie


Sorry Tim you can't apply the national pride rule when it suits and saying it doesn't matter as much if your country isn't as good. It is not just a rugby league thing. The Japanese Rugby team have some distinctly non Japanese looking players. Even the mighty All Blacks are full of players who would identify themselves as something other than a New Zealander. In soccer Zhaka and Shikiri made an Albanian national jesture to Serbian fans which is bad enough but they were playing for Switzerland at the time. No outrage here about Blake Austin. Just disappointment that he is the best England have.

2019-10-19T00:42:07+00:00

RogerTA

Roar Rookie


Do you ever get tired of having to repeat yourself Tim? :shocked:

2019-10-19T00:40:58+00:00

RogerTA

Roar Rookie


Is that you “Steve”?

2019-10-19T00:39:11+00:00

RogerTA

Roar Rookie


Can we have a “thumbs down” button please editors?

2019-10-18T21:44:15+00:00

Meatpy Sausageraul

Roar Rookie


You do yourself no favours referring to anyone or anything as a ‘minnow’, Tim. Look it up. Gives the impression you see Tonga – and by default other nations of a similar standing – as insignificant. Pretty sure that’s not what you meant.

2019-10-18T21:41:37+00:00

Max

Guest


Happens in soccer, RU & Olympics all the time. Nobody whines about it. But if RL dares to do it, it is the worst thing in the world & a sham.

2019-10-18T20:47:02+00:00

Meatpy Sausageraul

Roar Rookie


As an Englishman I can’t say I’m thrilled that Austin is in the side ahead of some fine homegrown talent. The rules are a mess. But for an Australian to take issue with it is beyond funny when the Kangaroos – going back years – have, despite having an immense player pool of their own, been happy to select players who at least could have represented other nations before Australia. Curious too that you draw the line with Austin when Coote and Hastings are both in the Lions squad. It may not be the exact same but Josh Papalii, born in Auckland, is a current Kangaroo. Question the rules by all means but don’t dig out one bloke just because you think he’s not doing it for the right reasons, whatever they are.

AUTHOR

2019-10-18T15:00:14+00:00

Tim Gore

Expert


Minnow State

2019-10-18T13:07:34+00:00

Simoc

Guest


The name Austin is very English, so much in fact, that a car of about the writers vintage was named Austin. In Rugby League terms that more than satisfies playing for the country of choice.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar