Four hard truths for Australian rugby

By Rugby Geek / Roar Rookie

With the World Cup over for Australia, the men in gold are arriving home justifiably disheartened by their failed mission and the prospect of being known for falling short for the next four years.

Cruel and unkind judgement is something Aussie fans do way too well. Players end their career and coaches look for opportunities overseas. but the rugby juggernaut heads on for another four-year cycle.

Then we talk up our chances and spin doctors go into hyper-spin to get us all hooked again. And we do!

But what happens now? Who will be our coach? Who will be the next John Eales or Nick Farr-Jones? Do we have a Rod Macqueen out there to take the reins?

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

The press, fans, CEO and chairman all want a silver-bullet answer. Dave Rennie? Jordan Petaia? Some say yes, some say no. The press will use these topics to write articles and devoted fans will interact. Life goes on.

But we do need to drink from the cup of reality.

The fact is we are ranked where we are: outside the top five in lowly sixth place, a true reflection of our recent performances.

We have a rugby administration that’s made more than enough PR mistakes. They pretend, we pretend and the self-deceit of rugby in Australia goes on.

Senior-level competitions are chaotic, with a premier club going broke and not enough players, yet other clubs put 20 players in the stands each week without the prospect of getting more than a few games for the season.

Our young players have learnt to catch and pass but are being signed to NRL clubs who recognise their talent and will secure their code’s future with our players.

Suburban clubs are made to stay amateur, meaning anybody who wants to invest in their local rugby club’s on-field success cannot help players with a few bucks. Remember a first-grade suburban rugby league player can earn a $1000 per game. Then there are those clubs which have five Colts teams for a three-team competition and struggle to find a game for all of them to play.

Administrators are blocking, Clubs are manipulating and self-interest wins out.

Women’s interaction with the game is our glory moment. It’s been such a joy to watch the sport in Australia succeed in this new frontier.

But where do we go from here?

Let’s get into a truth session and look at ourselves.

(Cameron Spencer/Getty Images)

First truth: Rugby is a grassroots game
Wallabies success starts with kids. Get them inspired and coached well and give them a pathway that sees success for them as players. Teach them the catch, pass, run, kick and tackle skills needed. It’s not that hard; it’s just a focus thing. Ask any high school teacher. Build your base and watch the growth towards success.

Second truth: Administrators serve players, not the other way around
Why make rules that say ‘no’ when all you want is for them to succeed. Could Scott Fardy or a Will Skelton have made a difference this World Cup? We can only wonder. What did we gain by not even choosing to look at them?

Our administrators should focus on getting players to play. Have feeder club systems that make it easier for players to move up and down the ladder. Focus on players playing our game every weekend. It works for rugby league, why wouldn’t it work for us?

Add support to the system by reducing registration fees, supplying rugby kits to players and getting young players on sandwich contracts of education and playing.

Don’t use the cop-out of not enough money – get your sponsorship team onto the task. The association of corporate and public is the name of the game.

Oblige the pro players to have active roles developing and inspiring the young ones coming through. It’s about professionalism as a player – after all, we all work a 40-hour week, so they can as well.

Respect for people is earnt on the field of play and off the field in training and working with the base.

I was at the Hamilton 7s tournament and the Australia girls 7s team attended to mix with the players, run water and coach. Giving back, earning respect and not a dollar asked for – how good! I am so proud of our Aussie 7s girls.

Third truth: Secure young talent
Our base is not that large but it does okay for its size. What we can never afford is to lose talent to other codes. What we want are talented players from other codes to come to us. Rugby offers so much to young aspiring players; all we need to do is to get them into the system on small sandwich contracts at 15 to 16 years of age that has them study and move into premier rugby clubs for monitoring and coaching. It builds the sport. Let’s not lose the talent because we don’t have a spare $10,000

We have marquee players earning millions with secondary endorsements contracts and possibly only two years to play in their elite career. New talent with 15 years to play must be scooped up. Investment in youth always makes sense.

Fourth truth: Rugby is a young man’s game
We love the game, we play the game and we try to defy the game, but elite rugby has a short time frame during which you’re at your absolute best. That’s usually in the 20 to 34-year-old age range.
Australians love their heroes, and it’s great to show respect for the effort they put into the game. As Jordan Petaia showed great talent at this year’s World Cup one day, he too will have to face the prospect of being the Adam Ashley-Cooper of his day. It’s the natural cycle of things.

Coaches come and go, players come and go – it’s actually good to see. As long as they come and go in greater numbers, our prospects will hopefully come and stay.

Fingers crossed the next three months in Rugby Australia brings a halcyon era with sensible reform.

The Crowd Says:

2019-10-26T21:33:41+00:00

Craigo

Guest


Only in NSW.

2019-10-26T21:29:58+00:00

Craigo

Guest


Union people have been beating that dead horse that because RU is more international people will want to play it. Been hearing that for 30 years and RU keeps going backwards. You can travel playing league also. England, France, New Zealand and RL World Cups overseas also. It's not as big as Union but it's 100 time more international than AFL.

2019-10-26T14:24:56+00:00

Sanbacca

Guest


Given the total PR disasters that Clyne has presided over during his reign to make Rugby a laughing stock not to mention the waste of money re-branding for ARU to RA as a result of those PR disasters which could have been spent elsewhere his business acumen would have to be questionable at best. The buck stops with the chairman!

2019-10-25T10:23:23+00:00

Dave

Guest


Immediately cut the fat from the ARU machine. I once read a quote, "The ARU is the sheltered workshop for private school alumni." Paying suburban players is not the answer, all you do is create a large group of mercenary players. On an international level, bring back the ELVs, only penalties for offside and foul play. As is the case now, you should not ordinarily win an international or next tier down game by scoring less tries than your opposition.

2019-10-24T11:03:27+00:00

Dale Abbott

Guest


Qld Country Rugby is dead. I am an original Bowen Mudcrab player and our club has survived from the early 80’s. During this period we have been on our own. Harry Hockings was a junior here. 2019 we have no team, we have a stalwart committee, but no team.I totally agree with a top down clean out, we have always known it’s up to us as a country club and I do not complain about it, north of the Sunshine Coast forget it, oh throw in a second string reds player for a coaching clinic and Goodo, we are done with the hayseeds, but when even your prems clubs in the capitals is losing players and respect, it is totally wrong on the whole ARU administration. If you picked a team from the leading premier teams in Brisbane and Sydney this season they would have beaten some of the super teams.Why would you play union, when there is no respect for your national coach and admin, I believe the current australian players have been very gracious in their comments.

2019-10-24T09:30:59+00:00

Emery Ambrose

Roar Rookie


I just hope they can sort it out. Get a structure going that supports the game at all levels, not over spending at the top and leaving nothing for the mid tier. Somewhere for young ones to aspire too. Combo of twiggy and ARU would certainly be a starting point for finance.

2019-10-24T08:04:56+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


What’s Clyne’s self interest? What has he got out of it?

2019-10-24T08:01:07+00:00

Objective

Guest


Those ingredients you list are indeed important. But they mean little if they are overridden by incompetence, stubbornness and self interest - all of which Clyne has in spades.

2019-10-24T07:54:39+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


The point is about eligibility. The first part of point 2.

2019-10-24T07:51:43+00:00

Objective

Guest


I see. So the game is there for the administrators. If you really do work for RA as your comments lead/want us to believe, then you my friend embody the problem.

2019-10-24T06:55:58+00:00

Admiral Ackbar

Guest


Fifth truth: Andrew Forrest should be running Rugby Australia, not Cameron Clyne and Raelene Castle.

2019-10-24T06:46:37+00:00

AaronL

Roar Rookie


5. Coach 6. Our collective rugby brain

AUTHOR

2019-10-24T04:22:38+00:00

Rugby Geek

Roar Rookie


My son had a very similar experience.

2019-10-24T01:18:26+00:00

Max50

Roar Rookie


Wrong you are.. CAS/GPS rugby were very strong in the 90”s... 1996 at kings you had future wallabies like Julian Huxley and super rugby players eg Digby Beaumont.. Joeys had wallaby lock Al Campbell. And the competitions in the 90”s were fierce where all the schools each year had competitive sides and anyone could beat anyone on there day..

2019-10-24T00:49:28+00:00

MaxP

Roar Rookie


It seems that the lack of payment for players at club level may indeed be a cause for the disconnection in development pathways, and the reduction of our pro-ready base. The conditioning required for pros mean that we’ll never see another Steve Merrick plucked out of obscurity. I can only cite my own experience, where I finished school the first year rugby went professional. Some of my 1st XV team mates were identified and sent on a professional pathway with the Reds Academy. A few ended up Reds and Wallabies, while others carved out interesting professional rugby careers overseas. I didn’t get selected for this path, but continued as an amateur in clubs but ultimately had to give it in when work and life got in the road. I couldn’t devote enough time in the gym or on the training park to keep at the same standard as my former team mates. As a young bloke, though, I reckon some form of remuneration would have maintained the interest to work harder and play beyond my 20s. Likely I wouldn’t have gone on to higher levels, but I would have contributed to a better standard of club rugby, which in turn would have helped prepare more depth and bridge the gap

2019-10-24T00:23:48+00:00

Gus

Guest


Very well said now we also need for the State Rugby Associations to stop squabbling amongst themselves and also all push & focus in the right direction to get the whole of Rugby in Australia successful....

2019-10-23T22:30:33+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


That's not playing talent. That's participants. The decision to alienate a large portion of your available talent When you make that comment you start talking about the production of elite talent.

2019-10-23T22:27:35+00:00

robel

Roar Pro


My claim was the 3rd largest group of players, Piru quoted me correctly.

2019-10-23T21:27:10+00:00

Max50

Roar Rookie


Wrong

2019-10-23T21:26:35+00:00

Max50

Roar Rookie


But he opposes AAC selection he says he’s too old which is just plain wrong . And rugby is becoming an 18-40 sport at elite level

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar