England to have the edge over box-happy Boks

By Will Knight / Expert

That the Springboks have played in two World Cup finals and won both of them without scoring a try in either tells you a lot about South African rugby.

Pragmatic, no-frills, attritional. And unapologetic.

They’ve reached another final with a typically uncompromising style; it isn’t pretty to watch but they’ve muscled their way into the decider against England on Saturday night.

Michael Cheika isn’t a fan of the “kick and defend” strategy, but the former Wallabies coach’s unwillingness to adopt anything that resembles grinding rugby has resulted in him being back in Sydney and not in Yokohama for the final weekend of the tournament.

Yep, boring is the go in Japan in 2019 and the Boks do it best.

And there’s more chance of Eben Etzebeth taking the kick-off than Rassie Erasmus preparing his Springboks team to play any differently against England. Power in the pack and Faf de Klerk putting up box kick after box kick until they get a sniff inside England’s 40-metre area.

“It’s (the final) going to be another physical one,” summed up Handre Pollard.

How many times did South Africa and Wales kick the ball between them in general play in their semi-final? 81.

Incredible. Two sides hardly looking to take control of the game, but instead aiming not to lose it.

It was labelled by some as one of the dullest games in rugby history. Turgid was another way it was described.
South Africa’s traditional style is arguably perfectly suited for the pressures of tournament rugby; take few risks, pounce on any mistakes and pounce on the chance to kick penalty goals.

Erasmus won’t care about winning praise for playing pulsating rugby, just as his World Cup-winning predecessors.

Will Rassie be grinning at full time of the RWC final? (Photo by David Rogers/Getty Images)

In 1995, South Africa beat the All Blacks 15-12 in extra time in Johannesburg and in 2007 ground down England for a 15-6 victory in Paris.

It should be noted that the 12-year gap between Boks titles is up this year.

Another intriguing detail to ponder is that South Africa’s flyhalf Pollard captained the Junior Boks in 2014 and took them to the Championships final against England. Who was the England skipper that day? Maro Itoje.

The second-rower has been outstanding for England at the World Cup. If Sam Whitelock and Brodie Retallick were the benchmark for locks with a mix of toughness, high workrate and athleticism, then Itoje matches that and adds anticipation and speed.

Itoje is at the centre of much of England’s forward drive, and he’s powering them often for the full 80 minutes. He was everywhere against the All Blacks, ruled the lineout, won turnovers and topped it off with an opportunistic strip of the ball from Codie Taylor.

Itoje started the last time England took on South Africa, a game won – with a controversial finish – by England 12-11 at Twickenham last year. Angus Gardner chose not to penalise Owen Farrell for a shoulder charge that could’ve given the Boks a late chance for victory.

England’s pack that day also included Kyle Sinckler and Tom Curry. But England’s forwards for the final look a lot more balanced and intimidating with the addition of Mako Vunipola, Jamie George, Courtney Lawes, Sam Underhill and Billy Vunipola in place of Alec Hepburn, Dylan Hartley, George Kruis, Brad Shields and Mark Wilson.

They also didn’t have Manu Tuilagi at Twickenham, and even though Ben Te’o gave them a sturdy midfield presence, Tuilagi is as fit and aggressive as he’s been for a while.

England threw a lot more in attack at New Zealand than South Africa did against Wales, but Eddie Jones will be confident that his pack can get the better of the Boks.

England don’t mind a box kick either so expect halfback high-balls – from De Klerk and Ben Youngs – over their forward packs to be a feature of the final. They might just be happy to box back and forth between both 22m lines until someone slips up.

It might not be exciting but it is effective and the Boks and England, by using it consistently throughout the tournament on the way to the final, have proven that.

For this reason, the back three are called upon to do a lot of work to secure possession in the air. The England trio of Elliot Daly, Anthony Watson and Jonny May are better co-ordinated and aerially superior to win this key area of the final.

South Africa’s fullback, Willie Le Roux, has been underwhelming for much of the World Cup. He’s fumbled a fair bit of the ball and thrown some poor passes. He’s lost some speed.

England will target him, as they will Cheslin Kolbe. He’s a brilliant ball-runner, but given the winger stands at only 171cm, the England backs will be confident they can outleap and outmuscle Kolbe.

There’s a decent chance that South Africa might go a third World Cup final without scoring a try. But unlike the previous two, that won’t be enough to claim the title this time. England by eight.

The Crowd Says:

2019-11-04T11:13:09+00:00

Graeme

Roar Rookie


Really happy that the Boks proved you so wrong ... they were under estimated by too many ...

2019-11-02T02:10:53+00:00

Double Agent

Guest


LOL another one! "NZ gave England a free ride at the breakdowns" GOLD :laughing:

2019-11-02T01:51:13+00:00

rebel

Roar Guru


See plenty in the last 10 minutes before golden point. Hardly see any in Rugby, most I see are during the knockout stages of a WC. Does not warrant a rule change for a few matches every 4 years. Dan Carter only kicked 8 in his whole test career, Steve Larkham 2, Beauden Barrett 2, Handre Pollard 4 and Johnny Sexton 4. Surely the English would have kicked plenty, but no, Owen Farrell just 3.

2019-11-01T23:37:17+00:00

Double Agent

Guest


How is two penalty goals - probably one or both contentious -worth more than a try in the corner that may have started 75m out? I agree though there are more important things that could be changed.

2019-11-01T23:34:25+00:00

Double Agent

Guest


How so? There's not been a lot of field goal attempts in league since it was dropped from 2 points to 1 point and that was decades ago.

2019-11-01T23:31:32+00:00

Double Agent

Guest


:laughing:

2019-11-01T19:53:25+00:00

Partyhat

Roar Rookie


:crying:

2019-11-01T19:27:58+00:00

Graeme

Roar Rookie


You may just be onto something there Jonty. Question is ‘is Eddie buying it’?

2019-11-01T19:27:49+00:00


:laughing: Far side of the field

2019-11-01T19:26:19+00:00

Graeme

Roar Rookie


England with an extra days rest to add to the discussion

2019-11-01T19:23:25+00:00

Graeme

Roar Rookie


If he scored opposite the main stand wouldn’t he be in touch Corne ;-)

2019-11-01T19:21:52+00:00

Graeme

Roar Rookie


SA were not as one dimensional as last weekend in the Rugby Championship (or should that be The). The benefit of last weeks game plan is that they’ve given very little away with respect to what else they are capable of. I expect they will have something a bit different tomorrow. England’s big challenge is peaking again. Their game template is set with a few variations to throw in so SA know what to expect. Makes for an intriguing contest. I don’t know that England are as stronger favourites as many are suggesting.

2019-11-01T18:40:37+00:00

Ragnar

Roar Rookie


Yes, amazing that nobody ever mentions that try. It was 100% legitimate. The other aspect of that game they hardly mention is the complete wipe out of Lomu by James Small. Or the fact that Kobus Wiese was even bigger than Lomu and much more intimidating that day! But endless talk about the ''alleged'' food poisoning. Most of us have had a bout with real food poisoning and we all know you could not even run onto the field let alone play just 10 mins at that pace and pressure! Pathetic. I thought their coach acted with poor grace after the match and kept on whinging for years.

2019-11-01T18:40:33+00:00

Loftus

Guest


Lol, love all this fuel for a written off, backs against the wall, Bok. Apparently this English side has no weaknesses. Has anyone noticed that NZ gave England a free ride at the breakdowns and tackled like chickens?

2019-11-01T18:02:49+00:00

Barney

Roar Rookie


If England wins, this would be some World Cup triumph to beat all 4 Rugby Championship countries. Never been done before and probably highly unlikely ever again. Respect.

2019-11-01T15:57:10+00:00


I remember that non-try, opposite the main stand playing left to right.

2019-11-01T15:35:46+00:00

MMaaxx

Guest


Boks did actually score a try in the 95 final which was ridiculously disallowed. Ruben Kruger got it but thankfully they still won the game so it’s hardly mentioned. While my head thinks England will win, I’ve found the English press this week to be at their arrogant and delusional best. So many articles mentioning that not one Bok would make the Eng team, that England would win the final even if not at their best or that the only chance the Boks would have is if they played beyond their ability. Endless disrespect all week.

2019-11-01T15:24:32+00:00

FunBus

Roar Rookie


Jonny May is well-known as being very, very weird.

2019-11-01T14:51:30+00:00

adastra32

Roar Rookie


Yes, they were rather “gentlemanly” weren’t they? “After you, dear boy.” “No, no, I insist, after you.” LOL

2019-11-01T13:09:23+00:00

rebel

Roar Guru


Still more

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar