Rugby league's pandemic world: No crowds, forward planning and Canterbury errors

By Scott Pryde / Expert

A new rugby league era was born on Thursday evening at Homebush when the Bulldogs and Cowboys squared off in front of their coaches, some officials, media and 80,000 empty seats.

It was, in a word, eerie. Very eerie.

And while the game itself was a bit of a damp squib, with the men from Townsville picking up their first win of the year, who would have guessed that, even if it’s a low crowd, the TV product actually needs those people in the stadium to make it work.

Whereas normally, a long run would be met with cheers and noise, last night it was met with some awkward clapping from the men sitting on the bench and club officials stationed directly behind it.

While players shouting and calling could be heard loud as day over the microphones, the lack of noise didn’t seem to help the Bulldogs, who were still clunky as all hell in attack.

To the end of the game, they had just 44 per cent possession, and while some teams could blame a dodgy penalty count or run of momentum, the blue and white could only blame themselves as they dropped the ball for a ridiculous total of 16 errors, completing at just 62 per cent.

Sixteen errors. Just let that sink in. On a dry night, a professional rugby league team made 16 errors in 80 minutes.

Maybe the Dogs can blame their handling on a soapy Steeden? (Photo by Cameron Spencer/Getty Images)

Given the clunkiness of their attack to start the season, it’s a struggle to see where the Dogs’ first victory is going to come from in this scary, weird, new rugby league world.

Valentine Holmes continues to struggle in his return to rugby league though, but two competition points should take some of the pressure off both him and coach Paul Green, who surely has his head on the chopping block if the Cowboys don’t find a way to fire.

And of course, some of the blame could be given to the fact the Cowboys only jetted into Sydney this afternoon, leaving them with no game-day preparation other than sitting on an aeroplane for three hours on the flight south.

That didn’t stop Jason Taumalolo though, who set the record for most metres run in a game, rolling over the Bulldogs for a staggering 345. The only question it leaves – is there anything this man can’t do?

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

For what it’s worth, the Cowboys were the better side, but not by much, and they have a mountain of improvement to make if they want to be challenging to play finals footy, and to win a premiership when September (or October, maybe November) rolls around.

In the end, those errors were the difference between the two sides at the empty Homebush, in a game with little else worth talking about.

But, back to the topic at hand, and the reaction on social media was mixed to the lack of crowd in the stadium. That, you’d expect, is something people will get used to as they tune into the footy to try and forget about what’s actually going on in the world for a couple of hours each day.

Although, in saying that, it just didn’t feel right. The thousands upon thousands of empty seats left you with a feeling that something wasn’t right, even if that is often the picture that greets games at Homebush.

(Photo by Mark Metcalfe/Getty Images)

The NRL keep saying just how much money they stand to lose if the competition gets suspended, and frankly, there is no right or wrong answer with the measures in place as to whether the competition should be continuing.

But if top-flight rugby league is going to not only survive this period but thrive into the future, then there need to be some fast decisions made.

Self-isolation of players seems extreme, but it’s been announced, will happen, and given the way this virus spreads, is important to stick to for all members who have access to the teams, including the players themselves.

Essentially, if one player gets the virus, no matter how much the NRL tells you it won’t, the competition will be suspended or at the least impacted on a large scale with many entering quarantines, including teammates and opposition who have been on the other side of the park.

The leadership on display from the AFL during this period has been outstanding, cutting the season by five weeks. It’s essentially saying: “Yes, there will be a shutdown. We don’t know when, but let’s make a season achievable in that case.”

The NRL must also immediately move to allow player loans so that clubs who become impacted – particularly the Warriors, who will have two weeks of quarantine for any player who flies across the ditch – will be able to continue at some level of competitiveness.

(Photo by Ashley Feder/Getty Images)

On top of the self-isolation and player loan matters though, the NRL has to move to protect clubs financially, and one of the big movements would be playing as many double-headers, or triple-headers, as possible.

For example, this weekend, the Cronulla-Melbourne game could be pushed to Friday night, the two Gold Coast games played on Sunday, and the two Leichhardt games Saturday.

This saves on ground hire, with two clubs able to split the cost, while broadcasters will also be happier, only having to set up one camera crew and location.

From next weekend, it could be a case of moving games within their various cities. For example, Manly could play the Warriors at Homebush before the Rabbitohs-Roosters game, and the Sharks-Knights game could be pushed to Campbelltown on Sunday alongside the Tigers and Bulldogs.

Yes, this would require some flexibility from broadcasters in terms of which games are on when, and yes, it would mean some teams’ turnaround times are changed, but crazy times call for drastic measures.

The idea that this pandemic is going away anytime soon is madness, but rugby league, and the AFL for that matter, bring their fans a sense of normality.

Normality has gone out the window in just about every element of life, and sport has the power to keep things ticking along somewhat at this time, even if only for a few hours at a time.

While the NRL may not be able to go on for long, it should while it can. And to do that, the authorities must pull out all the stops to keep it sustainable.

This is going to be a weird season for the foreseeable future. There are no two ways around that.

And last night was just the beginning. Tonight will be another challenge, when the Broncos take to Suncorp Stadium for the first time behind closed doors.

Just how it’ll go is anyone’s guess.

The Crowd Says:

2020-03-20T05:28:28+00:00

matth

Roar Guru


Well clubs used to say that playing in front of a small crowd at Homebush felt like there was no crowd at all. Now they know exactly what no crowd feels like.

2020-03-20T05:27:18+00:00

matth

Roar Guru


Drinkwater ran through a hole that JohnnyRipe's 5 year old could have sliced open.

2020-03-20T05:26:28+00:00

matth

Roar Guru


The thing about JT13 is that because he's been around for a while now and performs the amazing almost every week, it's become his normal and people forget just how good he is.

2020-03-20T04:54:06+00:00

Nick

Roar Guru


to be fair...playing at ANZ is a bit soulless at the best of times. I think the more sapping experiences are going to be at the local grounds, where at night time they will absolutely feel like a training session.

2020-03-20T04:42:13+00:00

Big Daddy

Guest


I think the absence of a crowd creeps into the minds of NRL players and this was evident last night. It's a weird feeling watching these games and I'm sure this also affects the physche of players. Whoever is stronger mentally appears to hold the upper hand.

2020-03-20T04:06:03+00:00

hayboy

Roar Rookie


For the NRL "In front of 80,000 empty seats" sounds way more impressive than the actual crowd figure lol

2020-03-20T03:41:58+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


Totally understand your annoyance about asking for handouts, BD. I'm not saying that's unreasonable, but right now,the government has a gazillion better things to worry about. By all means, the NRL has to have money coming in, but asking for handouts when there's no firm picture about what guaranteed revenue they'll have once this crisis is over, makes it look like greed IMO. I'd also suggest the NRL powers that be, show they're willing to make some sacrifices eg cutting their wages, before demanding support from the Government

2020-03-20T03:17:09+00:00

Big Daddy

Guest


I think double headers would work if they spaced them a couple of hours apart . They could have sanitising people come in giving an early match say at 3pm have a general clear out and sanitize and have the next match at say 7:30pm. They could do that in Brisbane / Qld and get the 3 Qld teams plus warriors to play double headers in Brisbane and Gold Coast on a Saturday or Sunday. This would cut down on travel and ground costs. If it's going to go ahead minimise costs. Play no matches in Adelaide or Perth and if that means SOO so be it.

2020-03-20T03:08:07+00:00

AGO74

Guest


If one person gets it it is game over anyway so doesn’t really matter for the NRL. Though I get your point about broader group of people in close proximity as a general health issue.

2020-03-20T02:41:06+00:00

Big Daddy

Guest


Paul, the trouble is there is so many differing opinions. I'm sure there are probably other players that think like Smith but are afraid to voice their opinion for fear of rebuke. Some one on this post said even CH 9 guys are backing the NRL stance which is understandable as they have a vested interest. Whatever the outcome good or bad we will have a game but at what level no-one knows. The thing that does annoy me is the NRL asking for handout from the government. For years this league operate on a year to year basis and to be honest haven't planned for the future.

2020-03-20T02:07:04+00:00

baz

Roar Rookie


Adjust, move on and be grateful you can still enjoy the greatest game of all from the comfort of your home.

2020-03-20T01:57:05+00:00

E-Meter

Roar Rookie


Double header is a smart idea. Only issue may be the number of people gathered together at any one time.

2020-03-20T01:54:42+00:00

AGO74

Guest


Ordinary game between two ordinary teams (Taumololo excepted) but I enjoyed it just because it felt normal even for a couple of hours to watch a bit of footy. If - and its a massive if - the game could quarantine itself safely and without placing strain on any other public resource like has been suggested at that place up in Central Qld then perhaps there is an option for it. If players want their salary in these uncertain times then they would have to make a sacrifice also. Can't have your cake and eat it too in this environment. Still a massive "IF" and honestly I'm just waiting for the first NRL player to come down with COVID 19. Lastly, was it just me or on the Fox coverage did I hear a Chanel 10 1980's style "Rank Arena Replay" music played after each try when commentators were dissecting the replay of a try?

2020-03-20T01:20:36+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


the problem with the Smith comments BD was the timing. He had his say and only a day or so later, both the NRL and Players Association came out and said the players, Clubs and the NRL were unanimous the rounds should continue. at least for the present. I don't think Greenberg or V'landys would have cared if he'd said this before round 1 for example, but saying what he did, when he did, was perhaps not what's needed right now, especially coming from such an influential player. It's totally wrong to take issue with Smith's comments. As you rightly point out, he's expressing the views of many, not only in the footy community, but Australian society as a whole. I'm happy he's had his say, though can see why his timing might have been better, or maybe he could have chosen a different form of words to get the same meaning across.

2020-03-20T01:18:58+00:00

Nick

Roar Guru


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UiFNlRwmONw Get this man to commentate...he's very experienced in commentating in front of no crowds. Btw, this match is not being played behind closed doors. SPL attendances almost never crack 500.

2020-03-20T01:17:07+00:00

Nick

Roar Guru


Can the loan system work for coaches too? That way we can send Mary McGregor offshore, and then hire a better coach for two weeks.

AUTHOR

2020-03-20T01:04:04+00:00

Scott Pryde

Expert


Coen Hess is so talented. Hope he can consistently get back to his best.

AUTHOR

2020-03-20T01:03:37+00:00

Scott Pryde

Expert


Agree re quality, but I don't want to judge it until more games have been played. On one foot you could actually argue the opposite. Thursday night at Homebush against an out of town team in a game the crowd would have struggled to get into due to the dropped ball and handling errors. Normally, crowd noise would be minimal anyway. Taumalolo is a freak.

AUTHOR

2020-03-20T01:02:26+00:00

Scott Pryde

Expert


I've heard some bad over exaggerations over the years, but this takes the cake.

AUTHOR

2020-03-20T01:02:00+00:00

Scott Pryde

Expert


G'day Paul, Yep - to me, it looks like a lot of teams aren't quite prepared to play footy, although it always takes a few weeks to get the cobwebs out, so let's wait and see. Absolutely - and to make sure the NRL survives this, let's say lengthy, interruption, it needs to think outside the square as much as possible and explore every idea on or off the table.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar