Are these rugby league's best-ever commentators?

By Mark Scarfe / Roar Guru

Rugby league is a fast-moving game that produces a kind of passion among its fans that few other sports can replicate.

To bring this excitement to the radio listener and to enhance the pictures for the television audience rugby league needs a commentator who can bring out what they see on the field.

Ray Warren is the doyen of world rugby league commentary. After being sacked by Channel Ten in 1986 he reinvented himself on the Channel Nine coverage of the game and is still going strong into his 70s. Rabs is the standard all others try to emulate.

(AAP Image/Jason McCormack)

Rex Mossop took over at Channel Ten when Ray Warren left but had a rich heritage with Channel Seven before that. With pipe in hand he was the master of the tautology. You either loved or hated Rex, but the Manly great could not be ignored.

Frank Hyde famously broadcast from the sidelines in the old days with sidekick Col Pearce. A North Sydney premiership winner, Frank was a standard all others in radio looked up to.

Ray Hadley has used the sideline card table gimmick when calling games from the underused SCG for effect. Hadley started the famous Continuous Call Team in 1986 with Ray Price and later John Gibbs but fell out with both. A decorated caller of most sports, Ray Hadley had success at 2UE and effortlessly transformed that when he went to 2GB. So good was the show that they constantly won the radio ratings even when they didn’t have the rights to call the game.

Peter Peters and Greg Hartley were the kings of radio rugby league calling pre-Hadley, starting on 2UE. Full of bluster, the former Manly forward and the referee were highly entertaining and had a very loyal audience.

Ray French is an icon of rugby league broadcasting. The BBC legend played 330 games and represented Great Britain in rugby league and rugby union. A talented broadcaster on both radio and television, he retired in 2019.

Eddie Hemming was a long-time Sky Sports commentator in the English Super League. The pay-TV broadcaster had a long-time partnership with Mike Stephenson, who spent the off-seasons in Australia, where he had a stint as a player.

Tiger Black was in the Frank Hyde mould but played only two games for St George. A rival to Hyde on Sydney stations 2UW, 2UE and later 2KY, Black was one of the great callers in the 1950s and 60s.

Darrell Eastlake was the voice of State of Origin in the 1980s. Also know for his excitable weightlifting calls, Eastlake had a memorable calling partnership with the super coach Jack Gibson.

The Crowd Says:

2020-04-22T20:26:16+00:00

Steve

Guest


Bit late here but why did they shaft Hammo? And whatever happened to Richard Svenson?

2020-04-22T09:28:47+00:00

SydGeoff

Roar Rookie


I grew up in that same era and Lovejoy was the best. Once the footy came on TV, I really liked George Doniger who I think was on Channel 0 (now 10) and loved his call when a player was flattened in a high tackle...."How's the head Fred?"

2020-04-22T09:25:04+00:00

SydGeoff

Roar Rookie


Kerry Cooper I think.

2020-04-22T04:38:18+00:00

MudgeeBulldog

Guest


Is he related to the NSW Cup caller Curtis Woodward? I have heard him a couple of times last few years and he goes good.

AUTHOR

2020-04-21T09:43:28+00:00

Mark Scarfe

Roar Guru


Thats how I remember them.

2020-04-21T06:46:18+00:00

Stevo

Guest


Your 100% right. Tiger was at 2KY when he retired. I didn't consider him a great caller and rarely listened to him, as unlike Hyde he could not hide his bias when he called St George games.

2020-04-21T03:52:34+00:00

GWSingapore

Roar Rookie


Tiger Black was on 2KY. When he retired 2KY expanded their racing service to Saturdays. Frank Hyde was on 2SM and Col Pearce on 2UE. However, after Frank Hyde retired from 2SM, he did work with Col Pearce on 2UE fora couple of seasons.

2020-04-21T02:06:09+00:00

Steve Franklin

Roar Rookie


I think Andrew Voss is the best at the moment and the worst by a long way and always was the worst is Ray Warren. I think all the older commentators like Mossop, Hyde etc etc were far better than anything of today.

2020-04-21T01:29:00+00:00

Cam Stokes

Roar Pro


Dan Ginnane should be the next voice of rugby league...

2020-04-20T23:31:55+00:00

Stevo

Guest


Col Pearce was never Frank Hyde's sidekick. Hyde was on 2SM, while Pearce replaced Tiger Black on 2UE. Frank also won a premiership with Balmain in 1939.

2020-04-20T11:08:43+00:00

Timmypig

Roar Rookie


1.5m it says a lot about the quality of the TV commentators we've been stuck with that 2 blokes on 2JJJ pulling the p1ss are more informative than the so-called experts....

2020-04-20T10:48:17+00:00

Forty Twenty

Roar Rookie


True.

2020-04-20T10:46:16+00:00

Nic Testoni

Guest


1989... Warren Boland commentating on ABC TV with Peter Jackson (RIP) Boland: “... and he’s (tackled) just six inches short” Jackson: “story of your life” ????

2020-04-20T10:32:56+00:00

Adam Bagnall

Roar Guru


For me, Andrew Voss is the best. I remember him calling the Arrive Alive Cup back in the day and his quirky nature makes it a joy to watch games. Sterlo is the best when it comes to analysis. Rabs has been in decline for 10 years. The game has passed him and he has struggled to maintain a once high standard

2020-04-20T09:28:43+00:00

JOHN ALLAN

Guest


I was going to suggest Jack Newton. No offence intended. I can recall a Wests player years ago with one arm. Can anybody remember who he was?

2020-04-20T09:01:51+00:00

JGK

Roar Guru


Boland used to do the Saturday Sydney premiership games on the ABC TV as well in the late 80s. He might have even done it with Morrow.

2020-04-20T08:59:33+00:00

JGK

Roar Guru


Not if you were a nudist!

2020-04-20T08:43:17+00:00

matth

Roar Guru


Yep it was the same guy. He moved north in retirement and commentated the local Brisbane Rugby League for the ABC. And it was John ‘Dallas’ Donnelly.

AUTHOR

2020-04-20T07:52:57+00:00

Mark Scarfe

Roar Guru


What ever happened to peter Wilkins. I knew he left the ABC to go to 2GB, then what?

AUTHOR

2020-04-20T07:50:53+00:00

Mark Scarfe

Roar Guru


Great stuff. Thanks for the insight.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar