Where to now for the struggling Brisbane Broncos?

By Larry Tine / Roar Rookie

The Brisbane Broncos have been one of the most dominant and well respected clubs in the NRL for a long and sustained period of time.

They have been the NRL’s financial drawcard with average attendance at home games at around 35,000 or more primetime views every Friday night, which are the most of any team in the NRL.

Surprisingly also the Brisbane Broncos are the only club in the NRL that is publicly listed on the Australian Stock Market (ASX)

Well can money and a huge fan-base stop them from losing? At the moment doesn’t seem so, but let’s look back, to the last time the Broncos had a taste of premiership glory.

The year is 2006, after the first week of the finals which the Broncos lost convincingly to the Dragons 20-4. Most punters wrote them off.

History would say otherwise, they gave the Knights their biggest defeat in finals history, went on to beat the Dogs in what was one of their best performances in a finals match and ground out win against the Storm to win the 2006 Premiership and send Shane Webcke off on a high note.

Fast forward to now and it’s 14 years since the last time the Provan-Summons Trophy was at Red Hill. Most players in that 2006 team have gone their own separate ways.

Coach Wayne Bennett has departed after his last stint ended prematurely, while some remained back with the club most notably Corey Parker and Darren Lockyer, with Locky holding a position on the board of directors and Corey part of the coaching group.

With so much expectation coming into 2020, this season for the men in Gold and Maroon has been turbulent to say the least.

They began the season well with wins over the Cowboys and an impressive performance over their former coach’s team.

However after those two first up wins, they have been at the wrong end of the score line, most notably their losses to the Tigers and the Roosters which are in the highlights package for the wrong reasons this season.

There have been some games which they were in control where they held a lead yet they surrendered, or sometimes they were impressive in the first 40, but trailed off.

Their losses to the Storm and more recently over the weekend their clash with Cronulla, where they failed to close a game out after leading for 71 minutes of the match, are examples.

You see such things hurt you and this will really test their mental edge in their next hit out, which is the grudge match against a Souths team full of confidence.

Much of the cause to them losing games is because of the lack of experience and they struggle to find the right combinations.

When looking at their roster, it is easy to notice that the average of the Broncos playing group is 23 and the average games per individual is below 20 games. Although I must say, the game against Cronulla was one of their best performances since the beginning of the season.

Also, their defence also has just been horrendous, horrible and just not the expected standard. To leak 31 points per game is just too much.

Is this their worst season so far? This season by far is the worst by a country mile when you take into consideration the points scored and the position they hold on the ladder

And then there’s Anthony Seibold. The other reason – or should I say the sole reason – why they have been losing so terribly.

His idea of “Mr Fix It” mentality of shifting players from one position to the other has caused the players to lose confidence in themselves, resulting in poor performances week-in, week-out.

Payne Haas of the Broncos is tackled during the NRL Elimination Final match between the Parramatta Eels and the Brisbane Broncos at Bankwest Stadium on September 15, 2019 in Sydney, Australia. (Photo by Matt King/Getty Images)

Can we blame all the reshuffling of positions due to injuries? You be the judge, I don’t really want to get into that.

Shifting players from key positions, for instance they have three players who have played fullback so far this season, two or more in the halves and six players on the wings respectively, surprising isn’t it?

If you compare past players with those from today, they played for the jersey, the team, the fans and more importantly they played with a badge of honour, respect, loyalty, sacrifice, etc. week-in, week-out – even if it was in a losing team.

The current playing group, although very young, have shown that these virtues, things which are the cornerstone of the club, are just pages in the book that they can rip off whenever they please.

The Broncos has always been the face of NRL in Queensland and with them reeling at the bottom of the ladder, it’s now time for some changes to happen.

The Crowd Says:

2020-08-04T22:25:55+00:00

DP Schaefer

Roar Rookie


Actually, with the cattle coming back I see a strong finish for the Broncos. With a week or two for combinations to settle and if Dragons run you back into form you could win most if not all the last 5.

AUTHOR

2020-08-04T06:15:50+00:00

Larry Tine

Roar Rookie


Well said.

2020-08-04T06:08:21+00:00

Walter Black

Guest


I fear that their fate in that department will rest more on what the Bulldogs do than anything the Broncos can achieve.

2020-08-04T05:35:08+00:00

Rellum

Roar Guru


The Broncs have never replaced Alfie. Kevie took us to the 2000 title with the same team full of legend forwards. Locky dragged us to the 2006 title inventing block/second man plays and relying on that same group of forwards to give him room. Even without Alf it took two all time great halves to lead the team around. Over time the great forwards retired and Locky tried his best but once he left that was that. 2015 I thought Hunt might have finally replaced Alf be alas that didn't happen. We have never replaced Alf. I cannot see us winning anything until we do find a new great half back, preferably a QLD one. Sam Walker was the next great hope but the bleeping Roosters pinched him so now we are back to maybe Deardon, who maybe turns into something but that is far from certain. Other than that, if there are no quality halfs coming through then we have to go all out and get one, Keary or Munster and the ones to go after for me. First of course we need to fix all the internal issues and get a new coach.

2020-08-04T05:32:47+00:00

rden

Roar Rookie


"Leave Seibold alone" ?? you kidding? Throw him out! Any idiot can operate a well oiled well tuned machine as were previous jobs he had - just switch it on and press the go button, and once in a while run it through the wash. But when it needs some grease and fading parts changed the operator needs to get down and get it done - either themselves or sub that work out to a mechanic. Seibs only ever did well when he was handed a machine in top condition, but had no clue how to identify when things needed checking. Even less when handed a machine that needs an oil change or just a go-over checking the nuts and bolts were tight. Everything he touched faded. He's the classic old lady driving a car: as long as it starts and runs that's all that's needed, only when it completely stops it's time to call the AA. ... never mind that funny noise that's been getting louder since a few months back ... in fact just turn up the radio and it's fixed.

2020-08-04T05:21:00+00:00

rden

Roar Rookie


One of the most basic needs is to have a coach; Seib's simply does not fit that description.

2020-08-04T00:22:11+00:00

PaulC

Roar Rookie


Everyone is an expert after the fact. Ever since the return (round 3) the Broncos have had almost half a run on team on the side lines. Add to that so many inexperienced youngsters in the team & you are going to get belted. Leave Seibold alone & let him build for 2021 & beyond. After Bennett left to go to St. George the Broncos lost 7 players to other Clubs, most on the advise of Bennett. There was also mess post Bennett this time to clean up.

AUTHOR

2020-08-04T00:05:22+00:00

Larry Tine

Roar Rookie


Facts, that's something the Broncos need to address, trying to finish the year strongly to avoid the spoon.

AUTHOR

2020-08-04T00:04:09+00:00

Larry Tine

Roar Rookie


Thanks mate, hopefully the off season is a good one for them.

AUTHOR

2020-08-04T00:03:35+00:00

Larry Tine

Roar Rookie


True, one of the key aspects of a healthy and progressive team is the management. If the management doesn't function properly, most likely the team will be dysfunctional.

2020-08-03T23:48:24+00:00

Tony

Roar Guru


Good first article Lawry. It raises lots of questions but the solution for the Broncos will be harder to find. I agree with Juerg that changes will need to be made from the top down - CEO, Coach, senior players. They have such a young, talented roster that they could achieve anything with the right leadership and a couple of hard-nosed professionals who would die for the club (think Petro, Tallis, etc). Just who are their modern day equivalents is hard to say, but McGuire and McCullough spring to mind. Walters should be coach.

2020-08-03T21:19:55+00:00

Walter Black

Guest


Where are they headed ? - simple, bottom of the ladder There have been a lot of excuses bandied about but there is one simple question I ask every time this subject is brought up. If Robinson or Bellamy were in charge at the Broncos, does anyone really believe that this Broncos team would be staring down the wooden spoon barrel right now? Q.E.D.

2020-08-03T19:29:22+00:00

Juerg Camastral

Guest


14 years a go is a long time and the current team and coach are lumped with bandaids and continues change. The problem lies deep in the organisation. The CEO is responsible to support the team and ultimately success on the field. No need to comment in the media, no need to criticise the playing group or coach just provide the team with a mature leader, work with the team and coach. Overall just concentrate on a strategy and admit to failures.

Read more at The Roar