Dream XV 2020: Backrow of the year

By Pundit / Roar Guru

The backrow are the boys who do the real job. The guys who top the tackle, breakdown, and forward-handling stats. Athletic guys with power to do pretty much all the dirty work.

The backrow is a mix of great tacklers, good jacklers, and mean ruck-players.

So who makes our backrow?

6. Pablo Matera
The moment the Argentinean skipper pointed to the emblem on his jersey and told the All Blacks to respect it was iconic. This was a man who took pride in himself and his team and their rugby.

He played three solid games in the Tri Nations, most notably in his crucial performance against the All Blacks in that historic, first-ever win. He is an excellent tackler and a brilliant breakdown operator.

7.Justin Tipuric
It has been a horrendous year for Wales. They dropped to ninth in the World Rugby Rankings, claiming only one win before their straight run of losses.

However, if there was one man who stood out, it was Tipuric.

Long one of the best flankers on the planet, Tipuric is an excellent tackler, brilliant in the breakdown, and extremely athletic and fast for a forward.

In the Six Nations, he achieved a 100 per cent tackle completion rate. In attack, he offers more than his 186 cm, 101kg frame of bruising power. He is one of the most skilful flankers of all time, with the distribution skill of centres, and great short passing and offloading off both hands. He typifies handling and speed in attack, with an effective chip-kick as well.

He is extremely all-rounded, and well deserves to be the openside of the year.

8. CJ Stander
Few Irishmen have shone as much as CJ Stander this year. He opened the campaign with a man of the match performance against Scotland, spending the rest of the year tirelessly pilfering every breakdown he was present at.

Tackling and carrying hard, also skilful over-the-ball, he has been in great form and will be key for the Irish in the years to come.

Honourable mentions
Two men who could have made the list under other conditions and just barely missed out are Sam Cane and Ardie Savea.

Cane was a consistently excellent defender and has an extreme work rate. In attack, he was fast on the ball and was good in support. A good All Black captain.

Savea was brilliant, it’s just that he was fielded out of position. Nonetheless, his tackling is bruising, he is the All Blacks’ most explosive ball-carrier and an excellent jackler. He has pace and agility, combined with leg drive in attack. As Roarer Harry Jones noted, he was not Kieran Read at 8, but simply because he’s not an 8. He would have made this team had the All Blacks fielded him at 7 or even 6.

Another man who came close was France’s captain Charles Ollivon. Hardworking, bruising, and mobile. He is a powerful flanker and his work in defence is crucial to France.

Gregory Aldritt has been playing in the form of his life, powering through defenders and winning turnover upon turnover. The number 8 is a true heir to Louis Picamoles.

Tom Curry was versatile in the 8 jersey and is as dynamic as ever.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Hoskins Sotutu played a blinder against the Wallabies in Bledisloe 3 and is probably the heir to Read. He is extremely effective in defence with his power and tackling. He is a complete attacker. Ball skills, passing and raw physicality go with good hands to get the ball away in the tackle.

Akira Ioanne was was extremely powerful and hardworking, with notably improved fitness that allows him to be there when they defend.

Both Scottish opensides, Jamie Ritchie and Hamish Watson, are excellent in the breakdown and dynamic tacklers and carriers.

All these contenders go to show how brutally competitive the backrow is.

The Crowd Says:

2021-01-04T02:57:24+00:00

BrewsterBandit

Roar Rookie


Like Bird and Barkley, he defies being limited to just one position. Like Bird and Barkley, he is just a flat out "Baller." Should be space for him in any backrow. Supreme competitor, skillful and accurate, very high rugby IQ, leadership qualities lifts performance of team mates, referees respond favourably to him.

2020-12-21T03:17:11+00:00

Bobbles

Guest


You cant seriously suggest Hooper is better than Tipuric.There is not one 7 in the top 10 teams Hooper is better than. Not one.

2020-12-18T09:55:20+00:00

Unders

Roar Pro


Bang on; Ollivon is class

AUTHOR

2020-12-18T00:05:50+00:00

Pundit

Roar Guru


In other words, Hooper is the 6th or 7th best openside, which explains australias world rugby standing

AUTHOR

2020-12-18T00:05:09+00:00

Pundit

Roar Guru


Even if Hooper is better than Tipuric, ill take Hooper out and we find our top5 being- Ollivon, Savea, Underhill, Tom Curry, Sam Cane,

AUTHOR

2020-12-18T00:01:58+00:00

Pundit

Roar Guru


He makes up for it with speed and skills. Brains beat brawn

2020-12-17T23:37:55+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


He is not. But I reckoned this was just a recent form sheet?

2020-12-17T21:43:29+00:00

Armchair Halfback

Roar Rookie


Hey Harry, Is Faletau the best No8 in rugby? He was good in the ANC, but he was poor in the 6 Nations and largely anonymous since the last Lions tour.

2020-12-17T21:39:11+00:00

Armchair Halfback

Roar Rookie


Navidi's been injured most of the year and Wales have missed him. Pivac hasn't been giving Moriarty a starting spot, not sure why. Faletau was good against England, his best game since the last Lions tour...

2020-12-17T20:41:46+00:00

Riccardo

Roar Rookie


Tipuric, too long in Warburton’s shadow, and better IMO Couldn't agree more...

2020-12-17T20:41:16+00:00

Riccardo

Roar Rookie


I thought Kremer was brilliant for Los Pumas. Same Cane was just awesome. He is carrying the ball well into contact as well, something we haven't seen as much of from him and gives him an edge here in my opinion. Still hard to fault your choices though Pundit. I'm a big Tipuric fan and Stander has been outstanding for Ireland for some time as has O'Mahony. If the Spring Boks had played more I"m sure Pieter-Steph would have figured too.

AUTHOR

2020-12-17T12:20:41+00:00

Pundit

Roar Guru


Well, though Tipuric got sidestepped by faster player by the likes of Fickou( a centre with a winger's pace and agility), he was a workhorse and by the way, speaking of Wales' best days, It was with Wainwright at 6, Tipuric at 7, and Moriarty/Navidi at 8 so i dont really understand why this reference. Bullied by England frequently? Near MOTM in the Six Nations with Wales playing like a candy shop with no doors. Honestly, these comparisons dont size up because all the sides you mention have proper solid 1-5s. Wales? Journeymen, other than AWJ and injured Ken oWENS

2020-12-17T11:33:20+00:00

Unders

Roar Pro


As much as I rate CJ Stander; he has a case of going missing in the big games; his physicality he showed in both games against Scotland and the 24-14 win over Wales earlier this year was not to be seen against France and England on 3 occasions. Curry and Underhill were better performers than Tipuric; I don't think that any Welsh player deserves to be near a current world XV team- Ollivon, Aldritt, Curry and Underhill were both the best performing back rowers and amongst the most successful. Wales looked more competent with Ian Botham's Grandson- James at 7; Tipuric may have awesome tackle stats but has inferior impact in collisions or a game in comparison to the mentioned back rowers.

2020-12-17T11:25:45+00:00

Unders

Roar Pro


I have to disagree with you; Tipuric is massively overrated- bullied frequently by England, Ireland and France this year. Hooper is definitely better than Tipuric; Wales' best days in 2019 featured Navidi, Wainwright and Moriarty in the back row

AUTHOR

2020-12-17T01:34:30+00:00

Pundit

Roar Guru


Honestly the Wallaby backrowers arent bad, it is just that everyone else is better.

AUTHOR

2020-12-17T01:16:25+00:00

Pundit

Roar Guru


Honestly, the Wallabies are midtable. They are goo, but that's all they are. At least better than last year

AUTHOR

2020-12-17T01:15:27+00:00

Pundit

Roar Guru


Hard to say because Matera is a 7 at 6

AUTHOR

2020-12-17T01:14:36+00:00

Pundit

Roar Guru


I consider Du Toit and kolisi as blinsides, so sorry on any disagreement

2020-12-17T01:09:06+00:00

Paddy

Guest


Pundit, that SA bloke goes alright too. I rate him higher than Hooper .Not scared of the tough stuff.

AUTHOR

2020-12-16T13:50:13+00:00

Pundit

Roar Guru


Here's the next piece on my series. Locks of the Year. https://www.theroar.com.au/2020/12/17/dream-xv-2020-second-row-of-the-year/

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar