The Sydney Swans are back with a bang

By Avatar / Roar Guru

After two years in the finals wilderness, a return to better times may not be far off for the Sydney Swans.

Over the weekend, the Swans produced arguably their best performance for over a year when they put Richmond to the sword at the MCG, winning by 45 points and sending a spine-tingling warning to the rest of the competition that they are here to contend in season 2021.

Not least each of the other 17 club captains, none of whom gave the red-and-whites any chance of returning to September football after finishing 15th and 16th in the past two seasons.

And it would not surprise you that it was their young brigade which was again at the forefront of the win, as they flipped the script and gave the more experienced and battle-hardened Tigers a footballing lesson on the field.

Two of last year’s draftees, Errol Gulden and Logan McDonald, continued to show maturity beyond their years, while Chad Warner played easily the match of his life in just his fifth career game.

Combined with impressive individual performances from a host of others, they managed to do what several other teams have struggled to do in recent years – bring down a machine with names such as Cotchin, Martin, Riewoldt, Nankervis and Prestia to name a few.

It marked the first time since rounds 7-9 in 2017 that John Longmire’s side have scored over 100 points in consecutive matches, further, they were also the first side to crack a ton against Richmond before three-quarter-time since St Kilda did so in Round 16, 2017.

(Photo by Ryan Pierse/Getty Images)

What made the win all the more impressive was the fact they were without their talisman Lance ‘Buddy’ Franklin, who remained in Sydney but is certain to return when the Swans face Essendon this Thursday night.

It was the first time Richmond had lost to a non-Victorian side at the MCG, or in Melbourne for that matter, since Round 13, 2017 – which also happened to be against the Swans.

For the most part of this millennium the club has been a defence-oriented team, as evidenced in 2006, 2012, 2014, 2016 and 2017 when, in each of those five seasons, they conceded the fewest points of any side in the league.

Further, in 2001 and 2005, they were the second-best defensive side, winning their drought-breaking premiership in the latter year.

During this period, despite boasting the likes of Barry Hall and Michael O’Loughlin in the forward line, their style of play has sometimes come under scrutiny – most notably, in the 2005 premiership season, they ranked 14th in offence, only ahead of Hawthorn and Collingwood.

Even wooden spooners Carlton scored 42 more points than the Swans that year.

Last year, Richmond coach Damien Hardwick savaged their game plan after the Tigers were kept to only 4.10 (34) while the Swans booted only 3.8 (26) themselves in the corresponding match at the Gabba.

He, however, praised the Swans for their performance on Saturday, saying they could’ve beaten his side by ten goals and that his three-time premiership side had simply been outclassed.

Put simply, the Tigers were beaten at their own game, and beaten convincingly.

After years of centring their game plan around defence and wearing opposition teams down, the Swans have revolutionised their attack like never before to the point that they have scored the most points than any other side, averaging 121 from their opening three rounds.

This included booting the highest score in each of the opening two rounds, including kicking 19 goals against the Brisbane Lions at the Gabba, where the northerners proved hard to beat last year.

A lot of this has been attributed to the presence of assistant coach Don Pyke, who arrived at the club after a year off following his tenure as Adelaide Crows coach, during which the club ranked first in offence in 2016 and 2017, advancing to the grand final in the latter year.

The Swans’ win over the Tigers came as personal revenge for Pyke, whose Crows were humiliated on the big day in 2017 when they only mustered 8.12 (60) – their lowest score for the whole season.

His time at West Lakes came to a sour end when the club missed the finals in 2018 and 2019, leading to his departure from the Crows and a year out of the game before re-emerging from the coaching wilderness in Sydney.

The red-and-white resurgence also has many comparing them to the famous “Baby Bombers” side of 1993 that won an unexpected flag with rookie names such as James Hird, Dustin Fletcher, Joe Misiti, Mark Mercuri and a reborn Tim Watson to name a few.

All but Watson (who retired at the end of 1994) then formed the nucleus of their 2000 premiership side, which also included, among others, Matthew Lloyd, Scott Lucas, Damien Hardwick, Steven Alessio and Dean Solomon.

Similarly, the Swans class of 2021 has Errol Gulden, Logan McDonald, Chad Warner, Justin McInerney and a reborn Lance Franklin around which to possibly build their next premiership team.

Buddy is also in the penultimate year of his nine-year contract with the Sydney Swans; it is expected he will retire at the end of next season, which is when it runs out.

A flag in either this or next year, while unlikely this year, would be the perfect way for him to ride into the retirement sunset, before which he is likely to crack the 1000-goal milestone, something that has not been achieved since 1996.

(Photo by Tony Feder/AFL Media/Getty Images)

It comes as cross-town rivals the GWS Giants continue to struggle with the Homebush-based club currently sitting in 17th place on the ladder with no wins from three matches this season and also enduring a six-match losing streak dating back to Round 16 last year.

In contrast to the Swans’ newfound attacking style of play, the Giants’ on-field fortunes have continued to deteriorate since being humiliated by the Tigers in the 2019 grand final, having cracked the ton just once since then – in Round 1 last year.

Therefore, it is possible that after several frustrating years of playing second-fiddle to their younger brothers, the Swans could this year reclaim their mantle as the top side in Sydney, and in New South Wales for that matter.

This will provide a subplot to the Round 5 Sydney Derby, which will be played at the SCG after last year’s only Derby was played at the unusual venue of Optus Stadium, behind Western Australia’s hard borders, which have since been loosened.

In that match, the young Swans shined on the Thursday night stage, keeping the Giants goalless in the opening quarter and preventing them from scoring freely with their only three goals that evening coming via free kicks.

Barring a major coronavirus outbreak, a full house will be expected at that match, but not before the Swans play Essendon in what promises to be a prime-time blockbuster under the SCG lights this Thursday night.

The Bombers will go into this match fresh off an unexpected 75-point thrashing of St Kilda, which has provided their coach Ben Rutten with some relief after they had started the season with a heartbreaking loss to Hawthorn and a poor loss to Port Adelaide at the Oval.

Buddy’s return will be a case of bad timing for the Bombers, whom the 34-year-old has consistently dominated kicking more goals against them than any other side in the competition at an average of 4.3 goals from 16 matches.

Should the Swans continue their impressive early-season form, it is possible they could be 6-0 by the time they face last year’s runners-up, the Geelong Cats, at the SCG in Round 7.

While a timeslot for that match is still to be determined, it is highly likely the match will be scheduled for Friday evening, which would give the developing side the chance to shine on prime time television.

Without doubt these are exciting times ahead for the Sydney Swans and after years of dominance by Richmond, perhaps the Swans will be the team that no-one will want to face in September, should they get that far.

The Crowd Says:

2021-04-05T23:08:36+00:00

Asd

Guest


We will see longmire teams kick big scores but crumble under pressure they dont dael with it vs bulldogs vs hawks

2021-04-05T11:21:22+00:00

Mark.

Roar Rookie


That doesn’t make any sense. Cheer up grumpy.

2021-04-05T07:48:55+00:00

Mooty

Roar Rookie


You’re the type Longmire would love hanging about the place. Sound like a Collingwood supporter

2021-04-05T06:12:16+00:00

Glenn

Guest


Spot on. You have articulated the reasons why those of us that have watched the Swans as close as supporters do over the last 2 seasons, find the "ohh, but usually/statistically" comments of the "experts" laughable. The possibility of the Swans win on Saturday was easy to see by those who watch them and has been evidenced by the sizeable chunk of cash that the TAB gifted me. Yeah, the kids are good, but the slightly older group is exceptional. It's going to be a fun year to watch.

2021-04-05T05:28:39+00:00

Chris M

Guest


Hopefully the Swans can stay fit and healthy and any injuries that occur to players are minor and not season-ending. Some of the younger players' workloads may need to be managed over the course of the year. Lance Franklin and James Rowbottom will probably return to the top team this week and Robbie Fox and Sam Naismith may eventually push for selection once they recover from their injuries. Dylan Stephens, James Bell, Matthew Ling, Will Hayward, Ben Ronke, Lewis Melican and Will Gould are other young players who could easily rotate in and out of the team to rest younger players and if they are continuing to develop their games behind the scenes, given the chance they could push their own case for being part of the first twenty-two.

2021-04-05T04:55:28+00:00

Chris M

Guest


Any team can beat any other team on their day, except perhaps North Melbourne at this very moment. Fortunately for the Swannies, both Sydney and Essendon are coming into the game off a five day break. Fortunately, Essendon's strong win over St Kilda may deter a level of complacency that may have otherwise crept into the Swans. It may well come down to which team has recovered the best after Saturday's game.

2021-04-05T03:58:36+00:00

George

Guest


Fair comment. Good not to lose sight of importance of Kennedy, Parker, Rampe. Vital to acknowledge McCartin, Dawson, Heeney. Good also to reflect on depth of squad, in case of injuries (esp. those nurtured over 2020) Clarke, Stephens, Ling perhaps even Amarty. Good tyo acknowledge the skill of the oversight of the club... nurturing, training, long term planning.

2021-04-05T03:34:22+00:00

Old Man behind the Goals

Guest


We have beaten Brisbane up in Brisbane, and the reigning premiers at their fortress... there is plenty to be excited about. Those two wins were sans Buddy.

2021-04-05T02:35:24+00:00

Charlie Keegan

Roar Guru


you know who else started 3-0 Essendon in 2012. Im not gonna say that the Swans are doing their best Essendon 2012 impersonation Im not not saying it though.

2021-04-05T02:33:48+00:00

Charlie Keegan

Roar Guru


yeah but the Bombers took the youngest and least experienced side into the weekend, and with that experience comes inconsistency. I believe the bombers will push the Swans but it may not be a win.

2021-04-05T01:36:59+00:00

Kick to Kick

Roar Rookie


Exciting time for the Swans. But a few myths are already abroad. There’s commentary that it’s mostly new recruits making the running. They’ve been fantastic for rookies but this week they weren’t the difference. Campbell actually had the worst champion data ranking of the whole team against the Tigers. Only 12 disposals and 3 or 4 clangers. The only player on either side who scored worse was Prestia because he was subbed off early for injury. New draftees are going to be inconsistent but Campbell might be due a rest if they want to find a spot for Rowbottom against the Bombers. Gulden and MacDonald were solid but not game breakers. Warner and Wicks were enormous which is a sign there’s enough youth to spread the load. But the big contributors this week were the mid-age to younger players that Longmire has worked to develop over two years: Dawson, Papley, Mills, Florent, Heeney. Plus older hands keeping things steady. Luke Parker was best on ground. Which goes to the second myth, that there’s been a sudden revolution in game style. The club has been recruiting younger players who are quick and can kick over 3 or 4 drafts now. As Longmire said in his press conference post match they worked on the new game plan playing fast through the corridor during last year but skill errors, turnovers and injuries meant it hasn’t flowered til now. This year’s success so far sees a flowering of long term planning and recruitment.

2021-04-05T00:13:15+00:00

Mooty

Roar Rookie


Sydney have won a couple of games and everyone is gushing about it. Three rounds in remember, very early, anything can happen. Where did they finish last year, bottom four from memory, now we have people in this forum talking about them playing in the Grand Final. Come on be realistic

2021-04-05T00:05:12+00:00

FabPhil

Roar Rookie


Dominated perhaps a wrong choice of words (comfortably maybe, aided by the Crows' inaccuracy) but regarding the Swans, I think we're saying the same thing.

2021-04-05T00:01:25+00:00

Yattuzzi

Roar Rookie


Swans have done a great job researching and then doing a number on the first three sides they played. Who would do research on Essendon? Even if you did, they change every week anyway. Dons win against Saints is as good as Swans against Tigers. Everyone is just assuming that Tigers are good and Saints are fairy floss. So will be a good game with Dons right in there, or a flogging.

2021-04-04T23:58:23+00:00

Timbo's rules

Guest


Dominated! Getting a bit ahead of yourselves. The Swans still have flaws, highlighted by Tex getting 4 goals from holding the ball frees. Swans are good to watch. Imagine saying that. But Crows, who are honest but not great, could have beaten the Swans if they'd kicked straighter.

2021-04-04T23:55:09+00:00

Mark.

Roar Rookie


Pretty sure Swans finished 3rd in 2005 and 2012 as well. Ideal spot.

2021-04-04T23:51:54+00:00

Mark.

Roar Rookie


Lol nah

2021-04-04T23:38:08+00:00

FabPhil

Roar Rookie


Swans have now beaten two very good teams on the road and dominated another up-and-coming side at home, with a pleasant, attacking style to boot. Fair to say they've got a lot to look forward to. But many teams that got off to flying starts have unravelled - and it doesn't take much. I'd think the Swans should have the poise to be consistent this year but in the grand scheme of things, March and April aren't the months that matter.

2021-04-04T23:31:24+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


A long way to go to start making predictions.

2021-04-04T23:28:30+00:00

Angela

Roar Rookie


I worry that everyone – thankfully apart from Longmire – is getting a bit carried away. It’s a long season. To go from near the bottom of the ladder to winning a GF is perhaps a fantasy. Young players need ‘managing’, we don’t know what injuries might occur (presumably we’re in good shape because missing finals we had a long preseason), other teams, eg, Richmond, Brisbane, Port will toughen up and improve etc. Time to take a breath, enjoy the wins and the resurgence after a few lean years, accept the losses, which will come, and settle down.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar