BRETT GEEVES: Forget AFL's latest tease, only the map of Tassie will excite us now

By Brett Geeves / Expert

Once, in the middle of a night club, my friend – who stands 6’3, 115kgs – asked if I had ever smelt the cheese. Replying “Nah” in a tone that suggested I was excited by the prospect was my first mistake.

Bending down to sniff his clenched fist (cheese) as it sat on his dinner plate sized hand was my second mistake.

Continuing to drink and not seeking medical attention, after his fist slammed into my nose, was the third.

But perhaps the biggest mistake of all was trusting the intention of someone who should have been looking after me through our life-long connection. This was a relationship built on respect and love, and my desperation to be involved in the revelry saw me taken advantage of and punched in the face.

The good news, for me, is that I am not alone in this whole “trust, love and want for involvement in the revelry so bad I will do and believe almost anything” thing. Tasmanians have been smelling the AFL’s cheese for longer than anyone can remember.

The most recent recommendation handed down by the AFL, via a feasibility study authored by former Geelong President, Colin Carter, presented this as his summary of findings.

SUMMARY OF FINDINGS:
The case for Tasmania is strong, and the recommendation is that Tasmania should be represented by a team in the AFL/AFLW national competitions – but the best form of that team is less clear-cut. It could take the form of a 19th license and that case can be made. But re-location of an existing team if a club is keen to take that path, or a joint venture between Tasmanian stakeholders and a Victorian team that secures strong support in the two markets from the outset, would arguably produce a more sustainable outcome.

The one thing I love about the English language, and how we roll it out, is the use of “but”. It provides freedom to do the exact opposite of your opening statement.

No disrespect, but I am now about to blatantly disrespect you.

I’m not a racist, but … I did a racism – thanks Taylor.

WHAT IT REALLY MEANS:
The case for Tasmania is strong, and the recommendation is that Tasmania should be represented by a team in the AFL/AFLW national competition – BUT the reality is that we have wasted even more money and time to fashion up a bunch of words that were aimed at getting Tasmanians to see it our way via these three offerings, of which, only two are viable through the use of “BUT”.

1. Own team – not viable.

2. Relocate North Melbourne or some other low membership and deficit ridden Melbourne based club down their full time under the guise of “joint venture”.

3. Victorian clubs continue to play out of Hobart or Launceston.

The above options will be explored through the implementation of their own separate feasibility studies, formation of four taskforces and three steering committees so that this will drag out long enough that the Tasmanian state government will have to continue to be the booty call of the AFL if it wants access to AFL games and stimulus into its winter economy.

In short – the AFL just punched us gullible Tasmanians in the face . . . again. No standalone Tasmanian team is incoming.

We want THE MAP. Stand alone. Green foundation. Yellow Map. Maroon T and trimmings.

We don’t want a failing club relocating here for the cash. You think attendance is low for North Melbourne games now, wait until we really hate them because “they took our jobs”.

We have appreciated the offering of AFL into the community, our hospitality and tourism industries have loved the injection of participants into their winter financials, BUT we are done.

(Photo by Getty Images)

And so, it seems, is Premier Peter Gutwein; who arrived to his 11am press conference, established to respond to the Carter Review, in a White Cortina (Tasmanian equivalent to a White Knight) and said “NAH”, except this time there was no enthusiasm or body language that suggested further exploration would be taking place.

“The AFL have taken the view that they can kick the can down the road. Well let me be clear, there will be ramifications for that” said Premier Gutwein in a fashion that provides imagery of him flicking the bird at any offering of cheese making.

Blessed AREN’T the Cheese Makers, says Premier Gutwein.

And the rest, I’m paraphrasing here:
• Premier Gutwein said a joint venture is not an option for a Tasmanian AFL entity.
• That he won’t roll North Melbourne and Hawthorn contracts over until he gets a satisfactory response from the AFL.
• If the response doesn’t come this year, then there will be no money from the Tasmanian Government and no games in Tasmania. And this will be on the AFL’s head.

Tasmania’s savior. Premier Peter Gutwein. Not only has he stopped COVID from entering the state through his hardline stance on border control, but he is now putting a stop to the 3am desperation call from Gill after GWS, Hawthorn, North Melbourne and the sporting graveyard of the Gold Coast stopped buying him drinks because they all ran out of money.

The Premier has indicated strongly in the past that he was willing to rehab the state’s addiction to these immoral practices by standing up for the unified voice of the Tasmania football community.

And to see him hold firm on that stance, the only viable position for Tasmania to have a stand-alone team, is one that provides me, and I am sure the broader football community, with great hope.

We want THE MAP. Stand alone. Green foundation. Yellow Map. Maroon T and trimmings.

It. Is. Time.

The Crowd Says:

2021-08-18T06:30:10+00:00

Republican

Guest


Well articulated Handles, in the language that bankers comprehend......

2021-08-16T09:11:52+00:00

Vicboy

Roar Rookie


As you said - his home state Tasmanian should have a team - stuff the bean counters- just get it going Baldock, Stewart, Hart, Richardson, etc we should encourage more

2021-08-16T05:23:55+00:00

Handles

Roar Guru


The lesson from the GWS and GC exercise is that building a list through draft concessions is a sure way to sacrifice the careers of a bunch of young footy stars, and that it sentences teams at the bottom of the ladder to a 10 year 're-build'. Contract values for middling players (Tom Scully anyone?) get inflated, and everyone suffers.

2021-08-16T03:38:25+00:00

Thom Roker

Roar Guru


"After a quiet first match against Tasmania, the Gold Coaster proved his class with a best on ground showing, exceptional in defence as well as attack, with six tackles." Lachie Weller played U16, U17 and U18 for Queensland, including against Tasmania. I think if you play against your home state then you can't go back.

2021-08-16T03:33:33+00:00

Thom Roker

Roar Guru


https://www.afl.com.au/news/64395/lachie-weller-shines-for-queensland-in-u18s-win

2021-08-16T02:24:42+00:00

Bludger

Guest


Geevesy, if you are getting into fights at nightclubs no wonder Pup didn't want to talk to you.

2021-08-16T01:46:09+00:00

Vicboy

Roar Rookie


The hardest heart ;)

2021-08-16T01:45:19+00:00

Vicboy

Roar Rookie


https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lachie_Weller

2021-08-15T23:41:10+00:00

JamesH

Roar Guru


I'm not sure how an identity overhaul would alter the fact that the team is being shared with a Victorian suburb which already has many decades of established history with the club. It's like saving up to get your own house and then being told by the bank you have to buy into someone else's and share it.

2021-08-15T21:09:19+00:00

Thom Roker

Roar Guru


Lachie Weller actually played for Queensland as an under 16s against Tasmania.

2021-08-15T20:41:59+00:00

Vicboy

Roar Rookie


It should be Jack Riewoldt at CHF - sorry

2021-08-15T10:33:52+00:00

Thom Roker

Roar Guru


Next Generation Academy. Juniors who are Aboriginal and /or Torres Strait Islander or they have at least one parent born overseas. All clubs in Vic, SA and WA have this program. Some clubs spend more on it than others.

2021-08-15T09:38:32+00:00

Republican

Guest


I reckon you are on the money here Cat.

2021-08-15T09:32:58+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


What is NGA?

2021-08-15T09:28:41+00:00

Republican

Guest


Do they want AFL money you say Thom. Well the AFL seem to have loads to squander on pie in the sky ventures ie GWS. That's a real punt that may come off but to invest in a market of Tassies establ8shed pedigree shouldn't be such a leap as many seem to imply - including the apparent custodians of our code.

2021-08-15T09:22:58+00:00

Thom Roker

Roar Guru


Brisbane have father-son AND an Academy, although lately Richmond have been poaching a few of them. The Northern clubs don't have NGA though, so there is equalisation. The problem is, clubs voted to water down their own advantage. Absolutely clubs lucky enough to discover the next Jamarra Ugle-Hagan should be able to match a bid on their own player. Victoria has 12 junior clubs funded by the AFL, 6 in the metro area and 6 in the country. I'd rather be Geelong with their junior zone and ability to attract players to come back after 8 years than the Suns rebuilding every 4 years because kids want to go home.

2021-08-15T09:04:46+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


Ok...so do Brisbane have this luxury too?

2021-08-15T09:01:27+00:00

Thom Roker

Roar Guru


The Suns have their own recruitment zone. It takes in the greater GC area, including Northern NSW plus Central and Far North Queensland. They have programs in Darwin and the Pacific Islands. Any of these players can be bid on by any club in the draft, but the Suns can match the offers. For the past 2 drafts, the Suns have been able to pre-select Academy players without going into the draft

2021-08-15T08:36:53+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


The “academies” are players that are drafted though, NOT actual junior zoning. You seem to be implying that GWS & GC have distinct exclusive junior recruiting zones (a la NRL)

2021-08-15T08:31:57+00:00

Thom Roker

Roar Guru


Every club has an Academy. The 4 Northern clubs have boys and girls academies funded by the clubs. Last year, all 18 AFL clubs voted on Next Generation Academies (indigenous or migrant players) and the Northern Academies, choosing to get rid of the rule that benefitted 14 clubs and keep the advantage for the Northern clubs because it promotes the game in non-traditional States. I might add that neither GWS nor the Suns have father/sons and won't for many years to come. Michael Rischitelli's son is the first in 2032.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar