Essendon Round 23 review: The Bombers are finals bound

By Charlie Keegan / Roar Guru

We’re in the eight!

I’m going to repeat it for extra emphasis: the Essendon Bombers spent two rounds in the eight this season and have completed the unlikeliest of charges for the finals series.

These are my key takeaways from Essendon’s Round 23 clash against the Collingwood Magpies.

109.1 the magic number
Essendon finished the season with a percentage of 109.1, a testament to the offensive might they have brought to bear and the miserly defence that is still a work in progress. It is also the highest percentage they’ve recorded at the end of a season since 2003, when they were also eighth. However, the Bombers have the fifth-best offence across the season and have done it without the offensive stars other teams have had.

Sunday was no exception, as they had an equitable distribution of goal kickers, with Peter Wright (four), Alec Waterman (four), Devon Smith (two), Jake Stringer (two) and Mason Redman (two) all recording multiple goals as the Bombers scored above 100 points for the seventh time this season. They’ve also begun to tighten the screws defensively, going from the bottom two defensively to ninth, which is a more accurate reflection of their skills.

The Bombers now face a curious test against the Western Bulldogs, and they’ll be hopeful of repeating the heroics of three weeks ago.

(Photo by Michael Willson/AFL Photos via Getty Images)

Dynamic Devon Smith
Maybe it was the prospect of being dropped for an elimination final, but Devon Smith played his best game of the year, with 23 disposals, two goals, four goal assists and ten score involvements. Smith has often been criticised as a little too hungry for his own good, but gone was that aggrieved entitlement that has infected his game previously. He played hard, he played clean and he played well in what was arguably a best-on-ground performance that has been sorely missing since his 2018 Crichton Medal-winning year. If he can bring that sort of performance more than once a year, he will go down as an even better Bombers player and a key component of Essendon’s next premiership.

Midfield kicks it up a notch
A lot has been made of Darcy Parish and Zac Merrett’s seasons. To be fair, each of their seasons has been spectacular to the point they can be declared the best one-two punch in the competition, but I think the news of Kyle Langford and Jye Caldwell making it through another scratch match and Nik Cox getting another week of valuable rest has the Bombers in a very, very good place as they head into the unlikeliest of finals charges. My overall point here is if the Bombers can routinely get their best midfield on the park next year, then they’re going to be an outside chance for the top four.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Two-metre Peter does it again
Seven-seater Ford Titanium Peter Wright was at it again, clunking marks everywhere and kicking goals for the Bombers. Aside from an atrocious shank in the second quarter it was the perfect game from the prototypical key forward. There’s now news of Harry Jones getting through the scratch match alongside Anthony McDonald-Tipungwuti, which will create issues for an Essendon selection panel that has shown the ability to get the most out of the blue-collar Bombers. The four-goal haul takes his season total to 29, which is his second-best return across his career.

Team-oriented Bombers
Darcy Parish was extremely heavily tagged, a sign of his growing influence on the game. But the deep tag from Jay Rantall wasn’t able to stop 11 players having 20 or more disposals. In particular Tom Cutler played his best game, with 24 disposals and eight marks, to make it a near certainty that he gets a contract extension despite appearing on the chopping block as recently as a month ago. Dylan Shiel and Andy McGrath appear to be relishing the reduced responsibility that comes with being the third and fourth-best midfielders in the Essendon engine room.

Essendon’s epic opportunity
The Bombers have an epic chance to win their first final in 17 long years. They play an atrociously out-of-form Bulldogs, who have had the wood on the Bombers in recent years with the exception of their most recent match. Their form of late has been shocking, with three consecutive losses to limp into the finals series. Just quietly, the Bombers midfield bats almost as deeply as the Bulldogs, but Essendon have a better and less injury-prone defence while the Bulldogs have appeared a shadow of themselves over the last month of the season.

I give my Bombers a red-hot chance to get over the Dogs and snap their drought. With the finals as compromised as they are, any side, even the Bombers, can do it. And Ben Rutten and co have me hoping against hope that they can pull off the miraculous.

Final thoughts
The air-tight NASA experimental lid is off, ladies and gentlemen. I am keen for the finals next week, when the Bombers can break their agonisingly long finals drought.

Best six

  1. Will Snelling (16 votes)
  2. Tom Cutler (two votes)
  3. Jake Stringer (50 votes)
  4. Mason Redman (26 votes)
  5. Peter Wright (25 votes)/Alec Waterman (five votes)
  6. Devon Smith (11 votes)

Leaderboard

  1. Zac Merrett and Darcy Parish (65 votes)
  2. Jake Stringer (50 votes)
  3. Dyson Heppell (28 votes)

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2021-08-27T20:39:36+00:00

Charlie Keegan

Roar Guru


Cutler is still a little soft on the outside. But Langers I don't want to risk his hamstring

2021-08-27T15:48:47+00:00

Pierro

Roar Rookie


I'd bring Langford in for Cutler if Langford happens to be fit and we get through bulldogs .

2021-08-27T15:45:57+00:00

Pierro

Roar Rookie


Well tippa still not right upstairs by all accounts but still looks a bit unfit something’s not right . Caldwell in is great I would have dropped Durham as he had very few disposals last week and inexperience a worry . Guelfi stays and probably should in front of Clark but a few issues . With hind out I don’t think gleeson was a good move . McGrath could go back and you bring Caldwell in to middle . Then maybe you keep clarke to man mark libs or bontempelli . Also it’s going to be wet and tricky. We have not gone well in wet this year and it’s the tall timber that slow up in Stewart wright and maybe Durham to inexoerienced . Beveridge was smart to bring the game to Tasmania and make it a scrap in the wet . Fingers crossed But I would have balanced the team up with smaller runners and low centre of grsvity for rain a bit more hopefully we can get homenl by whatever margin . Shame Langford and tippa didnt make it . If we get to a dry track I’d start hooker but not in wet . Francis could still go back for Stewart who hasn’t been great and Langford in for Cutler for me

2021-08-24T13:05:54+00:00

Cam

Guest


Really reluctant to change a very settled team - perhaps the most settled it has been since late 2017. It's clear that for the less talented players, Rutten and Co have set clear no-frills roles for guys like Clarke, Cutler, Durham, Snelling etc. and its working well. No more than two changes please (Tipungwuti and Langford if available for scoring potential) but who goes out?! As much as Caldwell will be a gun, he's missed far too much footy to be of value now that McGrath has played two games since returning. Could Hooker come back to provide some big man versatility either back or up forward, but then who drops out? A real challenge awaits the selection committee on Thursday night.

2021-08-24T11:12:30+00:00

adhitya0710

Roar Rookie


Not sure how many agree but whenever Smithy gets an early goal in the game, he becomes a different beast. He becomes very moody when he doesn't get a goal, early goal makes a massive difference to his morale. Cuttler has cleared all our doubts, the Crows game was his turning point. He was a just a big-bodied player who couldn't do much but something has gotten into him and he has become a very very efficient player.

AUTHOR

2021-08-23T22:29:33+00:00

Charlie Keegan

Roar Guru


“Throws”.

2021-08-23T22:25:19+00:00

Chanon

Roar Rookie


Flick pass Chuck get it right man :boxing:

AUTHOR

2021-08-23T22:22:43+00:00

Charlie Keegan

Roar Guru


I think the bulldogs need to control the ball with handballs on Sunday if they want to win.

2021-08-23T22:21:13+00:00

Chanon

Roar Rookie


This is great l love the games leading up to finals feel sorry for the other also-rans that miss out, nah don’t really they are condemned just like the bombers on that arctic freeze on Sunday arvo :boxing:

2021-08-23T22:18:11+00:00

Chanon

Roar Rookie


Haha true well we have Martin & with an injection from your club doctor he should be right to go :silly:

AUTHOR

2021-08-23T22:14:05+00:00

Charlie Keegan

Roar Guru


Bah the bulldogs are on struggle street. I’m predicting Big Sammy to put Martin into retirement

2021-08-23T22:09:51+00:00

Aransan

Roar Rookie


If given a 200 point start. Do you have a ruckman yet?

2021-08-23T21:15:21+00:00

Chanon

Roar Rookie


Dogs to smash the Bombers by 150 points :stoked:

2021-08-23T21:14:03+00:00

Chanon

Roar Rookie


Give him time he will turn into Cox just wait! Keith will bury him into the Antarctic ice cap :stoked:

AUTHOR

2021-08-23T12:16:51+00:00

Charlie Keegan

Roar Guru


Hahaha you’re right on there. I think the lid is off all around the bombers community and I am eager to see how big the bombers numbers can be down in Lonnie

AUTHOR

2021-08-23T12:15:27+00:00

Charlie Keegan

Roar Guru


The seven seater is a better contested mark and he knows how to kick the ball flush.

2021-08-23T11:41:27+00:00

Aransan

Roar Rookie


Jones was important during the season but I don’t think he would have been mature enough for the finals. He will be a good player.

2021-08-23T11:30:45+00:00

Aransan

Roar Rookie


I am confident Cox will play and will play well. Managed one week, medical sub the next week sounds like a solid training block to freshen him up. For a 200cm first year player he has done remarkably well to play as many games as he has this year. Keeping Hooker going is insurance against either Wright or Stewart going down, good on him to keep it up — there is a lot more in a season than the best 22. I would expect Caldwell to come in, there will be a couple of very unlucky outs, but to repeat, it is more than the best 22.

2021-08-23T11:09:11+00:00

Seano

Roar Rookie


Harry Jones heading to the surgeon which is a shame, Langford wont play, tipper will. I cant wait, our % is strong which shows we are a decent side. Lids off brother! Also i said we would make the finals at the start of the year!

AUTHOR

2021-08-23T09:14:27+00:00

Charlie Keegan

Roar Guru


I think walla in for Clarke, and Caldwell in for guelfi. I think both are extremely unlucky, and I think we are also going to have to find room for Cox

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar