The England Lions squad is far more interesting than the England Ashes squad

By Paul / Roar Guru

The England and Wales Cricket Board (ECB) named the Ashes tour squad a few days ago, and there were no real surprises in store.

The only issue for me was why they named only a 17-man group for what is likely to be a tough series.

The attrition rate in Australian series in recent years has been high, with New Zealand, India and Australia all having more than a few players drop out through injury.

England have solved that problem by announcing a Lions tour that will bring a number of fringe players to Australia prior to the first Test.

England squad
Tom Abell, Josh Bohannon, James Bracey, Brydon Carse Mason Crane, Matthew Fisher, Ben Foakes, Alex Lees, Saqib Mahmood, Liam Norwell, Matt Parkinson, Dom Sibley, Jamie Smith and Rob Yates.

In effect this gives England 31 players to choose from prior to the first Test starting.

England have openly admitted to following Australia’s lead set prior to the 2019 Ashes, when we had two teams of first-class cricketers in England. This squad will play warm-up games against the Ashes selected players as well as a four-day game against an Australian A side during the first Test.

One of the reasons the ECB gave for going down this path was the poor quality of lead-up games on previous tours. In fairness, they have a point. I think for some years now both Australia and England have done the touring side no favours with the opposition provided in early tour matches.

This becomes even more critical in the modern era, when time for all forms of international cricket is tight to the point where the England Ashes squad will have only one three-day and one four-day practice game prior to the first Test. Sadly though, young cricketers or players not quite good enough to make first-class level miss out on a chance to mix it with the big guys.

(Photo by Ryan Pierse/Getty Images)

One really interesting comment came from England performance director Mo Bobat when the squad was announced: “There is a likelihood that a player can put forward a compelling case in the warm-up games and end up being around for the Ashes.”

I think this doesn’t apply to all players in the Lions squad. I can’t see guys like Mason Crane, Ben Foakes or James Bracey doing enough to force their way into contention for a crack at the first XI. There are some, though, who could be bolters.

Saqib Mahmood is one player who I believe has a real chance to stay for the Ashes. He played in the ODI series against Pakistan in the England summer and was named man of the series. He is a genuinely quick fast bowler who could be a serious handful on Australian pitches. The England Ashes attack lacks pace apart from Mark Wood, so Mahmood could be a real chance to make his debut in Brisbane or Perth.

Rob Yates’s first-class numbers are underwhelming, with a batting average of just 32, but he had a great county summer that culminated in back-to-back hundreds as his county took out the championship final. He’s only a young fella, but he seems to have a solid technique, and being a left-hander could make him an option if Rory Burns were to underperform. It will be interesting to see which of Dom Sibley or Yates gets the nod to stay given England included only two openers in its Ashes squad.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Josh Bohannon is a middle-order player who averaged 53 this year in county cricket and averages 44 in first-class cricket. I can’t see him outing Pope, Buttler, Bairstow or Stokes – if he makes the tour – but he might be an option for future Ashes tours if he does well on this trip.

The final player I really hope does well is Matt Parkinson. Dom Best and Jack Leach are fair to middling first-class spinners, but finger spin in Australia is incredibly hard to bowl well. All know how James Swann struggled on his last Ashes tour, and these two are not close to his calibre.

Parkinson is a young leggie with pretty impressive first-class numbers: 102 wickets at 23.35 and a strike rate of 50. He probably doesn’t have huge variety, but there’s no doubt he can get lots of spin on the ball as well as dip and swerve.

With the lack of quality spin options available, I think England should jump at the chance to keep him in the squad. To be honest, I didn’t understand why he wasn’t in the original Ashes party. He could be a serious handful in Sydney and perhaps in Adelaide if England were to be bowling on a Day 5 pitch.

There’s no doubt the Lions players will be giving it everything in the matches they’ll play in November, with the prize being a chance to stay on with the main touring party.

Hopefully they get to play on competitive pitches so these games are both exciting to watch and good practice for England’s batsmen and bowlers.

The Crowd Says:

2021-10-17T00:23:10+00:00

Arnab Bhattacharya

Roar Guru


So Mason Crane who averages over 41 with the ball in FC cricket is being taken to the Lions squad over Amar Virdi (119 FC wickets at 29.55 and helped Surrey win the 2018 CC). Great way of showing faith to performing spinners by the ECB selectors

AUTHOR

2021-10-16T23:58:10+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


Wow, no idea. That was a scary typo!

2021-10-16T23:54:19+00:00

DaveJ

Roar Rookie


I didn’t trust my memory so had tried Google for James Swann: James Edward Swann, Jr. a.k.a. The Shotgun Stalker (born 1964), is an American serial killer whose random drive-by shotgun shootings in Washington, D.C. in 1993 earned him his nickname in the press.

AUTHOR

2021-10-16T23:33:02+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


The only reference I could find was the 4 day Australia A match which is starting on the 9th of December and the Lions fly back to England on the 16th. Not sure when or even where these games will be played. You're right about Parkinson. His County numbers are way better than both Bess & Leach. I'm guessing Bess is there for his batting as much as his bowling and Leach was the bridesmaid to Moeen Ali all English summer and was in better bowling form than Bess, so perhaps that's why he's there, but I'd be giving Parkinson a run in front of these guys for sure.

AUTHOR

2021-10-16T23:26:58+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


thanks Nudge. I'm hoping CA screens these practice matches, as they did last summer with the Australia A/India games. I'd like to see some of the Lions players in action.

2021-10-16T23:07:14+00:00

DaveJ

Roar Rookie


Any idea where to find the Ashes warm-up matches and the Lions fixtures Paul? I couldn’t see it in ECB or CA websites or the Roar, or a few other sites that Google sent me to. These A tours are a good idea all round. One four day and one three day game is pretty poor preparation. Parkinson’s figures are extremely impressive for a leggie in England – can’t believe they took two finger spinners ahead of him.

AUTHOR

2021-10-16T22:54:21+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


No idea why I typed James Swann? I was listening the Party Boys at the time, so might have been thinking of John Sawn? I reckon Foakes is the best keeper in England and one of the top 2 or 3 glovemen in the world, but he seems to be at number 3 in the pecking order, behind Buttler and Bairstow, simply because their selectors reckon these other two are better batsmen. Given both are averaging under 34 and Foakes is averaging over 31, I'm not sure that's a good call.

2021-10-16T22:49:35+00:00

Nudge

Roar Rookie


Yeah good read as always Paul. It seams like the England selectors have picked a safe squad, which is smart for any sporting team when you are entering a competition as favourites. But when you aren’t, you need to take risks with selection and game plan. England, clearly are the underdogs and I would have thought picking a safe squad is not real smart. Parkinson’s first class average is fantastic so I would have thought he would have been picked. Personally I would have started first up with Leach and get him to try and bowl dry, but you’d have Parkinson there ready to go. Mahmood as you mentioned should be there as well. Wood is the only one that can get it up to 145 clicks and he would be one of the most injury prone players in world cricket. Foakes is another that should be there and I think he will be the first one brought in from the lions. Pretty sure he was injured most of the English domestic season. He is the best keeper in England according to better judges then me and you wouldn’t want to be dropping a Smith Warner or Labuschagne early in their innings, and his first class record with the bat off the top of my head is as good as Bairstow and Butler. I’d be taking a slight risk and going with him. In saying that Butler always worries me be he never delivers. Anyway looking forward to the build up over the next 6 weeks

2021-10-16T20:20:30+00:00

badmanners

Roar Rookie


Thanks for the read Paul, might be Graeme Swann you were thinking of. I would like to see Foakes given a go as keeper rather than whichever JB is doing it nowadays, he'll contribute as many runs but far fewer byes and missed chances.

Read more at The Roar