'As far removed as you can get': Everything Bailey said on Marsh snub, Khawaja vs. Head, Pucovski's chances

By Tony Harper / Editor

Australia’s chief cricket selector George Bailey says he is leaning a particular way when it comes to the contentious No.5 spot for the Ashes team, but won’t reveal his hand just yet.

Bailey announced Tuesday a 15-man squad for the first Ashes Test at the Gabba next month with the key talking points a battle for the middle order place between Usman Khawaja and Travis Head, no place for Mitch Marsh and call ups for Jhye Richardson and Michael Neser.

Bailey told a news conference that he didn’t want to lock in a No.5, but was happy to confirm Marcus Harris would open the batting alongside David Warner.

“I really want to encourage us to have a squad mentality full stop,” said Bailey.
.
But Bailey also said the selectors wanted to show loyalty to players after selecting them for Brisbane, meaning they would stick with players to give them an extended run in the team.

Here’s everything he covered about the Test squad in the news conference

On the showdown between Khawaja and Head

“We’re starting to get pretty close to where we’re going to land on that,” Bailey said.

“I thought that might be the one of the questions that comes up out of naming both of those guys in the squad – but they’ve both started the year really well and finished the year really well. We know both could perform at Test level so we’re really positive on both fronts.

“We’re leaning towards one of them but the whole purpose of naming a squad is to have a squad there. So we’ll work through that much closer to the start of the first Test.”

The final decision will be made “the same way that we make any decision – around the runs they’ve been scoring, the form they’re in, the role that we expect them to play through the Test series.”

Bailey was asked outright to tell the media who was the frontrunner.

He smiled: “No, you’ll have nothing to write about tomorrow, then. I want to see where you guys land. Have a crack at it. It will make the Shield game a lot more exciting next week.”

Asked if Khawaja’s age could be a factor, Bailey replied: “That’s one of many, many factors. But I think for the here and now of trying to win this Ashes series it’s not particularly relevant.”

On the decision to leave out Mitch Marsh despite his T20 World Cup form

“I think T20 and Test cricket are about as far removed as you can get from a cricket format,” Bailey said.

“We’ve just got to be really careful about necessarily assuming that one will lead to the other.

(Photo by Michael Steele-ICC/ICC via Getty Images)

“But what I said about Mitch the other day, and I’ll say it again, is just how thrilled we are for him to have had the World Cup that he did. And to finish with the game he did in the final was just superb and great reward for the way that he’s prepared himself for the last couple of series for Australia.

“I’m just so excited about his next number of years. Hopefully injury concerns behind him and just the age he is.

“I think we should be seeing the best of Mitchell Marsh for the coming years and I’m really excited about what he can produce. We know he can play at the Test level so I’m excited that hopefully some of those performances will be in all three formats.”

On concern over bowlers’ readiness and fitness after T20 WC

“There’s not [concern], barring making sure that they’re ready for it,” Bailey said.

“The boys got back to the Gold Coast only recently so we’ll take stock there and see how they pulled up from that.

“There’s a really clear process for how they’re going to build up for this Ashes series. It’s not the first time that they’ve gone into a Test series with a less than ideal preparation or without any red ball cricket behind them. So it’s not new to them.

“They’re professionals, they’ll work through it and we’re expecting them all to be to be raring to go.

“There’s obviously enough data and analytics around which bowlers perform well at certain grounds and how they will match up together. There’s a whole raft of things that come into that. But first and foremost, it’s really about the preparation for those guys.

“Fast bowling is so physically challenging and there’s so many different factors that come into what you’re trying to put together when you put a bowling group together.

“It only takes one or two things to shift, and then it can have a bit of a flow on effect to how everything else looks as well.”

He said he was not trying to be coy around the bowling lineup but said there were many factors to consider.

“Given that the boys have just got back from the World Cup, they’re in quarantine, I don’t think they’ve even had a training session yet, so in terms of just taking stock and letting them build up over the next couple of weeks, it’s going to be really important,” Bailey said.

On annointing Marcus Harris to partner David Warner

“I really like Marcus Harris, he’s done everything that we’re asking in terms of scoring a mountain of domestic runs, he’s gone away, had a really good strong winter playing for Leicester as well,” Bailey said.

“So he just continues to do all the right things domestically. I’ll back up what I said the other day – we’d love nothing more than being able to back him in and give him an extended run up at the top of the order.

“We know how important opening partnerships are trying to find someone to forge a really strong relationship with David at the top is really important for our Test team.”

On the emergence of Jhye Richardson

“Getting excited by Jhye,” Bailey said. “Physically he looks as strong as I’ve ever seen him.

“I like the fact he’s had a couple of niggles yet he’s worked his way back from those so he’s starting to build some resilience into his body, which is still a young body.

“He’s worked his way into the last three Shield games quite nicely but one particular spell, I think it was the morning of day two at the Gabba, was a really impressive spell. He ended up getting the wickets of Marnus and Joe Burns, who both commented that it was impressive quality.”

On the progress of injured skipper Tim Paine

Paine just needs to “get some cricket under his belt, which we’re really confident he’s going to get,” said Bailey.

“From all reports surgery has gone really well, he’s feeling really confident.

“I think they’ve actually had to hold him back a little bit in the last couple of weeks to make sure the actual healing process has gone well, and now it’s just a matter of actually getting some game time under his belt. So he’s really confident and really excited to be leading the team come the first day at the Gabba.”

On Will Pucovski

Bailey was asked if the Victorian opener could play any part in the Ashes.

“It’s probably unlikely,” Bailey replied.

“He hasn’t played any cricket up until this point. It’s a really big step to process for him.

“It’s about getting symptom free and feeling good physically. And then secondly, it’s about just putting together a batch of games.

“I think if you look back over his last couple of years, it’s been really hard for him to get that body of work together. My chats with him, is first and foremost, get yourself right and look after yourself.

“And then secondly, I’m not that concerned about what he’s playing. I’d love to see him playing some grade cricket. I’d love to see him playing some state cricket. I’d just love to see him playing a lot of cricket and really getting some confidence that he can put together a string of games.

“You’ve got to have a bit of body of work to know that he was up for it. I’m not discounting the fact of how talented he is.”

On the pick and stick selection mentality

Bailey said he would love to think that the selectors could stick firm and give players an extended opportunity.

“I think once you’ve made those decisions, it’s important to give guys an opportunity,” said Bailey.

“We know that Test cricket is hard. And if you’re riding each and every innings then I think A: it puts the players under enormous pressure and B: that’s just the yin and yang of the game.

“One of the other reasons for naming to the end of Adelaide is there’s a little bit of uncertainty still around what the summer is going to look like and one of the things we learned from last year was wherever possible if we can provide players the opportunity to to get back and play some cricket rather than just being part of the squad and not playing at all, that’s important for them.”

The Crowd Says:

2021-12-04T08:30:25+00:00

Curmudgeon1961

Roar Rookie


I do agree about Bailey's place on batting merit but outside of Cummins it is pretty ordinary for leadership in the Test squad. And re the actual article why this love slash hype for Puckovski ? He gets donged because he used to playing on roads and his technique is crap. I know he is probably a nice young man.

2021-11-19T03:19:50+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


Long term captain at Subiaco in a stack of flags then appointed as coach at Claremont the year after and led them to a flag. Has been an excellent assistant coach at Freo including development roles. His wife also played for Freo then went on to assist as a coach there. There'd be a fair bit of footy in their world. He is a Port Melbourne player originally so it all looks like a good fit. He'll be a players' coach much in the ilk of Ash Hansen.

2021-11-19T03:10:05+00:00

Chanon

Roar Rookie


Don, what’s Marc Webb like as coach he’s been installed as mid & stoppage coach at dogs?

2021-11-18T19:32:25+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


what concerns me is the way CA isn't dealing with this concussion issue If Puckovski had badly injured the same arm, leg, hand or foot a dozen times, it's almost guaranteed he would not be even chance to play first-class cricket. He's had far more severe injuries to a much more vulnerable part of the body and everyone's saying "when can he be ready for Test cricket and face seriously quick bowlers again?"

2021-11-18T13:32:09+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


No reason it can't happen

2021-11-18T13:17:42+00:00

Chanon

Roar Rookie


He’s a midget but he has some mongrel

2021-11-18T13:15:58+00:00

Chanon

Roar Rookie


Damn shame he was earmarked as a future captain, long career as opener most likely never to occur. Selectors are hell bent on making sure he’s recovered & playing shield if he could string a season without any hiccups the selectors will play him in 22/23’

2021-11-18T12:49:30+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


We were.

2021-11-18T11:58:59+00:00

DaveJ

Roar Rookie


We are?

2021-11-18T11:57:49+00:00

DaveJ

Roar Rookie


Didn’t have that problem but often have an issue with getting to the reply when I get a notification.

2021-11-18T11:55:50+00:00

DaveJ

Roar Rookie


Hope so!

2021-11-18T10:19:38+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


We all know that. It's actually not his problem. That's the stereotypical reading. I did indicate the history of his concussions include incidents other than batting.

2021-11-18T09:33:29+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


yeah, but there's injuries like shoulder dislocations or broken fingers from keeping...then there's permanent brain damage.

2021-11-18T09:25:19+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


At some point soon, WP stops being he "emerging talent" and rapidly becomes a huge problem for CA. I'd reckon he has maybe this season and next to sort out his health issues or CA needs to walk away and make sure he's not involved in any cricket they manage. He won't be the first player that had to give the game away thanks to injury at a young age.

2021-11-18T09:02:30+00:00

Ed Gein

Roar Rookie


No problem. He takes his eye off the ball when he ducks under the high ball. This is not how you’re coached to play this deilvery. He’s actually had 10 concussions (he’s only just turned 23) I can’t think of another international standard batsman who has had more the 3-4 concussions in an entire career. Two former Australian captains (Taylor and Clarke) have also expressed grave concern for him in recent times – Taylor also suggesting a possible technique issue (there’s a WWOS article out there). This week Keegan Hipgrave retired at 24 after suffering 5 concussions in the last 3 seasons of NRL. If you think Pucovski with 10 (that we know off) should keep going without some dramatic changes to his game, I don’t know what to say.

2021-11-18T06:20:21+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


Oh OK. Yeah I reckon he can still extract swing even on grounds where swing isn't obvious. He's not a huge exponent of seam, but he also has a great yorker and his pace and skiddish balls when full, are a handful. It's his lower delivery height that opens batsmen up for LBWs or through the gate. Goodness help the England batsmen if they don't adjust their typical back foot play / back in the crease, approach. There will be a few LBs and bowleds I reckon if they get to face him, even where swing isn't prevalent. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e_G6SWzmOls

2021-11-18T06:07:37+00:00

DaveJ

Roar Rookie


No, I meant that while swing is his strength, the ball doesn’t seem to swing much on Australian grounds in recent years after the first few overs. Except maybe under lights.

2021-11-18T05:56:41+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


What's going on with the site today? I click on multiple "reply" notifications and I keep getting taken to the same reply. I click on "like" notifications and it takes me to comments with no likes? Is it just me or anybody else having the same issue?

2021-11-18T05:44:26+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


“I think T20 and Test cricket are about as far removed as you can get from a cricket format,” Good stuff then that our front line Test pace attack is also our front line T20i pace attack. -- Gee, don't agree Jhye lacks swing. That's his weapon. Or do you mean there is lack of swing at the grounds? He's got a solid record at most Aus grounds. His lack of height and bounce gets those swinging balls coming in low and fast. Will do well at Brisbane and Adelaide. Would do well at the WACA, though Perth Stadium is an unknown. MCG and SCG I think will be his weaker venues, as they are with Starc mostly.

2021-11-18T05:36:42+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


If this was NRL or AFL, I'd expect the club would be running a mile by this stage - would be delisting him and paying out his contract. I guess there must be medical advice behind all of this, but seems to me CA - and Cricket Victoria - are on a very slippery slope re duty-of-care obligations if they keep selecting him. And this isn't a personal attack on WP, but just from a team balance/certainty perspective, he's a real liability now unfortunately. I just don't see how this can keep going on season after season.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar