NRL News: Collins faces season-ending ban but NAS, Radley, JWH to escape with fines, Hasler doesn't fear Manly axe

By The Roar / Editor

Sydney Roosters prop Lindsay Collins may not play in the NRL again this season after being charged by the NRL for a hip drop tackle on Melbourne’s Tom Eisenhuth.

Collins is looking at a four-game ban after being hit with a grade three charge – his third offence of the year.

If Collins were to fight the charge and lose at the judiciary he would receive a five-game suspension.

With a round-25 game against South Sydney next week, the only way Collins could play again this year is if he takes the early guilty plea and the Roosters reach the grand final, or he heads to the judiciary and fights to have the charge downgraded.

Coach Trent Robinson declined to discuss the incident after Friday’s 18-14 win.

The prop, who was in his first game back from concussion, was not the only Roosters player facing a nervous wait on Saturday.

Thankfully for Robinson, Jared Waerea-Hargreaves will escape with a $3,000 fine for appearing to lead with his head at Nelson Asofa-Solomona when the Storm forward was on the ground.

Asofa-Solomona was also charged and likewise will get away with a $3,000 fine after appearing to put his elbow near the face of young Roosters winger Joseph Suaalii.

The concerns don’t end there for the Roosters with star lock Victor Radley knocked out in a sickening collision with Storm captain Jesse Bromwich.

Radley attempted to tackle Bromwich but ran into his hip and was left convulsing on the field, before being taken off on a stretcher.

Lindsay Collins. (Photo by Brett Hemmings/Getty Images)

The lock was able to gather and celebrate with teammates post-game but will receive an $1800 fine for making dangerous contact with Jahrome Hughes.

“Victor is Victor – he is back in there (the locker room) and remembers everything about the game except that tackle, but it didn’t look good on the field,” Robinson said.

Roosters winger Daniel Tupou opened the scoring with a try in the left corner, but his joy was short-lived.

Tupou left the field less than 10 minutes later with a groin injury, casting doubt on his availability for the finals.

The 31-year-old has a history of groin issues and Robinson admitted the injury was a major concern for the Roosters.

Des Hasler not afraid of sack despite Krilich claims

Manly coach Des Hasler says calls for his axing don’t faze him, encouraging his critics to “line up”.

While the Sea Eagles’ season has fallen to pieces in losing five straight games – including their last three by a combined 70 points – Hasler maintained spirits hadn’t dropped in his dressing room as they approach Saturday’s encounter with Canberra.

Former Manly captain Max Krilich led the charge against Hasler earlier this week, telling News Corp his tactics were “stale” and the two-time premiership coach had “probably had his time”.

Hasler downplayed the comments and backed himself in to get the side headed in the right direction.

(Photo by Matt King/Getty Images)

“It’s just another one – line up,” he told reporters. “Those things will be rolled out, so Max is entitled to his opinion, he’s a good fella.

“But 12 months ago, Max was, I’m sure, pretty excited about the way the side was going, where the club was headed. I can just let Max know that obviously clubs go through difficult times, so it will come through this okay.”

Manly skiper Daly Cherry-Evans insisted earlier this week the side’s problems weren’t to do with their support of Hasler and the coach agreed, pointing to their injury crisis as responsible for their late-season woes.

“Without making excuses, there were 13 (players) on the sidelines, it’s been made a bit more difficult from that point of view,” he said.

“We’ve injected some young players to get the taste of experience and they’re just working with a few things to gain experience like that this weekend to make sure we can feel solid and competitive.”

Flegler out of hospital after throat scare

Brisbane prop Tom Flegler has escaped suspension and is out of hospital but coach Kevin Walters still has plenty of headaches after what he called a “terrible” night at the office.

The Broncos will slip out of the NRL top eight if Canberra beats Manly on Saturday after a dire night all-round display in the 53-6 loss to Parramatta at Suncorp Stadium on Thursday night.

Flegler was rushed to hospital when he left the field in the second half clutching his throat.

“He copped an elbow to a throat. He couldn’t breathe and was having trouble,” Walters said.

Flegler returned to Suncorp Stadium a couple of hours after the match after being released from hospital.

“I’m all good,” he told AAP,  before returning to spend the night at his home.

Flegler was at Broncos HQ with the physiotherapist on Friday morning and was later resting at home.

Broncos head of performance David Ballard said Flegler could still be available for the Dragons.

“We will see how he recovers over the next few days before determining how he shapes up for next week’s game,” he said.

Flegler had earlier been put on report for what the match officials deemed a shoulder charge on Reagan Campbell-Gillard, but the match review committee  adjudged it to be dangerous contact instead and Flegler will pay a fine of $1000 with an early plea.

Star Broncos halfback Adam Reynolds and forward Kobe Hetherington both failed to return from HIA tests against the Eels while centre Brenko Lee re-aggravated a lower leg injury and will have a scan.

Walters was hopeful Reynolds and Hetherington would be fit to play against St George Illawarra in the final round clash that the Broncos must win if they are to play finals football. “He’s just got to pass all the tests with the protocols,” Walters said.

The Broncos have conceded 189 points in the last five weeks.

“I’m not going to make any excuses. It is just not good enough,” Walters said.

Back-rower Kurt Capewell said the season had started with a defensive focus. “We’ve definitely seen it slip the last few weeks,” he said. “Once something goes against us … teams are putting a big score on us. We’ve got a fair bit to fix, and a week to do that.”

Walters said centre Herbie Farnworth was “an outside chance” of returning next week from a biceps injury.

Prop Pat Carrigan will return from suspension against the Dragons and winger Selwyn Cobbo is expected to play after sitting out the Eels clash due to fatigue.

Meanwhile Eels forward Campbell-Gillard was charged with a shoulder charge on Jordan Riki but will escape with a $3000 fine if he takes the early plea.

Payten keen to extend Cowboys deal

Todd Payten is certain a new NRL coaching deal will soon be negotiated to keep him at North Queensland.

The Cowboys are preparing for their first finals campaign under Payten, who signed a three-year contract in mid 2020 after steering the Warriors for 14 games in their first COVID affected season in Australia. 

In his maiden season as head coach in Townsville, the Cowboys struggled with injuries and slumped to their fourth consecutive bottom-four finish.

But after blooding some of their now exceptional younger talent late in 2021, his side has flipped the script on a season where they were tipped to struggle again.

They are now just two wins away from securing two home finals in September.

Payten has one year remaining on his contract after this season and said while he’s yet to enter negotiations with the club is confident it’ll get sorted in due course.

“The club are well aware of how much I love the town and the club,” he said on Friday.

“That’ll get sorted when the time is right and I’ve got no doubt that it will.”

When asked whether he would prefer a short or long-term deal, Payten was not without his regular dry humour.

(Photo by Ian Hitchcock/Getty Images)

“As most money for as long as possible,” he quipped.

Although the forthcoming finals series will be his first as head coach, Payten brings with him premiership-winning experience as an assistant.

He was a deputy to the late Paul Green when the Cowboys triumphed in 2015 against Brisbane alongside South Sydney coach Jason Demetriou, whose side his team will meet this weekend in a must-win clash.

Both sides will look to boast their premiership credentials at Accor stadium on Saturday with the Cowboys looking to keep a strangehold on second place on the ladder.

They are tied with Cronulla on 34 points but have a superior for and against, which will be the difference should both sides win their final two matches. 

For the Rabbitohs last week’s loss to Penrith has them looking over their shoulder at the ninth-placed Raiders to maintain their spot in the eight with a clash against cross-town rivals the Sydney Roosters in round 25. 

The Cowboys can finish their season with a winning record in their travels to Sydney should they see-off Demetriou’s side, with a clash against minor premiers Penrith in the final round. 

Johns warns Dragons over Hunt-Griffin clause

Immortal halfback Andrew Johns has called on St George Illawarra to stand firm in light of a request from Ben Hunt for his contract extension to be tied to coach Anthony Griffin’s future.

Hunt has publicly stated he wants to continue at the Dragons until the end of 2025 and he wants Griffin to remain as coach. They are both off contract at the end of next season.

Johns, when asked whether he would entertain a clause in Hunt’s contract which gives him a get-out option if Griffin is no longer coach, said: “No. Not a chance” on his Freddy and The Eighth podcast with Brad Fittler.

“If Hook goes, he’s going to go. Your captain or your player doesn’t decide who’s the coach.

“I can understand his loyalty. A lot of those players came through the Brisbane system when they won the under 20s [under Griffin]. Obviously they’ve got that relationship but you cannot be dictating to the club that if the coach goes, you go.”

(Photo by Jason McCawley/Getty Images)

The Dolphins and potentially the Titans could make a multimillion-dollar play for Hunt if the Dragons do not increase their extension offer, reportedly around $750,000 per season.

Johns said his value is upwards of $900,000 to $1 million per season “when you see what other halves are getting”. 

Fittler disagreed, pointing to the team’s poor record of just one finals campaign with Hunt at halfback, saying he was worth around the $800,000 ballpark.

The NSW coach said he would like to see Hunt stay to help bring Jayden Sullivan through into the NRL.

Tolman wants to go out ‘on a high note’

Veteran Cronulla prop Aiden Tolman has announced his decision to retire from rugby league.

The 33-year-old, who is the eldest and most experienced player in the NRL with 314 games under his belt, said he only came to the decision earlier this week.

His retirement call follows the decision of teammate and fellow front-rower Andrew Fifita on Tuesday to leave the club at the end of the season.

Tolman made his debut in 2008 for Melbourne and enjoyed a 10-year stint at Canterbury before linking with the Sharks in 2019.

“It’s probably only in the last 48 hours I got that answer,” Tolman said. “I want to go out here on a high note.

“I know the time is right and I’d much rather go out being happy and winning games.”

Tolman, who was born and raised on the NSW mid-north coast, said he hoped to move into a development role in country NSW. 

The Sharks host Tolman’s old club Canterbury on Saturday as they aim to wrap up a top-two spot and secure a home semi-final. 

var request = new XMLHttpRequest();

request.open('POST', '/wp-admin/admin-ajax.php', true); request.setRequestHeader('Content-Type', 'application/x-www-form-urlencoded;'); request.onload = function () { if (this.status >= 200 && this.status

The Crowd Says:

2022-08-28T22:51:46+00:00

uglykiwi

Roar Pro


No comments on Munster's hit on Walker? Thought, fine at minimum. If Walker stays down, Roosters get penalty.... But plays on as he's not instructed to try and milk penalties like the Storm players!

2022-08-28T22:09:01+00:00

Glory Bound

Roar Rookie


Thanks to a clear obstruction TRY that ended up being the difference between the two teams. "He [Ivan Cleary] used to work for them. He used to work for the referees before returning to coaching. I have assume he has some mates there still" - Wayne Bennett

2022-08-28T14:00:32+00:00

Westie

Guest


Of course JWH & Asofa-Solomona walk away with just fines . That’s all they ever get. Foul play doesn’t apply to them .

2022-08-28T13:56:08+00:00

Panthers

Guest


The Panthers looked alright versus South Sydney.

2022-08-28T04:06:25+00:00

Bloke7

Roar Rookie


If JWH were Corey Waddell he'd get 4 weeks for those fingers al lover the eyes and face. Much worse aggression than what Corey did, once over the eyes and twice over the jaw and mouth.

2022-08-28T02:14:22+00:00

Hard Yards

Roar Rookie


:laughing:

2022-08-27T08:28:00+00:00

Tony

Roar Guru


And he wouldn't lower himself

2022-08-27T07:14:55+00:00

Glory Bound

Roar Rookie


He doesn't fumble the ball often enough and he can't kick a ball mate. :silly:

2022-08-27T07:10:23+00:00

Hard Yards

Roar Rookie


I agree. He’s great for the game but he is injury prone. He would have done well in the AFL.

2022-08-27T06:29:34+00:00

Adam

Guest


Collins has got at least 4 wks and he is a rooster. Radley also has served time before. But fully agree on jwh, couldn't get a more perfect dream run at the match review. Needs to be consistency and given some time on the sideline. Would hurt the roosters but fair is fair

2022-08-27T05:49:25+00:00

Tony

Roar Guru


Hope they haven't given up their day jobs

2022-08-27T05:48:14+00:00

Glory Bound

Roar Rookie


Pity Turbo has had such a bad run with injuries. Like Latrell, the game needs him on the field not sitting on the sidelines.

2022-08-27T05:44:23+00:00

Relaxed and Comfortable

Guest


Hate to think mate! Their combined fines could bankroll the stadium rebuilds across Sydney.

2022-08-27T05:42:16+00:00

Hard Yards

Roar Rookie


Yes. But I would be building a team assuming no Turbo. He hasn't played much.

2022-08-27T05:22:30+00:00

Tony

Roar Guru


I wonder what it would actually take for either JWH or NAS to be either sent off or suspended?

2022-08-27T05:10:55+00:00

Pete

Guest


How on earth does NAS get off with a fine again for driving his elbow into a players head? He did it just a few weeks ago and still he gets just a fine? Ridiculous decision.

2022-08-27T04:18:48+00:00

Glory Bound

Roar Rookie


To be fair mate Manly were anything but a rabble last year in their run to a preliminary final with Dally M Player of the Year Tommy Turbo stoking their fire... before the Rabbitohs emphatically put that fire out in the preliminary final.

2022-08-27T04:15:14+00:00

Glory Bound

Roar Rookie


Although Manly could use some key signings in certain areas there is no doubt that Turbo's absence has had a devastating effect on Manly's fortunes this season. Just like how Latrell Mitchell's return turned the Rabbitohs season around. Look at how Nathan Cleary's absence has influenced the Panthers loss of form. The same would be true of Mitchell Moses from the Eels, James Tedesco from the Roosters or Adam Reynolds from the Rabbitohs Broncos.

2022-08-27T04:09:38+00:00

Glory Bound

Roar Rookie


It appears that the NRL are only concerned for player welfare on the offensive side of the ball.

2022-08-27T04:07:20+00:00

Glory Bound

Roar Rookie


Ben Hunt owes a lot to Barney Rubble (Griffin). What other coach would have paid him $1 mill a season to underperform for 4 years of a 5-year contract? Of course it's the measure of the man that he should coast along in the background for 4 years and save his best Dally M form for the last year of his contract. Perhaps the timing was coincidental. But I don't buy it.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar