REACTION: Bans loom for Kangaroos duo after shoulder charges tarnish one of the best Tests of all time

By The Roar / Editor

Kangaroos forwards Liam Martin and Tino Fa’asuamaleaui could be banned for the World Cup final after they rocked New Zealand with shoulder charges which left commentators bemused and Kiwi fans fuming.

The epic semi-final at Elland Road will be remembered as one of the most intense clashes at international level of all time with Australia and New Zealand producing a high-octane 80 minute performance which featured several lead changes and brilliance in attack and defence.

However, the hits by Martin and Fa’asuamaleaui were questionable at best and the World Cup match review committee will scrutinise whether they should cop bans before next weekend’s final against the winner of the England vs Samoa semi.

Australia emerged victorious 16-14 on the back of a Cameron Murray try in an otherwise scoreless second half after the Kiwis held a 14-10 advantage at half-time.

CLICK HERE for a seven-day free trial for your favourite sport on KAYO

Fox League analyst Cooper Cronk said “a couple of class plays from the Australians got them the win”.

(Photo by Alex Livesey/Getty Images for RLWC)

Martin hit Kiwis prop Nelson Asofa-Solomona with a shoulder charge in the 59th minute which forced the ball loose and led to a melee involving several players from each team. At one stage Martin was being roughed up by Panthers teammate James Fisher-Harris as club loyalties were set aside but no punches were thrown.

He made another hit on JFH a few minutes later which looked to have no arm wrapping motion which could also earn a sanction from the match reviewers.

The Fa’asuamaleaui incident happend in the 65th minute when he launched his right shoulder into Charnze Nicoll-Klokstad as he tried to ruck it out from his own line.

“After the earlier ones maybe they feel as if they’ve got the green light. We thought the Martin shot on Asofa-Solomona probably was (a shoulder charge) and they think well if we can get away with that, let’s try our luck with another one,” Fox League commentator Andrew Voss said.

“It’s certainly not a conventional tackle if you want the arms going in. They’ve disguised it well.”

(Photo by Alex Livesey/Getty Images for RLWC)

Kangaroos coach Mal Meninga said it was great to see top-class Test footy back on the biggest stage after more than two years being lost due to the COVID-19 pandemic.

“It was fantastic. That was Test match football. It was good to have it back. We had to fight hard. New Zealand, they threw everything bar the kitchen sink at us and I thought we handled it really well,” he said.

“I thought we used our skill a lot better tonight. We created plenty of opportunities, they created plenty of opportunities. Scrambling defence, desperation, commitment, all those characteristics you want in Test match footy came out tonight.

“It’s right up there (as one of the best Tests), there’s no doubt about that. It was a great challenge for both sides. I thought both sides handled it really well. It was a great advertisement for the game.

“We’ll have a review on our game, I certainly think we can play better.”

On the match itself, Voss summed it up superbly at full-time.

“World Cup, world stage, world class. Both teams, an effort that was worthy of being rewarded with a finals appearance,” he said.

Kiwi forward Brandon Smith, who was exhausted after not being interchanged, paid the price for being slow in defence in what turned out to be Murray’s match-winning try and Cronk said that was what cost the New Zealand in the end.

“He just didn’t get off the line at all,” Cronk said. “Brandon Smith, for a guy who moves and accelerates on every play, he was caught on his heels and was resting. He’d been playing for long minutes. He was tired and he basically just cost the game a little bit there because Cam Murray just went through where he should have been standing.”

Kangaroos centre Latrell Mitchell said the team had put “a lot of effort and sacrifice to come over here”.

“We left our families six weeks ago to achieve something, our collective goal and we’re one step away from achieving that,” he said.

“For me it’s something to tick off, I didn’t come over to the other side of the world to not achieve that. The job’s not done.”

New Zealand coach Michael Maguire was visibly moved and said “there’s a fair bit of emotion at the moment” in his camp when interviewed soon after full-time.

“Moments in games, they win you Test matches and unfortunately we just didn’t capitalise on a couple of them there,” he said.

“We can’t look back, the result’s the result. One thing I do know is the boys have closed the gap on where we’ve been and where we are as a group now. It could have gone our way but unfortunately the bounce of the ball in that corner there was there (to decide the game).

“I’m really proud of my players. I’m abslutely gutted for them.”

The Crowd Says:

2022-11-14T07:29:47+00:00

Richard POWELL

Roar Rookie


Forget about shoulder charges. It looks like head highs are being swept under the carpet for the WC

2022-11-14T02:40:19+00:00

boognish

Guest


You aussies can't win against the kiwis without an aussi ref. league is the Only international sporting event without a neutral ref, but very luckily for aus ashley was the man of the match for ignoring yellow card offences, not giving a yellow when required and var ing EVERY nz try possible.

2022-11-13T14:02:59+00:00

Tim Carter

Roar Pro


If the backline is set and Cleary has the ball, do you really think he sees Wighton, has a recollection that Jack has the number 10 on his back, and decides not to pass it to him because that's a number that a prop normally wears??? The players know who each other are. We all agree that the numbering is dumb, but it's been over a month now. Can we all finally just move on?!

2022-11-13T09:45:02+00:00

Choppy Zezers

Roar Rookie


League fans blaming a ref is hardly a new concept. And many footy fans lack of knowledge on the laws is also not a new concept. Just listen to the Fox commentary team and you'll get all your examples there.

2022-11-13T02:31:26+00:00

Maxtruck

Roar Rookie


Cairns Kangaroos Trinity Bay High Kirwan State High Townsville ( defeated Westfields Sports High NRL schools cup 2019) Qld Cup Northern Pride Cairns NQ Cowboys Qld State of Origin 2022 Aust World Cup 2022 I think he is eligible for Qld!

2022-11-13T02:09:34+00:00

Maxtruck

Roar Rookie


Why ? Neither tackled player went of injured or for a HAI No penalties awarded The NZ forwards gave as good as they got Its a world cup semi final, not under 6s Play on

2022-11-12T22:20:42+00:00

Maxtruck

Roar Rookie


So then "JennyFromPenny". If you are the head of the IRL, who are you appointing to ref the final?

2022-11-12T21:42:51+00:00

Maxtruck

Roar Rookie


Cleary's preference to go right limited Mitchells chances, And I think we did not play with enough depth in attack, crowding our own backs repeatedly. If we could have got the ball to Mitchell or Wighton 5m from the defenders they would have gone straight over the NZ centers.

2022-11-12T11:35:03+00:00

Rob

Guest


Nah Tamou being in the NZ World Cup training squad and then pulling on a Blue Jersey a couple of months later was contortionists stuff. Wasn’t Nagas from Bowraval somewhere?

2022-11-12T11:19:29+00:00

JennyFromPenny

Guest


Curiously, their most common nickname, from so many footy fans often not convinced they are from the same planet.

2022-11-12T10:42:35+00:00

Choppy Zezers

Roar Rookie


If every ref was sacked for real or perceived howlers, there would he fewer league ref's than there are wombats on Jupiter

2022-11-12T10:36:28+00:00

Choppy Zezers

Roar Rookie


It would be the epitome of irony if a player is suspended for a tackle on NAS

2022-11-12T09:51:50+00:00

Tim Buck 3

Roar Rookie


ACT players have also helped Qld be more competitive. Mal Meninga from Qld and Laurie Daley from Junee. The best example of eligibility flexibility is Greg Inglis of Bowraville, NSW.

2022-11-12T09:50:18+00:00

Phantom

Roar Rookie


They should have been sent off.

2022-11-12T09:13:45+00:00

JennyFromPenny

Guest


Is the only workplace known where incompetence never leads to an exit door. The only penalty they've ever received for repeated shockers is a weekend's relief of duties, paid to sit on a couch. Klein, 100%, is now the ref for the final. imo he should have never blown another whistle, past his over-influencing involvement in the Tigers-Cowboys game.

2022-11-12T08:02:46+00:00

Tony

Roar Guru


He just loves the sound of his own voice

2022-11-12T07:55:32+00:00

T

Guest


That’s not what I saw re NZ. I saw NZ constantly looking for the offload while Oz looked a bit disjointed and scared to make a mistake (like you say). The only reason this game was close is because Oz were average. I’d play DCE for the final.

2022-11-12T07:51:37+00:00

T

Guest


We lost the World Cup to NZ because of a massive Slater blunder remember. Not saying this team is better. It’s not. It’s the weakest Oz team I can remember. I’m not sure Yeo and Cleary the best for Oz. This isn’t club footy and I found Yeo taking too much control.

2022-11-12T07:47:28+00:00

T

Guest


Surely you jest. The BBC coverage and commentary is bloody shocking. Even when thee games doesn’t involve England they find a way to talk about them. The coverage of the game in terms of cameras etc is also poor compared to the coverage on Fox. .

2022-11-12T07:23:29+00:00

criag

Roar Rookie


Yes, seemed obvious he didn't touch it, but he kept going on and on about it, as they do. "I'm not convinced he didn't touch it!"....well, that's a shame, just call the game!

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar