Say what you will about the Windies, but they've got plenty of ticker

By Tim Miller / Editor

The West Indies will not win this Test. Hell, it’ll take a minor miracle for them to even draw it.

But while the scoreboard makes for ugly reading – particularly with the ball – the tourists have at least ensured, after a second consecutive strong start with the bat, that they will leave Perth with dignity intact ahead of the day-night second Test in Adelaide which will surely feature more favourable bowling conditions.

Any positives do need to be taken with a grain of salt given they’ve taken just six wickets and conceded 780 runs in the process, and it’s impossible to ignore the fact that this is, talent-wise, one of the weakest teams to tour these shores in many a year.

They could easily have folded into oblivion, though, after that disastrous first innings; instead, they’ve gamely fought on despite their limitations and ensured a plodding, at times difficult to watch Test at least makes it through to a fifth and final day.

It’s the little wins with West Indies cricket at the moment that need focussing on, and on a personal note, it’s a nice feeling to be writing something with a positive slant after four days of whingeing and moaning about everything from the pitch to David Warner’s form.

We’ll start with the centurion, captain Kraigg Brathwaite; the Windies’ most impressive player in both innings and probably the team’s only genuine international-calibre batter.

Brathwaite’s Test average of a tick over 35 is a sign of his limitations at the highest level – indeed, he certainly wouldn’t have played 80 Tests had he been born just about anywhere else in the world – though it’s worth noting that through his career, the Caribbean has statistically been the most difficult place to open the batting in the world.

He can sometimes look ungainly, and he doesn’t possess a shot that makes you sit back and marvel. He’s an accumulator more than a plunderer, as evidenced by only hitting 11 boundaries in his century on Day 4.

It was the running between the wickets, and his ability to push good balls into gaps, that made this innings. Doing those well enough to push his strike rate up unto the 60s, when his career mark sits at 40, would have been commendable on the first day of the match, never mind after four exhausting days in the field, having spent just 44 overs in the sheds since the start of play on Wednesday.

Captaining an impotent bowling attack can’t be easy either, but Brathwaite never gave in, persisted with attacking fields on Days 1 and 2 despite yielding precious few rewards, and probably only let the game drift early on the second day when his bowlers began to truly let him down.

With 64 in the first innings and now with a chance for a ‘daddy’ hundred on day 5 – this pitch isn’t the road it was on Day 1, but neither is it offering anywhere near enough for this stage of a game – the 30-year old (he celebrated his birthday on Thursday) has blunted an attack now shorn of Pat Cummins but still blessed with three bowlers with more than 200 Test wickets.

His 11th Test century would surely have to be regarded as his finest, given both the situation of the game, the quality of the opposition, making it in foreign, international conditions and in the fourth innings of a match for the first time.

Marnus Labuschagne is a monty for player of the match, but no one in Perth has enhanced their reputation more than Brathwaite.

Kraigg Brathwaite of the West Indies celebrates his century. (Photo by James Worsfold/Getty Images)

Even gutsier, if less eye-catching on the scorecard, was Brathwaite’s opening partner Tagenarine Chanderpaul. Debuting in an overseas Test against Cummins, Hazlewood, Starc and co. is hardly a cushy start to the international arena, but at no point this match has he looked anything short of international standard.

It’s a lofty comparison after one Test, but while obviously he will forever be associated, and judged alongside, his famous father Shivnarine, there’s a bit of Justin Langer about him. Early-days Langer more than the later-career destroyer of worlds with Matthew Hayden, to be clear: wearing blows to the body, at times surviving rather than thriving, but always there, always fighting, but talent shining through with every brutally played pull short or immaculately timed cover drive.

West Indies first-class wickets are much lower and slower these days than this Perth offering, but at no stage did he look uncomfortable with the conditions. In a baptism of fire, he emerged from the flames slightly singed but undoubtedly stronger for the experience.

In time, he’ll learn that at international level, judging which balls outside off to chase and which to leave requires one’s entire focus. Particularly in the second innings, his half-hearted waft outside off that saw his stumps splattered off the inside edge by Starc looked ungainly, and probably cost him a significant milestone of twin half-centuries on debut.

Nevertheless, the spot as Brathwaite’s opening partner should, and will be, his for the foreseeable future.

It was likewise good to see Jermaine Blackwood restrain his usual urge to slog everything he can reach to play controlled, measured innings (for the most part) both times this Test. It’s the bare minimum, but impatience is something the Windies in their current state simply can’t afford from one of their senior batsmen. Putting on half-century partnerships with Brathwaite in both innings, he’s a key reason, though not as large as the openers, why the Windies still have a puncher’s chance of escaping this Test with a draw.

It’s the most minor of details, but I also have great respect for the decision by Kyle Mayers, after a first-innings failure, to not call for a nightwatchman and face the final overs of the day himself.

Sure, if he’d have got out he’d have been derided, and looked a goose to boot, but you’d have forgiven him for not particularly wanting to go out there at the worst of times to bat. He did, safely negotiated three balls, and no tailenders were harmed in the process.

With the ball, there has been even less to crow about, but Jayden Seales looks a talent, Kemar Roach and Alzarri Joseph gave a red-hot Labuschagne a real test early on Day 4 (except for THAT no ball, of course), and Jason Holder is as honest as the day is long, and could be a threat under the lights in Adelaide.

You couldn’t say that the future is bright for West Indian cricket; with every passing generation, the talent pool grows thinner, the bowlers less formidable, and their chances of a return to glory slimmer.

But having been no chance at winning this game since basically tea on Day 1, they’re now three sensible sessions of batting away from a commendable draw. They’re low on talent, but this team has plenty of ticker.

The Crowd Says:

2022-12-05T05:37:15+00:00

Chanon

Roar Rookie


He can field & he can bat but not to the standard required but……. he can bloody bowl, worth the punt when the Goat retires.

2022-12-05T05:19:07+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


In red ball cricket, yeah...although I reckon they'll go Swepson first. Can't pick Agar or Zampa until they play some red ball stuff. Pity Murphy can't bat or field.

2022-12-05T01:46:02+00:00

qwetzen

Roar Rookie


Only if we had another Gilly in the pipeline! Look, Gilly is a fine man. Honest, hard-working, articulate and a terrific batsman to watch. I just wish he'd never played cricket. Watching the best keeper in the land used to be a feature of a Test for me, but now, thanks largely to him, the selection principle of picking the best keeper has gone the way of the leather-soled cricket boot.

2022-12-05T01:29:03+00:00

qwetzen

Roar Rookie


I've seen a fair bit of Murphy this season, he's a serious prospect. Possibly the only finger spinner in Oz who can try for either edge. He has a nice touch of aggression too, and not just in his bowling. He gave excellent return serves to Henriques after MH sledged him in I4.

2022-12-05T01:17:32+00:00

Chanon

Roar Rookie


Don if Lyon went down with a injury me thinks Todd Murphy would debut :stoked:

2022-12-05T00:37:23+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


I wonder what Nick Hockley's kids play like.

2022-12-05T00:36:22+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


We do. We have about 5 Gillys, including Carey. One day folk will realise that Ashton Agar is a batsman who bowls well...and that Joel Paris is a Shield centurion and that Matt Kelly and Jhye Richardson can bat and Corey Rocchiccioli scored 50 in 30 balls in the Shield final. Just have 4 specialist batsmen, 2 all rounders and the rest bowlers who can score 20 to 50.

2022-12-04T22:33:21+00:00

Chanon

Roar Rookie


Don at the moment Hardie is the better batsman but Sutherland is the better bowler. It depends in future series if the selectors prefer a batsman/bowler or the reverse but in order to nail No.6 they would prefer a batsman all rounder. Sutherland can still develop into a quality player for Australia in test cricket, hard to know if at 6 or 7 or even at 8. Only if we had another Gilly in the pipeline!

2022-12-04T21:07:37+00:00

Munro Mike

Roar Rookie


Both W.Sutherland and A.Sutherland are starting to emerge. Very good for Australian cricket both mens ad womens.

2022-12-04T21:04:01+00:00

Munro Mike

Roar Rookie


actually wasn't thinking Melbourne. In the drawn Sydney test - 1st innings - Cummins 20 over 2/68 (got Buttler and Wood); Boland 14.1 overs, 4 for 36 - got Crawley, his 'bunny' Root, Bairstown and Broad. 2nd innings trying to push for the win - Cummins 22 overs 2/80 and Boland 24 overs 3/30. Cummins again...got Buttler and Wood. Boland got Hameed, Root and Bairstow coming back late to suddenly open the door when it looked like Bairstow and Leach would see it out........alas light was fading and it ended up with Smith bowling (but he did pick up Leach). Boland definitely out bowled Starc - - match figures 34 overs 1 / 124. By Hobart - England just couldn't get back on the plane quick enough. re the MCG - that 2nd innings - it was Starc who got the first 2 (Crawley and Malan) and then Boland that evening picked up Hameed and night watchman Leach to leave England in tatters. Cummins and Starc the next morning saw Root and Stokes putting up a fight but again it was Starc who got Stokes and then Boland came in and weaved a magic spell that no one is going to suggest is the standard. That said - - all the commentary about finishing his first test on 7/55 and how his average of below 8 wouldn't last.........yeah.........true........the next 11 wickets came at the cost of 117 runs.........reality hit home!! I look at a guy like Starc - - failed to clean up the tail on day 5. 1/65 and Chase and Joseph were handling him pretty comfortably. And yes - no Cummins - - the irony of Starc is that yep - good to have in the first innings but then almost becomes a liability. His 4th innings bowling from the India tour of 20/21 to now is 6/478 (at basically 80 runs a wicket) at 3.06 runs an over.

2022-12-04T07:20:59+00:00

Chanon

Roar Rookie


His old man might be able to sway & cut through some red tape :stoked:

2022-12-04T07:18:20+00:00

Chanon

Roar Rookie


It’s really important to bring in the next generation otherwise you tend to go stagnant plus it’s the life blood of Australian Cricket getting the youngsters to strut to a revitalised tune. :thumbup:

2022-12-04T07:18:09+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


He'll be competing with Aaron Hardie.

2022-12-04T07:15:41+00:00

Chanon

Roar Rookie


Really impressive young man slowly finding his feet & starting to dominate. An early ton in shield now all he needs is a really big score in conjunction with lots of wickets. 39 in 1st innings was ok. Tough caper being a allrounder. I’m sure in the next 2 years he could develop into a No.6 batsman with Green at 4

2022-12-04T05:59:36+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


Yes. Sacking Phil Jaques is not the answer. They need to develop batsmen. For a population like NSW's, their batting depth is so shallow. Gilkes at #5 and Abbott at #6 is as weak as any Shield side has ever been.

2022-12-04T05:56:08+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


Sutho has that Michael Neser, Matt Kelly tenacity.

2022-12-04T05:39:54+00:00

badmanners

Roar Rookie


7 wickets for Todd Murphy is handy as well. NSW can't keep carrying underperforming batsmen even with high profiles. A chance WA might pull off an unlikely win yet!

2022-12-04T05:27:21+00:00

Chanon

Roar Rookie


Sutherland’s 9 wickets against NSW was impressive.

2022-12-04T04:09:28+00:00

DaveJ

Roar Rookie


Good call. Not only did Braithwaite tough it out, he had to do it while listening to Marnus yabber on for hours on end. Above and beyond the call of duty. Not quite sure how an international-calibre player would be defined, but Jason Holder ranks 19 th in ICC bowling rankings, ahead of quite a few well regarded players, and 5th among all-rounders. Not that he’s looked great here.

2022-12-04T03:07:13+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


Meanwhile at the Gabba, after having scored a ton in his last Shield game 20 months ago, Ashton Agar has stroked a stunning 72. Great to watch.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar