FLEM'S VERDICT: Look out, England - Scott Boland with a Dukes ball could be an Ashes 'matchwinner'

By Bowlologist / Expert

After he went wicketless in the first innings in Adelaide and saw his Test bowling average balloon out to above 10, the gags about Scott Boland’s future in the game looking uncertain came out.

And then within one over on Saturday night, his average was back down in single figures. He’s just sensational.

The thing I love most about Bolo is there are just no warm-up balls. The only reason he bowled that over was that Michael Neser pulled up a little lame in the previous over – Smith was talking to him and he just went, ‘I don’t know if I’m right’.

From ball one (literally) Boland’s ability to bowl that perfect line and length, straight into the ‘Bowling Boulevard of Bewilderment’ sets such a high standard. He hit the seam, moved the ball in and out – he was all over the West Indians, and gave the Aussies half a sniff of finishing it that night.

He was unlucky with that none-for in the first innings after bowling well. But that’s just a sign of how good Australia’s fast bowling depth is. No Josh Hazlewood or Pat Cummins for this Test, so Neser and Boland come in, one takes the wickets in the first innings and the other dominates in the second.

It makes you think: if Boland’s making this Kookaburra move, then what’s he going to do with the Dukes ball and its more pronounced seam when they head over to England next year?

He gets wickets in all different conditions over in Australia, so I can’t see that being any different in England. His only issue is that it’s hard to get a game when Cummins, Hazlewood and Mitchell Starc are all fully fit. Starc is talking about playing some county cricket after just one Test on the last England tour, so that’s not going to hurt his chances of being picked either.

If Boland misses, though, you’ve got a potential matchwinner sitting on the bench.

In the immediate future, I’d have thought that even if Neser had got more wickets than him again in the second innings, Boland would be likelier to play against South Africa at the Gabba, because I don’t think Hazlewood will be fit in time. Cummins has been bowling in the warm-ups out on the ground in Adelaide, so that leans towards him being fine and leaves one spot up for grabs.

So Bolo’s more than likely going to get another Test – do well again, he’ll be well and truly putting pressure on for positions in the first-choice XI.

It will be interesting to see whether Australia rest and rotate the quicks a little bit during the South Africa series, especially Mitchell Starc. With Boland now, you know you’re not getting any release of pressure, so he might actually end up playing three or four of the Test matches, which is handy.

(Photo by Chris Hyde/Getty Images)

Selectors, when they pick their best team, want one or two players who are really unlucky. They’ll certainly have that for the rest of this summer.

Aside from Boland, the other standout from Day 3 was some really good DRS work from the Australians in both innings. Early on, Nathan Lyon was the only one who thought his LBW against Joshua da Silva was out. What I loved was that Steve Smith backed him and sent it upstairs, and was proved right.

There’s plenty of trust in that relationship, because Lyon’s really quick to, if there’s an LBW appeal, say whether it’s going down leg or was too high. You’ve got to get your reviews right in the modern game, and it’s a great boon for Smith and Cummins to have a senior player who has their trust, and who got it bang on here.

We saw a good one later on from Alex Carey off Mitchell Starc, too, to get Tagenarine Chanderpaul down the leg side. Really the only ones half-interested were Starc, Carey and Travis Head from on the boundary; once again Smith backed them, and it was the right call.

The DRS hasn’t always been Australia’s strongest suit, but with that going well and the balance of the bowling attack perfect, it’s just yet more layers on a completely dominant series.

Batting-wise, the big negative from their quick second innings was David Warner’s push to get a score of note this series failed again. He’s becoming a bit unlucky with drag-ons and other misfortunes.

I was a little bit concerned the Aussies might bat out the day and then stretch the game out, because then you have to bat another session on Day 4 because there’s no point declaring overnight in good batting conditions. Declaring midway through the last session was the proactive way to go about it, and they’ve been backed up by the bowlers.

CLICK HERE for a seven-day free trial to watch cricket on KAYO

As long as they get the fourth-innings target near enough to 500, I think the Aussies are happy, and then obviously that gave them a real chance to have a crack at the West Indies under the lights, which obviously worked really well.

From the West Indies’ end, one of the few highlights has been Alzarri Joseph, who has got better as the series has gone on. That was a deserved three-wicket haul in the second innings, even though the Aussies were slogging a bit. The Windies just need to find at least one fast-bowling partner for him.

The other positive has been Chanderpaul, who has emerged as someone who should be able to open with Kraigg Brathwaite for a very long time.

The main thing that really let them down on Saturday was their running between the wickets. There were ‘only’ two run-outs, but there could have been half a dozen.

The miscommunication that led to Chanderpaul getting sent back by the nightwatchman Anderson Phillip and caught short was the worst of the two. You’ve got to be able to recognise that if there’s going to be a run out, it can’t be an established batter, it has to be the nightwatchman who takes the bullet.

Their running between the wickets was symbolic, really, of how their tour has gone on.

The Windies probably need another batsman that’s got defensive capabilities, and then they need to unearth a gun from somewhere. It doesn’t need to be a Brian Lara-level champion, but a gun bat who can average over 40 and score a bit quicker is essential for them to improve.

They’re coming out to Australia again next year – I don’t know how much Test cricket they’ve got in the meantime, but now they’ve had some experience over here and know what they’re up against, let’s hope they can get a bit of a stronger squad together for next summer.

Looking ahead to the South African series, it will be interesting to see how we get tested by a better team, particularly batting-wise. They haven’t really been challenged at all, aside from a few spells from Joseph, this summer, and I think we’re about to find out how they all go against genuine pace, against bowlers who send down a high percentage of short balls.

Even further ahead, England have a good attack as well – they might not play at the same time, but Mark Wood and Jofra Archer are extremely quick too. That batting order will have to face plenty of genuine pace over the next 12 months.

We’ll have to hope Travis Head and co. can continue to bat like that in the middle order, and hopefully some runs from Cam Green will be forthcoming. At least then we’ll know that the number six is locked in for the tours of India and England, and then we’ve got to work out who the spare batsman will be.

First someone who can play spin better for India needs to be found, and then someone else adapted to English conditions for that tour.

The Crowd Says:

2022-12-12T00:56:57+00:00

Clear as mud

Guest


Clem was primarily a swing bowler here especially into the wind at the WACA and at the Gabba. hope you are right re Boland. don't want him to be like Siddle over there

2022-12-11T06:19:00+00:00

DaveJ

Roar Rookie


Will be interesting to see. Boland doesn’t swing it like Alderman and Massie. Doesn’t have the height of McGrath, which was key along with his accuracy.

2022-12-11T05:59:22+00:00

Simoc

Roar Rookie


I don't see it with Boland in England. He will do just fine but he is a one trick pony to date against poor batters. He lands the ball in the same spot over and over, the area of uncertainty; as Mohammed Abbass did for Pakistan and Glenn McGrath for Australia (McGrath being taller got damaging bounce). Boland is the ideal backup for two speedsters (not including Green) in the Australian team. But Neser can do very similar and bats way better. Bit of a tossup there. I think they're behind the top four quick bowlers but we only need two quicks and one medium. Green is the bonus quick. So I think we play Hazelwood or Starc but not both, in future tests. My number 4, Jyhe Richardson, is an able replacement for all the top 3.

2022-12-11T05:17:20+00:00

Pumping Dougie

Roar Guru


Boland will get much more swing in England overcast conditions with the Duke ball though, just like Alderman and James Anderson did compared to their performances in Australia. But you might be right – maybe Boland doesn’t have an outswinger, maybe he just has offcutters and nibblers.

2022-12-11T03:52:24+00:00

Clear as mud

Guest


I just saw on cricinfo you played 5 FC games in 2001. You are there on Wikipedia too. Sorry - it’s the Covid fog!? Anyway you would have done much better than Binga in the tests considering his 10 wickets at 500 each or whatever it was (You really should put more of “you” in your stories. Modesty will get you relegated around here!)

2022-12-11T03:41:07+00:00

Clear as mud

Guest


Hey Flem how come you missed out in 2001? Injury? noffke??? 1997? Bickel Kasper and BJ there. And Pistol getting the call when Dizz went down? It’s a long time ago. Surely you would have been one of the first picked if fit?!

2022-12-11T02:50:12+00:00

Clear as mud

Guest


Yes but he had an outswinger. Not seen Boland bowl those. McGrath was taller, had more bounce and moved it more IMHO. Maybe he should have moved it less? Maybe Siddle. And he was never THAT successful in England

2022-12-11T02:43:30+00:00

Geoff from Bruce Stadium

Roar Rookie


Trying too hard I guess. Can't be easy after having watched Head and Marnus doing it so easily. He doesn't seem to be the sort of batsman who can score quickly as soon as he gets in. He needs time to build an innings. That was one thing Tim Paine was good at - always proactive when he got to the crease and kept the scoreboard ticking over. Warner, Head and Carey are also pretty quick out of the blocks. I think Green just needs to think about how he ca get a single and rotate the strike and belt the bad balls for 4. Green looks too negative and defensively minded for mine. But he's still young.

2022-12-11T02:41:13+00:00

Pumping Dougie

Roar Guru


McGrath the metronome did well everywhere. Going back further, Terry Alderman starred for Australia in England (40 wickets one series), by bowling in that corridor of uncertainty.

2022-12-11T02:36:08+00:00

Geoff from Bruce Stadium

Roar Rookie


Terry Alderman took over 40 wickets in England in both 1981 and 1989 at just over 20 per wicket. Medium fast – used to bowl mainly outswingers but became lethal when he developed an off cutter and took a record number of LBWs. Have to hand it to the English umpires – they knew when a bloke was plumb LBW. No need for DRS back then. Bob Massie was similar – medium fast or maybe brisk medium – swung the ball both ways – took two 8 fors in his first test at Lords. Dennis Lillee was down the other end and was bowling well but Massie was just unplayable -took 16/137 for the match. Unfortunately Massie only played 6 tests. Boland has the potential to be as good as these blokes. Check them out on Youtube when you get time. Probably two of the smartest medium fast bowlers I’ve seen play for Australia. Lillee, McGrath and Warne up there as well of course. I’d argue McGrath and Boland bowl at a similar pace – along with Hazlewood. Don’t have to be super quick in England. Just get the ball in the right areas. Broad and Anderson have demonstrated that for what seems like decades. Boland could do extraordinarily well. I’d have him in the team before Starc if the conditions suit.

AUTHOR

2022-12-11T02:30:07+00:00

Bowlologist

Expert


I think Josh is doubtful for Gabba . P Cummins has been bowling flat out in middle before play so he looks fit

2022-12-11T01:41:32+00:00

Clear as mud

Guest


Stuey Clark was in the ball park but a few inches taller and only got the two games when pretty much almost gone

2022-12-11T01:39:51+00:00

Insult_2_Injury

Roar Rookie


What, sorta like Marnus at the Gabba and Handscomb at the G?

2022-12-11T01:22:30+00:00

Insult_2_Injury

Roar Rookie


I'd love to know what the Bowlologist thinks of the handling of Cam Green the bowler. As a batsman he has no choice but to sit and wait thru big partnerships and will learn as much from that as going in at 4 for buggerall as to how to build his innings. My concern is that his bowling is being hampered by over restrictions, which include short barrages. He's bowled less than 6,000 balls in all senior cricket, but at 23 and all the best bowling coaches CA can muster, doesn't seem to have a stock ball to build pressure and one variation to create uncertainty at his pace, which his age indicates is vital in long form. Surely all the tricks come with experience once the basics are mastered? Right now though it seems the coaching staff are restricting his chances (to safeguard a longterm prospect!), while asking him for maximum exertion by bowling short. Surely Flem, that just builds bad habits where young players automatically go to too short a length regardless of the track and situation? I also woulda thought with decades of biomechanics in the database, stopping a 23yo from bowling to 'save him for the future' is flawed. The Steve Waugh theory of taking 20 Tests to learn the skills needed seems to be borne out time and again, but with 16 under Green's belt, I believe the coaching has done his bowling development a disservice, especially in the Perth Test when extended spells were needed from him.

2022-12-11T01:15:39+00:00

Clear as mud

Guest


trying to think who is a Boland type and has done well in england? haven't really got one. maybe Reiffel but he kissed the surface a bit more. Mick Malone's one test was ish-ish but he was probably a bit slower than Boland's top?

2022-12-11T00:30:34+00:00

JGK

Roar Guru


Wouldn’t Neser be a better bet at his home ground at the Gabba. And then Scotty at the MCG.

2022-12-10T23:36:47+00:00

Clear as mud

Guest


Hasn’t really had the circumstances to do so. 4-430 should always mean having a tonk. And then the Head thing happened. Same in the second dig - and Tonk he did Smarter captains would have elevated him in the second dig I reckon

2022-12-10T23:31:30+00:00

Johnb

Guest


Am I the only one who doesn't understand why Hazlewood is an automatic pick ahead of Boland?

2022-12-10T23:24:46+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


Just not getting a bat. Having a quick slog doesn't count.

2022-12-10T23:16:07+00:00

Chanon

Roar Rookie


Boland made a comment after play suggesting he decided to bowl a fuller length compared to first innings & then bingo he reaped the rewards. FLEM do you have any idea how long Hazlewood will be out injured with his side strain? Agree Boland in England will wreck havoc plus l’m sure they prefer he didn’t play :laughing:

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar