Spin twins: Playing two offies on the table with Bailey not fazed about throwing Murphy into Indian fire

By Paul Suttor / Expert

Australia will have no qualms throwing off spinner Todd Murphy straight into the first Test at Nagpur even though he would be thrown into the fire of trying to bring down India’s star-studded batting line-up on their home turf.

Chief selector George Bailey said the uncapped Victorian 22-year-old had the maturity to cope with the ultra tough assignment and he was also unperturbed about playing him alongside fellow offie Nathan Lyon.

Murphy is vying with left-armer Ashton Agar and leg-spinner Mitchell Swepson to be Lyon’s first-choice partner in India after all four were named on Wednesday in the 18-man tour squad.

Bailey said all-rounder Cameron Green (broken finger) looks like he will be fit to play on February 9 in the series opener.

CLICK HERE for a seven-day free trial to watch cricket on KAYO

He would then operate as the third seamer behind captain Pat Cummins and Josh Hazlewood with Mitchell Starc out injured, which gives Australia the flexibility to include two spinners in their line-up for what is tipped to be a turning wicket. 

Todd Murphy. (Photo by Matt King/Getty Images)

“He’s a great kid. Absolutely, he’s a chance to play,” Bailey said when asked about Murphy. “It’s certainly not a development tour. He’s earned his spot through his performances and what we think he can do.

“Clearly whether he can play alongside Gaz is a question, but they are different as far as off-spinners go. So I don’t think you’re necessarily looking at the same type of bowler. We’ll get across and assess the conditions and what we think we need once we hit the ground. 

“When you’re putting any attack together, you’re after complementary skills and wanting to make sure you cover as many bases as you can. But you often play two right-handed quicks if they’re your best two. That’s something we’ll weigh up.

“We do think we’ll probably get the heavier spin conditions in Nagpur, that’s probably what we’re planning for.”

Australia have rarely used two frontline off spinners in the same line-up – all-rounder Glenn Maxwell was the fifth bowler and operated in tandem with Lyon in India a decade ago but the last time two offies were selected among the four main bowlers was when Gavin Robertson and Colin Miller teamed up for a Test on the 1998 Pakistan tour.

Prior to that it was way back when Peter Taylor and Tim May were together for two Tests in Pakistan a decade earlier.

Middle-order batter Travis Head can also send down some more than handy off-spinners. He took 4-10 against Sri Lanka at Galle in June and chipped in with three breakthroughs in the home summer against the Windies and Proteas.

Murphy was given a taste of subcontinental conditions on an Australia A tour of Sri Lanka and India last year and has excelled at Sheffield Shield level this summer with 14 wickets at 17.71 for Victoria. He also bagged three wickets for Australia A against the West Indies at Canberra in November. 

“I am under no illusions as to how difficult it might be at times with how well they do play spin bowling,” Murphy told reporters on Thursday in Sydney where he is preparing for the Sixers’ BBL clash with Perth on Sunday. “To play against guys who have grown up playing spin their whole life, it’s something I’m going to have to be really patient with and try and learn along the way and figure out ways to outlast them.”

Bailey questioned the notion of whether there is “a good or a bad time to debut someone”. 

“I think he’s a very humble, hard working, good kid and at times you forget that he’s only 22 years old,” Baile said. “A lot of the traits that you look for in any young athlete, he’s really keen to learn, open to learning, a fierce competitor if you’ve had any opportunity to watch him play for Victoria. He wants to have the ball in his hand and wants to impact the result which is fantastic. 

“And he’s someone that we’ve seen improve quickly, every time we’ve given him some form of exposure. Anytime you get the opportunity to take someone new on a tour, it’s fantastic but particularly when someone’s displayed the talent and the performances that he has at such a young age is going to be great.”

“I’m sure if you ask the player ‘yeah, we’re thinking about playing you mate but we’re just going to hold off until we think we can find an easy game’. I’m not sure that that’d be that keen on that. So we don’t pick someone unless we think that they’re ready to perform if they get an opportunity.”

While Murphy is a definite chance to become Australia’s 465th men’s Test cricketer next month, Bailey said Agar and Swepson were also in with a strong chance. 

Bailey said white-ball specialist Adam Zampa was strongly considered for a Test call-up on this tour but Swepson, who took 10 wickets in four Tests on the Pakistan and Sri Lanka tours last year in his first forays into international cricket, was considered the better option as the chief leg-spin option. 

“Certainly in India we would like to have the availability of the left-arm orthodox. So it was great that we had the opportunity to get Ash a game (in Sydney), he hasn’t had a great deal of red-ball cricket. In horse racing terms, I think he will be better for the run,” Bailey said. 

“Swep’s on the tour because if we feel that we need a leg-spinner, we think he’s our best option.”

Mitchell Swepson. (Cricket Australia)

Assistant coach Daniel Vettori is Australia’s ace up the sleeve when it comes to the art of spinning out wickets on the subcontinent.

The New Zealand stalwart took 98 of his 362 Test wickets at Asian venues. 

“The type of person he is and the way that he engages with all the bowling group, not necessarily just the spinners, in its entirety will be fantastic,” Bailey said. 

“His ability to work with the spinners and that goes right from someone like Nathan Lyon who you’d classify as well experienced in these conditions to some of the guys who haven’t had the opportunity to play as much in the subcontinent, I think you’ll be a wonderful sounding board and coach for those guys.”

The Crowd Says:

2023-01-13T06:23:02+00:00

Vamsi K

Roar Rookie


A funny anecdote when it comes to off-spinners. The much acclaimed Ashwin was bowling to Sehwag in the nets and Sehwag, who doesn’t care about getting out in actual match itself, was clobbering every delivery of Ashwins everywhere. After the practice Ashwin asked him how could he hit him so easily and asked if he would give any suggestion to improve his bowling. Sehwag blankly said he doesn’t consider off-spinners as bowlers :laughing: and went away laughing. Ashwin still says that net session left deeper scars than actually getting hit in a match.

2023-01-13T06:06:34+00:00

Vamsi K

Roar Rookie


I believe there might be something to do with culture as well. Indians, specifically Hindus, do most of their cultural and religious related things with right hand only. Doing these things with left hand is literally prohibited. As such children from a very young age inadvertently do most of the things with their right hand. Till a few decades back, apart from a minority of course, children weren't encouraged to write with left hands even if it was their natural/dominant hand. It's not as if they were punished or something, just subconciously parents or elders would correct them or suggest them to write with right hand. Thing is no one stopped anyone doing non-cultural or non-religious related things with either hand but when a child does many things right handed, unless their left handedness is too dominant it might get corrected without anyone realising it. Overtime people have started realising the importance of letting the dominant hand prevail, so even when correcting/suggesting the use of right hand in cultural aspects it is being done in a way to let the child know that it is so only for this purpose and for all other things they can use the dominant hand.

2023-01-13T01:58:17+00:00

Clear as mud

Guest


That first Ashton is Ashwin

2023-01-13T00:33:20+00:00

Big Daddy

Roar Rookie


I think the tests will be fairly competitive and even but I also notice there are 3 ODI matches which are a different kettle of fish with the test team virtually being the ODI team whereas India will be completely different.

2023-01-12T22:14:53+00:00

Clear as mud

Guest


Pitch didn’t suit Agar types at all. Especially as it effectively a day 3 pitch Not aided by Cummins’ invisible teapot every time he bowled, him getting taken off when he did beat the bat. Most Spin was from wide footmarks. Perfect for big spinning no pressure offies, and Marny’s junktime sugar hits Lyon got 2 wickets from 55 overs and spells as long as he wanted. That comparison point keeps getting disappeared

2023-01-12T22:10:48+00:00

Clear as mud

Guest


Ashton bounces it less than Lyon and has the carrom etc. threaten both edges etc etc - we struggle withS Lyon has worked on his non spinners but still may have to bowl too full to hit stumps for LBs - compared to Ashwin jadeja - bowled faster and flatter than Agar. Not much turn but every now and then jags one. Threatens both edges. Agar is much taller, and much taller than the round armer SOK. So may have to bowl too full to hit stumps We really need a mystery spinner Gleeson type/ Chris Green seems to be the closest with his funky action. Big spinning offies like Lyon and Krezja will get occasional bags. But they are also comfortably within the comfort zone for most of their batters most of the time It’s one reason why we rarely win games let alone seasons there. Really up to the batters to make 500 and make us unbeatable. Grind them down as we did Pakistan. Refresh between test 2 and 3. Bowl as a squad etc etc

2023-01-12T22:01:56+00:00

Clear as mud

Guest


“I overbowled Lyon”

2023-01-12T20:30:54+00:00

qwetzen

Roar Rookie


you might be thinking of Sydney Nope. T'was Briz Vegas. The problem was mostly with that 16*, a score that took Ian Bishop 82 balls, most of them from Matthews, to compile. CI scorecard: https://tinyurl.com/59cuuypc Aside: I once tangled with Ian Bishop, at Lords, pre-game even. Sitting in the Mound Stand prior to some LO domestic final (Lancs v Derby, '93), someone shuffling along to their seat stood heavily on my foot. I started to look up at the culprit with something pithy on my mind only to realise that this huge figure was completely blocking out the sky. "Sorry mon", said Mr Bishop. 'What a nice man' I thought, "No worries" I said.

2023-01-12T19:52:05+00:00

Choppy Zezers

Roar Rookie


He can’t find his hands so that’s why they look to Head

2023-01-12T17:22:52+00:00

Rowdy

Roar Rookie


... and Neil Young is her father

2023-01-12T13:17:58+00:00

Mo

Guest


Not a fan of Mathew’s really but he competed as hard as he could and was superb in the field. He earned test player status. Did some good stuff with bat and ball on occasion

2023-01-12T13:13:07+00:00

Mo

Guest


I know less than most if not all of you but when asked the question Jim maxwell said he didn’t think agar did enough to trouble good batsmen. In Sydney head did seem more dangerous. Agar could temp as an all rounder but not as frontline spinner for mine.

2023-01-12T12:38:40+00:00

DTM

Roar Rookie


Murphy is not a leg spinner. Swepson is a leg spinner but not from Victoria. Yes, Corey has 22 wickets from 5 SS games and Murphy only has 21 from his 3 games. I've been watching Corey since he was 15 or 16 - he's a terrific young man and I would love to see him in a baggy green. However, I don't have a problem with the selector's choice of Murphy.

2023-01-12T11:32:08+00:00

Chanon

Roar Rookie


They love Lyon plus he’s got his curator hat on prior & during a game, tactics within tactics Rowdy :silly:

2023-01-12T11:24:20+00:00

Chanon

Roar Rookie


That’s exactly what Two heads response would have been :stoked:

2023-01-12T11:15:38+00:00

Rowdy

Roar Rookie


I always think bowling is about wickets, not containment. But getting Murphy into the team, drop Lyon, so he gets a feel for what it's like in the team. It has the added bonus of keeping Lyon keen.

2023-01-12T11:12:28+00:00

Rowdy

Roar Rookie


Dunno

2023-01-12T11:10:04+00:00

Rowdy

Roar Rookie


Simples. Agar spins it, good. If he doesn't, then bad.

2023-01-12T10:58:03+00:00

Chanon

Roar Rookie


Agar was picked so Boland couldn’t surpass Hoff in the pecking order. Going toe to toe may have won us the test match, shame!

2023-01-12T10:47:20+00:00

Rellum

Roar Guru


So why was Agar picked them?

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar