Hagan’s Round 3 Talking Points: Two minor rule tweaks make major impact with scoring up and ladder upside down

By Michael Hagan / Expert

The two minor rule tweaks in the off-season are having a major impact on the first three NRL rounds with a lot more tries being scored and plenty of room to move on the field.

With players now required to get both feet back 10 metres behind the line of the referee and the call of “held, release” now happening straight away, there is more time and space for the hookers, halves (and outside backs) to operate.

We saw some pretty high scorelines across the board this round with the Titans and Storm scoring six tries each in Gold Coast’s 38-34 win on Saturday. 

There are other factors behind there being so many tries – we’ve had an unseasonably warm start to autumn and the late start to the pre-season for a lot of players due to the World Cup means quite a few teams are not yet match fit.

CLICK HERE for a seven-day free trial for your favourite sport on KAYO

It all adds up to the speed of the game going back up and the teams with mobile forwards and quick metre-eaters in the back five are thriving. 

(Photo by Mark Metcalfe/Getty Images

The play-the-ball speed is quicker on average this year and nearly every team with the quickest play the ball speed won over the weekend.

Having to have two feet behind the referee means teams are not able as much to rush up on the attacking team with their line speed. Therefore the team with the ball can get on a roll a bit easier and get the defensive line backpedalling.

And then you couple that with the “held, release” call – last year there was a gap between when the ref would call held, then release and we saw teams in defence hold an attacking player up with three tacklers swarming all over him and it could be upwards of seven, eight, sometimes nine seconds for them to play the ball.

It was a deliberate strategy to slow down the ruck.

We’re not seeing that now with these two tweaks. There’s not as much wrestling going on in the ruck. 

Scores will naturally come down as the teams get their match fitness up, they adapt to the new rules and the temperatures come down.

A team like Manly is benefiting because they’ve got mobile forwards who can exploit this like Haumole Olakau’atu and Taniela Paseka, clever halves and then Tommy Trbojevic coming off the back fence to score tries. 

When I first came across him six years ago when he made the 2017 World Cup squad, he was a gangly 20-year-old.

But now he’s got the physical bulk and strength as well as his natural speed and evasion – he’s so tall, fast and powerful, how do you stop a weapon like that? 

Kotoni Staggs scores. (Photo by Bradley Kanaris/Getty Images)

Brisbane are another team that have got athletic back-rowers and centres and it’s no coincidence that they’re also undefeated.

I think we’ll see coaches adapt quickly and go with more mobile packs after seeing how the first few rounds have played out. We did a similar thing with the Kangaroos at the World Cup last year when we were using Cam Murray and Pat Carrigan as part of our front-row rotation off the bench.

A few years ago when the six-again stuff was introduced, clubs were complaining that they didn’t have time to tinker with their roster to shed a few lumbering big men from their roster but I think most teams now have got middle forwards who have the agility to cover a lot of ground and play big minutes.

The difference in average play-the-ball speed can only be a fraction of a second between the teams but over the course of 80 minutes it adds up and can be decisive.

Some of the better defensive teams from last year like the Storm, Parramatta and Cowboys are struggling with these new interpretations. 

The grinding, defensive third man, slow play-the-ball stuff is going to come back into play a bit more when we move into winter and the night games have slipperier surfaces but at the moment, it’s a very open and fast pace.

Melbourne and the Eels have both had to bring in a few new players, especially in their pack, and it’s having an effect. 

Neither team needs to start panicking but when you’re 0-3 like the Eels now are, the pressure gets turned up a few notches, particularly when you’ve got Penrith next week and the Roosters the week after. 

They’ve had a bit of an unfair draw the first few rounds because they faced Manly coming off a bye and that’s happening again this week when they’ll face a Panthers side that’s had a week off.

There have been a few anomalies in the schedule early on – the Warriors will be playing for the first time in Auckland next weekend because their first home fixture was taken to Wellington and they’ve been in Australia the past fortnight and Souths have started off with three straight road games.

Tohu Harris is tackled. (Photo by Ian Hitchcock/Getty Images)

Warriors remodelled under Webster

The Warriors were supposed to be the ones who would struggle in the tropical heat in Townsville but they were very impressive in their 26-12 win over the Cowboys. 

They’ve got Tohu Harris in the middle who can play 80 minutes when needed and they’ve recruited Mitch Barnett and Marata Niukore in their back row to give them a high work rate in their pack that they’ve lacked in recent years. 

Their back five is really powerful and they got through more than 80% of their sets against North Queensland.

Andrew Webster has changed their playing style and their mindset in a short space of time and they’re flying at 2-1 heading into next Sunday’s game against Canterbury at Mt Smart Stadium. 

Competition ladder flipped on its head

We’ve got Parra, the Cowboys, Melbourne, Souths, Sharks and the Raiders, who were all finals sides last year, at 1-2 or worse. 

And the Warriors are up there with Brisbane, the Titans, Bulldogs, Manly and the Dolphins at the pointy end of the ladder so I’d like to shake the hand of anyone who could have predicted that a few weeks ago. 

What you did last year doesn’t give you a guarantee of your position. 

Even a bloke like Craig Bellamy looks more frustrated than usual, Todd Payten and Brad Arthur are feeling that way a bit too but they’ve got plenty of time to turn it around. 

Dolphins vs Broncos is already a rivalry 

Kevin Walters is doing the old coach’s trick by trying to play down the hype about the game against the Dolphins next Friday at Suncorp but it’s going to be huge.

The build-up and hysteria in Brisbane is going to be enormous and Kevvy can say there’s no rivalry but with the game already a sell-out, it’s clear that there’s going to be plenty of extra feeling in this one.

Broncos vs Dolphins has the potential to become like what we saw on Friday night with the Roosters and Rabbitohs game a special event on the regular season calendar.

(Photo by Cameron Spencer/Getty Images)

And we’ve already had the Redcliffe mob poach a couple of Broncos stars in Tommy Flegler and Herbie Farnworth and then there’s the Wayne Bennett factor. 

He will fire a few shots across the bow this week. 

And with both teams unbeaten after three rounds, you couldn’t set it up any better. 

Back to Belmore a beauty

As a “very old” former Bulldog – it was great to see their loyal fans turn out in huge numbers at their spiritual home at Belmore.

They showed heaps of class in the first 60 minutes with Josh Addo-Carr scoring a brilliant try on the back of some lead-up work from his centre partner, Paul Alamoti, on play one in kick reception.

And Matt Burton took advantage of some quick ruck speed with an outstanding solo effort under the posts.

There were some nervous moments for their coach, Cameron Ciraldo, and their fans in the last 15 minutes when the Tigers scored three tries in five minutes.

Wests at least competed and look dangerous when Api Koroisau gets out from dummy-half and it looks like John Bateman will add a bit to them this year.

The Crowd Says:

2023-03-21T01:55:20+00:00

DP Schaefer

Roar Rookie


:laughing: :laughing: probably.. unfortunately..

2023-03-21T00:02:11+00:00

Bernie

Roar Rookie


effective anything would be useful. ????

2023-03-20T23:51:01+00:00

Rellum

Roar Guru


The offload stat is not useful on its own. The Tigers currently lead that stat. Effective offloads would be more useful

2023-03-20T23:34:21+00:00

Bernie

Roar Rookie


dont forget our class-leading stat of total missed tackles from last season, worse than the tigers & that takes some doing. their forwards play is so outdated, but there's no-one with any differentiation, other than J.Kerr who can pop a pass but that's probably why he was in reserves last year.

2023-03-20T23:28:02+00:00

Bernie

Roar Rookie


pretty sure "the guy" was immediately banished to outer Mongolia for revolutionary thinking.

2023-03-20T21:20:47+00:00

Bernie Vinson

Roar Rookie


Rule changes - lots of close games and the usual regulators involved. For example I came in when Raiders led 24-10 . The next 9 decisions/non-decisions went to the visiting Sharks until the touchie had to tell the ref there was an obvious Canberra penalty in play the ball – it was back to a one score game (which is the TV ideal) before Canberra received a "pick one out of your a*^$" freekick (set restart) shame Ricky is up to $50k for post match comments – the little man was ref…

2023-03-20T19:46:36+00:00

DP Schaefer

Roar Rookie


That might actually work in our favour. I've seen lots of instances where the main playmaker returns after a spell and everybody just relies on them and they can be rusty.... It might be our only hope. That or Hook has a week off and the guy who coached our first half in that memorable Souths game last year stops by for another shot.

2023-03-20T19:42:10+00:00

DP Schaefer

Roar Rookie


Ha ha ha haaaaa pffffftttt

2023-03-20T19:41:10+00:00

DP Schaefer

Roar Rookie


Haven't looked at the stats but what you're saying doesn't shock me. Such a waste of talent. Look at the amount of tries scored, teams are keeping the ball alive and exciting, except for us and the spooners. When Hook answers my email offering some coaching advise I'll bring you along as well....

2023-03-20T11:39:26+00:00

Pilferer

Roar Rookie


Agree though I'd prefer 4-6 man bench with permanent sub

2023-03-20T04:59:16+00:00

Rellum

Roar Guru


Your also second last in supports so that just shows it is just hit up after hit up. That style of football should not be enough to win games against teams who can defend. Slone is the one guy who is breaking it up for you

2023-03-20T04:53:31+00:00

Rellum

Roar Guru


You sure, I am happy to get the popcorn :silly:

2023-03-20T04:52:37+00:00

Rellum

Roar Guru


I think the Dragons are one of the most reserved sides in the comp. They are dead last on Pass Receipts and only three offloads off being last in that stat as well. You play a power game with your wingers and centres, outside of Lomax, basically just playing as extra forwards. If you don’t run over teams in the middle you need Hunt to work his magic or you are going to lose. And you will need to play games with lots of stoppages. Any games where the ball is in play and the opposition runs your defence around a bit is going to erode the power game. You saw that against the Broncs, the heat in the end allowed the Broncs to open up

2023-03-20T04:50:05+00:00

Bernie

Roar Rookie


yep agreed. Sharkies have Nicho back next week, he'll make a difference to them.

2023-03-20T04:24:05+00:00

DP Schaefer

Roar Rookie


For 60 minutes. And if the coach is half decent, he gives them the belief that it's something to build on. But for a kick or dumb error or two (or 7-8, there were lots of them) they cold have bought home the cookies. So they can be positive facing Sharks next week. But knowing Hook as I don't, he'll get them to tighten up and be more defensive and boorrriinnnggg and they'll still lose. They need to be more expansive, got some dynomite in the outside backs and need to use them.

2023-03-20T04:20:16+00:00

DP Schaefer

Roar Rookie


:shocked: :unhappy: :crying: :boxing: :boxing: :thumbdown: :thumbdown:

2023-03-20T04:10:16+00:00

Bernie

Roar Rookie


at least they competed DP. i saw the score at 18-all and though ooh, maybe maybe. phooey that the score blew out but the Broncos are red hot at the moment and Saints are only ever going to be tepid. good to see J.Sullivan with some nice touches.

2023-03-20T03:49:41+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


With the short off-season and the heat it's hard to say if it's the firmer rules or those factors. It certainly feels like teams can run in points post the 70min mark. Temperature is set to moderate this week in Sydney so will be interesting to see.

2023-03-20T02:33:28+00:00

NQR

Roar Rookie


The loose 10m and hold down is for teams trailing on the scoreboard from what I’ve witnessed. The look better because their attack is moving the football. It starts with the dummy half service. Not saying JMK was bad more Mahoney’s strength is his consistent long, quick, accurate service.

2023-03-20T01:10:41+00:00

NQR

Roar Rookie


I’ve read a lot of comments about teams having good and bad draws? It’s assumed certain teams are easier but as the competition ladder suggests that’s a misconception. A good draw relates to travel and turn around times and the luck of meeting teams with injuries IMO. I’ve got a suggestion the draw could be better especially in the first 3 rounds. Could we please use NZ as a magic round and maybe consider the Warrior have home games early. Also I’m a Cowboys supporter but asking any team to play afternoon games in Townsville in March is garbage. Even the fans hate watching in the heat and humidity? Maybe 3 away games would make for a better spectacle especially considering I haven’t seen anything but slow, errors riddled football and players lying down constantly?

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar