To catch SRP's ‘haves’, the Waratahs and Reds need to find their spine

By Brett McKay / Expert

After eight rounds of Super Rugby Pacific, there are clear parallels between the table and what we see out on the field. They’re observations that have been building over the last few weeks, but became truly apparent this weekend just gone.

Five teams – the Chiefs, ACT Brumbies, Hurricanes, Crusaders and Blues – have at least four wins.

Then there is a clear, six-point gap to the next group of four teams – the Queensland Reds, Highlanders, Fijian Drua, and NSW Waratahs – who are separated by just two points.

The Waratahs have one win fewer than the other three, but like the Blues find themselves attached to the group of teams immediately above them courtesy of a competition-leading five bonus-points.

The first group, the clear top five, all have strong for-and-against records, ranging from the Crusaders’ +69 to the Hurricanes +177. All have scored at least nine more tries than they’ve conceded. Or 17 more, in the Canes case.

The Tahs are the outlier among the bottom seven teams: their 20-point win over the Western Force on Saturday night pushed their differential back into the black for the first time in since Round 3. And that’s noteworthy because if they if they can find a couple of wins in the next three games – all of them against teams immediately above them – they can climb the ladder quickly.

Of those with negative differentials, they’re not insignificant margins. The Reds’ -21 is the best of this bad bunch. And with a bye, a couple of Australian derbies, and the Chiefs coming, making that red number black won’t be easy.

On the field over the weekend was where the other part of this week’s theme came to light, however. Those top five teams – and I’m calling them the ‘haves’ for reasons that are about to become obvious – are the best-performed teams because they have the best-performing shape in attack.

Central to that shape is the prominence of the secondary playmaker from fullback pushing their attack on subsequent phases after their flyhalf makes the first inroads.

Shaun Stevenson and Damien McKenzie from the Chiefs are probably the form players in the competition, but the way the Brumbies, Crusaders and Blues attack all fit this same method. Stephen Perofeta and Beauden Barrett even trade places in games for the Blues.

Damian McKenzie. (Photo by Michael Bradley/Getty Images)

The Hurricanes are the asterisk in this group for the number of different players at 10 the horribly underrated Josh Moorby has supported from the back, though they make up for that with Jordie Barrett doing his fair share of creating stuff from inside centre.

The Rebels and Drua are worth mentioning too, because you can see what is building.

Melbourne have played primarily off Carter Gordon at 10 and he’s looked impressive doing it. Lachie Anderson has been growing into the fullback role in recent weeks, and Andrew Kellaway’s spark from the back has been noticeable since his return from injury, too.

The Drua have used at least three different players at 10 this season as well, but the injection of international fullback Kitione Taliga on Friday night was a major reason they gave the Brumbies as big a headache as they did. If he and Teti Tela start connecting, they’ll be a completely different team in attack.

Central among the ‘have nots’, therefore, are NSW and Queensland.

I’m not quite in full agreement with my television colleagues who raved about the Waratahs’ “connection across the backline” on Saturday night, but it was certainly the best and maybe even the most connected they’ve looked in attack in more than a few weeks.

But that connection is not between 10 and 15. It’s not really even between 10 and 12. Instead, and almost despite all attack trends this year going back to playing from first receiver, the Tahs continue to play mostly off Jake Gordon at 9, and then from whatever young Max Jorgensen can spark with his free licence to run from the back.

Their support game is good and did work well on Saturday night, but it doesn’t exactly scream ‘repeatable pattern’.

Similarly, the Reds aren’t quite sure whether they want to attack from Tate McDermott at 9 or Jordan Petaia roving infield off the right wing. Lawson Creighton is playing the same distribution game at flyhalf that Tom Lynagh played in the opening rounds, and James O’Connor wasn’t quite able to find the same spark at 12 as he has done in recent weeks coming on to finish games at 10.

Further to this, Jock Campbell has been unusually quiet this season, and plays more of a running fullback game anyway (Tom Banks immediately comes to mind) as opposed to the aforementioned secondary playmaker.

Petaia is starting to play that secondary role though, which only strengthens the argument of those suggesting fullback is the position from where he can be a more naturally dangerous player.

Jordan Petaia (Photo by Bradley Kanaris/Getty Images)

And maybe he can. But like Jorgensen, unless he can find that currently missing connection with the frontline attack, then both the Reds and Waratahs are going to continue their existence further down the ladder than expectation and their own goal-setting would have them.

This attacking spine has been the difference between the top teams and those following this season, and you see the success in this for the top teams in their tallies and in their attacking shape.

And the better these teams go in attack, the more confident their defence seems to look as well. ‘We’re happy to attack you because we’re also not letting you in’ seems to be their mantra.

It will be fascinating not just to see how this evolution plays out for the top teams, but to see which of the ‘have nots’ can find the connection in attack they’ve not shown much of over the first eight rounds.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2023-04-19T00:01:05+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


You're right John, it has been Joe Pincus playing fullback, with Anderon on the right wing - but funnily enough, it is Anderson that I'd noticed getting more involved as the secondary playmaker..

2023-04-18T19:36:46+00:00

Bluesfan


Understand that seems to be the simple solution but personally think worthwhile considering that given that for both RA and NZRFU their income is not based around the Super Comp success/failure but rather Wallabies and AB brand. So to dilute strength of NZ franchises could effectively kill the golden egg in endangering the AB brand and hard to see given the risk why the NZRFU would go down that route? Think your last comment is key "will self-interest allow it" - I think to term it as self-interest is wrong. Both RA and NZRFU are effectively both competitors and partners but the key interest for both unions is retaining and expanding their respective incomes. In large part both entities need to ensure that their commerical interests are meet first and foremost and it's hard to work out given the risk to NZ rugby, why they would release control of their crown jewel - player strength. If it went well - (unless NZRFU took some ownership interest in Oz Super franchises), I can see the pay off for Oz rugby but what would NZ gain e.g. would RA be prepared to spilt increased gate earnings/TV rights contracts? And if it went poorly - potential to that long term golden egg in terms of AB branding and associated income streams. So I think from an Oz side it always looks like a no brainer decision - but from NZRFU side I think it's a whole lot different and introduces some serious business risk that for what is a very conservative Union maybe a "Bridge to Far".

2023-04-18T19:21:30+00:00

Bentnuc

Roar Pro


Great read Brett :rugby: think that Teti Tela has been excellent for the Drua. Very underrated player. Tom Wright is looking the goods at 15. What the Wallabies need is a good playmaking 15. We have had a decade of running full backs in Folau and Banks and it hasnt helped. I actually think that playing Stewart at 15 fir Engksnd was where Eddie went wrong. They were a better team with Daley

2023-04-18T13:10:08+00:00

John Ferguson

Expert


Hey Brett, thanks for the read! I think two playmakers is important and the interesting pendulum between 10 and 15 is an interesting analysis! See South Africa with Willemse and La Roux! Also I think you either meant Jooste or Pincus at Fullback for the Rebels, I don’t think Lachie Anderson has played a game there. Cheers.

2023-04-18T10:38:37+00:00

Jez North

Roar Rookie


Uru has been the Reds’ biggest disappointment this season for mine. I thought he was desperately unlucky to have been ignored by DR for the Spring Tour. He played above his weight and with real mongrel in 2022. The only thing I’ve noticed him do this season is give away penalties.

AUTHOR

2023-04-18T09:46:19+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


I also haven't mentioned Zack Holmes and Alex Newsome in a good while, OA, since we're naming names. (Morahan especially, and Maddocks are often mentioned around here too, but given you've joined the site this week, "never discussed on here" I can only assume you mean 'never' as in since your arrival...)

AUTHOR

2023-04-18T09:39:40+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


Yeah, we will Lebowski. It's really curious about Campbell - it's like he just hasn't been able to get into games and have the kind of impact we know he can..

AUTHOR

2023-04-18T09:36:22+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


They don't ATW. Very much in the 'have nots' group, because they're similarly disconnected in attack as NSW and Qld..

2023-04-18T09:13:11+00:00

WEST

Roar Guru


Haha :laughing: some more than others :thumbup:

AUTHOR

2023-04-18T09:05:22+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


The shame of it all is that it's needed in the first place.. :unhappy:

AUTHOR

2023-04-18T09:03:47+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


The Highlanders and MP highlight that, I think Blues. But I do think there is a lot more will and benefit to both sides of the joint venture if your second point comes through. Simple things like national player declarations can resolve residency attempts and poaching claims, and on paper at least, it just strengthens the competition. The $64 question is the same as it ever was, however: will self-interest allow it?

2023-04-18T09:00:05+00:00

Overseas Aussie

Roar Rookie


Just to throw into the mix about the fullback issue, there are 2 Aussies playing in France who are playing consistently in arguably the best league in the world and are never discussed on here… Luke morahan and jack maddocks??

AUTHOR

2023-04-18T08:54:31+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


And entirely tongue in cheek on my part, Chivas..

AUTHOR

2023-04-18T08:53:35+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


Cheers mate, I will add to the growing playlist..

AUTHOR

2023-04-18T08:52:49+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


Exactly ;-) It's just about how much we're willing to give and take! :laughing:

2023-04-18T08:35:16+00:00

jeznez

Roar Guru


You got a gorilla on your back? You seem cranky.

2023-04-18T08:03:31+00:00

Bluesfan


Yea I guess that is the Crusaders team with 17 players out injured.... Reality is that bar the Brumbies currently the rugby put out by the Oz sides is pretty/really poor. They can all play well for 20 odd minutes here or there but no sustained quality. Harsh reality is that Oz can't sustain 5 quality (what happens to the Force if they lost all there foreign players?) super sides but due to commerical reasons we have to have them in the comp. All in all it's makes for a weak and pretty much one sided comp (current score 12-1 for Kiwi sides) and very hard how it can be improved unless Oz cut 1 or 2 sides (which will never happen) or alternately NZRFU open floodgates and allow Kiwi players en-mass to play for Oz super franchises and allow AB's to select from them. Noting however that in regards 2nd point - NZ Depth as indicated by Highlanders is razor thin and in lot's of ways NZ resources are being stretched to the max with having to supply 5 sides e.g. how many top/international quality NZ tens will actually be playing in Super rugby next year?

2023-04-18T07:52:10+00:00

Chivas

Roar Rookie


That was quite a witty repartee.. made me smile :happy: Hopefully Jez reads it and it lifts his mood.

2023-04-18T07:50:57+00:00

peterj

Roar Rookie


Just a huge thank you from me Nic. I looked forward to Wednesday every week because of your articles and the unique perspective and professionalism you always provided. Not sure where you’re writing now but hopefully somewhere we can visit and interact with you again soon. Cheers mate

2023-04-18T07:49:06+00:00

Chivas

Roar Rookie


Were they lucky Brett? I thought it was a calculated decision by the Brumbies to throw that game. Who knows what difference playing their best side would have. It's a hypothetical isn't it?

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar