AFL News: Challenges galore after week of MRO carnage, Pies fears over Sidebottom injury

By The Roar / Editor

Carlton will challenge Adam Cerra’s one match suspension for a dangerous tackle, as off-field upheaval is set to cast a further pall over the struggling club.

And they won’t be the only team to front the Tribunal, with Fremantle’s Jaeger O’Meara and Sydney’s Luke Parker also challenging their bans.

However, Hawthorn captain James Sicily has accepted his one-match suspension for a high bump on St Kilda’s Anthony Caminiti.

Cerra was cited by the match review officer for rough conduct on Sydney ruckman Tom Hickey during the Blues’ deflating loss at the SCG on Friday night.

The 23-year-old put a big tackle on Hickey, slamming him into the turf, with the Swans veteran’s head bouncing off the ground in concerning fashion.

The MRO graded the incident as careless, medium impact and high contact.

The Blues announced on Monday morning they will challenge the ban at the Tribunal, in a bid to free Cerra for Friday night’s clash with the Demons at the MCG.

O’Meara’s rough conduct charge comes for a tackle on Melbourne’s Charlie Spargo which was also rated careless conduct, with medium impact and high contact by Christian.

Sydney co-captain Luke Parker was also offered a one-game suspension for a dangerous tackle of his own against Carlton on Friday night.

Parker drove Sam Walsh into the ground during the third quarter and pinned the Blues star’s arm.

Sydney (5-6) have the bye next week but Parker will miss the Swans’ round 13 clash with St Kilda if he is unable to overturn the decision at the tribunal.

Carlton slumped to a sixth defeat in seven games to have their once-promising season in tatters.

The result was made even worse with captain Patrick Cripps, midfielder George Hewett (concussion), defender Nic Newman (hamstring) and winger Ollie Holands (shoulder) hurting themselves.

Hewett will definitely be sidelined through the AFL’s concussion protocols, while Cripps and Newman will receive scans on their injuries.

Off-field, things are going just as poorly, with board member Craig Mathieson handing in his resignation.

Mathieson, whose uncle, club powerbroker Bruce, has been a fierce public critic of the struggling team in recent weeks, was a notable supporter of president Luke Sayers’ 2021 push to replace the outgoing David Teague with Ross Lyon, who chose to pass over the club.

The resignation reportedly comes after a heated exchange between Mathieson and Sayers in the Carlton rooms following Friday night’s loss to Sydney, according to Channel 7 chief football reporter Tom Browne.

Pies sweating on Sidebottom scans after milestone heartbreak

Collingwood will nervously await scans to determine how long Steele Sidebottom will be sidelined by the knee injury that soured his 300th AFL game and his side’s 35-point win over North Melbourne.

Sidebottom will have scans after suffering a medial collateral ligament injury in his right knee in an awkward tackle on Cameron Zurhaar in the opening 10 minutes at Marvel Stadium on Sunday.

Collingwood were clearly initially rattled by Sidebottom’s misfortune but were able to keep a gutsy but scrappy North Melbourne at arm’s length to claim a 16.9 (105) to 10.10 (70) win and maintain outright top spot.

The Magpies were celebrating Sidebottom’s milestone and Mason Cox’s 100th game, when the winger felt for his knee and headed straight down the race before being officially substituted out for Will Hoskin-Elliott.

“Well it looks like he’ll miss a few weeks,” coach Craig McRae told reporters. 

“I’m not sure exactly – three to four potentially, he might be back after the bye. I don’t know, we have to get scans and the like. 

“But it’s a shame – we sort of build the whole day up around what it means for him and all of us. 

“And jeez he started well too – he was on fire early.”

Jordan De Goey was at his dynamic best for the Pies, racking up 35 disposals, 10 inside-50s, 589 metres gained and one goal.

“I didn’t want to say anything – I thought, ‘Keep quiet on Jordy because he’s having a ripping season,’” McRae said.

“Today was out of the box.

“The difference between Jordy maybe two or three years ago is his work ethic and his ability now to cover ground.

“You watch how hard he’s running, you watch him get to a contest – and defensively as well, he’s buying right into that.

“That was a pretty special game.”

Nick Daicos collected 32 disposals and seven clearances, wingman Josh Daicos and Brody Mihocek kicked three goals, while Isaac Quaynor intercepted at will.

For North, former No.3 draft pick Will Phillips racked up 29 disposals and five clearances, while Hugh Greenwood (25 touches, 10 clearances) was strong and Nick Larkey finished with five goals.

The Magpies raced away with the first four majors of the game, but the Kangaroos remained in the game for a half.

Collingwood exploded after halftime with a six-goals-to-two third quarter to nudge their lead out to 53 at the final change.

The 17th-placed Kangaroos fought it out with a six-goal last quarter.

Caretaker coach Brett Ratten rued a lack of execution but relished his charges’ effort against the AFL “benchmark” in Collingwood.

“Everybody (thinks it is) doom and gloom because they look at a loss beside your name, but today was a really good step,” he said.

“What we’ve seen over a period now is the performance against Sydney was full of merit and then today wasn’t exactly what we wanted for the four quarters, but jeez there was a bit to take away.”

(AAP)

The Crowd Says:

2023-05-31T03:29:44+00:00

AdamDilligafThompson

Roar Rookie


I reckon georgie is gone for sure and agree his attitude was very off early not sure why but definitely seemed to have the sooks.lol.

2023-05-30T09:19:48+00:00

BillyW

Roar Rookie


It's interesting Adam...and this may sound silly but for me, I'd feel stronger on keeping him if he had been here from the start (a 32 yo Marshal say). Dixon (as much as I love him) was traded in to makes us better (successfully....sort of) and so I'm ok to trading him out to makes us better.....having said that I hope he stays!! haha.... I prefer a Dixon, Marshal, Finlayson with Lord rotating off the bench to a combination with Georgiades (I think we get more for George...yes it contradicts my earlier statement but I was so disappointed with his laziness at the start of the season)

2023-05-30T09:06:02+00:00

BillyW

Roar Rookie


To be fair if I were Lord's manager I'd be suggesting one year also....he is back in the pecking order but always likely to get a few games this year, go from untried promise to shows a bit and up to the level.....gives him a chance to increase his value whether he stays or goes at the end of this deal.

2023-05-30T03:01:47+00:00

AdamDilligafThompson

Roar Rookie


I think it was lords idea, gave us some insurance but also gave him option if he wanted them, still a very strong link to geelong as far as I know.

2023-05-30T03:00:44+00:00

AdamDilligafThompson

Roar Rookie


It's amazing how things have changed over the years, not to long ago people would of called for blood at the thought of losing such a loved and at time important player for us but now people are keen as long as the team can cash in on it. Which as much as I wouldn't want to see Charlie go if it set us up.for the future you couldn't really complain could you.

2023-05-29T19:54:15+00:00

Virgil

Roar Rookie


They need to sort out their forward line. Reminds me of the Arsenal team a few years ago that would have lots of possession but were toothless in the final third.

2023-05-29T19:23:33+00:00

Maxy

Roar Rookie


I see Lord signed on for 1 extra year,find that strange,surely a young key tall showing signs of progress would get at least a 2 year deal.I wonder if it was Port or Lord's idea.Most think Georgiades will leave and Tom Scully is very raw so he probably a couple of years away

2023-05-29T17:57:15+00:00

Scyphus

Roar Rookie


He was sacked from the Lions' den a good while ago...

2023-05-29T10:23:38+00:00

BillyW

Roar Rookie


It would be a shame to lose Dixon but I think Lord has shown enough to suggest he might be better....has the aggro, almost the size and reads the play better. So if we happen to be in a position where we can get something for Dixon before the end of his career....I'd take it

2023-05-29T07:31:33+00:00

AdamDilligafThompson

Roar Rookie


Im thinking it's his back giving him some troubles. Got to feel for Cripps he gives everything he's got but feels like not everybody is in the same page or everybody just sits back waiting for him to do it and if he can't they figure we'll if he can't we can't. Almost need to give him 6months off and teach the others how to play and stand on there own two feet without him.

2023-05-29T07:17:14+00:00

PeteB

Roar Rookie


Well he struggled through 2020 and 2021 with niggling injuries and back issues. You can tell when he is 100% as he was in 2018, 2019 & 2022. There’s no doubt at the very least he has some niggles or the General Soreness.

2023-05-29T07:10:54+00:00

AdamDilligafThompson

Roar Rookie


Can't argue with that. For the first say 10 or 15mins roughly i thought you were both struggling with your disposals but swans seemed to find there mark after a little bit where as the blues seemed to be the same all night. At one point early I do remember asking of it was wet or raining at.all and not being a smart as. about it bit it's really hard to pick up on TV these days.lol. I still swear after watching cripps for a for weeks hes carrying something too, just his ability to work from contest to contest and provide an extra option seems to be struggling and I dont think its effort at all.

2023-05-29T07:05:00+00:00

AdamDilligafThompson

Roar Rookie


I heard that too actually so thats it don't think there's anything to it. We'll hopefully not anyway.lol.

2023-05-29T07:04:34+00:00

PeteB

Roar Rookie


Just watched most of the Swans game. They’re just repeating the same errors and mistakes as all season. It’s mental laziness or maybe they’re just not clever enough. They have no trouble getting the ball, but the decision making and execution is so bad. Everyone watching can see what they’re doing wrong, but for some reason the coaches and players aren’t doing anything about it.

2023-05-29T06:46:27+00:00

Maxy

Roar Rookie


Heard Charlie say he might even stay in Adelaide after his career finishes so cant see him leaving,especially if we are playing finals,if he has a new girlfriend from up there that might change though lol

2023-05-29T06:40:22+00:00

AdamDilligafThompson

Roar Rookie


Whoops actually Sicily is out maybe isn't he.

2023-05-29T06:39:44+00:00

AdamDilligafThompson

Roar Rookie


Thats what im hoping it was and nothing more.lol. I reckon you could be right, although it would be nice to have Charlie with Sicily around but better to be cautious still a long season to go.

2023-05-29T06:26:41+00:00

Maxy

Roar Rookie


Probably ducked home to Cairns to catch up with family while he has been out injured,sounds like he will miss again this week ,they may rest him until after the bye..freshen the big fella up for a big 2nd half of the season

2023-05-29T06:20:41+00:00

Peter the Scribe

Roar Guru


Andy Maher is a smart guy but who can handle all those backroom Blues board brawlers? Poor Voss. Thrown into the Lions den.

2023-05-29T06:06:04+00:00

AdamDilligafThompson

Roar Rookie


It's a harder decision to stick by what you've got and to work through it as a group/team than what it is to lay the blame in one particular area and think thats going to fix everything. Something like that anyway I think theres a saying.lol.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar