Ashes Scout: England line-up CONFIRMED, Cook turns up heat on Marnus, Broad's bold Warner call, Harris rebukes stopgap plan

By The Roar / Editor

James Anderson has been recalled for his home Ashes Test at Old Trafford, after England made the call to drop their pantomime villain Ollie Robinson.

England confirmed on Monday that Anderson’s return would be the one change for the fourth Test against Australia from Wednesday, with Jonny Bairstow keeping the gloves as expected.

Spinning allrounder Moeen Ali is again listed at No.3 after batting there in the fourth innings at Headingley last week, with Harry Brook back at No.5.

Anderson was left out of the team’s three-wicket win at Headingley, but there was always a thought the 40-year-old had been kept on ice for this match.

On his return, Anderson will have the chance to bowl from The James Anderson End for the first time in an Ashes match, after the pavilion end was renamed after him in 2017.

Anderson has had an underwhelming Ashes so far, taking three wickets at 75.33.

James Anderson. (Photo by Darrian Traynor – CA/Cricket Australia via Getty Images)

But the forecast of cloudy skies and some wet weather for this Manchester Test is likely to suit the hometown seamer.

The decision to leave Robinson out comes after he had declared himself fit to play at Old Trafford, following back spasms at Headingley.

One of England’s best bowlers for the past year, Robinson has taken 10 wickets in this series for England.

Robinson has also become known as Australia’s arch-villain throughout the Ashes, after giving Usman Khawaja a send-off in the first Test and sending several barbs in the direction of the tourists.

However he has not looked as threatening as other bowlers, with England opting to keep the pace of Mark Wood in their side and all-round ability of Chris Woakes as a fourth seamer.

ENGLAND: Zak Crawley, Ben Duckett, Moeen Ali, Joe Root, Harry Brook, Ben Stokes (capt), Jonny Bairstow, Chris Woakes, Mark Wood, Stuart Broad, James Anderson.

Cook applies heat to Marnus

Former England captain Alastair Cook believes Marnus Labuschagne’s dip in form could cost Australia the Ashes unless he bounces back in the last two Tests.

Cook also said James Anderson has also struggled for England but he has an excuse in that he has had to bowl on unfriendly pitches. He is adamant Labuschagne has no reason for his struggles.

“From appearing as an injury replacement for Steve Smith at Lord’s in August 2019 through to the start of this summer he averaged 62. In his past four Tests, he averaged 26,” Cook wrote in his column for The Sunday Times.

“If he can’t reverse this decline in the next two matches then Australia’s chances of winning the series are significantly reduced.”

The record-breaking former England opener wonders whether Labuschagne is overdoing his preparation for each match and that he is muddling his thoughts.

Marnus Labuschagne has struggled in England. (Photo by Alex Davidson-ICC/ICC via Getty Images)

“Every professional takes his cricket seriously but Labuschagne seems particularly intense. When he is not playing he spends a lot of his time watching and thinking about the game.

“I’m not saying England have got inside his head but in Australia’s second innings in the third Test at Headingley he looked like a man struggling with himself — and his dismissal reflected that.”

Cook thinks England should promote Joe Root to first drop when the fourth Test gets underway at Manchester on Wednesday with Ben Stokes elevating himself to No.4 before Harry Brook, Moeen Ali and Jonny Bairstow.

Broad claims it’s hard bowling to Warner

Despite dismissing him 17 times in Tests, veteran England seamer Stuart Broad claims he finds it hard bowling to his batting bunny, Australian opener David Warner.

In a column for the Mail on Sunday, the 37-year-old quick conceded he struggled early in his career against Warner and still has his work cut out for him despite employing his successful around-the-wicket strategy.

“The truth is I’ve always found it difficult bowling to Davey, and I still do. By going round the wicket I’ve tried to minimise the width he loves outside off stump, but also bowl a fuller length and make him play at 80 to 85 per cent of deliveries,” he wrote.

“He used to sit back against me and hit me through the off side, and before the 2015 Ashes our bowling coach Ottis Gibson pointed out that my average was much higher against left-handers.

(Photo by Stu Forster/Getty Images)

“The Aussie team that season was full of lefties, and Ottis said I’d be out of the team if I didn’t find a way to bowl to them.

“I spent four months practising round the wicket. I wanted to bring the stumps into play, while still threatening the outside edge. By the time I got to Trent Bridge eight years ago I bowled round the wicket all the time — and picked up 8-15.”

Broad dismissed Warner cheaply in both innings at Headingley and the Australian left-hander is under pressure to retain his spot for the final two Tests with the Ashes on the line.

No country for makeshift openers: Harris

Marcus Harris has warned Australia’s opening role should be reserved for specialists in England as he believes elevating hard-hitting middle-order players is fraught with danger.

Australia are still mulling over their options for the fourth Ashes Test, after Pat Cummins and Andrew McDonald both stopped short of guaranteeing David Warner his spot.

If Warner was to be dropped, it would likely allow Australia to play a fit-again Cameron Green and in-form Mitch Marsh to play in the same side as they pursue an unassailable 3-1 series lead.

Options would include moving either of the allrounders to the top of the order, while Travis Head and Marnus Labuschagne would be alternatives.

And while it remains unlikely the 30 year-old understudy Harris will be the man to come in, the opener is well aware how difficult opening in England is.

He averaged 9.66 across three Tests in England four years ago, while the average opening stand in the country in the past four years has been 28.48.

And after spending the past three years playing county cricket in England, Harris believes it would be the toughest place for a makeshift opener.

“My experiences from county cricket are if you cop the wrong time of the day to open the batting, especially if you’re a destructive batsman it’s probably not ideal,” Harris said.

“In the subcontinent, it is probably the best time so to have someone destructive like Heady, he can open the batting there. 

“But in England and in Australia, and the way the wickets have been the last couple of years and New Zealand, it’s more of a specialist position. 

“You want your destructive players like Greeny or Mitch or Travis to be coming in against a bit more of an older ball.”

Harris also threw his support behind Warner, with the veteran left-hander and Usman Khawaja having got Australia off to three 50-run opening stands before his double-failure in the Headingley defeat.

Opening options Marcus Harris and David Warner. (Photo by Robert Cianflone/Getty Images)

“Davey’s obviously a bit of a lightning rod for opinion, but I think they’ve done really well as an opening partnership when you can get the team off to a good start,” Harris said.

“Even if you’re not getting the big runs you want to get, if you can still contribute to the team in some way, shape or form, I think you’re doing a job.”

Warner’s looming retirement in January has also opened the door for Harris to soon return, with selectors having made clear in recent months they view him as next in time.

Harris is confident he is an improved player on four years ago in England, with more experience around the world and in county cricket.

“I just try and be ready to go all the time. You never you never know what’s going to happen these days,” Harris said.

“Davey’s earned the right to pull the pin whenever he wants to pull the pin and he’s done well this series. 

“So if I have to wait till then and then so be it but if something comes up earlier, I’m ready to go.”

with AAP

The Crowd Says:

2023-07-19T21:16:30+00:00

Wikipetia

Roar Rookie


only if our general decline meant that that approach was the best way to be competitive. which is where England currently are, waiting for a generation of test quality batters to come through and help Brook replace (Cook), Root and Stokes, and Bairstow when on.

2023-07-18T06:56:41+00:00

Opeo

Roar Rookie


Is it this or are they not letting him leave it? I would be curious to see the percentage of balls hitting Marnus' stumps in this series compared to previous series.

2023-07-18T06:56:12+00:00

matth

Roar Guru


I assume you mean Woakes. Unfortunately for England, Bairstow has a mortgage on the keeping spot. He and Warner should get together after the series to toast their good fortune.

2023-07-18T06:52:02+00:00

matth

Roar Guru


Well Smith's last get out shot was on a par with Marnus, so he probably needs to look after himself at this point.

2023-07-18T06:49:28+00:00

matth

Roar Guru


Coupled with the fact that Marnus seems to have lost his ability to leave. he used to be very good at playing the waiting game and getting the bowlers to bowl to him.

2023-07-18T02:24:51+00:00

Nick

Roar Rookie


I’m guessing part of the deal for signing a very healthy central contract with Cricket Australia is to front the media, so in that regard, I’ve no issues about Harris being asked to make comments. That doesn't mean be thrown under the bus. The "healthy" contract is about a fifth what Warner's is. Warner should be out there answering those questions, not Harris.

2023-07-18T02:24:00+00:00

Opeo

Roar Rookie


I mean, if Maxwell batted at three and got runs that would be OK, but Ali has played 66 tests and averages 28 with the bat. I just cannot imagine Australia dropping Carey so that two guys that have had loads of chances at test level can average 28 batting in the top three.

2023-07-18T01:37:06+00:00

Opeo

Roar Rookie


Actually, I do see your point. If Labuschagne got injured right now, Marsh, or Green, at three seems more likely than Smith or Head going to three. This is an ongoing issue for England though. If Handscomb came in a scored thousands of runs, I really doubt that Carey would be dropped to allow Handscomb to bat at seven. We are also not persisting with an opener that has played 37 tests and is averaging 28 to allow Handscomb/Smith/Head/Green to all bat in the middle order. Bacroft, Renshaw, and Harris, have all played 14 tests and average 25-30. Can you fathom one of them getting to 37 tests and still averaging less than 30 with Glen Maxwell batting at three and Handscomb keeping?

2023-07-18T01:30:55+00:00

Wikipetia

Roar Rookie


eight poor games. i was just riffing off your initial point

2023-07-18T01:22:35+00:00

Opeo

Roar Rookie


Nah. If the batting order changed every time someone had four poor games, the top seven would change every match. Even if it was a good idea, I do not see how it would work. Labuschagne, Warner, and Green would all have to move down the order in the next test. If Smith struggles in the next test he might have to move down the order too. All of a sudden we have five guys for three spots between four and six, and no opener, or no number three.

2023-07-18T01:03:47+00:00

Wikipetia

Roar Rookie


well with Marnus' lack of mental resilience when batting maybe smith should move to 3 for this test. take some of the pressure off?

2023-07-18T00:45:01+00:00

Pierro

Roar Rookie


this worries me if Anderson and foakes are in it means there will be a green tinge and movement under clouds . that means Davey would be in deep trouble straight away . moreover Australia should play neser for Murphy and hazel for Boland

2023-07-18T00:40:37+00:00

Opeo

Roar Rookie


Root is better equipped to bat at three than Bairstow, but Bairstow at three is less bad than dropping your keeper and putting Ali at three. I am less sure about Brook but he looks like he could bat at three and is probably a better option than Bairstow.

2023-07-18T00:32:02+00:00

Wikipetia

Roar Rookie


that sounds like a bad thing tho?

2023-07-18T00:27:33+00:00

Opeo

Roar Rookie


Probably not because there are players that a less senior/established that could be shuffled around the order. This is the same reason why I nominate Brook or Bairstow to go to three and not Root. If Smith was 10 matches into his career, like Brook is, he probably would not refuse to bat at three.

2023-07-18T00:09:18+00:00

Wikipetia

Roar Rookie


yes but smith could be at 3. smith would be at 3 if Marnus opened. or would he???

2023-07-17T23:57:05+00:00

Opeo

Roar Rookie


Marnus is at three? Maybe the English selectors need to tell Bairstow or Brook to bat at three or they will not be playing.

2023-07-17T23:52:08+00:00

Wikipetia

Roar Rookie


rhetorical or you've lost your memory?! (it was possibly open for Warner or don't play the 3rd test for Head, his dismissal in test 2 innings 1 was pretty poor.) Smith could be 3. prefers 4.

2023-07-17T23:43:01+00:00

Opeo

Roar Rookie


Didn’t Head open in India? I agree about Green though. His comments came across like he could pick and choose where he bats and I do not think that he has earnt the right to do that.

2023-07-17T23:30:52+00:00

Wikipetia

Roar Rookie


selectors select. on tour, the captain is the key selector. with the coach in this set-up. if he plays, blame them, not warner.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar