Okay, they've lost 17 in a row - but North's future is shining brighter than ever

By Dem Panopoulos / Expert

It has been a pretty diabolical season overall for North Melbourne – there’s no sugar-coating to be done there.

The loss to West Coast in Round 20 sort of sums it up, really. Playing a team equally as dismal, the defeated team was always going to cop criticism.

Let’s not confuse results with progress, though. Small steps in the right direction are happening at the Kangaroos as they seek a brighter future.

Obviously, the criticism existed before the game against the Eagles and justifiably so, but as is the case in our reactionary world, this loss has ramped up statements made in AFL media to a ridiculous level.

Clearly, the icicle representing football shame has been passed from West Coast to North Melbourne after a single result. All the issues regarding priority picks, or Ben McKay’s impending free agency compensation, see every man and his dog having a say. They don’t deserve any help, is the argument; they got themselves into this position through bad management.

It’s quite amazing that while the heat was on the Eagles, North lost all those games in a row and there was an acknowledgement that they didn’t quite have the talent to compete. But as soon as even a whiff of a priority pick is in discussion, North Melbourne suddenly has a heap of young stars and shouldn’t get any handouts for more. For as bad a season as it has been, along with the coaching disruptions that they have endured, the last few weeks in particular have seen the club heading incrementally, in the right direction.

Luke McDonald and Alastair Clarkson celebrate victory. (Photo by Michael Willson/AFL Photos via Getty Images)

Early in the season, having written this critical piece, it really seemed like the opening stanza of 2023 was pointless for North. There was no proper style of play, they were one of the older playing groups on the park, and their veterans had been mediocre.

Since then, Alastair Clarkson hasn’t been in charge much, though his return to the fold occurs this week. Interim coach Brett Ratten had a difficult task to try maintain the ethos that will be hammered into the group for the long term, and it remains to be seen how long it’ll take overall.

While performances have mostly stayed shabby, he last six weeks has certainly seen a shift in attitude, where those criticisms have slowly been addressed.

The simplest one has been the demographic of the playing group. From having an average age of 26 and 107 games of experience early on, the last month has brought it down to roughly averages of 24.5 and 85 respectively.

The Roos have moved on from guaranteeing games to Jack Ziebell, Ben Cunnington, Aaron Hall and Daniel Howe. Hugh Greenwood is a positively helpful depth player, which seems to be understood, while Todd Goldstein has taken a backseat with Tristan Xerri’s return. Luke McDonald’s title as leader may have helped him avoid the fate of other veterans.

Liam Shiels is perhaps the only senior figure that has had a genuinely consistent, positive impact on the team after he un-retired. His tackling pressure has been typically sensational, and his adaptability has been important in filling a number of key role to open up doors for kids.

It’s the simplest thing a team can do – get younger and get more experience into those who may be able to take you forward.

Not that it has necessarily been perfect – there have been a few fringe players inexplicably returning to the senior fold without standout performances in the reserves, such as Kayne Turner last week. But as we said, small steps.

Over the last month, too, the style of play the Roos want to play has been much clearer: it’s about pressure, pressure and more pressure.

North Melbourne is averaging 77 tackles per game in their last four matches , up from 53 through the first 15 of the season. They’ve been the best pressure team in the competition in that short period of time.

When a team is this bad, it’s about simplifying the approach. The process is always more important than the results at this stage of a rebuild, and there have been patches in the last month as a neutral observer where the performances have been more impressive than at any other stage of the season.

As for the young talent: it’s definitely there, and my opinion on that has never changed. This isn’t going to be an argument for or against the priority pick, and when it comes to free agent compensation, people simply must understand that if McKay were to leave, the pick they receive is a separate matter altogether.

The truth is, the Roos have been excellent drafters for a few years, and now that they’ve shifted their approach and are starting to give out more opportunities to said hgih draft picks, the development ball has started to roll – before anyone jumps in, Jason Horne-Francis was the right choice and they got a very solid return for him when he left for Port Adelaide.

Seeing a centre bounce group of Luke Davies-Uniacke, George Wardlaw and Will Phillips is wonderful. The occasional Harry Sheezel clearance, a Cam Zurhaar burst from a stoppage, a Tom Powell sighting, all held together by co-captain Jy Simpkin’s steady hand, is what good drafting gets you.

George Wardlaw. (Photo by Quinn Rooney/Getty Images)

Nick Larkey has 50 goals. On this team. Not bad for a 73rd pick.

The father-sons have also been getting a chance, with Jackson Archer showing decent signs in defence and Cooper Harvey looking a raw if likely type. Paul Curtis has to find consistency but looks unstoppable at times, Eddie Ford is also around the mark, while Charlie Comben could be a real handful if and when he can string games together. Josh Goater is talented as well.

But first, can we circle back to Sheezel for a second? Whichever third of the ground he settles in, he’ll be a star. He’s got such poise, class and vision, especially for a first-year player – that’s what nailing the draft is all about.

Brayden George hasn’t debuted yet, either: he was a personal favourite at draft time and could even be better than Sheezel or Wardlaw in the long run.

More than just listing these players, and a couple of others who would have been worth a mention, is that finally, they’ve started getting senior games.

Already there have been a couple of big retirements at the club, with Ziebell and Hall hanging up the boots, and there may be one or two more by season’s end, all of which contribute to the greater good of this football club.

CLICK HERE for a seven-day free trial to watch the AFL on Kayo Sports.

There is truly no more pointless exercise than rewarding mediocrity from experienced players in a rebuilding group; now that’s out of the way, what’s happening at North Melbourne is far more palatable.

Of course, there are plenty of issues and there’s no quick fix to be had at Arden Street. There’s never an acceptable way to look at the 17 losses in a row, nor really the last four years for this team.

But while everyone is taking their turn to have a dig at the Kangaroos, the easiest thing any footy person could possibly do after losing to the Eagles, there simply has to be a reminder that it’s a process-based game right now for them, with results a secondary consideration.

They have young talent that is starting to get a bit of experience, and at least two, if not three, elite prospects to come in the upcoming draft.

(Photo by Daniel Pockett/Getty Images)

Not only are younger players getting games, but they’re actually getting proper opportunities. Veterans aren’t playing the key loose defender roles, or the prime midfield minutes. They’re not occupying a wing to themselves or taking all the ruck minutes anymore. It’s the young guys getting these chances, and while they aren’t winning, they’re hungry.

They’ve been told to tackle, so they’re tackling. When it’s time to attack at all costs, they’ll do that – just look at how Wardlaw plays. There will be mistakes along the way, but the recent draftees have all been good characters first. That will change a club over time.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

So yes, it’s been an awful season for North Melbourne, on the back of other awful seasons; but this time, it’s truly the first chapter of a long journey.

Whether or not they get there in the long run is contingent on plenty of things going right, but at the very base of it, the last month has shown a clear plan and a shift to the young brigade.

North Melbourne’s last month has been positive – and the club has started taking steps in the right direction. All while the losses have kept mounting.

The Crowd Says:

2023-08-09T04:19:54+00:00

Munro Mike

Roar Rookie


The Adelaide game highlighted the structural issues. The age factor skewed a bit by a handful of oldies like Goldstein, Ziebell, Shiels and Greenwood (sub - came on for Goldstein) all over 30. Granted - the Crows had Walker, Sloane and Smith. However the Crows Sub was a 23 yr old for a 23 year old vs North with a 31 yr old for a 35 yr old!!! The key area is in the midfield - - the Crows that day had more maturity in that 25-29 age range (Laird, Keays, Milera, Dawson......even Hinge based on age/physical maturity). That's the engine room where North effectively top out at Simpkin (a young 25 and 120 odd games)........down to 19 year old Wardlaw and even 18 year old Sheezel. Shiels doing a bit of outside work for us.......I'd actually have preferred that Greenwood played that entire game to provide a bit of support from a stronger body. And we've seen it since - - we struggle for consistency and to run out quarters - and when Simpkin missed a couple of weeks after another head knock - - we were 24 and under. Even bottom age compared to the Eagles (who had the likes of Sheed, Gaff, Kelly, Hunt, Duggan and even subbed Yeo in. Our danger is that the young guys need to avoid developing 'losing habits'; and very much need to learn how to win.

2023-08-06T16:01:10+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


No one is judging any of the young players. They have the best young players in the AFL.

2023-08-06T11:39:34+00:00

Munro Mike

Roar Rookie


#Don Freo......and arguably that's why Freo have dropped away a bit this year - - O'Meara only supplies so much; and ironically former Roo (and Demon) Corey Wagner has come in and had a very good last 4 weeks - as a 26 year old. The key for Freo this year is to not judge too harshly......23/24 year olds aren't robots. And especially 19-21 year olds aren't.....poor Heath Chapman hasn't been able to take a trick in 2023.

2023-08-05T00:13:55+00:00

Brad JD

Roar Rookie


Thanks Dem, this is one of the best articles I’ve read this year. Why is it the media find it so hard to be balanced. Also the talk that they’ve received enough support – what does that mean? A 2nd and 3rd round pick that must be traded plus the option for two rookies is galaxies away from what other clubs have received in the past. The likes of Wilson/Barrett/Kornes really need to pull their heads in. It’s sensationalism.

2023-08-04T07:18:08+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


They are the same age as LDU and don't have the experienced back up.

2023-08-04T06:53:24+00:00

Munro Mike

Roar Rookie


Yeah but 20 year old Brayshaw, 20 yr old Cerra came in with 28 yr old Fyfe starring in the midfield - by end of 2020 Fyfe had just turned 29; had 187 games under his belt and 2 Brownlows. At that point (rnd 18 2020) Brayshaw was up to 56 games; Cerra 58 and Serong a year younger was up to 14. There was another useful player holding that midfield together....name of Mundy. Along with Stephen Hill, even 24 yr olds in Acres and Aish. The contrast at North - -is that North were going great.......Round 19 2021 the 'best ever 18th placed team'.........we beat Carlton by 39, Larkey kicked 7 and Cunnington had 27 with 10 clearances............and then bang. We lost our one midfield talisman.

2023-08-04T06:37:01+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


Most likely not. Has had no impact on Serong and Brayshaw in a squad much younger than NM's.

2023-08-04T03:32:55+00:00

Munro Mike

Roar Rookie


#Don Freo Did I say 24 was management/nurturing age?? I don't believe I did. LDU only turned 24 at the start of June; and has only missed games this year due to hammy/calf injuries. He played 41 games in 2021/22 and sadly for North has played only 12 so far this year. A major reason for us winning so few games. He is ready to lead in 2024 and would be my pick for captain. My point relates to over burdened players through age 18-23. Sam Walsh is the obvious example - a year younger and played more games in first 2 seasons......also played 42 across 2021/22 and......only 14 this year and is currently sidelined with hammy issues. The problem with Walsh is he's already had back surgery and bulging disc issues......at age 22. He's now 23 and.......the question for him is whether he can return with power for Carlton in a possible finals campaign this year; let alone step up in 2024 to help Carlton go a step further. Or......is he going to be one of those with chronic issues that need to be managed. Wait and see.

2023-08-04T03:22:26+00:00

Munro Mike

Roar Rookie


Hawthorn is interesting - - young list too. Brought Karl Amon in as a 27 yr old mid (outside/wing). Nash at 6'6" is a beast if not brought up on the game (Irish). My personal feeling is we would have had them covered back in Round 3 (remember we were 2-0 at that point) - - however Simpkin was suspended and LDU a late out due a 'bruised heel'?? What was obvious was without those 2 that we were no chance of a win......lost by 19 points (although flattered a little - 11.14 to 9.7.......Hawthorn ran away from us in the final term 2.9 to 2.2). Our 24 year olds were either Larkey/Logue (book ends) or Stephenson/Zurhaar (forwards who might pinch hit in the mids but aren't 4 qtr mids). Even Hawthorn out gunned us in that 24-26 age bracket. We just couldn't afford no Simpkin and LDU. And we've had a few games through the year where we've got really, really close with one missing......and pretty sure with the other in then we'd snatch it. Much more optimistic for 2024. Across the mid/back end of this season we've seen Tarryn Thomas return and show enough again to believe that with a fully focussed pre-season that his 2024 could be anything - next year he'll hit that age of 24 and games tally of 80-90; Bailey Scott started a bit slowly however has subsequently produced his first 30+ disposal game (Rnd 10) and 2 more since then - avg 20.5 disposals a game this year up from 18.5 in 2022. Just turned 23 a month ago. THAT will then be the core group - - Simpkin, LDU, Thomas and Scott.......Powell and Phillips will turn 22 next year and Sheezel and Warlaw at age 19......will feel a little more protected. And see what Brayden George can produce.

2023-08-04T02:56:51+00:00

Epochery

Roar Rookie


I do see the light at the end of the tunnel. North could have won 6 games this season and with stronger more experienced bodies next season the 4 quarter efforts will continue to improve. Hopefully we can add 3 or 4 too 20 picks from this seasons draft and a few more experienced players. I have faith we will see a much better North next season.

2023-08-04T01:28:34+00:00

Non Serviam

Roar Rookie


You would hope after nearly 4 years in the bottom 2 their young players would be greater than wce.

2023-08-04T00:45:29+00:00

Non Serviam

Roar Rookie


Alot still needs to go right for north to not be bottom 2 next season. I have watched this club implode a little to much the past few years to call future is bright just yet. It should be but felt the same when plough took over Richmond so we will see.

2023-08-04T00:30:39+00:00

Gilberto

Roar Rookie


Not sure I buy that, compare them to the Hawks midfield of Worpel, Ward, Newcombe, Nash & Day. No one over 25 there and have been losing most of the season but they've had a lot more wins then North.

2023-08-04T00:11:29+00:00

Shane

Roar Rookie


In their losses to Port Adelaide and Adelaide this year North fielded much older sides. Their situation is not as bad as WC but they are hardly brimming with youthful talent.

2023-08-03T23:39:56+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


You could get Joel Hamling for nothing.

2023-08-03T23:36:38+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Roar Rookie


Could have beaten all of Syd, Ess and St K. Then played two dreadful quarters vs WC and still had a chance to win. I feel sorry for Bretty Ratten. He deserves a medal.

2023-08-03T23:34:00+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Roar Rookie


Yeah but he's not back until mid season probably.

2023-08-03T23:04:15+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


24 is not management/nurturing age. It is leadership age. I am referring to how the previous regime treated them then.

2023-08-03T23:01:50+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


Logue comes back. He was good.

2023-08-03T23:01:31+00:00

Munro Mike

Roar Rookie


#Don Freo the kids have to be managed and have a chance to learn. Sometimes.......that's in the VFL. LDU has struggled this year with heal/calf/hammy. So we have to manage him very carefully. And not force him to carry the team as if he were 28 and not just turned 24.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar