AFL News: Goodwin responds to Maynard bump, Pies' Noble gesture, Dusty meets with Dimma

By News / Wire

Collingwood defender Brayden Maynard faces a nervous wait on whether the attempted smother that knocked out Melbourne’s Angus Brayshaw will put his AFL season in jeopardy.

Young Melbourne forward Jacob van Rooyen will also sweat on how match review officer Michael Christian assesses his high swinging arm on Collingwood tall Dan McStay, and whether that rules him out of a sudden-death semi-final.

Brayshaw will miss Melbourne’s semi-final against either Carlton or Sydney under AFL concussion protocols after he was flattened by Maynard less than 10 minutes into Thursday night’s 9.6 (60) to 7.11 (53) loss at the MCG.

Maynard jumped towards Brayshaw, attempting to smother his kick inside 50, and turned and collected the midfielder high with his shoulder, knocking him out cold. 

Brayshaw required lengthy attention on the field before leaving the field on a stretcher and in a neck brace.

The on-field umpire could be heard on the broadcast saying Maynard was reported for the high contact. 

“I don’t want to say too much, but it’s a footy act,” Maynard told the Seven Network.

“I came forward, I jumped to smother the ball and yeah, unfortunately I just got him on the way down.

“So I don’t know. We’ll have to wait and see what happens.”

Melbourne coach Simon Goodwin certainly wasn’t doing Maynard any favours.

Brayshaw, 27, cannot play again for at least another 12 days, while he has a lengthy concussion history and wears headgear.

“I guess that’ll be sorted out during the week, but we’ve got a pretty shattered player (Brayshaw) in there,” Goodwin said.

“Look, you can only go by the facts: he jumped off the ground and knocked a guy out.

“So I guess time will tell.”

Beyond the concussion, Goodwin said Brayshaw only had a “shiner”.

Collingwood coach Craig McRae queried whether there was malice to Maynard’s action.

“I’ve caught it on a phone. One view of it, one angle, it looks like he’s in the air,” he said.

“The act itself, it didn’t look like it had much malice but I’ll leave it up to others to decide if that’s worthy of a suspension or not. I don’t know.”

Van Rooyen collected McStay on the jaw with his arm after the Magpie dropped a mark in the first quarter and the ball spilled between them.

Goodwin said: “I haven’t really seen too much of it but I’m pretty sure McStay stayed on the ground.”

The Magpie went off the ground for a concussion assessment but returned and played out the game.

(AAP)

Angus Brayshaw was knocked unconscious in a collision with Brayden Maynard. (Photo by Quinn Rooney/Getty Images)

‘Shout out Johnny Noble’: Pie explains touching act for dropped teammate

Collingwood players have made sure to include defender John Noble in their victory celebrations following the Magpies’ seven-point qualifying final win over Melbourne, despite him being dropped from the team.

Noble, who had played 83 consecutive games prior to being left out of the 23 for Thursday night’s final, was embraced by his teammates on Wednesday afternoon after the call was made by Magpie selectors; before ensuring the 26-year old was part of a raucous rendition of the Collingwood club song after their win over the Demons.

Speaking to Seven, Pies defender Isaac Quaynor, who pulled Noble into the huddle, said the gesture was about recognising the role he played in getting the Magpies to a qualifying final in the first place.

“It was obviously one of those calls that is just so tough,” Quaynor said of Noble’s omission.

“We played basically every game together… we’re good mates. It was tough to see him go out.

“The way he’s come and supported the group, his attitude, especially today, was unbelievable.

“As you can see in the end everyone was getting around him. He got in the huddle. He’s a big reason we got to the final. Shout out, Johnny Noble.”

Noble’s path back into the team may depend on whether Brayden Maynard is suspended for the collision with Angus Brayshaw that concussed the star Demon.

Dusty the Sun? Tigers champion reunites with Hardwick for Gold Coast chat

Ever-present rumours over Richmond champion Dustin Martin finishing his career elsewhere are set to go into overdrive, after the triple premiership hero was spotted reuniting with old coach Damien Hardwick on the Gold Cost.

Martin, who won three Norm Smith Medals in the Tigers’ 2017, 2019 and 2020 grand final wins, was photographed meeting with premiership coach Hardwick, who recently took over as senior coach of the Gold Coast Suns, at a pub on Thursday afternoon, in vision made exclusively available to Channel Seven.

Martin remains contracted until the end of 2024, but speculation has long existed about a move away from the Melbourne bubble to finish his glittering career.

In 2022, reports he would seek a trade to Sydney were proved false, but the presence of Hardwick at the Suns would make a move north a logical destination should he wish to leave Punt Road.

However, speaking on Fox Footy, former great Leigh Montagna was sceptical that the meeting would be more than a catch-up between old friends.

It’s hard to decipher whether he’s meeting the Gold Coast Suns coach or meeting a mentor and a very good friend and someone he’s had so much success with, who he probably hasn’t seen since whenever Dimma left,” Montagna said.

“I’m sure they enjoyed a few vodka lime sodas and just caught up. I don’t think he’ll end up on the Gold Coast.”

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Martin’s departure would be the latest in a string of changes at Tigerland in recent months: the club will head into 2023 with a new coach for the first time since Hardwick was appointed at the end of 2009, while stalwarts Jack Riewoldt and Trent Cotchin have both retired.

The Crowd Says:

2023-09-12T05:42:13+00:00

RT

Roar Rookie


I was wrong and I agree with you.

2023-09-10T11:03:25+00:00

PriddisJunior

Roar Rookie


It wasnt a smother attemp. I have no idea where this argument is coming from. Laid him out, in every way you look at it.

2023-09-10T06:26:25+00:00

Barb Dwyer

Roar Rookie


Launching yourself at a player under the guise of 'smothering' doesn't cut it. Even if he'd smothered it, the end outcome would be the same. Brayshaw's season is likely over and Maynard hopefully won't be seen again until 2024, if / when he realises that brain injuries are actually a serious issue.

2023-09-10T06:11:35+00:00

Chanon

Roar Rookie


Mudqueens of Chicago is worth watching Barb. A portion of proceeds goes to local woman’s charity.

2023-09-10T06:06:19+00:00

Barb Dwyer

Roar Rookie


I reckon boxing has a world of trouble awaiting it, though!!!

2023-09-10T06:02:36+00:00

Chanon

Roar Rookie


Hope so Barb :thumbup:

2023-09-10T05:59:49+00:00

Barb Dwyer

Roar Rookie


Agreed. The bump will stay. Reckless tackles should and will have consequences as will reckless bumps.

2023-09-10T05:52:15+00:00

Chanon

Roar Rookie


The bump is the harder one of the two evils to control. Inevitably the wobble of the head when one bumps & the collision of terra firma & the point of contact is harder to control. The tackling aspect has been a more refined analysis in play. No sling tackles are now enforced & a more measured approach of tackling has been remedied. Players have taken note & understand the new rulings.

2023-09-10T05:36:16+00:00

Barb Dwyer

Roar Rookie


I disagree re the actions of a 'few'. The NFL is showing the long-term effects of these clashes and the situation in the NRL is beyond a joke. They will look back on that sport in less than a generation and think, "why didn't we stop this?" And there are many in these two sports who believe AFL is even more dangerous. Not sure where your evidence is that the bump will be outlawed?

2023-09-10T05:29:28+00:00

Chanon

Roar Rookie


They have damning evidence based on scientific fact but the game & the people that run it will do everything they can to prevent such actions occurring. The rule changes & evolution of our contact sport that we luv will change dramatically in the future to benefit the actions of a few in our sport. The bump will be outlawed very soon & tackling will be scrutinised to an inch of its existence. The clashing of heads in a contest can never be stripped as two opposing players converge on the red leather. That’s the pantomime question :stoked:

2023-09-10T05:26:25+00:00

PriddisJunior

Roar Rookie


Yes mate, if you're knocking the bloke out, you're getting weeks. Doesn't matter how good it looks. I understand your point of view though Grew up watching Worsfold, and Beau Waters was another favourite player since then. But as PeteB says, the times have changed. You can't knock the head. Doesn't matter if you're taking mark of the year or making a bad smother attempt.

2023-09-10T05:18:42+00:00

AdamDilligafThompson

Roar Rookie


Im thinking the one at minimum despite all the debate whe t her it was a football act or not he still knocked him out and just like tackles that have led to suspensions they are a football act as well that just happened to cause an accident. Same same to me.lol.

2023-09-10T05:15:54+00:00

Barb Dwyer

Roar Rookie


'Restrictions' but no signs of stopping. Maybe we should listen to the experts.

2023-09-10T05:14:02+00:00

Barb Dwyer

Roar Rookie


Agreed. Let's hope so. I don't think 4 is out of the question. This is the chance to send a very clear message for an indisputably reckless act.

2023-09-10T05:11:22+00:00

Chanon

Roar Rookie


The continuing push to protect the head will lead inevitably to the restrictions or restraint of children playing contact sport.Most experts in neurodevelopment are pushing for this to occur.

2023-09-10T05:04:41+00:00

Barb Dwyer

Roar Rookie


You can't use "it's a contact sport" as the first defence line for everything. Maynard has clearly broken the defined rules, based on increased class actions of the AFL. Brain injuries affect people for life. The AFL has no choice but to act and it will rightfully be a minimum of 2 weeks for Maynard. Comparisons of yours to the AFLW have no relevance to this issue. Who is is that wants to stop kids playing contact sports? Where are these people?

2023-09-10T04:05:37+00:00

Chanon

Roar Rookie


It’s a contact sport Barb the only way to decrease head contact is to slow the game down, speed kil.s They want to stop kids playing contact sports. 15+ start for all & sundry. If they implement this change in time the sport will be the equivalent of watching AFLW. Preaching safe & measured approach is fraught with danger. Incidents will always occur in a human sport where bodies collide & emotions are let loose. Creating robotic puppets will take time to implement if that’s what you want :cricket:

2023-09-10T03:54:10+00:00

Naughty's Headband

Roar Rookie


Did you even watch the incident? Or are you from the “he changed his mind in mid air after he missed the ball and decided to iron him out, he wasn’t instinctively trying to stop from getting split” school of “thought”?

2023-09-10T03:52:12+00:00

Naughty's Headband

Roar Rookie


Because sometimes bad luck happens in football.

2023-09-10T03:49:11+00:00

Barb Dwyer

Roar Rookie


Another player has concussion because another player launched himself at him. The laws have changed due to class actions. If Maynard wants to ignore this, then accept the minimum of 2 weeks he'll receive. Minimum. Not at all difficult to see what is wrong with this.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar