Sheffield Shield Round 6 Wrap: Who's hot, who's not heading into the Test summer?

By Gibbo / Roar Pro

The final round before the Big Bash League gets underway and the Test summer… let’s see who impressed in an intriguing Round 6 of Shield cricket!

New South Wales vs Tasmania 

3 Sentence Summary: Tricky conditions and a difficult pitch led to some incredibly low scores in this match. New South Wales skittled Tasmania in this game in what was in many ways a major upset. Credit to the conditions and the groundsmen for creating an interesting match.

Who pushed Test claims? Chris Tremain is in red-hot form. A nine-wicket haul in this match further enhanced his credentials as a quality bowler, and if Scott Boland, two years his senior, can be in the reckoning, then surely Chris Tremain can be selected as a backup in the Test squad?

Who did not push Test claims? Caleb Jewell has had a shocker start to the Shield season. For a player representing Australia A at the start of the year, it is not the start that he would have wanted. Hopefully, he can use the BBL to freshen up a little and work on some consistency.

Queensland vs Western Australia

3 Sentence Summary: A battle of two giants in the Shield did not disappoint. On a tricky deck that had something in it for the bowlers throughout, Usman Khawaja and Hilton Cartwright stood up under searching attacks and produced classy centuries. Cameron Green and the selectors would be feeling much better about his form heading into the Test summer as he compiled a poised 96 in a relatively tame draw.

Cameron Green. (Photo by Bradley Kanaris/Getty Images)

Who Pushed Test Claims? Mark Steketee continues to go from strength to strength highlighting why he continues to be picked for Australia A. Hopefully a strong showing in that match will put him in good stead to become part of the wider squad at some point during the summer.

Who Did Not Push Test Claims? Cameron Bancroft did his Test recall prospects a bad turn when he left a ball from Jack Wildermuth that came back in to hit the off stump. Let’s hope that the selectors’ judgement is sounder than Bancroft’s when selecting the Australian side.

South Australia vs Victoria

3 Sentence Summary: Both sides will be rueing their middling scores on what was a bowler-friendly pitch. Both sides had opportunities to put the other away, but thanks to a century from Sam Harper and the response from Jake Fraser-McGurk, both sides had almost parity in their first innings. In the end, a South Australian collapse was all it took for Victoria to win by just 23 runs.

Who Pushed Test Claims? It was good to see Will Pucovski back playing top-flight cricket. Although his second innings 65 was his first score of note for the season, it will be an encouragement to him and to the Victorian and Australian selectors to see him back playing consistently.

Who Did Not Push Test Claims? Henry Hunt will be disappointed to miss out in both innings as he continues to push to show that he deserves selection in a post-David Warner Australia. Unfortunately, he will head into the BBL with few runs under his belt in the first half of the Sheffield Shield.

Best XI across the first round:

How this is selected – this looks at the best players in each position and fits them in where appropriate. Players can be moved down a rung in the batting order from where they normally bat, but they cannot move up. For example, Matthew Renshaw could open or bat at 3, but since he did not make runs in the middle order, he would not be eligible to bat in the middle order. The objective of this is to track the consistency across the Shield season. At least one player from each side should be selected unless one team utterly dominated that round.

Matt Renshaw
Joe Burns
Will Pucovski
Cameron Green
Hilton Cartwright
Jake Fraser-McGurk
Sam Harper
Gurinder Sandhu
Lawrence Neil-Smith
Mark Steketee
Chris Tremain

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Stay tuned for the remainder of the season after the Big Bash break!

The Crowd Says:

2023-12-04T11:28:28+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


Thanks Gibbo. :thumbup: :cricket:

2023-12-04T06:51:35+00:00

Munro Mike

Roar Rookie


100% - I can only assume the author discounted the bowler friendly conditions. It should be pointed out - - for the Vics - just how crucial Siddle and O'Neill were; because outside of them - the bowling struggle at times.

AUTHOR

2023-12-02T09:42:37+00:00

Gibbo

Roar Pro


If you read the rules, they can only be selected in the position they’re in or the one below it. In Khawaja’s case, I think it was a toss up between him and Green. I think that Green’s was more significant for him and for his side in the grand scheme of things. Khawaja doesn’t need runs. He’s assured of a spot in the Test team. So yes, a little stiff to miss out here, but he’s in the Test side already! Also why Marnus didn’t make my disappointment list cause he was right up there!

AUTHOR

2023-12-02T09:32:40+00:00

Gibbo

Roar Pro


Jeez not sure how I missed either of those two, tbh! Yes, both deserved to be selected. Sorry for overlooking it! :shocked:

2023-12-02T01:36:08+00:00

cricket tragic

Roar Rookie


How is Khawaja not #3 ahead of Pucovski (or #4 over Green for that matter)

2023-12-02T01:04:16+00:00

Doctor Rotcod

Roar Rookie


And Richardson with five for the match from 40 overs and a rapid 30+ in company with Cartwright. Good to see him back in the baggy yellow.

2023-12-01T23:32:59+00:00

BigGordon

Roar Rookie


In comparison to the track where Cartright and Green made runs, the SCG was a goat track, yet Ollie Davies once again top scored in the match with 81no. Interesting Puckovski gets the nod when Khawaja made a terrific hundred. And spare a thought for Lawrence Neil-Smith. 10 wickets in a match including a 7 fa and his team gets beaten! I don't think selectors gained much from that Shield round, thanks to ordinary pitches and rain. The one guy who hurt his chances badly was Marcus Harris. He played a real "get out" shot in the first innings.

2023-12-01T22:06:11+00:00

Opeo

Roar Rookie


O’Neill with 10/111 and 48 runs is stiff but not to make your 11.

Read more at The Roar