Five things we learned: Aussies given early Super Rugby warning, Lolesio's timely reminder

By Christy Doran / Editor

There might have only been one trans-Tasman fixture over the weekend, but Australian rugby was given an intimidating reminder of what is coming in 2024.

It wasn’t just the shellacking the Force copped against the Hurricanes, but the derby that kicked off the season between the Chiefs and Crusaders.

Despite the Chiefs losing several starting forwards and the Crusaders farewelling arguably the two most successful Super Rugby players ever (Sam Whitelock and Richie Mo’unga) as well as the competition’s greatest coach Scott Robertson, last year’s finalists put on a show.

Played in lovely conditions, both sides showcased running rugby at its finest while displaying an incredible amount of physicality.

Damian McKenzie was a case in point.

The Chiefs playmaker, who is a man on a mission to try and convince new All Blacks coach Robertson that he is a Test quality fly-half and not simply an awesome utility back, would get rocked to the core in the opening 40 minutes and then take the Crusaders’ defence to the cleaners with his vision and pace.

It’s that aspect that Australian sides have failed to cope with over the past decade, which was showcased by the Hurricanes blowing away the Force in every aspect of the match on Friday night.

Indeed, it’s the missing hardness that Eddie Jones was speaking of during his final days as Wallabies coach during his rare moment of candidness.

The other local derby not being spoken about as much either is the Highlanders’ win over Moana Pasifika.

Neither side will push for the trophy at the end of the season, but the skill, pace and physicality on display in Dunedin ensured the opening weekend of Super Rugby was a memorable one.

The Highlanders’ back-row trio Sean Withy, Billy Harmon and Hugh Renton ensured the home side got across the line, while Pari Pari Parkinson, who was a tad fortunate not to be sent to the sin bin early, brought the necessary hardness to compete in the competition.

Keep an eye on Highlanders fullback Jacob Ratumaitavuki-Kneepkens, who might be a mouthful but looks to finally be the replacement the franchise have long wanted in the No.15 jersey since Ben Smith left in 2019.

Next weekend’s Super Round, where there will be three trans-Tasman fixtures, will give a strong indication of whether Australia will have another side other than the Brumbies who can compete in the tournament.

The Reds will take on the Hurricanes, while Rob Penney, who was sacked by the Waratahs early in his second season in charge, will take on his former franchise. The Brumbies will also play the Chiefs.

FORGOTTEN FLY-HALF DELIVERS TIMELY REMINDER IN WIDE OPEN 10 DEBATE

Noah Lolesio dropped out of the Wallabies conversation last year under Eddie Jones.

But the 23-year-old delivered a timely reminder to Joe Schmidt and Rugby Australia officials as he enters the final year of his contract.

The Brumbies will be desperate to keep Lolesio, but much will depend on whether he receives a national top-up. If he doesn’t, he could be lost to Australian rugby.

That might not hurt the Wallabies as much as the Super Rugby competition, but heading into his fifth season of professional rugby, it’s only now that we should be starting to see him flourish and enter the national conversation.

Lolesio certainly outplayed his opposite Carter Gordon.

Noah Lolesio delivered a timely showing for the Brumbies during their big win over the Rebels at AAMI Park on February 23, 2024, in Melbourne. (Photo by Asanka Ratnayake/Getty Images)

Where Gordon missed an early simple shot at three points and later touch from a penalty, Lolesio was sharp and took the ball to the line.

His decision to play the short side to set up Corey Toole was first class.

It’s not like the Rebels’ pack was beaten either.

They had plenty of chances and front-foot ball, particularly when Taniela Tupou entered the fray after half-time, but Gordon was quieter than hoped.

Over in the west, Ben Donaldson had an unconvincing first display in the Force jersey.

It wasn’t easy playing behind a beaten forward pack, but when Donaldson started running the ball more in the second half he looked better. As did Max Burey, who will give Simon Cron much to ponder given his acceleration.

In Brisbane, Tom Lynagh was solid on a greasy night after evening rain while Harry McLaughlin-Phillips was sprightly off the bench.

The Waratahs, meanwhile, struggled to find any real rhythm in their attack.

REBELS SHOOT THEMSELVES IN THE FOOT

With their future hanging in the balance after falling into voluntary administration, the Rebels didn’t help themselves on Friday night against the Brumbies.

Needing a strong performance to try and change the narrative, the Rebels sunk even lower by delivering a deeply disappointing display.

After two promising trial matches, the Rebels dropped the ball on the field as their skill sets let them down.

The Rebels had 16 entries into the Brumbies’ 22m zone yet managed just three points. That’s inexcusable.

Rob Leota was left seething following his side’s poor execution against the Brumbies. (Photo by Asanka Ratnayake/Getty Images)

Once again, the lineout was their Achilles heel.

Jordan Uelese, who was taken to last year’s World Cup because of his broad shoulders and ability to scrum, was the main offender with his throw letting him down again.

He wasn’t alone in making clumsy mistakes, with Vaiolini Ekusai stupidly grabbing hold of Tom Hooper’s jersey not once but twice as his teammate and captain Rob Leota charged to the line to score.

The moment of madness not only denied the Rebels a second-half surge but summed up their head-shaking performance a week out from hosting Super Round.

THE OTHER BRUMBY WHO ANNOUNCED HIMSELF

Charlie Cale’s marvellous try against the Rebels put himself on the Super Rugby map, but his back-row teammate Luke Reimer made an even bigger statement.

Behind a quality back-row featuring Rob Valetini and Pete Samu last year, breakdown specialist Reimer was largely limited to game-changing moments off the bench.

Now with Samu gone, Reimer has arrived. Fraser McReight watch out.

Luke Reimer is expected to get big minutes in the No.7 jersey for the Brumbies following Pete Samu’s departure to France. (Photo by Daniel Pockett/Getty Images)

The 23-year-old could well be the best breakdown exponent in Australian rugby already.

It’s not just how often he manages to pinch the ball, but the timing of it too.

Reimer swings matches with his timing.

That can be easier when matches get more open later in games, but what will encourage Stephen Larkham is that for the first time as a starter, he did it from the outset.

FORCE’S SET-PIECE CONCERNS HAVEN’T GONE AWAY

Off the back of their busy work in the transfer market, many were quietly optimistic about the Force in 2024. They still might be proven right.

But, for that to be the case, they’ve got to fix up their set-piece struggles otherwise they’ll have no chance.

Against the Hurricanes, the Brumbies’ scrum largely struggled and their lineout crumbled.

Cron wasn’t helped by losing Izack Rodda and new skipper Jeremey Williams, as well as loose-head prop Harry Hoopert, but their absence highlighted the raw underbelly of Australian rugby.

Marley Peace, who was cited for a high tackle in the second half after failing to drop his body height, will develop into a strong prop, but the 20-year-old isn’t ready yet to start at loose-head prop week-in, week out.

The struggles up front also meant they didn’t get the front-foot ball they wanted for their new halves pairing.

If they don’t manage to rectify it against the Rebels, it could be another long night for them in Melbourne during Super Round.

Christy Doran’s Australian team of the week

Alex Hodgman, Matt Faessler, Harry Johnson-Holmes, Nick Frost, Seru Uru, Rob Valetini, Luke Reimer, Harry Wilson, Tate McDermott, Noah Lolesio, Corey Toole, Hunter Paisami, Josh Flook, Dylan Pietsch, Andrew Kellaway.

The Crowd Says:

2024-02-28T04:04:46+00:00

Spunkmeyer

Roar Rookie


Holloway and Hanigan are hard, they can be your locks. T Wilson and Bowen for 9 10.

2024-02-28T03:15:51+00:00

LuckyPhil

Roar Rookie


Same things as the last few years. Missing 4 and 5 with a bit of hardness, Jake should stop trying to play like Nick White, and Tane Edmed needs more experience.

2024-02-28T01:39:17+00:00

Spunkmeyer

Roar Rookie


No he wasn't needed for the Reds to win easily.

2024-02-28T01:37:57+00:00

Spunkmeyer

Roar Rookie


Imagine if they weren't flakey. It would have been a much bigger thumping.

2024-02-28T01:36:34+00:00

Spunkmeyer

Roar Rookie


Did you learn anything about the 2024 Waratahs?

2024-02-28T01:34:43+00:00

Spunkmeyer

Roar Rookie


6th thing. Tahs have a woeful roster and out of his depth coach.

2024-02-27T23:59:19+00:00

Hoy

Roar Guru


How I see it was that he was so attuned to attack, he saw opportunity where it was, but others were not on the same page. The Reds were generally attuned, but at international level, other team's players were just not used to how he saw things. I think of it this way... You have to be in that frame of mind. Playing touch for example, and it is normally, robotically, 3 trucks up the middle, and then look up for the last 2... but if you look up on the 2nd, see something on, and want to throw a long pass to a gap, your team MUST "see it" too, otherwise, they just aren't ready for it and it goes to ground in bad field position. Players in Australia have been so robotically trained to follow game phase plans that situational awareness is not something any of them can now pick up quickly. It's like our players have been taken through stations... I have seen it at club training... phase 1 here, then do this for phase 2, then this for phase 3... but anything outside that, and noone knows what to do then. I was sure the Wallabies used to train unopposed. That is how obvious it looked that we could not combat actual opposition disrupting our plans... It was like we weren't ready for it for years and years at International level.

2024-02-27T20:27:04+00:00

Cec

Roar Rookie


Relative to young Quade, it would be TRC21. Those four wins vs Boks and ARG. Kick at the end from 45m out after White”s pilfer. Namaste

2024-02-27T12:49:30+00:00

Red Dog

Roar Rookie


Possibly as back up to the superior Fraser.

2024-02-27T12:48:38+00:00

Red Dog

Roar Rookie


Was there ever a Zen Iceman ?

2024-02-27T12:20:53+00:00

Cec

Roar Rookie


Nice way to put that. But for me the young Quade would do something brilliant followed up with something ugly to turn over the ball & I saw that as showboating & a bit selfish back then. The Zen Quade in TRC21 didn’t make those turnovers or 50/50 plays so we retained the pill for more opportunities for the team.

2024-02-27T09:46:28+00:00

The Strategist

Roar Rookie


So many including Wallaby coaches have thought that Wilson needs to improve his footwork to make another metre or 2. What Wilson brings to the table is very fast ball recycle when he runs it. He sacrifices a metre to create fast ball. Valentini's greatest weakness is that he sacrifies fast ball for another metre. Both Ireland and the All Blacks don't care about the metre they care about fast ball. Schmidt will pick Wilson for this fact alone. Slow ball is the enemy of modern rugby, and it is part of the reason why Wallaby coaches have failed so dismally.

2024-02-27T09:35:25+00:00

The Strategist

Roar Rookie


Coker, I 100% agree with your comment. I am a fan of Valetini however he is not anywhere near the skill level of Wilson. Valetini's season in 2023 was poor and especially in Gold. He is simply not an 8. Wilson is an incredible talent, however, as is so often the case in Australian rugby players are tarnished or glorified beyond reality. Wilson is tarnished by people who simply are spectators of the game rather than experts of the game. Wilson is one of the first Wallaby players who would be picked in an All Black side. So would McReight. All Blacks 100% of the time play a team game. There are no individual All Blacks. Wilson and McReight are the best team players in Australian rugby. Ireland play the same and it is why Schmidt will select both these guys.

2024-02-27T06:39:40+00:00

DJ

Roar Rookie


I thought maybe a bit slow too at first, there was a good video on here that showed it but Roar taken it down now. Rebels number 12 got across and slowed him that let Carter catch up (Stan got it wrong saying it was Leota). Thought it was a decent run, for a 10.

2024-02-27T05:38:20+00:00

Hoy

Roar Guru


What? Quade has always enabled teammates... probably the only difference is before, he would throw to the hole. The Quade now, probably holds those passes when he sees others don't see it.

2024-02-27T05:34:58+00:00

Hoy

Roar Guru


He took an intercept on the defensive 22, and was mowed down by about the other half's 40 from memory.

2024-02-27T05:04:22+00:00

Cannonball

Roar Rookie


80’s/90’s at the Roodogs mate :thumbup:

2024-02-27T04:35:28+00:00

Hoy

Roar Guru


Agree with Peitsch and CT, however I thought MN was quite, except for the intercept.

2024-02-27T04:35:13+00:00

ScottD

Roar Guru


A very underrated player and definitely a future international imo, but not sure if that is an over reach.

2024-02-27T04:27:31+00:00

ScottD

Roar Guru


If he doesn't think it's working then I guess he'll make abolishing it a condition of his contract extension. If he does elect to accept a contract extension, that might tell us something too.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar