The Super Rugby season is not yet at the halfway point, but a review of Darren Coleman’s Waratahs is already underway.
The Roar can reveal that Rugby Australia this week started their review into the Waratahs, who earlier this year handed over their Super Rugby license to the national governing body.
It’s believed Mike Chu – a high performance manager with World Rugby, who previously worked for New Zealand Rugby and Rugby Canada – has been tasked with running the review.
Waratahs players this week were told they might be tapped on their shoulder to help with the review.
It comes as RA, together with NSW Rugby, consider whether to offer Coleman an extension, with his entire coaching team off contract at season’s end.
But after just one win from their opening six matches, which has included four straight defeats of less than seven points, all signs point to a changing of the guard.
Darren Coleman’s future is on the line, with Rugby Australia starting their review. (Photo by Matt King/Getty Images)
The unusual timing of the review comes as RA looks to give clarity to all parties, with Coleman keen to work out his future.
The governing body wants to get their house in order as quickly as possible too, particularly with a British and Irish Lions tour only 15 months away.
“This is business as usual, right? You run a review of your program, of the coach, and there wouldn’t be any difference from any other high performance organisation globally,” RA director of high performance Peter Horne said last week.
Should there be a change in the head coaching role, Coleman’s assistant Jason Gilmore, Junior Wallabies coach Nathan Grey, and Michael Cheika, the franchise’s only Super Rugby winning mentor and the 2015 World Rugby coach of the year, are the three favourites.
It’s understood Andy Friend, who returned from Ireland late last year after five seasons at Connacht, won’t put his hat in the ring.
The experienced coach is enjoying other opportunities, including mentoring fellow coaches and spending time at other high performance teams across the world.
Gilmore denied the off-field uncertainty was impacting the Waratahs’ season.
“I don’t think so,” he said.
“We’re aware of what’s going on and all that type of thing.
“You’ve just got to park it.
“If you get too caught up and live in that space then you’re going to die in that space as well.
“The boys have been really good. Their intensity and application at training have been excellent.”
Gilmore, who also coaches Australia A and led the Junior Wallabies to the 2019 under-20s world championship final in Argentina, added some clarity would help.
“It’s always nice to know and have clarity of what’s going to happen,” he said.
The Waratahs look defected following their loss to the Rebels in Sydney last Friday. (Photo by Matt King/Getty Images)
While a lot of the attention has been on the Waratahs’ on-field struggles, several figures are also looking at the back office, including chief executive Paul Doorn.
Questions have long been bubbling in the background as to how the Waratahs have gone from a $3.5 million profit to a deficit extending into the millions.
Nor has the Waratahs’ move from a series of demountables to one of Australian rugby’s finest high performance facilities helped either.
The return to Allianz Stadium hasn’t helped either, with the Waratahs’ biggest crowd in 2024 13,533.
The uncertainty at Daceyville comes as the Waratahs look to snap an 11-game losing streak against the Brumbies, which included last year’s 40-36 heart-breaking defeat at the death in Canberra.
That four-point defeat came just days after Brumbies chairman Matt Nobbs lit the fuse by saying the rivalry had gone cold and was dead.
On Thursday, Gilmore said there was still plenty of meaning between the arch-rivals.
“Probably to an administrator it is, potentially, but I think if you look at how the two teams have battled it out, it doesn’t look dead to me. It’s on,” he said.
“In my time here every game’s been a real battle from both sides.
“Whether it’s dead or not, I’ll leave a bloke behind the desk describe that but I know from a footy point of view this is a big game.
“This week naturally you get up for it.
This week’s about effort, execution and keeping your detail good.”
Jason Gilmore says the Waratahs want clarity on the future, but the off-field distractions won’t affect them against the Brumbies on Saturday in Canberra. (Photo by Matt King/Getty Images)
Gilmore said the match up would be “personal” for the playing group, with new Wallabies coach Joe Schmidt bound to be watching closely.
“Playing the Brumbs is always a big derby, it’s like playing the Reds, heavily stacked with Wallabies in their forward pack in particular, there’s a couple of our boys that see this as a personal challenge as well,” he said.
“It’s going to be a big battle up front.”
But Lachie Swinton, who admitted it had been a “grind” to get to his 50th match, said the Waratahs couldn’t afford to look beyond this weekend.
“We’ve got to focus on ourselves at the moment and look after our backyard and start winning before that (international selection) starts poking its head up,” he said.
“It’s quite a good match-up across the board from 1-15. It is somewhat personal.”
Swinton added that the Waratahs were embracing the underdog tag.
“We’re going down there swinging and when we’ve been in these positions, we’ve shown up,” he said. “It’s all ahead of us.”
Muglair
Roar Rookie
… and more. National coaching and development scheme was chopped down by JON in 1994 and yet to be replaced. Just like players, we have no depth of coaches ready for super rugby.
Muglair
Roar Rookie
I thought about that, but there is a limit, even if they are all still available. Professionally speaking, you probably cannot properly analyse any franchise, the Wallabies, or RA without access to all of the financial information and a comprehensive understanding of all of the internal dealings, especially wage top ups for elite players. You would like to think somebody has done that, but I would be pretty confident nobody has. Equally confident that if somebody has done it, correctly, then it is a closely guarded secret. Pretty stupid because if rugby is to survive in Australia, then like Victoria, it requires the rugby community to step up financially. Secrecy is not a strategy to gain allies.
Muglair
Roar Rookie
:angry: :shocked: I wondered what the extra charge was for? Always a risk taking the cheapskate option
Wig1
Roar Rookie
Open box until they screw the roof on :laughing:
kingplaymaker
Roar Guru
Yes and it's a pattern which has meant the Australian franchises have been beaten easily for the past decade.
Cec
Roar Rookie
I would think that you’d have to look at the financials from 2014 onwards
Muglair
Roar Rookie
I would have thought it would be the winning year they made a profit. Either way I just looked at the financial statements at 31 December 2022 and the whole thing becomes quite mysterious. Where did these massive losses and deficits come from? I suspect a lot of misreporting by “journalists” who think they can read a financial statement. Or who just cut and paste what they are told to write?
Cec
Roar Rookie
Not sure. But is it in context to loans or forgiven debt in that same year.
Muglair
Roar Rookie
When was this $3.5m profit? I am guessing 2014. It is hardly a surprise at all.
Muglair
Roar Rookie
Yes but off field performance leads back to Moore Park
Muglair
Roar Rookie
Both assistants were helping Penney, then co head coaches, then assisting Coleman. There is a pattern there, and you don’t need to look for it.
Muglair
Roar Rookie
Stadium hasn’t changed the crowds much, the rugby slightly better than since it was pulled down. The 2014 Waratahs did not recover the crowds lost after 2010, I don’t expect them back until there is a major change in how rugby is promoted.
Cec
Roar Rookie
We’ve heard plenty of anecdotal reasons why more good money after bad should still be pumped into the Tahs, but where is the business case or numbers to support this argument? If the Tahs proposition is to be looked at as a business case then the actual numbers matter way more than empty promises or potential. I would have thought three decades of operating would be sufficient data to say “you’re fired!” There’s three strikes here against the Tahs in Christy’s article. ”Questions have long been bubbling in the background as to how the Waratahs have gone from a $3.5 million profit to a deficit extending into the millions. Nor has the Waratahs’ move from a series of demountables to one of Australian rugby’s finest high performance facilities helped either. The return to Allianz Stadium hasn’t helped either, with the Waratahs’ biggest crowd in 2024 13,533.”
Muglair
Roar Rookie
:crying: :crying: :crying: I am in an “open box” and wondering what it means. A long way to travel to get wet and I don’t want to contemplate losing as well.
Muglair
Roar Rookie
Very true about the tough draw, but then the next four games are against 1,2,3 and a possibly resurgent Crusaders. Personally I don’t think they are anywhere near as bad as last year, but maybe I am just getting used to it. Like 2016-2019 :crying:
Muglair
Roar Rookie
Yes they table them, and then file them. Apparently they lose all value if you let anyone see them, apart from selected excerpts for selected jopurnalists.
cs
Roar Guru
Just sayin' I don't think they're playing that badly and if there was a simple way to make them better one of the last three coaches would have found it. In particular, I reckon a 'get tough(er)' approach more likely to lead to poorer rather than better performance. For mine, the Tahs need more poise and cohesiveness to realise the talent. How do you get that?
Train Without A Station
Roar Guru
I actually think it’s a funny situation where there’s no bad decision or no good decision. Like it’s reasonable to say he’s 1-5 and while the team has been competing after 3 years we’d expect the team to be converting those to wins. But also you can easily point to strong performances to decent teams and say it was a tough draw to start the year (which everybody said before round 1) and while it’s all about wins we need to look deeper to make the call.
Guess
Roar Rookie
You serious? Different situation. Coaches inject youth all the time. Just because mad man went over the top doesn't mean it's bad
cs
Roar Guru
Going for youth worked well for Eddie.