Penrith Panthers vs Parramatta Eels: Parra upset Panthers 20-12

By Stuart Thomas / Expert

Panthers

12

Match Complete

Eels

20

77M. Moses
76M. Jennings
N. Cleary65
J. Tamou64
N. Cleary56
W. Egan54
45M. Moses
44R. Mahoney
24M. Jennings
14M. Niukore

2
Tries
4
2
Conversions
2
0
Penalty Goals
0
0
Field Goals
0

Match result:

The Parramatta Eels have begun their 2019 NRL season with an unexpected win over the Penrith Panthers, prevailing 20-12 at the foot of the mountains.

It was a match that the visitors controlled and thoroughly deserved to win, despite the sin-binning of Michael Jennings that saw the Panthers mount a second-half surge.

Earlier, it had been all the Eels with a dominance in possession during the first half that saw two tries send them to the break with an 8-0 lead.

Not long after the intermission, Michael Jennings was sin-binned for a high shot on Isaah Yeo, that saw the young forward leave the field in less than full coherence.

The Panthers pounced and tries to Wade Egan and James Tamou brought them back within two points, and the Eels held a 14-12 lead as Jennings returned to the field.

However, it was to be Parra’s day and as soon as he did, the Eels clicked back into gear and played the better football over the last 15 minutes.

After appearing to score with five minutes remaining, before being denied by the bunker, a late hit on Mitchell Moses saw them given another chance and Jennings redeemed himself with a try out wide before Moses converted to send the Eels into the first-round winners’ column.

It was a great win for the wooden spooners of 2018 and the Panthers will feel they played well below their potential in the wet conditions at Panthers Stadium.

Final score
Penrith Panthers 12
Parramatta Eels 20

Match preview:

The Penrith Panthers and Parramatta Eels clash in a traditional NRL western derby at Panthers Stadium. Join The Roar for live scores and commentary from 4:05pm (AEDT).

Both the Panthers and Eels have nervously waited as club after club has taken to the field to begin their NRL campaigns for 2019.

Finally, Sunday afternoon sees their opportunities and the long awaited appearance of the two popular clubs will put smiles on the faces of thousands of supporters.

Sadly, most of those supporters will not be at Panthers Stadium, with torrential rain predicted for Sydney throughout much of the day.

The spectacle will no doubt be affected and a tight, low scoring affair seems likely. Such has been the quantity of rain this weekend in Sydney that the rare sight of pooling water may come to pass; something quite rare on well-drained, modern NRL surfaces.

Expectations around both sides could not be more different. The Panthers loom as a top four team in 2019, with Nathan Cleary at the helm in the halves and a host of exciting and hard running back-rowers ready to take another step forward and improve.

Isaac Yeo and James Fisher-Harris are two such players and along with Dylan Edwards, Waqa Blake and Josh Mansour in a now experienced back line, Penrith look strong across the park.

Parramatta are hoping for anything but another season of misery. Much expectation will be placed on new signings Blake Ferguson and Shaun Lane, with Mitchell Moses taking on the majority of responsibility for the creation of attacking opportunities.

Squad depth looks to be a serious question for the Eels and Brad Arthur will be under the pump right from the outset.

Prediction
The Panthers should mop up the Eels easily in this one, however, the weather looks like keeping things tighter than many would expect.

The power running of the Panthers up front will dent the Parramatta defence on a consistent basis and a trickle of points in the wet will be enough for the home side to claim victory.

Catch all the action on The Roar live coverage from 4:05pm (AEDT).

Where: Panthers Stadium, Penrith
When: Sunday 17 March 2019, 4:05pm (AEDT)
TV: Fox Sports, NINE Network
Betting: Penrith Panthers $1.50, Parramatta Eels $2.55

Panthers
1 Dylan Edwards 2 Josh Mansour 3 Waqa Blake 4 Dean Whare 5 Dallin Watene-Zelezniak 6 James Maloney 7 Nathan Cleary 8 James Tamou 14 Wayde Egan 10 Reagan Campbell-Gillard 11 Jack Hetherington 12 Isaah Yeo 13 James Fisher-Harris.

Interchange: 15 Tyrell Fuimaono 16 Moses Letoa 17 Hame Sele.

Reserves: 18 Jarome Luai 19 Tim Grant 21 Malakai Watene-Zelezniak

Eels
1 Clinton Gutherson (c) 2 Maika Sivo 3 Michael Jennings 4 Brad Takairangi 5 Blake Ferguson 6 Dylan Brown 7 Mitchell Moses 8 Daniel Alvaro 9 Reed Mahoney 10 Tepai Moeroa 11 Shaun Lane 12 Marata Niukore 13 Nathan Brown.

Interchange: 14 Will Smith 15 Tim Mannah (c) 16 Kane Evans 17 David Gower.

Reserves: 18 Josh Hoffman 19 Oregon Kaufusi

Comments:

2019-03-17T08:09:08+00:00

Doug Graves

Guest


I had a feeling this was gonna happen, good thing I tipped the Eels in my multi! Penrith are massively, massively, overrated this season. I can see them limping into the finals in 7th or 8th and easily going out first week. So much for Gould's 5 year plan it's headed for year 9 now!

2019-03-17T07:52:36+00:00

Harry

Guest


Sorry to hear that, I feel for you. I had a multi also dependent on the Panthers that would have returned $100 from $13.

2019-03-17T07:40:53+00:00

Joe

Roar Rookie


Never thought I'd ever say this but Mitchell Moses defensive effort probably won the Eels the game. He was outstanding tonight and probably the Eels best.

2019-03-17T07:36:48+00:00

Joe

Roar Rookie


Good win by the Eels. They really turned up for this one and started so well then finished it off after the Panthers threatened a comeback. They were definitely the better team. Their debutantes were very good. It seems that whenever they get written off they seem to turn up. Dare i say they will be challenging for the 8?

AUTHOR

2019-03-17T07:27:01+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


The Parramatta Eels have begun their 2019 NRL season with an unexpected win over the Penrith Panthers, prevailing 20-12 at the foot of the mountains. It was a match that the visitors controlled and thoroughly deserved to win, despite the sin binning of Michael Jennings that saw the Panthers mount a second half surge . Earlier, it had been all the Eels with a dominance in possession during the first half that saw two tries send them to the break with an 8-0 lead. Not long after the intermission, Michael Jennings was sin binned for a high shot on Isaah Yeo, that saw the young forward leave the field in less than full coherence. The Panthers pounced and tries to Wade Egan and James Tamou brought them back within two points, and the Eels held a 14-12 lead as Jennings returned to the field. However, it was to be Parra's day and as soon as he did, the Eels clicked back into gear and played the better football over the last 15 minutes. After appearing to score with five minutes remaining, before being denied by the bunker, a late hit on Mitchell Moses saw them given another chance and Jennings redeemed himself with a try out wide before Moses converted to send the Eels into the first round winners column. It was a great win for the wooden spooners of 2018 and the Panthers will feel they played well below their potential in the wet conditions at Panthers Stadium. Final Score Penrith Panthers………...12 Parramatta Eels……..…..20

2019-03-17T07:18:45+00:00

Rob

Guest


Bad luck Scott. After last years craziness I wouldn’t even attempt that bet in the first round. I wonder if the referring has helped people a least get most correct? Last year was a nightmare.

2019-03-17T07:12:14+00:00

Papi Smurf

Roar Rookie


The Titans are without Ash Taylor, Scott. So I don’t think that the Titans will be doing you any favours. Spare a thought for the Panthers fan who put $4,000 on the Panthers to win today. Update: and 12 mins in the Titans have lost Tyrone Roberts for the game. No Taylor, no Roberts, no hope for the Titans.

AUTHOR

2019-03-17T07:10:24+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Boo Penrith!

2019-03-17T07:09:26+00:00

Scott Pryde

Expert


Well, I almost pulled off the greatest bet of my life - Storm, Knights, Rabbitohs, Warriors 13+, Tigers 13+, Panthers and Titans... Would have paid $774 from $3, and the Panthers just had to go and ruin it, didn't they?

AUTHOR

2019-03-17T07:09:21+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Thanks for being on board for the match. The match report will follow in ten minutes. Be sure to stick around for the Roar's coverage of the Titans and the Raiders from the Gold Coast.

2019-03-17T07:08:53+00:00

Hard Yards

Roar Rookie


Stone the crows.

2019-03-17T07:08:49+00:00

Papi Smurf

Roar Rookie


Some poor Panthers fan put $4,000 on the Panthers! Didn't they read the fine print, "Gamble responsibly"? What a goose!

AUTHOR

2019-03-17T07:06:38+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


FULL-TIME In an upset, the Eels have beaten the Panthers. Penrith Panthers………...12 Parramatta Eels……..…..20

2019-03-17T07:06:34+00:00

Papi Smurf

Roar Rookie


Eels win! I wonder whether thay are going to do a lap of honour? ;-)

2019-03-17T07:06:13+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


Well deserved win...

AUTHOR

2019-03-17T07:05:56+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


80' Penrith have it and kick long in desperation. Parramatta have it. Penrith Panthers………...12 Parramatta Eels……..…..20

AUTHOR

2019-03-17T07:05:29+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


80' Gower does the same. Penrith Panthers………...12 Parramatta Eels……..…..20

AUTHOR

2019-03-17T07:05:08+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


79' Mannah settles things down up the middle. Penrith Panthers………...12 Parramatta Eels……..…..20

AUTHOR

2019-03-17T07:04:49+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


79' Penrith try the short kick and win it back before Tamou is stripped and the Eels will run down the clock. I think. Penrith Panthers………...12 Parramatta Eels……..…..20

AUTHOR

2019-03-17T07:04:07+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


I knew he would kick it. That's why I went off so early. Penrith Panthers………...12 Parramatta Eels……..…..20

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar