Crow collapse makes this Sydney's flag to lose

By Josh / Expert

After the Adelaide Crows last night coughed up a 29-point capitulation to the West Coast Eagles on their home turf, the Sydney Swans must surely be the clear favourites by a wide margin to take out the 2016 premiership.

Less than a month ago the AFL coaches said that the Swans should be premiership favourites – well, more than half of them did anyway, according to an AFL survey.

I thought it was a bit of surprise at the time. The Swans were good, sure, but the clear favourites? With only 11.8 per cent tipping Adelaide, and absolutley no one backing Geelong? In what seemed like such an even year, it felt bizarre that one side would be so heavily backed.

But they were ahead of their time, it seems. Or ahead of me at least. Because right now the magic eight-ball is saying that all signs point to a Sydney premiership.

Before that – an enormous amount of credit is due to the West Coast Eagles for their win last night. They’ve had an incredible turnaround in the past few weeks, made all the more impressive by their ability to cope with the loss of Nic Naitanui.

After being criticised all year for failing to compete away from home, and failing to compete against the best sides, they’ve won three consecutive matches against top eight competition, two of them on the road.

In fact, their three-week stretch of form has been arguably the most impressive three weeks we’ve seen any club put together all year. And they are certainly doing it at the right time of the season.

The Crows, in contrast, must be feeling absolutely crushed. They could potentially have claimed the minor premiership with a win last night and would at least have made a top two spot virtually certain.

Instead, now, they’re clinging to the hope that one of Geelong, Hawthorn or GWS will cop a loss this week. If those three sides all win – and they’re all favourites going into their matches – the Crows will miss the top four entirely.

Twenty-four hours ago my expectation was that Sydney and Adelaide would finish top two on the ladder this season and then eventually play off in the grand final – Sydney probably going in as favourites, but not by much.

However that’s now off the cards and Adelaide will have to fight their way to the final day of September with at least two and maybe three finals wins required interstate if they’re going to lift the premiership cup.

The Swans just seem to be on the right side of all the percentages now. So long as they beat Richmond today – and that seems extremely likely given the Tigers’ youth focus – they will have the minor premiership locked up and can ride successive home qualifying and preliminary finals all the way to a grand final berth.

Whoever they face will be at the disadvantage. Sure, for Geelong and Hawthorn it’d be a home ground advantage, technically, but the Swans have beaten both those sides on the road this year, and I’d back them in to do it again.

Geelong have the Dangerwood factor but Sydney have the Kennedy-Parker-Hannebery-Mitchell quartet. Hawthorn’s ailing forward line is no match for Sydney’s stalwart defense. Adelaide, who I saw as their strongest rivals, will probably be just too tired from taking the hard road to the final – if they make it there at all.

Can West Coast or GWS threaten? They don’t even have top four spots locked in at the moment though and like Adelaide they’re just going to have to put so much more work in to make the final that surely the Swans would make short work of them on the big day. And the Western Bulldogs and North Melbourne would need a miracle to be anything better than making up the numbers in September.

It’s been a season of surprises, and I won’t dare write off another one. Anything could still happen. But if everything goes as it most probably will, the Swans will be cheer, cheering the red and the white come curtains on grand final day. If they play their cards right, the flag is theirs to lose.

The Crowd Says:

2016-08-28T03:20:05+00:00

Cat

Roar Guru


In the last 7 weeks: Sydney 6-1 overall, 1-1 against top 8 sides Geelong 7-0 overall, 2-0 against top 8 sides Hawthorn 4-2* overall, 2-1 against top 8 sides GWS 6-1 overall, 1-1 against top 8 sides Adelaide 5-2 overall, 0-2 against top 8 sides West Coast 6-1 overall, 3-0 against top 8 sides Bulldogs 4-2* overall, 1-1 against top 8 sides North 2-5 overall, 0-4 against top 8 sides *final games to be played today North is clearly off the pace, Adelaide hasn't beaten a top 8 side recently while the rest are fairly similar. I don't see Sydney ahead of any of the other top 4 sides. West Coast might have the best form heading into finals but can it continue on the road for 3 or 4 weeks in a row?

2016-08-28T03:11:20+00:00

Momentbymoment

Guest


Any team that can make the Hawks their bunnies is in the race for the flag. Hasn't been done too often in the last 5 years.

2016-08-28T02:08:13+00:00

Swift foetus

Guest


I second that! Quite amazed at people being so confident of who will will the GF at this point in time. I get there are favourites but all it takes is one slip up and that team is gone. Would not be shocked if Gws beat Syd.

2016-08-28T00:11:08+00:00

VivGilchrist

Guest


Why should they have one? What does that even mean? Crows absolutely smashed them in the last quarter. Nice logic.

2016-08-27T23:00:06+00:00

Sydneygirl

Guest


Sydney looked good yeste day. But competition in finals is going to be a lot stronger Niger than Richmond were.

2016-08-27T22:28:35+00:00

michael RVC

Roar Pro


Swannies has been making this statement for weeks now. Ok, you may be proven right, I hope so, but it's an all or nothing call. Fair enough, but discounts other very good teams. Form? Yes. Definite win? Nope. It's on the day.

2016-08-27T21:54:25+00:00

Cam

Guest


Dogs are the only team to have beaten the Swans twice on the SCG in the past 2 years. Just sayin....

2016-08-27T15:31:04+00:00

Raimond

Roar Guru


If GWS, Adelaide, and West Coast finish 4, 5, and 6 then it would clearly be the best chance under this system for a team from one of those positions to take the flag.

2016-08-27T15:19:49+00:00

Raimond

Roar Guru


This should be emblazoned on The Roar's AFL home page if the Giants take the flag.

2016-08-27T13:17:01+00:00

Cat

Roar Guru


Beating a bunch of witches hats proved what exactly?

2016-08-27T12:51:01+00:00

Mister Football

Roar Guru


Swans might now be favourites - but you can't compare their season (in 2016) with Carlton in 1995 and Essendon in 2000 (two losses and one loss respectively).

2016-08-27T12:27:25+00:00

Swannies

Guest


After today's win, Swans look unbeatable. Like Essendon in 2000 and Carlton in 1995. They are a class above everyone else...including the Hawks. 2016 will be the Swans year.

2016-08-27T11:33:55+00:00

13th man

Guest


Talk about tempting fate...... surely all Swans fans would be saying "na Hawthorn are still favorites..."

2016-08-27T08:34:32+00:00

fairsuckofthesav

Guest


Schadenfreude. What goes around comes around.

2016-08-27T08:33:51+00:00

Sammy

Guest


Every adelaide supporter hopes you are right as well..go and make the 4 guys not playing on proud...please

2016-08-27T08:05:06+00:00

Birdman

Guest


Crows appear to be victims of a soft run into finals which inflated their credentials until last night. Swans may be favoured but they are no certs -since their last loss (against Hawks) they have played Carlton, Freo, Port, Saints , North and Richmond - .pretty soft IMHO.

2016-08-27T06:50:45+00:00

RooBoy16

Guest


PP7...Adelaide always makes me nervous! I would rather play any team away but the Crows. North have a shocking record in Adelaide and can't see us turning it around in a hurry. But hopefully North have saved their best till last and can overcome GWS tonight.

2016-08-27T06:08:16+00:00

david graham

Guest


Keep a lid on the optimism! We don't want to tempt fate or bad luck. I also think we a good chance to win the flag but we need a bit of luck. Who will be the X-factor? Xavier the X-factor? Would make a great headline! In the 2012 Grand Final a few people predicted that Moreton would kick some crucial goals. Go Bloods; the team with a soul.

2016-08-27T05:35:19+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Guest


Go North and the Colliewobbles

2016-08-27T05:13:44+00:00

Sydneygirl

Guest


Swanniies, I think we need to keep a balanced view and not get ahead of ourselves. Sydney are a good chance but I wouldn't discount a couple of others just yet, especially given the season it has been. Meanwhile cheer, cheer the red and the White.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar