All Dogs go to heaven: Swanning it up at the Big Dance

By Rocko / Roar Guru

Saturday’s classic fulfilled a childhood dream to attend the MCG on grand final day and watch my beloved Swans in action.

Having been blessed as a footy fan with five previous opportunities, following a wonderful run for the Swans since 2005, for me it was now or never.

With three kids under six, and commitments left, right and centre in the hustle and bustle of life (including the hide of friends having two weddings in 2006 and 2012), the joy of obtaining a standing room ticket last Wednesday in the Swans’ final ballot built a great sense of anticipation – off to the last Saturday in September (oops, well not quite!), and the chance to witness premiership glory.

Saturday morning was best encapsulated with the following highlights:
• Driving into Melbourne from Albury with football analysis blaring on the radio uninterrupted for a few hours.
• Grabbing a train from a mate’s place and disembarking to a sea of various combinations of red, white and blue at Jolimont Station.
• The exhilaration of picking up a ticket from the ticket office on the morning of a game at the ground – since when does that happen anymore?
• Nabbing a selfie with Michael O’Loughlin.

There were queues galore, but everyone was good natured and clearly looking forward to the clash. I snuck a traditional watery beer and cardboard Red Rooster delight before working out exactly where to stand.

The experience of a standing room ticket was a novelty. I was on my own to view the game, but had a few mates who had travelled across the border, scattered around the ground in varying degrees of comfort.

I was standing next to Tom Papley’s partner’s Mum, and also a 20-year-old Saint Kilda turned Bulldogs supporter for the week. We traded a couple of beers and talked about how the Saints are potentially not far off a tilt like the Dogs.

Pre-game Vance Joy and the Living End had decent background music you would expect in an Aussie beer garden, and Sting, whose dynamics were certainly challenged by the cavernous acoustics of the home of Australian sport, was caught between promoting a Ben Sherman and Chesty Bonds combo shirt – but at least it enabled him to undertake his own form of a two-gun salute.

I won’t go into onerous detail on the game, but the intensity and manic pressure from both teams was breath-taking and commendable.

I will say watching the Bulldogs’ fourth quarter (particularly over the last month) is like watching a David Attenborough documentary covering the Venus Fly-trap.

Cue Attenborough voice: the fly-traps have lobes that exhibit rapid plant movement by snapping shut when special sensory hairs are stimulated. The lobes close over in less than a tenth of a second, and are surrounded by stiff, thorn-like protrusions that gel together and prevent large prey from escaping. So it was for the under-siege Swans defensive unit on Saturday afternoon.

Once the unfortunate prey is unable to escape and the inner surfaces of the lobes are continuously being stimulated, the lobes fuse together, sealing the trap and creating an enclosed ‘stomach’ in which digestion takes place. Liam Picken, Tom Boyd and even ‘The Package’ feasted on the trapped Swans in the back-half of the final term.

In terms of the Norm Smith medal, having watched the game live, you generally patch together a player who can pull a series of key moments together without the benefits of replay or expert analysis – and in this instance I was very surprised Boyd did not receive the best on ground, after playing the ruck-forward role to near perfection.

His three goals were interlaced with significant off-ball defensive pressure, three or four tremendous relieving contested grabs, and a solid work around the ground. I guess this view harks back to a time before the ‘obsession with possessions’.

As a Swans fan, the biggest mistake John Longmire made was taking in both Jared McVeigh and Callum Mills into the game. They were both clearly cooked just after halftime.

In the wash-up, I wasn’t overly impressed with all of the umpiring (or, more importantly, non-umpiring), but the Bulldogs thoroughly over-ran the Swans in the back-half of the last term and deserved to sign off in style on an amazing month of football.

Following the match, the feeling that comes to haunt any hardened footy fanatic is the end of your team’s season. I can now relate to the wonderful novel Loose Men Everywhere by Jon Harmes.

Tim Lane neatly surmised Harm’s anguish when reviewing his book in 2002:

“Then in 1995, after the Cats’ fourth grand final defeat in seven years, Harms promises to give them up but knows it is a promise he can’t keep. His is the thinking footy fan’s conundrum: how can something so fundamentally frivolous be allowed to take so much time and emotional energy out of one’s life?”

I can understand why so many people love the joys of a preliminary final win more. Your hopes and dreams are built in the lead up to a grand final, only to be mercilessly snatched away suddenly and irretrievably through a loss.

I was privileged to see the Bulldogs win their second premiership – incredible to think that their last flag featured before the launch of television in Australia.

The sheer unbridled joy on the faces of long-suffering Doggies’ fans deep in time-on softened (partially at least) the cruelling nature of a grand final loss. Until the questions came:

Did I really just drive over 700 kilometres to watch Kurt Tippett disappear into the MCG turf? Where was Brett Kirk when we needed a warrior at three-quarter time? With all the Swans injuries, surely it was the time for Teddy Richards to cameo in a final game for the red and white?

Following the exit from the G, commiserations followed with mates at the Cricketer’s Arms on Punt Road.

The side alley was neatly closed off and a couple of beers before a nice Italian meal back up near Jolimont Station embodied what footy is all about for me. Passion, commitment, friends and fun.

For those who have never been lucky enough to attend a grand final, I cannot recommend the experience enough. I had the cliché day with many iconic venues and stop-overs, and was lucky to see my team there.

In closing, I would like to touch on an excerpt from Bruce Dawe’s wonderful footy poem ‘Life Cycle’:

Hot pies and potato-crisps they will eat,
they will forswear the Demons, cling to the Saints
and behold their team going up the ladder into Heaven.

At the conclusion of Saturday’s match, you could certainly say all Dogs go to heaven.

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2016-10-06T04:00:04+00:00

Rocko

Roar Guru


G-fox - yes she did - went to an elderly relative (I asked same question myself!)

2016-10-06T03:12:23+00:00

DingoGray

Roar Guru


I feel for your grasp on reality

2016-10-06T03:07:34+00:00

Pumping Dougie

Roar Guru


�?�

2016-10-06T02:33:15+00:00

anon

Guest


I feel for Sydney. From the 13 minute mark of the 1st quarter until 5 minutes into the 4th quarter they received ONE FREE KICK, while the Bulldogs received a whole host frees that resulted in direct goals, weren't penalised for throwing the ball (which again result in Bulldogs goals), etc.

2016-10-06T02:23:44+00:00

Pumping Dougie

Roar Guru


Another Swans umpiring sook? My, my.

2016-10-06T01:31:24+00:00

I hate pies

Guest


Nope. I hate it too, nearly as much as I hate the term "home deck".

2016-10-05T23:14:24+00:00

MG

Roar Rookie


For me to be Minor Premiers and make the Grand Final were incredible achievements in a year where I expected us to drop down the ladder and possibly even out of the top 8. Bulldogs dominated in the middle not so much in numbers but in efficiency. Their movement to half forward was far superior. Our supply to the forwards was poor quality leading to our forward structure failing similar to the GWS game. I therefore don't blame the forwards. They had poor games because of poor supply. Swans have tended to have better hands than the opposition but Beveridge has taken the Bulldog's handball efficiency to another level. The fact we were in it with 7 minutes to go despite the umpiring is a huge credit to our defence but once Hannebery got taken out they ran over the top. Playing McVeigh and Mills was indeed a mistake. Amazing game. The better team won on the day but I hope for fair umpiring and beating them next year.

2016-10-05T22:18:10+00:00

Gyfox

Guest


Great article, Martin. But couldn't Tom Papley have got his partner's mum a seat?

2016-10-05T09:59:48+00:00

Bruce

Guest


Parker seemed to go missing for large periods of time. Kicked the opening goal but not much after that.

2016-10-05T06:47:42+00:00

D Fitz

Roar Rookie


Correct. We thought the same that JJ kept bombing into the Swans and creating turnovers. Similar to Dangerfield.

2016-10-05T05:21:22+00:00

Sydneygirl

Guest


Sadly mcGlynn had little or no influence,neither did Papley and Rohan. Kennedy, Jack, Rampe, Grundy and others were stars. Parker was his usual hard self along with several others. Mitchell got a lot of the ball but butchered it at times, as he often does. As Kieren said we will be back, not going anywhere and so will the supporters. Western Bulldogs played well.

2016-10-05T05:19:19+00:00

Minz

Guest


JJ was a great, flashy possession winner. However, I couldn't help but wonder at the time if the Dogs would regret his poor kicking. Has the run to be a real star, but needs to do better with it. It's a pity that the award-pickers all go nuts for possession these days - the great non-midfielders deserve their share of the acclaim.

2016-10-05T03:41:42+00:00

BigAl

Guest


cultural Imperialism no doubt, but there are worse things . . . anyway, it will never replace "the grannie"

2016-10-05T01:55:54+00:00

Pete

Guest


Am I the only one that hates the term "The Big Dance" ????

2016-10-05T01:23:22+00:00

Col from Brissie

Roar Guru


I am glad that you got to witness your dream live Dougie, unfortunately there were a lot of Doggies and Swans supporters not so lucky. I was fortunate enough to go to the 1968,69,70 (yes part of that record crowd for that famous comeback) 72 and 73 grand finals for 3 wins and 2 losses and the memories are still clear as day (although a bit blurry in 72 and 73 when finally of drinking age). Since moving to Brisbane I haven't had the chance to attend another one but hopefully will get the chance to again take in that fantastic atmosphere that is the MCG on GF day.

2016-10-05T00:00:46+00:00

Jim

Guest


The problem with the N/N ruck combo is that they offer absolutely nothing going forward at this stage - I think Naismith in particular can improve in that part of his game (and maybe Nankervis too), but they need to be a threat around the ground too. I don't think we could set up the team to fit them and Tippo - who was also a disappointment on GF day (he really is only any good when fully fit - he's not one to carry an injury). I fear Nankervis will want out though for opportunity - and while I think he is never going to be a premier ruckman, in the right combo he can be a very hand 2nd ruck, and more importantly he doesn't mind throwing his weight around, which is something any team can use. The missing player the Swans could have really used was a fit and firing Sam Reid. XR did some decent stuff at times in his first handful of games, but his lack of impact during finals highlighted there is a long way for him to go as a forward - and raised in my mind a question as to whether he will be good enough to be a long term AFL player. A fully fit Reid can play a similar sort of role to what Boyd did on Saturday - oh how we could of used a forward that could get up the ground and take a few contested marks. But whether SR has the body to ever stay fit enough is another question all together.

AUTHOR

2016-10-04T23:52:42+00:00

Rocko

Roar Guru


Cheers PD - and congrats! Dale Morris was an absolute rock on Saturday. JJ was certainly a ball butcherer on the weekend.

AUTHOR

2016-10-04T23:51:29+00:00

Rocko

Roar Guru


Thanks Jim - agree about the passengers - but the pleasing thing as you noted is that most of those guys are first-year players and will be better for the experience. Grundy, Rampe and Kennedy enormous. I really liked the Naismith Nankervis ruck combo through the season - they complement each other so well - and it will be interesting to see if they can hang onto big Toby.

2016-10-04T23:37:50+00:00

Pumping Dougie

Roar Guru


Cheers Jim ... I still can't believe it.

2016-10-04T23:34:01+00:00

Jim

Guest


Glad you enjoyed the experience Martin - it was my third grand final live at the ground after '12 and '14, and while it was clearly a disappointing day in the end for us Swannies faithful, it was a far better feeling than '14, where the players are still being searched for in the depths of the MCG, as they just didn't turn up that day. The Swans gave their all, and in the end we had just a few too many 'passengers' on the day - and in many ways, it was a monumental effort for us to be in the game for as long as we were - given the passengers we had, a lack of any rub of the green in terms of umpiring, and our completely malfunctioning forward line, and the overall dominance of the game the Dogs had (so much of it really was on their terms). Unfortunately we really only had the one period in the 2nd quarter when we got on top, and even then we never managed to open up a sizeable lead, which may have forced the Dogs to chase the game again. We had some standout performers - Kennedy was outstanding (clear BOG in my book for us), Grundy was his dependable self. Rampe and Mitchell played well. Naismith battled manfully in the ruck, and was good early in particular (Was for him to really come on in 2017 with a full pre-season). But serious questions have to be asked of some of our fringe players - Rohan had another shocker on GF day, Hewett struggled, Papley just couldn't get going, McGlynn was dreadful. Some of our bottom six are very young and inexperienced and will get better - but I fear some are really passengers going forward. Then there were the poor selection decisions - as many predicted, both Mills and McVeigh struggled big time, and that certainly didn't help the case. But in the end, the dogs were just too good on the day that counted and deserved their premiership.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar