Cummins should target next Ashes for Test return

By Ronan O'Connell / Expert

The inevitable push to fast track Pat Cummins into the Test team has begun and even Australia’s bowling coach David Saker is on board.

Cummins return to the Test XI should come as early as their next Test, against Pakistan in Brisbane next Friday, according to former wicketkeepers Brad Haddin and Darren Berry.

Meanwhile, Australian captain Steve Smith told media it was “possible” Cummins could join the Test tour of India in February, with Saker also nominating this as a realistic goal.

This fervour to get Cummins back in a baggy green has emerged each summer since the outrageously-gifted paceman stunned the cricket community by taking seven wickets on Test debut as an 18-year-old.

It is easy to understand the excitement around Cummins and the desire to see him in Australia’s Test attack. This is a young man who, in a stop-start international career across three formats, has taken 67 wickets at an average of 21.

Since returning from another long-term injury this summer, Cummins has been in scorching form, grabbing 21 wickets at an average of 17 from eight 50-over matches for Australia and NSW.

He was arguably man-of-the-match in his second match game for Australia on Tuesday when he took 4-41 including the key wickets of New Zealand guns Kane Williamson and Martin Guptill. In that match Cummins left no doubt as to why massive hype has followed him for five years through layoff after layoff.

He bowled with a potent combination of speed and skill only possessed by a couple of cricketers worldwide. What would have caught the eye to the casual observer was the manner in which Cummins hurried the Kiwi batsmen with his pace, which was consistently above 145kmh and as high as 151kmh.

Yet it was his subtle skills which undid Guptill and Williamson. The New Zealand opener nicked a beautiful leg cutter from Cummins, who then fooled Williamson with a clever slower ball.

He was the standout bowler in the match. That’s an extraordinary effort when you’ve only recently returned from a year out of the game and the list of quicks you outbowled includes Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood, Trent Boult and Tim Southee.

What will happen if Cummins is thrown into the line-up at some point in the Tests against Pakistan? I’d back him to cause major headaches for the visiting batsmen, more than would the incumbent third seamer Jackson Bird.

But I’d also believe that Cummins would be put at serious risk of breaking down once more. At 23 years old he is now approaching the stage at which the male body typically starts to fully mature.

It is at around this age that many express pacemen of the past shook off the injuries that had plagued them in their teens and early 20s.

This was the case for the last two quality express bowlers to represent Australia, Mitchell Johnson and Brett Lee. It might surprise you to know Johnson had actually played a lot less professional cricket than Cummins when he was 23.

By the end of the 2004-05 season, Johnson had stepped on to the field just 12 times (six first-class and six List A matches). Cummins, meanwhile, has played 94 matches (48 T20s, 38 List A, and eight first-class fixtures).

Johnson, of course, went on to take almost 600 international wickets for Australia across all three formats. If Cummins body holds up he could well match Johnson’s record. In fact he is, in my opinion, a more talented paceman than Johnson.

Only in short bursts of his career did Johnson ever display the accuracy which has been a hallmark of Cummins bowling since his Test debut five years ago. In that match, South Africa boasted a magnificent batting line-up featuring four all-time great Test cricketers – Jacques Kallis, AB de Villiers, Hashim Amla and Graeme Smith.

Coincidentally it was Johnson who the Proteas feared leading into that Test, with the left armer having roughed them up in the previous two Test series between the countries.

Yet Johnson managed just 2-168 for the match, while Cummins snared 7-117, including the huge wickets of Kallis, Amla and de Villiers. Since that day Australian fans have dreamed of a fully fit Cummins tearing the Test format apart. I have no doubt that if his body holds together he can become one of the greatest bowlers Australia have ever produced.

But after five years of crushed hopes, that “if” keeps getting bigger and bigger. The key, surely, is not to rush Cummins back into Tests. The man himself has expressed reservations in the past about the prospect of being vaulted into the rigours of five-day cricket without adequate preparation.

It would be tragically comical to pick him against Pakistan when he hasn’t played a first-class match in 16 months, and only four in the past five years. If Cummins is considered ready for a return to red ball cricket then the aim should be for him to play four or five Shield matches for New South Wales after Christmas.

The next step would be to venture to England in April or May and get a half a dozen more first-class outings under his belt. If he gets through that 10 or so games fit, healthy and in form he could be strongly considered for the two scheduled winter Tests against Bangladesh.

That would leave him well placed for a tilt at England in next summer’s Ashes. If, instead, he is rushed back into action either against Pakistan or India, the selectors will be playing Russian Roulette with Cummins’ health.

The Crowd Says:

2016-12-10T06:37:47+00:00

Dexter The Hamster

Guest


Your last comment is spot on, which is why Smith should worry about his batting, not his bowling.

AUTHOR

2016-12-09T07:50:00+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


Dougie I rate Pattinson extremely highly but I'm also a lot more pessimistic about his future RE: injuries than I am Cummins. Cummins is just 23yo and plenty of express pacemen have been riddle with injuries in teens early 20s before growing into their bodies about 23yo. Whereas Pattinson is 26yo and should really be battle hardened by now but he's not. He returned last summer with a new action and then ditched it after a few games, returned to his old action and promptly re-injured himself. That is a huge concern. I'm not convinced Pattinson will ever be fit to be a regular Test player. Also, he relies on his pace more than guys like Cummins or Starc, and his fragile body suggests he may well struggle to keep bowling 145kmh-plus beyond 30yo so his window of opportunity could be brief.

2016-12-09T02:48:33+00:00

Craig Swanson

Guest


Others also in frame for Ashes selection. Bancroft, Behrendorff, Cartwright, Richardson, Tremain, Whiteman. Possibles: Harris, Stanlake, Gibson, Conway, Stoinis, Turner.

2016-12-09T02:39:36+00:00

Craig Swanson

Guest


Bit of a dilemma with Cummins. Every cricket loving Aussie wants him back in the baggy green. But...not at the expense of another breakdown. Having said that, the man himself says he has never felt better at a similar time frame of his many rehabs from serious season ending injuries. Do we really need his sheer pace for India where decks ar flat and slow? On the other hand do CA want to wait as long as the next home Ashes before unleashing him. Plenty of questions.

2016-12-09T02:12:05+00:00

jameswm

Roar Guru


As crazy as it is, I would consider Cummins for the pink ball test, based on him bowling 3 x 5-over spells per day (one per session). Not for other tests and not for India. Starc and Hazey 20 each, Lyon 25-30, and part-timers 5-10 overs. If not Cummins, then surely Sayers after that last effort against NSW.

2016-12-09T02:09:00+00:00

jammel

Guest


My ideal Ashes XI: WarnerV Renshaw Khawaja SmithC KPatterson Handscomb Wade+ Starc Pattinson Hazlewood Lyon Key reserves: SMarsh O'Keefe Cummins Sayers Others I'd like to see pressing for inclusion: Nevill Faulkner Bird

2016-12-09T01:36:58+00:00

Tana Mir

Roar Rookie


Ashwin, Jadeja, and Yadav will be happy regardless what team you pick. If Renshaw does take his chance against Pakistan, how do we fit S. Marsh? I've said previously, the only player that intimidates Ashwin in India is Maxi. The way Uzi is playing, it will be silly to drop your most in-form batsman.

2016-12-09T01:25:48+00:00

DingoGray

Roar Guru


yeah poor description. Mind you Hazelwood will probably be medium pace speed in India.

2016-12-09T01:21:50+00:00

BurgyGreen

Guest


Yep, Pattinson is the one I really worry about. At 26 if his body doesn't sort itself out soon we could be largely missing a huge talent. He's an absolute joy to watch - conventional and reverse swing and really nasty pace and aggression. Plus a very clean striker of the ball, better batsman than Starc and Cummins in my opinion. And I agree, if all four were fit I'd probably leave out Cummins. Although I'd be hugely tempted to play all four - imagine that on a pacy wicket like Centurion.

2016-12-09T01:11:04+00:00

BurgyGreen

Guest


Definitely Shaun Marsh rather than Khawaja. Ussie's heroics against SA don't change the fact that he is clueless against spin.

2016-12-09T01:10:05+00:00

Pumping Dougie

Roar Guru


Pattinson seems to be forgotten about in these discussions. He has 70 wickets for 17 tests and a bowling average of 26 (which is superior to Starc). Not to mention a test batting average of 27. What will the selectors do if Cummins and Pattinson both have a sustained, injury-free run? How can you leave one of Starc, Hazlewood, Cummins or Pattinson out for a "serviceable" spinner, such as Lyon. Maybe they can dispense with Lyon when that happens and bring one of Head or Maxwell in as an allrounder spinner.

2016-12-09T00:35:26+00:00

Dan

Guest


He's quick and very talented but I'm not sure if he moves the ball enough at the moment. I think he gets a lot of wickets because the batsmen have to score in the shorter form. May not be as effective in test cricket where a batsmen can sit on him and wait for a bad ball. I could be completely wrong and I hope I am but not for me at this stage. -- Comment from The Roar's iPhone app.

2016-12-09T00:15:39+00:00

Gordon Smith

Guest


Agreed Sideline - the people happiest about that team would be Ashwin and Jajeda

2016-12-09T00:13:28+00:00

Stucco

Guest


Pakistan just played here in NZ. Based on those displays I would say that them getting a score of 400 in Brisbane is an extremely remote chance as the most they scored was 230, and that was in Hamilton when the pitch had completely flattened out. So this seems as good a time as any to give Cummins a run, maybe as part of a 4-prong pace attack along with Hazlewood, Starc and Bird.

2016-12-08T23:14:02+00:00

Sideline

Guest


Surely S. Marsh should be included for his form and skill against spin.

2016-12-08T22:51:53+00:00

Linphoma

Guest


Why oh why is anyone pontificating on Pat Cummins Test prospects when he hasn't played a first-class fixture for so long? Based on his ability in some 10-over outings? Give the kid a break and get some sanity in selections.

2016-12-08T22:47:42+00:00

Tana Mir

Roar Rookie


Got to play your best bowers. I don't think, against India, we have 2 spinners good enough that can trouble them. Is the Copeland injury that bad? With O'Keef and Maxi we should be OK. And Smithy needs to hit the nets and get his bowling going for Indian tour. Anyway, our bowling will be OK, it's the batting that will decide the series.

2016-12-08T22:35:14+00:00

Insane and delusional

Guest


Does Cummins even play first class cricket? If you are just going to select guys who don't perform at Shield level, we should ditch it and just pick people from Sydney grade cricket. It would save a lot of money as the Sheffield Shield costs a lot of money to run.

2016-12-08T22:19:22+00:00

Magnus M. Østergaard

Roar Guru


I would like to think I inspired this article Ronan. BTW Tongue planted firmly in my cheek.

2016-12-08T22:18:37+00:00

Magnus M. Østergaard

Roar Guru


Starc and Hazlewood are medium pacers?

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar