Five talking points from the Wallabies vs Scotland

By Connor Bennett / Editor

Scotland have snapped their Wallabies losing streak and landed their first ever win against Australia in Sydney, coming out on top of a tight 24-19 thriller.

Both sides took turns in dominating play with the Scots coming out the better side in the first half, but the Wallabies took control in the second, only to fall short in a tantalising final ten minutes as they hammered the Scottish line.

Has Scotland become the Wallabies’ most realistic rivalry?
If you ask any fan of Australian rugby or any sports fan in Australia for that matter, and they will tell you the Wallabies’ biggest rival is New Zealand, the Kiwis, those across the ditch that continue to haunt us.

While they may be our historical rival, the All Blacks are anything but a heated rival when all they do is arrive, defeat and leave for the better part of one and a half decades.

A good rivalry is one that produces those thrillers on a regular basis, those tight contests that have fans invested 100 percent in the contest with genuine emotion to want to beat them.

Every one of the last six games now between Scotland and Australia has been won by six points or less and both sides have won three each. If that’s not a realistically close rivalry then I don’t know what is, and Aussie fans just jump on board.

The last three games specifically have all been drama-filled, close games of rugby, especially the World Cup quarter-final that saw the Scots robbed in the dying seconds and on the Spring Tour last year when Tevita Kuridrani’s right arm stole it late.

New Zealand may be the main rivalry of the Wallabies, but Scotland have become the one to watch and a side that you know is producing great rugby storylines and contests for the fans to be invested in.

Inconsistent starts
I spoke last week in talking points of Australia’s blistering start against Fiji but their inability to keep it going. Letting off the gas as it were.

This week they did the exact opposite.

Scotland shot out of the gates and, thanks to a litany of Wallaby errors and penalties, were able to spend the bulk of the opening half an hour entrenched in the Australian half and inside the 22.
Australia couldn’t seem to clear their way out of an empty car park the way they continued to gift the ball back to Scotland and were lucky the Scots were falling short in execution for the most part.

Their kicking, in particular, was lacklustre in the opening 40 minutes, often failing to find touch or the other side of halfway and hitting the breadbasket of the back three the majority of the time.

Will Genia’s kicking from the back of the ruck was off from last week as well, but I’ll get to that.

The Wallabies continued their clumsy ways in the second stanza as the penalties and errors continued to flow, but they were at least able to turn it around and hump all the pressure on the Scots end of the park.

They need to figure out if they want to be fast starters or gradual climbers or late finishers in a contest because changing between them isn’t doing much for Michael Cheika’s men.

Or is it even too much to ask for a complete 80-minute performance?

Charge down tries are stupid
I hate charge down tries. I just hate them. They shouldn’t happen, people should never allow a charge down try to eventuate.

If you see someone there, just don’t kick it. If someone is close enough to be able to charge down your kick, then it’s likely they are right next to you and you should know they are there.

Just don’t kick it. If they are that close it’s quite obvious that your kick just isn’t going to go through them, because that’s not how science works. Take the tackle, throw a dummy, pass it off. Anything is better than the embarrassment of being charged down and giving away an absolute gift.

Now that that’s out of the way. What are you doing Will Genia!

Even leading up to the moment Genia ploughed his kick straight into the arms of Scottish flyhalf Finn Russell for their second try of the game, Genia’s kicking just seemed a bit off.

He wasn’t quite finding his mark, not quite getting his distances right or accuracy and when Bernard Foley was yellow carded, he was given extra kicking duties.

It didn’t work out for him in the end and Dane Haylett-Petty then took over with the boot for the most part until Foley reemerged.

Scotland were struggling to find the line despite dominating possession in the opening half and that charge down try just let them off the hook and put the Wallabies into a little hole. It should never have happened.

Different results on either side of the ditch a glimpse into the future?
Just one day prior to the Wallabies losing to a lesser-fancied Scottish side in Sydney, the All Blacks decimated a lesser-fancied Samoan outfit in Auckland with a 78-0 hammering.

Every year the Wallabies take hope into the Bledisloe Cup, hoping that this is the year, hoping that the pain will finally stop, hoping that maybe we can win back that little cup that has haunted us for so long now.

If this weekend of rugby proved anything, it’s that the Wallabies are still a long, long, long way off.

Now that seems like an obvious statement to anyone that’s been paying attention to rugby at any points in the last five years, but it was really obviously highlighted over the past few days.

Both came up against opponents they were expected to beat, opponents that are no pushover but should have realistically been some form of stepping stone into the Rugby Championship in August.

New Zealand were clinical, they were near-faultless from kickoff to the final whistle and they tore the Samoans apart with 12 tries and an incredible 50 points in the second half alone.

That’s how the best side in the world does it. They perform at 100 per cent regardless of the opposition and they don’t let themselves be complacent. It’s the type of relentlessness and ruthlessness that Australia simply doesn’t have.

In stark contrast, the Wallabies limped and spluttered their way to a five-point loss to Scotland.

Maybe Samoa isn’t as strong an opposition as Scotland, but could you really see the Wallabies scoring 78 points and conceding none if put in the same game as the All Blacks faced?

There’s such a huge contrast between these two games and they are the kind of early signs that should have Wallaby fans nervous to take on the All Blacks later in the year.

Is this another step in the rise of Scottish rugby?
Scotland have now won seven of their last nine games since losing to Australia last year by a single point at Murrayfield.

They tied second in the Six Nations earlier in the year, only dropping down the table on points difference, but they lost just two games, one of those being to an England side who were on a record winning streak at the time.

They got past Ireland and Wales, two sides who have traditionally been better than them in recent history and expected to win, in the same way Australia were in Sydney.

Despite missing star players Stuart Hogg, who has won player of the tournament for the Six Nations two years in a row now, and Tommy Seymour, Scotland stepped up to a full-strength Wallabies side and they conquered them.

Scotland only had two players picked in the highly sought after 41-man Lions squad that is currently in New Zealand and they were out to prove a point against the Wallabies and show that they have so much more than that.

They performed well in the World Cup in 2015 and they’ve begun to surprise many with their performances in the Six Nations over the last two years, but a win away from home against a top three side like Australia, that’s the biggest sign to world rugby that Scotland are serious business and they are on the rise.

The Crowd Says:

2017-06-19T21:39:44+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


No. 2. Hogg and Laidlaw. They may be missing players through injury. But so is Australia so that doesn't count. Kerevi, Slipper and others are out injured. Beale was not available. Pocock was not available.

2017-06-19T16:18:16+00:00

bloodypom

Guest


HA! Top 3 Side? Australia? Ha!

2017-06-19T12:57:31+00:00

dhakapete

Guest


article says Scots missing 2 players to lions tour...wrong...3 players part of initial Squad. 3 further key players missing through injury including Ritchie Grey. overall has to be good for Rugby to have 8 or 9 competitive tea m s rather than just 4 ir 5.

2017-06-19T05:55:47+00:00

Timbo (L)

Roar Guru


Any of them eligible to play for Australia?

2017-06-19T05:53:07+00:00

Timbo (L)

Roar Guru


One Ups do work, if executed properly. It requires that the next phase ball comes out quickly with the next pod hitting it at speed. It is all about cycle time and the ability to commit defenders. What Scotland were able to do was to slow don the play allowing their defensive line to reset, ready to pounce and hit them on the wrong side of the gain line. The 1-3-3-1 Pod doesn't work against a big opposition until their line gets bent. It needs to be 4-4 with all players able to do their jobs, then break out into 1-3-3-1 as momentum builds.

2017-06-19T05:42:37+00:00

Timbo (L)

Roar Guru


Alcock, Hardwick, Smith, Butler, Faienga, Take your pick, I don't Care They are all great in a ruck and over the ball. Gill and Pocock back in the next season or 2. Reid Injured or playing 6. No depth at 7?

2017-06-19T05:31:17+00:00

Timbo (L)

Roar Guru


I am worried about the Saffas and the Bargies At least they will be exciting contests.

2017-06-19T04:49:50+00:00

piru

Roar Rookie


Perhaps if they'd made Sharpie captain when they should have, instead of just giving it to their favourite of the week, there wouldn't be such a dearth of leadership options now.

2017-06-19T04:42:56+00:00

Kirkizzle

Guest


Whatever happened to the Gray brothers?

2017-06-19T04:42:01+00:00

Marto

Guest


Nathan " Noodle Arms" Sharpe is always confused,he was part of the decade of decline of our rugby ..So he should apologize to the current fans as well..

2017-06-19T03:19:55+00:00

Xiedazhou

Guest


Thats not true EJ. "Neutrals" like Leiliifano were quoted at the time of Links demise as saying they had no access issues and were sorry to see him (and Patson) go. The cancer in the team was there, and has since been promoted/rewarded. Trouble is, the chickens are now coming to roost as coach and a few of his selected untouchables are being found out on the field.

2017-06-19T02:19:58+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


Yet only 2 players were unavailable for selection at all. Hogg and Laidlaw.

2017-06-19T02:10:10+00:00

Ted Dwyer

Guest


10 players were from the Glasgow Warriors, who don't even qualify for Heineken Cup. They came 7th in the Pro12. A proud club, but hardly worldbeaters. Hogg & Seymour (Lions tour) are a massive loss for the Scots. Basically, The Wallabies were defeated by a slightly improved Glasgow Warriors. Pathetic.

2017-06-19T01:51:33+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


It's not a Scotland 2nd XV. They had 2 players out on Lions duty. They then had injuries just like we do.

2017-06-19T01:45:29+00:00

John R

Roar Guru


That's the sad thing about it aye. I used to watch a line out and wonder what the set piece play was going to look like, now I'm just hoping we don't fu*k it up somehow, and at least retain possession. Same when we're building phases. Hooper somehow pulls a rabbit out of the hat with 30 seconds to go, and you just know that we're gonna knock it on or do something stupid like that to blow any chance we may have had. It's such a bummer, cause I genuinely believe we have the players, but they just keep letting themselves down with mistakes.

2017-06-19T01:44:46+00:00

Ted Dwyer

Guest


Well done Scotland, but lets face it there is something seriously wrong when the Wallabies lose to a Scotland 2nd XV. I think the biggest issue is the Wallabies training & recovery regime. They look overcooked to me. Marathon runners out there will know the dangers of overtraining. Insufficient recovery time from intense training leads to a breakdown of the immune system. Typical signs include low energy, lack of focus (leading to errors), fatigue, plus decreased motivation. Now - where have we seen these symptoms lately? The Wallabies looked like they were at 80% from the start. The Scots looked fresh and at 100%. Big difference at that level and it's not the first time I've seen it in the Wallabies over the last 24 months, either. Cheika is well known for his brutal training sessions & I suspect he's not giving the guys enough recovery time. Fix that problem and at least we will see an improvement in performance.

2017-06-19T00:59:32+00:00

Harry

Guest


Like many others, I accept that we have no realistic hope in this year's Bledisloe and would be rated, at best, one chance in 10. TBH, first time I've ever felt like this as a 50 year Wallaby supporter. And last year's Sydney thrashing in Bled 1 is the low point for me of the Wallabies. EJ there is a difference between thinking we are better and thinking we can improve to match them and beat them. It HAS been done in the past and requires skill, determination and teamwork. Its a realistic goal but of course won't happen easily. What dismays me is Australian rugby seem to be getting worse rapidly.

2017-06-19T00:42:14+00:00

Jibba Jabba

Roar Guru


cheika said it was hoopers and hopes it helps him grow in the role !

2017-06-19T00:35:47+00:00

Jibba Jabba

Roar Guru


But when pocock was there he was picked at No 8 to keep mr hooper in the team eh bro...

2017-06-19T00:31:41+00:00

Jibba Jabba

Roar Guru


A 2 edged sword, so he can take pulver with him...

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar