Curtains close On Bulldogs campaign

By Samuel Ord / Roar Guru

Round 10 of the AFL’s 2018 season has arrived and with it comes the end of the Western Bulldogs’ premiership campaign after a 35-point trampling at the hands of Collingwood on Friday night.

Played out at Etihad Stadium in front of more than 37,000 onlookers, Collingwood overcame a one-sided first quarter to defeat the Bulldogs 13.12 (90) to 8.7 (55).

There’s still plenty of football remaining in the season and the Western Bulldogs will be one of 18 sides along for the ride, but barring a miracle from the Gods above, the boys in red, white and blue will not play finals.

Friday’s match showcased the Western Bulldogs at their worst, downhill skiing to an incredible degree.

Collingwood controlled the majority of the possession in the first quarter but the Bulldogs managed to light them up, out-tackling them 21 to ten and with a few helpful decisions from the umpires blasted five goals to one.

With a little luck on their side the Bulldogs fought hard for the ball and set up a tidy advantage early.

In the second quarter Collingwood fought back from the ropes, bumping up their pressure and speed around the contest and booting four goals to three to be within 18-points reach at half-time.

(Photo by Adam Trafford/AFL Media/Getty Images)

After feeling the heat from Collingwood in the second term, the Western Bulldogs returned from the main break and completely shirked the contest.

In the second half they managed just four behinds while at the other end the Magpies slotted eight majors to set up what evolved into an easy win.

With Collingwood’s trademark high-possession football firmly in place after half-time – 469 possessions to 374 – the Bulldogs pressure evaporated, with the tackle count finishing even at 58 apiece.

The Bulldogs were smashed in the contested possession by 31.

Last week it wasn’t too hard to forgive the Bulldogs for kicking just two goals in a match. In Round 9 they played Adelaide, a top-four fancy, in Adelaide, in miserable conditions. Constantly consumed by wind and rain, scoring was difficult for both sides, and in the end the better side comfortably got the job done.

The Bulldogs registered more than 100 tackles in four quarters of hard footy, and while they clearly lacked the skill to match the Crows, at least you could say they tried.

No such excuse or justification can be afforded to the Bulldogs in Round 10.

The Western Bulldogs now sit in 13th spot with four wins and with a percentage worse than one-win Brisbane. Looking ahead, it’s about to get a lot worse.

Up next for the Western Bulldogs are eight consecutive matches against teams within reach or within the top eight.

(AAP Image/Julian Smith)

First is top-four placed Melbourne followed by a road trip to South Australia to face Port Adelaide. Then back to Melbourne for the much-improved Kangaroos, then Geelong and Hawthorn.

The Bulldogs then take on Melbourne for a second time followed by ladder leaders West Coast and finally Port Adelaide for a second time. After that it’s Round 20 and match with St Kilda in August. It’s hard to see them winning any matches between now and then.

Jackson McCrae was good again, chalking up 30 disposals, seven marks and four tackles, but with just six contested possessions and no clearances you start to wonder what the point of it all is.

Toby McLean battled hard for 33 touches and ten tackles to go with seven clearances and five inside 50s. It’s a real shame that so few of his teammates tried to match his tempo.

There are 22 players out there in the red, white and blue and there’s a greater than one in six chance that when a tackle was laid by the Dogs it was one bloke in McLean.

If I was a Collingwood fan, I’d be getting excited. The Pies now sit in sixth spot with six wins and have a great month ahead. The run begins with a very winnable encounter with Fremantle at the MCG, then Melbourne, Carlton, the Gold Coast and Essendon.

I’d be giving Collingwood a chance to win all of those matches, the toughest being Melbourne. Conservatively saying that they get done by the Demons, that still leaves Collingwood with ten wins before Round 17.

[latest_videos_strip category=”afl” name=”AFL”]

Last season 15 wins put a side (Adelaide) on top of the ladder, 14 wins and a strong percentage got you a top-four spot and 12 wins and a modest percentage landed you in the eight or just outside.

The energy from Collingwood is mostly generated from the midfield at this stage, and when it all comes together they’re one of the best in the comp to watch.

Adam Treloar could collect 35 disposals with his eyes closed, Scott Pendlebury is a captain who needs no introduction and Taylor Adams is ruthless in patches.

Jack Crisp has become an excellent user of the footy and Steele Sidebottom is a top-tier midfielder who flies under the radar.

Levi Greenwood is another strong addition, applying pressure to opposition midfielders in tight like few can, and Daniel Wells was missing from this outfit tonight but is more than capable of dictating the flow of play.

You’ve also got Jordan De Goey, a goal-kicking machine who loves winning his own footy, and Will Hoskin-Elliot, who has rewarded Collingwood for their interest in him.

Did I mention Brodie Grundy? He’s arguably the best ruckman in the competition. Grundy crushed the Bulldogs combo of Tom Boyd and Jarryd Roughead in the ruck 38 hit outs to 18. He also collected 26 disposals and seven marks.

The sky’s the limit for this Collingwood outfit if they can get it all working at once. Sadly, the same can’t be said for the Western Bulldogs.

Over the coming weeks the Bulldogs are likely to be put to the sword time and time again and they’ll be forced to ask some serious questions about the talent on their list, the application of certain players and the strength of their game plan.

The Crowd Says:

2018-05-27T01:22:09+00:00

User

Roar Rookie


Nic, gawn, Grundy and lycett are best rucks in comp atm Ryder as he gains fitness is in there as well

2018-05-27T01:08:08+00:00

JamesH

Roar Guru


Of those 5, Nic Nat is the only one who might be picked ahead of Grundy right now. Goldy is a shadow of his AA best, McAvoy has never been an elite ruck, Ryder is returning from injury and Sandy is in his twilight. If the AA team was named now, Grundy would be an absolute lock for the ruck spot.

2018-05-26T08:24:42+00:00

Paul D

Roar Guru


Matty loves to think people are genuinely upset at him when he gets slammed on these pages for being boring and repetitive. He used the tears line yesterday too when everyone voted for HTH to take a long overdue hike after he offered to depart. If you keep antagonising he’ll demonstrate how he doesn’t understand free speech by complaining about being censored Apparently he thinks free speech means you have to let boring stuff you’ve read 100’s of times before slide without comment

2018-05-26T05:57:11+00:00

Kevo

Roar Rookie


Fake news

2018-05-26T04:28:37+00:00

Pedro The Fisherman

Roar Rookie


Must have been a special on the "Bitter Pills" line. They are cheap at Footscray at the moment!

2018-05-26T04:26:46+00:00

Pedro The Fisherman

Roar Rookie


Oh Yeh - and Bevo lost the support of the playing group.

2018-05-26T04:00:02+00:00

Kane

Roar Rookie


Tell me once where I have teared up?

2018-05-26T03:13:57+00:00

Mattyb

Guest


That's fair enough Kane but you can't keep tearing up over sports commentary on a sports website. The dogs have been very poor over the past two weeks. Deflections,tears or delusion won't change that. The challenge for the doggies now is to accept these performances are unacceptable and try to improve. Any sort of waterworks aren't going to get us very far. When have waterworks and delusion got anyone anywhere?

2018-05-26T02:47:50+00:00

Kane

Roar Rookie


I'm not bitter at all Kevo, why would I be bitter? If someone wants to continually attack my club whenever an article is on this forum then I will give a bit back whenever his club gets mentioned in an article which mind you is not very often and there's a reason for that.

2018-05-26T02:18:47+00:00

Kevo

Roar Rookie


Must have been a special on the bitter pills this week Kane....

2018-05-26T02:15:36+00:00

Kevo

Roar Rookie


Overdose on those bitter pills Hyena? Bulldogs are not the same team as in 2016 and anyone who can read a team list or watch the football with their eyes open can see that. They cannot sustain the manic pressure they did in the 2016 finals when they did perform as a quality team as opposed to relying on a few stars. They are struggling now because apart from Zaine Corey, Toby McClean and maybe Jack McCrae their other young premiership players have either gone backwards or not improved and they are missing some older heads on the field and around the club (one of whom helped plot their downfall last night). Some of their kids look okay for the future in Naughton, Richards, English, Williams, Smith if he stays fit and Lipinski but they are inconsistent at this stage. Dogs need to treat this as a development year for their younger players certainly do not look good enough to challenge for the eight. Must make you choke on your brekky cereal everyday that the record books show them as premiers in 2016 ......forever.

2018-05-26T02:10:29+00:00

Kris

Guest


Disappointing from the Dogs. They spent large parts of the game trying to switch back and forth to go around Collingwood who were defending fairly narrow. It worked at times but with Boyd, Schache and Gowers up forward a more direct approach would surely have been better. Key was Grundy getting so on top of Roughead in the ruck that he began taking the ball out of the ruck comfortable that ROughead wouldn't compete or tackle.

2018-05-26T00:51:10+00:00

peter chrisp

Guest


I do great review

2018-05-26T00:29:54+00:00

Maurice

Guest


Grundy is very good. Not sure about best in the country. Eg Nic Nat, Goldstein, Mc AVoy Ryder Sandilands 5 first picks before Grundy .

2018-05-26T00:09:03+00:00

Kane

Roar Rookie


What an absolutely sad and tragic club Footscray have become (have been for 100 years but even more so now). 2 goals in a game last week and no goals in a half this week, I'm interested in the thoughts of Casper, mattyb, the ghost or whatever name he's going by today but I don't reckon we will hear from him until Carlton loses next. Must be time for a cash handout from the AFL to help keep them afloat so they can spend a million a year on a kid that plays more VFL than AFL.

2018-05-25T23:57:42+00:00

Mattyb

Guest


Very disappointing performance from the doggies,failing to kick a goal after half time two weeks in a row is clearly unacceptable in an elite competition. Interestingly the reserves side has also been suffering from some second half fade outs which points to a club wide problem. Zero goals points to mental application more so than fitness so hopefully these issues are addressed in the coming weeks.

2018-05-25T23:48:02+00:00

Nikelnuts

Guest


Seems to me there are two spots left in the 8 up for grabs between North, Cats, Hawks, GWS and Pies. So far the Pies have lost to Cats, Hawks and GWS. Would they be worthy finalists, if they made it?

2018-05-25T23:22:46+00:00

Rob

Guest


Thought this was an article on how bad the dogs were. Turned into an article about how good Collingwood is. Sneaky. No one wants to read that!!

2018-05-25T22:29:36+00:00

Hyena

Guest


Bulldogs have never been a quality team. Media, fans and refs got caught up in the romantic notion of them getting a premiership which the never deserved. They were given the rub of the green in 2016 and should never have made finals let alone the GF. Worst team ever to win a GF. Anyone who thinks they are a good team should take off their rose tinted glasses.

Read more at The Roar