Inglis’ gritty Queenslanders go down as they don’t get the crucial calls

By Tim Gore / Expert

The New South Wales Blues can wrap up only their second series win in thirteen years on Sunday June 24 at home after they ran out ten-point winners over the Maroons in State of Origin One at a packed MCG.

However, but for two crucial missed calls it could have been so different.

The ten-point winning margin flattered the Blues, who – but for some individual brilliance from a superb James Tedesco – may well have lost.

All the wash-up from State of Origin 1:
» The funniest State of Origin ratings on the internet
» How the Blues fared at the MCG: NSW Game 1 player ratings
» How the Maroons performed: Queensland Game 1 player ratings
» State of Origin highlights and match report

In the 47th minute the Maroons were in the ascendancy. They were up 12-8 after a Dane Gagai try and you could tell that the Blues were starting to struggle mentally and physically, looking around for the leadership that could get them back in a game that was starting to slip away in all too familiar fashion.

However, when Angus Crichton’s strip of Gagai wasn’t called by the officials it gifted possession back to the Blues. Instead of having to try and repel another Maroon onslaught on their line on the back of a penalty, the Blues instead attacked the Queensland line, with Latrell Mitchell scoring a crucial try that locked up the scores.

Then in the 69th minute Tedesco made a brilliant run from dummy half, splitting the Maroon defence. He was momentarily brought down by Michael Morgan – who was excellent at fullback – before he got the ball to James Maloney.

Maloney then passed to Josh Addo-Carr who scored in the corner. The problem was that Maloney’s pass to Addo-Carr was clearly forward, but again it wasn’t picked up.

But that’s football. Sometimes you don’t get the calls.

There were many predictions pre match that the referees would blow the peas out of their whistles. However – in true big game style – the officials swallowed their whistles instead, awarding just five penalties for the game. Arguably the emphasis was once more on game management rather than rule enforcement.

Notably there was no penalty called for the Crichton strip on Gagai.

And it was very costly for Queensland.

Queensland captain Greg Inglis could not have done more to lead his troops. He may have been born and raised in New South Wales but last night on the MCG he personified the Queenslander spirit.

He personally dragged and willed his troops forward in an effort for the ages that, if his side had got those two calls, would have resulted in a victory for the ages. He continually smashed his Sky Blue opponents with brutal defence.

His efforts screamed ‘Queenslander’ as loud as it has ever been yelled. He showed the way for his team.

Greg Inglis of the Maroons (Photo by Michael Dodge/Getty Images)

I have openly questioned the credibility of Inglis playing for Queensland in the past. I won’t do that ever again. I have no doubt that he is Maroon to the core after that effort.

With his side down 8-0 in the 26th minute, Inglis knew he needed to lift his side. Though massively offside, he lined up Tom Trbojevic and smashed him. Players ran from everywhere for some push and shove. It not only lifted his tiring men, who were down 55-45 per cent in possession, it bought them time.

In the next set Valentine Holmes saw James Maloney’s pass from a mile away, like his old Sharks teammate was actually passing it to him, and he streaked away to score an intercept try.

It was game on.

Inglis also smashed James Roberts, Nathan Cleary and Josh Addo-Carr. Each time he put on a hit his side lifted and regained the ascendency.

When his side went ahead 12-8 in the 42nd minute it looked like the Blues might be once more bested by the Maroons.

And but for those two missed calls they may have been.

Greg Inglis and the Maroons (Photo by Scott Barbour/Getty Images)

While the Blues may have drawn first blood, make no mistake: this series is well and truly alive. Just eight times in Origin history has the side that has won the first game not gone on to win the series, however this could well be the ninth occurrence.

Sure, the New South Welshmen got the win, but they did not convince me. They still look like a work in progress.

Because they are.

Taking eleven debutants into an Origin game was ballsy. Brad Fittler took a huge risk doing it as there was every chance that those eleven boys – for all of their potential, strength and speed – could have crumbled when the more experienced Maroons put the blow torch to their bellies.

While Inglis’ men did get their acetylene torches out on a number of occasions, Fittler’s side only made five errors for the game. Tom Trbojevic, for example, was continually targeted with high balls but took them all. Meanwhile, Will Chambers was doing his best Dylan Walker impersonation all night to try and get Latrell Mitchell to execute one of his patented brain explosions that we know him so well for. However, Latrell would not be baited.

However, that doesn’t mean the Blues side clicked. Sure, there were some good performances. Boyd Cordner worked his guts out with 21 runs for 165 metres and 33 tackles – and no misses – is superb stuff. Damien Cook’s 113 metres, a line break assist and 54 tackles for just one miss was as fantastic as we’d hoped.

NSW Blues captain Boyd Cordner (AAP Image/Dan Peled)

And of course James Tedesco was superb with 210 metres, 11 tackle breaks, two line breaks and two line break assists. He even shaded Inglis’ superb effort.

However, it was not a dominant victory by any stretch.

And just like last year the Maroons will be able to go back, regroup and assess their side. And they’ll certainly make some changes.

Firstly, Dylan Napa will be an unlikely starter on June 24. His six missed tackles and a return of only 82 metres just isn’t good enough. Expect Tim Glasby or Matt Scott to come in for him.

Further, I’ll be stunned if Kalyn Ponga doesn’t take Anthony Milford’s bench spot, with Will Chambers’ seven missed tackles also putting pressure on his spot in the side.

And of course Billy Slater, with all his experience, leadership and trash talking, will be back to give Greg Inglis some more leadership help.

So New South Wales supporters should be very wary of being too cocky. There is nothing more dangerous than the Maroons with their backs to the wall and their effort last night showed me that they are far from done.

In fact, if they’d got a few calls that they deserved I think they would have won.

The Crowd Says:

2018-06-08T05:43:10+00:00

Footy Fan

Guest


There's nothing ambiguous in the rule. Maybe with general understanding and the odd ref mis-calling. Have a read: https://playnrl.com/media/2636/arl-rules-book-2018-web.pdf

AUTHOR

2018-06-08T04:14:50+00:00

Tim Gore

Expert


"Tatoo reduction program" = total gold.

2018-06-08T02:58:54+00:00

Mumbles

Guest


So what did he mean by same result

2018-06-08T02:56:44+00:00

Mumbles

Guest


Yet every week passes are called for exactly the same thing - the rule is amibiguous

2018-06-08T02:54:55+00:00

Mumbles

Guest


There were 2 obvious calls that went to Qld and I listed them or don't you bother reading. Some were marginal such as holding down in the tackle which gets called on a refs whim.

2018-06-08T02:51:55+00:00

Mumbles

Guest


OK let the players ref themselves from now on

2018-06-08T02:49:58+00:00

Mumbles

Guest


Rubbish

2018-06-08T01:23:05+00:00

Dave

Roar Rookie


" The direction of a pass is relative to the player making it and not to the actual path relative to the ground. A player running towards his opponents’ goal line may throw the ball towards a colleague who is behind him but because of the thrower’s own momentum the ball travels forward relative to the ground. This is not a forward pass as the thrower has not passed the ball forward in relation to himself. This is particularly noticeable when a running player makes a high, lobbed pass" So it clearly was not a forward pass.

2018-06-07T23:32:42+00:00

Footy Fan

Guest


" The problem was that Maloney’s pass to Addo-Carr was clearly forward, but again it wasn’t picked up." Forget the refs - it's simply not good enough that paid commentators and journalists are unaware of core rules. On this occasion and plenty of others, too. Repeat it 1000 times: i. Never measure the pass relative to the lines of the ground ii. Always measure the pass relative to the passer. It has to be that way, otherwise players streaming downfield could only pass with a stupendous fling backwards over their own head. On the video Maloney is ahead of both the ball and Addo Carr at all times the pass is in the air. Maloney maintains a constant forward speed. When Addo Carr recieves the pass, Maloney's a metre ahead of him. Not only legal, but I'd say clearly legal. Seriously, it's not that difficult ... has only been the rule for 110 years. All those involved in the game, read the rules.

2018-06-07T22:31:07+00:00

Ray Paks

Roar Rookie


get real. If Inglis has the ability to travel 10m in 1 sec from a standing start, Usain bolt is not the fastest man in the world. He was in front of the ref by 3 metres, that's an offside..

2018-06-07T21:37:06+00:00

bazza

Guest


Mate your team didn't even look like scoring trys. NSW had 2 non trys and the last one i thought that was a bit suspect. There was lots of forward passes missed but the one for the try by NSW was def forward every day.

2018-06-07T21:33:50+00:00

Roger

Guest


Or Maloney kept running...

2018-06-07T21:28:32+00:00

Chris Love

Guest


Guys I dabble in long range shooting and deal with ballistics a lot. For this example you can quickly discount a few things. 1. Spin Drift over this distance is so negligible it’s not worth discussing. A 308 round going 2700fps at the muzzle is going to drift maybe 12 inches...... over 900meters with a hell of a lot more revolutions. 2. Gravity. The only time gravity has ANY impact on the forward motion of anything is because it forces things to hit the ground. For the time it is in the air gravity does not slow down a bullet or a football. This statement by Barry is completely false and is demonstrated in yr10 physics. This is basic basic basic stuff. “Soapit sorry mate but you’re on a different vector of reality. Gravity doesn’t just work “up and down” it’s also the force that stops an objects forward motion, Don’t argue this point. You are wrong,” 3. Drag. A football isn’t nearly as ballistically efficient as a bullet and it also has a surface for gripping that would create drag. But over this distance it would be so negligible that to the naked eye it would be impossible to detect. Where Maloney ends up when the ball is caught is completely relevant. If you assume that Maloney’s forward velocity remains constant or even slows then if the ball lands behind him relative to him then the ball was projected backwards from him. If you want to argue Maloney sped up after passing then that’s another argument. If you’re not making this argument it’s time to accept basic basic physics. Yes wether he threw it backwards and where he ends up could be two completely different things but all of the above applies and where Maloney ends up is a very good gauge.

2018-06-07T20:39:02+00:00

Chris Love

Guest


Travel forward yes but clearly decelerating. The ball however while no longer accelerating (disregarding wind drag) remains traveling forward at the same pace as Maloney was when he released it.

2018-06-07T20:20:50+00:00

Chris Love

Guest


Trajectory of the ball has NOTHING to do with a forward pass.

2018-06-07T20:18:51+00:00

Chris Love

Guest


Cameron Smith got away with it for 15 years and still does.

2018-06-07T20:14:30+00:00

soapit

Guest


yes emcie you are right, the object will have different vel in different planes. however what ever vel it has in the horizontal plane doesnt change as a result of gravity until it touches the ground

2018-06-07T13:33:21+00:00

Cousin Claudio

Roar Guru


Geez nearly 300 posts about we wuz robbed Queensland. It wasn't a forward pass because the referee and linesman didn't call a forward pass and it wasn't a strip because the referee and linesmen didn't call a strip. I was taught to accept the referees decision no matter what you think personally and get on with the game. I do agree there were a lot more issues about that game that went unpunished and mainly from the Maroons too. They haven't disallowed the Blues tries retrospectively and declared Queensland the winners of SoO 1, so we move on to SoO 2 now - come what may. SoO 1 was a great game in many respects and I really enjoyed watching it.

2018-06-07T12:31:16+00:00

Rob

Guest


Inglis wasn't even off side IMO. The Physic professors on this site will tell you a player can travel 10m in 1 second and if you watch Inglis time his run he comes from behind Sutton as the ball is picked up by Cook.

2018-06-07T12:25:51+00:00

Off The Bench

Guest


That photo of Cordner is from last year...fkn ordinary work The Roar

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar