Have the curtains come down on the Raiders season?

By Adam / Roar Guru

The Raiders season is heading towards a point in time where they will start looking towards their pre-season. For the past handful of seasons they have been highly fancied as a team that could make a run towards and into September.

Attacking wise they are the epitome of what excites fans and gets them through the gates. They have among the most dynamic outside backs in the competition. Nick Cotric, Jordan Rapana, BJ Leilua and Jarrod Croker provide Canberra with a backline that is among the best in the NRL.

Offensively they have outperformed every other team and have a highlights reel longer than a Parramatta Eels premiership drought. Such is their attacking ability, they top the competition in tries and points scored.

How does a team who have scored the most points, most tries, second most line breaks and second most tackle busts find themselves outside the top eight and very nearly calling curtains on the 2018 season?

The Raiders have been a very strong team offensively. Any team who scores as many points as they do would normally win more games than they lose.

That said, defensively the team has some serious weaknesses that cannot be ignored. Only four teams have conceded more points than the Raiders and those four are the kind of teams you would expect to be conceding points.

More importantly they can leak points at times when a game is in the balance, which has been a glaring problem with the team over past two seasons.

Canberra Raiders coach Ricky Stuart (AAP Image/Lukas Coch)

The side has lost by fewer than six points six times, as well as another game where they lost by seven. There has only been the single game where the Raiders have closed out a game with a margin of six points or less.

This points to a team that struggles in the clutch moments. When the game is on the line or needed shutting down the Raiders struggled. No more so than their Round 3 loss to the Warriors at home in Canberra. The Warriors managed to score a 76th-minute try and two field goals in back-to-back sets in the 78th and 79th minutes respectively.

Has the inability for the Raiders to close out tight games become a team psychological issue? The Bulldogs game in Round 17 might prove to be the catalyst for change, or may prove to be a false dawn.

In reality the Raiders season derailed to a large extent during last year’s world cup semi-final. They lost one of their most reliable and mature players. To lose a player of his quality for a side like Canberra should not be understated.

The Raiders have a bevy of players who play off the cuff and unstructured. Josh Hodgson is the perfect marshal on the field directing traffic and getting the team to where they need to be on the field.

The return of Hodgson in Round 15 coincided with one of the side’s best performances for 2018. Not to say that he was the only player on the park, but the improvement in the direction of Canberra was noticeable.

He is a player who has had some pretty lofty comparisons for his influence on a game since returning from his ACL injury. There have been suggestions that he is Cameron Smith-like in his ability to influence a game, which is a remarkable endorsement. Had he not suffered the injury it may have been a completely different season, with an experienced rake controlling tight games at the death.

The up and down nature of the team has continued to some extent, but they would consider themselves unlucky to not have had four wins from the past five starts and should really have done better against the Broncos after being up by 16 at half time.

One of the most telling stat from the Raiders season is the fact that they have played a current top eight team seven times, for no wins. This is of a major concern as all six games left in the season are against teams who are currently above them on the ladder.

It’s extremely hard to be competitive on the ladder without being able to beat at least a handful of the teams who will be playing finals footy and they need to win just about all of them to stand any chance.

Unfortunately, it appears the Raiders are going to look back on this season as what could have been. I hope that not too much emphasis is placed on perceived bias against the team.

Raiders fullback Jack Wighton. (AAP Image/Mick Tsikas)

This week, Ricky Stuart claimed the NRL treats the Raiders differently to others in the league. Which to some extent this view is probably justified, but not in relation to officiating.

Tim Gore has spoken about the rough deal the Raiders cop in regards to getting on free to air and this is an obvious mistreatment of a number of sides in the NRL, particularly the Raiders, Knights, Warriors and Titans. This in itself is not good enough and should be corrected as it probably does affect teams to compete financially, but is probably an argument for a different article.

What is clear is that a team with such try-scoring potency should really be in the finals, and may still make it if things fall their way, but if they do not make the finals it can hardly be blamed on anything besides an inability to shut out games consistently against quality opposition.

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2018-07-27T06:00:03+00:00

Adam

Roar Guru


Croker seems like a nice guy but doesn't seem to be they guy that can give the team a kick when they need it. He just lacks a air of authority.

2018-07-26T16:30:21+00:00

james bond

Guest


Hodgson, Josh Hodgson, was the difference this year, and i think the Raiders will be better for it in the long run as his absence has highlighted how important he is to the team. It feels as though he has been really given the primary pivot role in that team far ahead of the others. Who held that leadership has always been a little hazy between Hodgo and the halves, now there is no question. One thing i ask, where does the responsibility of all the close losses lie in regards to their captain? I don't think Croker is assertive enough to lead that team when it counts.

2018-07-26T12:54:19+00:00

Ian

Guest


The Raiders season has been over for a couple of months, realistically, Second season in a row where the team failed to be ready to play in the early rounds. What is wrong with the Raiders? 1. Plenty of talent but no real footy smarts. 2, Too many players prone to spectacular brain farts. 3. Poorly coached. 4. Club happy to just be in the big league, and for which success is a bonus not a demand. 5. No depth, so players fairly safe in the knowledge they can't be dropped.

2018-07-26T10:23:21+00:00

Cugel

Roar Rookie


Our season was over after 14 mins, when the Titans scored en route to us throwing away an 18 pt lead.

2018-07-26T07:49:43+00:00

Adz Sportz

Roar Guru


*Mathematically YES, realistically NO. They don't deserve to be there

2018-07-26T07:43:52+00:00

Adz Sportz

Roar Guru


Mathematically no, realistically yes. When you consider the refereeing howlers the Raiders have copped this year and the fact that poor refereeing has gifted the Broncos about 8 points this season, the Raiders could consider themselves unlucky not to be closer to the top 8. But at the same time, they haven't beaten any team currently in the top 8. So do they deserve to even be there? Tigers still a chance

2018-07-26T05:21:57+00:00

Concerned Observer

Guest


Think someone threw out the stat that the raiders haven’t pulled off a win against a top 8 side this year. That’s not “hard-done by” that’s unacceptable. How on earth can you ever hope to be finals contenders if you can’t beat the top 8? To me, Much of it comes down to onfield leadership because no one’s rallying the team in those close games and the team’s suffering as a result. With a renewed emphasis on quick players and impact centres/forwards I believe you could get away with a set of reasonable halves which is what Austin, Sezer and Williams are. However, someone in the team needs to have that capacity to increase the intensity and the focus when the game’s close. Thurston, Smith, Cronk, Luke Lewis, Inglis, Jurbo. The raider’s just need someone willing to consistently produce the captain’s knock

2018-07-26T02:26:00+00:00

Dutski

Roar Guru


My big questions revolve around that game management. They can’t close out tight ones. In that instance you want your halves standing up and running the show. Let’s be honest - neither Aiden Sezer or Blake Austin kicked on in their careers. Neither has Sam Williams. How can three reasonably talented halves fail to develop under Stuart? I remember being so excited about the Sezer/Austin potential which has evolved into a reasonable halves combo but never kicked on. Hard to say it, but they need a halves coach that isn’t the head coach.

2018-07-25T21:44:19+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


I look at a side like the Storm who have been renowned in recent years for getting the points in tight games. I don't know if they are coached in how to game manage these situations, but they all seem to know what to do and they execute probably better than any side in the comp in the last 5 minutes when the games on the line. I'm only guessing but I don't think Canberra has had the quality of onfield leadership needed to win the close ones consistently. Someone needs to take control of the side in a close one, instill belief the game can be won, but they also need the game plan, which the Storm appear to have. Put the two together and Canberra could befinals bound - next year.

2018-07-25T20:56:41+00:00

AJL.

Roar Pro


Honestly, the Raiders have beaten my expectations. But then I'm a pessimist. All of these issues were there in 2017, barring Hodgson's injury. Stuart has seemingly done SFA to fix anything, but will almost certainly get a contract extension beyond 2020.

Read more at The Roar