The heat is on the National Curriculum in Malaysia

By Brendo51 / Roar Pro

For all the criticism of the National Curriculum from some well-known commentators and ex-players due to another early exit from the recent World Cup, its real test is about to begin.

Today the FFA announced the national squad for the AFC Under 16 Championships to be held in Malaysia in September. This squad is made up of boys born after January 1 2002 and that means they are the first generation of players to have played their entire football careers under the National Curriculum.

Of course, one tournament should not be used to assess the success or failure of the National Curriculum, but as our first true look into the players educated under it, it will certainly give us some indications if the goal of producing more technically gifted players is starting to show fruit.

Drawn into a group with Iraq, South Korea and Afghanistan, the tournament will provide Australia with some decent competition.

Australia have seen mixed results from this tournament in recent years. In the last AFC U16 Championship in 2016 we were the top seed of our group which featured Japan, Vietnam and Kyrgyzstan. Not only did we fail to win a match, the Joeys scored only two goals from their three group matches and finished bottom of their group.

We may possibly start to see some of these boys appearing in the A-League soon. John Roberts at Melbourne City, Louis D’Arrigo at Adelaide United, Mark Moric at Newcastle Jets, Dylan Pierias at Melbourne City and Rahmat Akbari at Brisbane are the ones to watch out for this season.

Before that in 2014 we were the top seed in our group, which featured Japan, China and Hong Kong. This time we won all three of our group matches to finish on top. We ultimately lost on penalties to eventual champions North Korea in the semi-final. This group featured Daniel Arzani, Jake Brimmer and Kosta Petratos.

This tournament also sees a new coach at the helm of the Joeys. Trevor Morgan has taken the reins and this will be his first hit out as the head coach for our Under 17s after Peter Cklamovski resigned in January this year. Morgan, who comes from the Wanderers and was assistant coach under Tony Popovic, is an excellent choice on paper. He seems to be relishing the role and has been actively assessing the boys across the country, holding training camps in both Sydney and Melbourne.

With Morgan running several selection camps, there seems to have been a much stronger emphasis on seeing the talent across the whole of the country and the selections seem to have indicated this. From a total of 13 NSW players selected in the U15 AFF Qualification tournament, only six have survived to be in the squad for Malaysia. The replacement players being drawn from all states.

Of the 23 players that Cklamovski took to Mongolia for the qualifiers that only nine have been selected in this squad. The biggest surprise was Tyson Savas from Sydney FC not being selected, as he has been this cohort’s captain in a majority of lead-up tournaments.

Tristan Hammond is the only internationally based player to be selected in the squad. The vast majority of the players have been drawn from A-League youth teams with only a sprinkling from non-A-league clubs. Melbourne City have provided the most with five players.

To date, many of the proponents of the National Curriculum have rightly pointed to the fact recent poor results from our youth and senior teams were an indication of the problems that we faced prior to the introduction of the National Curriculum and exactly the reason why change was needed. The expectation from this tournament is this squad will start to show a sharp uplift in technical skill and comfort on the ball.

Although results at youth level can be very inconsistent, a poor showing (and even more importantly disappointing performances) in this tournament will reflect negatively on the processes and systems that have been put into place as a part of the National Curriculum.

At this stage, we don’t know how widely the tournament will be televised; hopefully a few streams out of Malaysia will be made available for those interested.

Group matches
22nd September Australia v South Korea 10:45pm
25th September Australia v Iraq 6:30pm
28th September Australia v Afghanistan 6:30pm

Knockout stage from 30th September to 07th October.

The full squad is:

Name Club
Joshua Benson Newcastle Jets, Australia
Timothy Boke Belconnen United (ACT), Australia
Jordan Bos Melbourne City FC, Australia
Noah Botic Rockdale City Suns FC (NSW), Australia
Jordan Courtney-Perkins Brisbane Roar FC, Australia
Luke Duzel Melbourne City FC, Australia
Jayden Gorman Perth Glory FC, Australia
Tristan Hammond Sporting Lisbon, Portugal
Oliver Kalac Western Sydney Wanderers FC, Australia
Birkan Kirdar Melbourne Victory, Australia
Jaiden Kucharski Sydney FC, Australia
Thomas Lambiris Melbourne City FC, Australia
Adam Leombruno FFSA NTC (SA), Australia
Adam Pavlesic Sydney FC, Australia
Alex Popovic Adelaide United, Australia
Joseph Roddy Sydney FC, Australia
Lachlan Sepping Marconi FC (NSW), Australia
Kerrin Stokes Croydon Kings (SA), Australia
Ahmad Taleb Melbourne City FC, Australia
Ryan Teague Sydney FC, Australia
Joshua Varga Melbourne City FC, Australia
Daniel Walsh Perth Glory FC, Australia
Adam Zervas Newcastle Jets FC, Australia

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2018-09-10T23:45:41+00:00

Brendo51

Roar Pro


Thx Griffo I agree lots of other things to throw into the mix when talking about youth development. Too many people focus on the NC alone. You have touched on one of the most important, football culture. Too many of our good players now are not spending enough time with the ball. Training 2-3 times per week is not enough, kids need to be playing in the school playground, parks after school and on weekends.

2018-09-10T07:27:04+00:00

Griffo

Roar Guru


Agree with Waz, there are many factors. I’d also add the fees for coaching courses (which then might put pressure on coaches to recoup costs, if not a living). Drop fees to encourage higher education at the grassroots level - should increase quality of coaching availability. Some comparisons in UEFA between availability of educated coaching numbers at youth levels indicates a link between this youth quality from articles read years ago. Another that can easily be overlooked is football culture in the sense that football is just another after-school activity - train once or maybe twice a week plus a game on Saturday. Seeing it this way is not universal but football as a part of life being more widespread and played outside of set hours a week would help. You could go into private academies and their effect in diverting money from families and quality of football education... ...ideally if A-League and National Team stars had skill segments as part of kids TV, this might help. There are apps but the youngest age groups would benefit imo. (Similar to what Tom Byer has done in Japan for years). Good article.

AUTHOR

2018-09-10T06:30:30+00:00

Brendo51

Roar Pro


It's bloody awful, has killed off the comments section on most article with only a few of the die hards now posting. They need to do something quick to resolve it.

AUTHOR

2018-09-10T06:27:59+00:00

Brendo51

Roar Pro


Thx Waz And I din't disagree that there are a lot of elements to football development that get overlooked with the NC often the scapegoat.

2018-09-08T12:57:20+00:00

Redondo

Roar Rookie


The most bizarre thing was going live without an option to get email notifications when new comments are posted. All sense of a conversation around each article has been lost. That was a key feature of the old format and a glaring omission from the new. Most regular commenters have abandoned ship and the advertisers will soon follow I imagine.

2018-09-08T11:01:56+00:00

Barca4life

Guest


By the way the new format is terrible, what happened to the old one? It should never had changed.

2018-09-08T11:00:02+00:00

Barca4life

Guest


Graham Arnold made an interesting point about the next generation and especially with the effect of the FFA National Curriculum when it first came out in 2009 these kids are now in the Joeys. 5. The stars of the future “I know they will come, it’s a matter of giving them opportunities.” “I went and watched an under-17 camp the other day with the Joeys. I saw 70 kids at the age of 15 or 16 and I saw stuff I’ve never seen before in Australian football. “Those kids that were at North Narrabeen with the Joeys, they were three or four years old when the curriculum started. These kids are now coming. I’m so excited about the future. “I know the FFA have spoken about expansion, expansion is coming. We are doing everything to make opportunities for the kids.” https://www.socceroos.com.au/news/10-things-we-learned-graham-arnolds-first-press-conference This quote was quite interesting if it was anything to go by, but like anything I prefer to judge them how they get older in senior football ranks and ultimately Socceroos. But I would be looking out for them closely to see there technical and tactical abilites on show, you could argue they are the first batch to go through the whole process from SSGs from SAP and upwards although previous youth teams have also experienced going through the curriculum principals and guidelines too.

2018-09-08T01:56:02+00:00

Redondo

Roar Rookie


It will indeed. Throw in South Korea and the Aussie boys will be facing a good range of quality and playing styles. The results will answer a lot of questions about how effective the NC has been (with some caveats, as noted above by Waz). As an aside MF, your comments are as tangentially evocative as great poetry, summoning up thoughts of fingernails dragged across blackboards, milk spontaneously curdling, foetuses self-terminating, whale pods inexplicably beaching etc etc. Is there anyone left in your real life who has not been driven away by your relentless passive-aggressive sarcasm?

2018-09-07T23:16:01+00:00

Mister Football

Roar Guru


Playing the likes of Iraq and Afghanistan will certainly provide us with a good gauge on how the NC is tracking.

2018-09-07T22:17:10+00:00

jbinnie

Guest


Waz -As you are no doubt aware, football history in Australia is often a "no-go" zone when it comes to the articles being written today. Our so called golden generation of players who took us back to World Cup football in 2006 using players, who in the main were playing with "top" clubs overseas, was made up of players who, probably being in an average age span of 27-30 years of age, were probably around 5-8 back when they started their junior football around the early 1980's. There can be little doubt that these self same juniors would have been influenced by the then decision to change junior football to a small sided game on small pitches that was introduced into our game around 1976 with little or no publicity or fancy sounding titles like National Curriculum, a "great leap forward" initiated by an extremely costly "plan" using coaching information that was at least some 20-30 years old. (The Brazilians introduced 4-3-3 in their 1956 World Cup team) and as said, the small sided game on small pitches was at least 30 years old when it appeared on the "National Curriculum". So, have we really advanced or is the same track being played over and over.? cheers jb

2018-09-07T21:48:01+00:00

Waz

Roar Rookie


Great article. There’s plenty of focuson the NC however it’s only one element - the quality and availability of facilities, the quality and availability of coaches, and the impact pay-for-play has are just as important, if not more so. There has to be some form of NC and it’s often misunderstood that it is a kind of religious-like mantra that is rammed down kids throats which is far from the truth. There are elements that can be improved upon but let’s start with more facilities, better coaches, and ending pay-for-play ... any system will struggle otherwise.

2018-09-07T20:49:30+00:00

Buddy

Roar Rookie


It wouldbe good to be able to see something from the tournament even if it is just a highlights package. With Foxtel running specialized EPL channels I often watch theyouth team games and they are often far more exciting and entertaining than watching the senior teams play. However, it is difficult to engage unless directly involved without some screening of the tournament that isn’t hidden on a secondary channel in the early hours of the morning.

Read more at The Roar