The Wrap: All Blacks seal 16th title as Wallabies stare down wooden spoon

By Geoff Parkes / Expert

Unlike Australia’s earnest but bumbling rugby side, golf’s Ryder Cup never fails to deliver.

By now we will know if the USA managed to fashion an unlikely win or not, but if the events of the first two days are any guide, the ridiculously huge and overtly parochial galleries, housed gladiator-style right on the top of the players, certainly seemed to electro-charge the European team more than the visitors.

Nobody does body language better than Wallabies coach Michael Cheika, but Tiger Woods this weekend gave him a run for his money, rather than feeding off his comeback tour victory last week, instead fixing a permanent scowl to his face, a droop to his shoulders, and shuffling around Le Golf National like the man who wasn’t there.

The format provides for two rounds of foursomes, where pairs of players hit alternate shots. It’s an interesting psychological challenge which some golfers deal with better than others. Not only do you still have yourself to blame but, in this game, if you find yourself hitting out of gnarly, shin-high rough it’s because a thoughtless teammate put you there.

Tiger Woods on the course. (Keith Allison/Flickr – CC BY-SA 2.0)

Alternatively, slapping one into a water hazard cannot be shrugged off as easily, when it is someone else who has to step forward and fix up your mess.

And so it was for the Wallabies in Saturday night’s Port Elizabeth Test, with Kurtley Beale teeing it up on the first and inexplicably wafting one wide to the right, out of bounds as it were, putting his teammates behind the game right from the get go.

The Springboks’ lead was doubled soon after, when Handre Pollard took advantage of Folau Fainga’a and Ned Hanigan losing contact in the front line, and whatever happened after that – and the game certainly evened up – the Springboks never seriously threatened to lose control of the scoreboard.

The frantic start did the Wallabies no favours, a combination of lineout and handling errors under pressure, and their dogged determination to kick for Israel Folau to chase, not allowing them to retain possession and settle into their work.

The Israel Folau saga is proving a major headache for Rugby Australia (Photo by Matt King/Getty Images)

Accordingly, while holding steady in the scrum, new starter Taniela Tupou spent 50 minutes chasing his tail and will today be wondering about a ‘different’ style of Test rugby that he will need to learn how to adapt to.

He was no lone ranger in that regard, the Wallabies struggling all match to distinguish between when to ‘flick the switch’ and seize an opportunity (like when Genia darted to the blindside to set up his own try), or to draw breath, focus on their line-out execution, and build pressure through sustained control of possession.

They are not the first team to visit South Africa and become confused by the defensive centre and outside winger dashing up out of the line, to create the illusion of an ‘umbrella’. One way to beat that is to play hard and directly on the advantage line, another is to employ a judicious, accurate long kicking game to try to force the Boks to play back at you.

A third way is to be intoxicated by the space left vacant on the edges, and to play around or over the umbrella, to free up flying runners. However the Wallabies mostly offered up Reece Hodge or Michael Hooper on the outside – both played well but neither had the pace to burn the Boks in a way that would stop them baiting Beale to keep throwing the ball wide across the field.

The Wallabies attack thus felt reactive and disjointed and – as it has done all year – continues to lack any real sense of identity and understanding about what cohesive style it is, that the players are actually locked into.

Some players seem more focused on maintaining positions than running hard in support of teammates, and as a result, tackled players were too often left exposed at the breakdown, without an offload option or enough strength in numbers to protect the area.

Jack Maddocks standing over the tackle, solo, is simply never going to cut it against a pack as abrasive as the Springboks.

There will be criticism too for ignoring kickable penalty goals but remember that the Wallabies did kick for goal twice in the first half and missed, and there was a sniff of a yellow card in the air, which came to fruition when Aphiwa Dyantyi lingered too long in the wrong place.

But that strategy is only as good as the ability to secure the ball from the attacking lineout, and here, once again, the Wallabies set-piece execution let them down.

If a call has not already been made, the manager of the Wallabies’ hotel in Salta should already have roped off the hotel car park to allow for continuous lineout practice (as will the Pumas hotel by the way – if you’re staying in a Salta hotel this week, best leave the car at home).

For their part, the Springboks weren’t overjoyed with their effort with the ball either, missing multiple scoring opportunities through a lack of composure at vital moments. They also offered Hooper too much latitude at the front of the line-outs that did work – the All Blacks successfully repeating that tactic a few hours later with Ardie Savea.

But for next week, these are mostly moot points – by now everyone knows not to read anything into how this Springbok side performs against other sides compared to the mindset they adopt for the All Blacks.

Tackling machine Peter-Steph du Toit continues to make every post a winner at flanker – he and hooker Malcolm Marx noticeably physically stronger than their direct opponents, in the contact areas.

Pieter-Steph du Toit’s effort for the Springboks against the All Blacks was immense. (Photo by Hannah Peters/Getty Images)

The All Blacks of course will relish the challenge, heading off a rousing, but deeply flawed, Argentinian effort, in Buenos Aries, 35-17.

This was an enjoyable match of high intensity, emotion and much chaos – one that should hold many of the less experienced, developing All Blacks in good stead for the future.

The Pumas were soundly thrashed in the scrum, which effectively killed off their structured backline attack and any winning chance they might have had, however it didn’t stop them dishing up waves of determined runners, particularly in the second half.

Once again heading the effort was Nicolas Sanchez, truly in the form of his life, although his cross-kick from an attacking penalty, straight to Waisake Naholo, managed to out-do even Beale’s pass, for bone-headed concept and execution.

That play capped a chaotic period where referee Mathieu Raynal (who enjoyed an excellent first 40-minutes) seemed to go off-piste, asking the opinion of TMO David Grashoff about a double movement by Tomas Cubelli, being provided with an accurate account, then summarily dismissing it, then also seemingly inventing a new law interpretation on the spot, to penalize Beauden Barrett for a dangerous tackle.

Raynal demonstrated to Barrett how he needed to wrap both of his arms around Sanchez in the motion of tackling him, not just one arm. Most likely, Raynal was indulging in some minor pants-wetting at the force of the collision, rather than accepting that there is nothing in the laws that prevents Barrett – or any player – using the full force of their shoulder in a tackle, simultaneously with that arm wrapping around the tackled player.

Sonny Bill Williams, Jonny Fa’auli, Steven Luatua – these are famous cases where dangerous shoulder charges have been rightly sanctioned. But sometimes a hard tackle is just a hard tackle.

Sonny Bill Williams of New Zealand looks back to the field of play as he heads for the changing rooms after receiving a red card. (AAP Image/Dean Pemberton)

Relishing that hard stuff was Savea, who grasped an unexpected starting opportunity at No. 8 with both hands, his trademark energy and determination proving a handful for the Pumas all night.

Another stand-out was the late cameo from Richie Mo’unga, who showed dash and composure, before expertly laying on the final try for Anton Leinert-Brown. This not only silenced the crowd, but also saved the Pumas’ scrum from the humiliation of conceding a penalty try.

With the win, the All Blacks sealed their 16th Tri Nations/Rugby Championship title, from 22 attempts. An argument remains that this degree of dominance is hurtful for the competition, although there can be no doubt that this year’s iteration has been the most competitive and interesting for some time, and that there will be no lessening of intensity next week.

At the other end of the table, the Wallabies are in danger of securing their first wooden spoon since 2009 – even a close win by less than seven points will not be enough to lift them off the bottom.

This is a week to forget about whether Michael Cheika’s job is on the line or not, but for his side to calmly focus – individually and collectively – on how to front up to a Puma’s side that, scrum aside, will feel that they have the Wallabies’ measure.

Michael Cheika (Photo by Dan Mullan/Getty Images)

The Wallabies could do worse than to look at the exploits this weekend of Mac (Tommy Fleetwood), Belushi (John Rahm), Alby Mathewson (Tyrell Hatton), Ricky Riccitelli (Francesco Molinari) and the rest of their European teammates.

Despite an incredible amount of noise and external distraction, despite weight of expectation and fear of failure, delivering on the elite stage is about channeling the right amount of energy and emotion into the performance so that performance is enhanced rather than impaired.

It’s fair to say that the Springboks found this zone in Wellington, and the Wallabies… well it’s a while since they’ve been there.

The news that Tolu Latu is flying to Argentina as reinforcement is hardly inspiring – Latu was hooked before halftime for NSW Country against the Fiji Drua, after no less than half a dozen lineout throws failed to find their mark, some by quite a distance.

Both Salta and Pretoria promise plenty – the least of all, with an eye to a World Cup now less than a year away, being some ripping post-mortems.

The Crowd Says:

2018-10-05T03:12:07+00:00

Akari

Roar Rookie


Belated but I agree GP that the Shute Shield clubs, Sydney Rugby Union, and NSW Rugby Union are responsible for the way rugby is run in NSW and must be held accountable for the fall in funding and crowds at games in that state. But no, they all point the finger at the ARU and want the ARU to fund their operations instead. Ridiculous, I say. I am however glad that Bakkies was kind enough to include Brendan Cannon's article in full here as it saved me from having to look for it. BC has asked pertinent questions and they need to be addressed and some by the state organisations responsible for running rugby. If his intent was solely for handouts from the ARU, it is wrong.

AUTHOR

2018-10-03T07:30:14+00:00

Geoff Parkes

Expert


Hi NV Almost too late.... :) Great comment about the Olympic golf. Huge wasted opportunity.

2018-10-03T02:55:17+00:00

The Neutral View From Sweden

Roar Guru


Hello GP Late reading and commenting from me, but I hope not too late. An excellent column as always and extra happy to see that you have given Ryder Cup some lengthy coverage. What a perfect sporting event it is in every regard. They really have every single detail right on the money. And speaking about money, it never stops to fascinate me that the only "pro" golfing competition with no money at all is the ultimate pressure tester for any golfer (sadly this option only exists for Europeans and Americans). The only sad thing after a Ryder Cup weekend is the realization that there are so few match play tournaments in pro golf. I would love it if at least one of the Majors were a match play tournament (The PGA would be a perfect fit) hence match play is a brilliant format to watch and it tests the players' skills in ways a stroke tournament never can. That the IOC made the Olympic golfing tournament a singles 72 hole stroke competition is one of biggest chances ever missed I say. Why oh why did they not make it a team competition with four golfers from every country playing foursomes, fourballs, and singles matches. It could have been epic TV sport and also given golf a perfect opportunity to finally have a team competition for nations - on the biggest stage - that really would have some serious prestige.

2018-10-02T22:38:24+00:00

RobC

Roar Guru


Thanks GP WBs playing CHECKers into a chess game Even sadder to see Pumas playing like how WBs should be playing. Scrum aside

2018-10-02T14:05:36+00:00

Bakkies

Roar Guru


Reece is supposed to be off to Connacht.

2018-10-02T07:17:30+00:00

Akari

Roar Rookie


I thought Raynal was pretty good apart from the BBBBB tackle and Cubelli's try: he communicated well and allowed the game to flow. I didn't think he was up to international level when I 1st came across him during the Lions Tour last year.

2018-10-02T07:10:15+00:00

Akari

Roar Rookie


But why is Ta'avao, an Australian, playing for the ABs, Bluesfan. Oh, yeah, now I recall. The Tahs and the WBs didn't want him and sent him packing and he found his way back to NZ rugby. How smart is that? They did the same with Michael Ala'alatoa a few years before but that was Cheika's brain explosion. The buggers continually mistake a polished turd for the genuine gem.

2018-10-02T03:33:30+00:00

David

Guest


GP: "What did you think of the Wallabies opening up access to the travelling journo’s?" It intrigued me, Geoff. When that happens in politics and other circles it's usually a backside-covering exercise to point the finger of blame elsewhere. But Cheika doesn't strike me as that kind of person: from what I've read and seen he is very loyal (think Nick Phipps!), and if the players thought he was fingering them for the blame he'd lose the dressing room real quick. So, I think he was trying to show the armchair critics that the coaches are not tactically incompetent or unaware of the things that need addressing, and that the team really do try hard to prepare well and translate that onto the field. But something is obviously going wrong between practice and the game, and I reckon it must be driving the whole group nuts. I suspect the team now expects to lose, and the players are not completely confident that their teammates will be there and do the right thing when needed. Addressing that mental side is really tough when a team continues to lose but it can obviously be done. I was really impressed by how well the Argentinians won the five minutes before and after half-time against the ABs in Nelson (didn't help them win the game,, however) and against the WBs at Carrara. That was a massive change in mental toughness from previous years. Don't know if Ledesma brought in someone to help with that side of things, but whatever he's done it's made a difference.

AUTHOR

2018-10-02T02:57:49+00:00

Geoff Parkes

Expert


The issue is way more complex than you are giving credit JSJ. It involves those clubs, the other Shute Shield clubs, the Sydney Rugby Union, the NSW Rugby Union and Rugby Australia. If Twiggy is able to be part of a solution that takes into account all of the issues at play, and provide a better outcome for rugby in Western Sydney, then that is clearly a good thing. What I spoke against was the notion that was being pushed in public by A Jones and others, that he should be allowed to set up a WSR side in Western Sydney, without that being part of a wider discussion. That's the context. The fact that those discussions have since been held supports my view.

2018-10-02T02:46:17+00:00

Bakkies

Roar Guru


Exactly JSJ. Western Sydney Rams may never get this opportunity again to go fully pro and have proper backing that they will never get from the local, state and national unions. These unions have basically given up already. Neither the Rams and the Force have anything to do with the existing comps. They will also create more professional opportunities for people in Australia at zero cost to the RA.

2018-10-02T02:31:34+00:00

Bakkies

Roar Guru


Geoff I am talking about right here and now as Rugby in Australia can't wait any longer to get the hard answers. I don't have the contacts to start pushing their buttons as we will never get the hard questions that we want to be asked by the likes of Pandaram, Tom Decent, Roy Ward and Sam Worthington. Kick and Chase unlike their South African counterparts don't ask the hard questions of the test team and the administration. Brendan Venter and Jake White's interviews with the likes of Naas Botha and Nick Mallett were excellent. As Jeremy Paul said recently the Foxsports team are too close to it. Very few journalists are making them accountable and apart from putting up a fan piece on here I can't get to the individuals responsible as the game doesn't have a couple of years to get this mess sorted out. This is why people are putting comments on here constantly to get this addressed. We can't just continue to put the hand in the sand and remain in the dark. We need these questions asked and points raised to the RA: - How are they going to sort out their financial mess without relying on windfalls and not cutting community Rugby funding to save a buck? - Why hasn't the Chairman resigned? - When is Rod Kafer's coaching plan going to come to fruition? - What are they going to do to get test crowds back? The fans are that angry winning isn't the solution. It is also about the connection that we built up at Super Rugby and test level and threw away through mismanagement - Listen to Andrew Forrest about his Rugby Roos project which he has already implemented in WA. He is using Force players as part of their contract obligations to go out on the ground and coach the game to kids in clubs and schools - Better integration with the grassroots - Forget centralisation teams aren't going to give autonomy to the RA after they used it to axe a side - Commercial structure needs to change without relying on test Rugby and Foxsports tv deals to survive. Europe addressed this nearly five years ago - Where do they see the NRC going as they are going to need more put in to promote the competition? I can't table this and get them in for an interview. Brett, Spiro, David and yourself certainly can. If this is seen as anti the RA so be it. They have dug their own grave and can't continue to get away with their mismanagement. The game in Australia might be done and dusted by then.

2018-10-02T02:26:49+00:00

Machooka

Roar Guru


Nice article Tragic...

2018-10-02T02:04:13+00:00

Machooka

Roar Guru


Morning G... apologies but better late than never! Good Wrap of da w'end's rounds... and all to play next w'end eh ;) And how gooood is golf... the Ryder Cup being the pick of round methinks. Par excellence :)

2018-10-02T01:12:46+00:00

Old Bugger

Guest


Whoa there big fella.......as long as the red is of similar vintage, then being an oldie ensures the taste, is more distinguished......don't you agree??

2018-10-02T00:13:28+00:00

JSJ

Roar Rookie


"as opposed to him establishing a beachhead in competition with existing competitions." I live in Perth, but from this distance I see reports about Penrith getting kicked out of the Shute Shield and West Harbour on the brink. My understanding is that Penrith and WH put their hand up for help. "Existing competitions"in Western Sydney are in trouble and the other Shute Shield clubs are always crying out for more money from RA. But RA have spent themselves into a hole propping up the Rebels. Twiggy offers to help rugby in Sydney and you want keep him out?

AUTHOR

2018-10-01T22:11:16+00:00

Geoff Parkes

Expert


Hi David Thanks for taking the time to write. It seems clear to me that it's a combination of factors, to do with Cheika, but also with coaching and talent ID, selection and skills devt issues over a number of years - all coming together. It's almost generational, so it's difficult to see how a substantial improvement can be made in the short term, or just by changing the coach at the top. Or perhaps it can, and gloom seems more palpable in low times like these? What did you think of the Wallabies opening up access to the travelling journo's?

AUTHOR

2018-10-01T22:04:41+00:00

Geoff Parkes

Expert


"letting Twiggy into Western Sydney was like inviting the fox into the hen house" Never mind the context JSJ. I've said for a long time - and in that article - that Forrest is good for Australian rugby, as long as his competition is co-ordinated with existing competitions, and there are financial benefits for the game that flow as a result - as opposed to him establishing a beachhead in competition with existing competitions.

AUTHOR

2018-10-01T21:59:19+00:00

Geoff Parkes

Expert


"You have been provided a platform that I haven’t" Ridiculous comment Bakkies. The Roar is a platform for anybody and everybody to start writing articles and build an audience. How do you think I started? There's nothing at all to stop you writing articles that bring RA to account - apart from the fact that you prefer to poison unrelated rugby articles and discussions with the same, broken record comments.

2018-10-01T21:41:09+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


Pollard on his home park can bang them over from 60 m and during SR he was about 90%.

2018-10-01T18:53:11+00:00

Bakkies

Roar Guru


Thanks for JSJ and Sheek. Sorry for the repetition with the new format you don't see your posts so they are stuck in the queue for an hour and post it again. At least with the old one they are visible and can put a dot in if they show up at the same time.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar