Mr Cricket: White, stale and male

By JoePhillips / Roar Rookie

The unabashed celebrity of Shane Warne’s running commentary on ‘Australian cricket’ belies the dangers of peroxide blonde tips leaking into the central nervous system.

Forever tagged as the greatest leg spinner to have ever lived, the great Australian ego cannot seem to be content with the boundless, rose-tinted praise that befalls a man who enacted more revolutions on a leather sphere than all others.

The simplicity of what Warne performed on the cricket pitch does not diminish his extraordinary cricketing prowess, but rather heightens it. He was a formidable opponent who enjoyed the complexities that encompass the simple act of bowling a cricket ball – the theatre of the contest, the personalities of the actors and the mental grind that grips the sporting voyeur.

However, the widely misconceived notion in the sports pages of Australia is that a celebrated sporting career can be as easily replicated in the media. These so-called purveyors of truth can be the most insightful, but also the most tedious.

Our expectations of sports commentators is to transport us to the narrative of the game. Great callers know when silence is golden and the precise moment to fill the void, driving us forever deeper into the contest.

Sport can be a riveting pursuit that distills all aspects of human society into the merest of moments, grabbing you by the scruff of the neck with an energy and verve ever onward.

The platform that Warne and others of his ilk (read Kevin Pietersen, Michael Slater et al) have is irrespective of their ability to dissect and analyse the game, but rather they parody and prance in pursuit of personal celebrity. It is a pathetic symptom of modern sport.

It is these transparent attempts to remain front and centre in the contemporary cricketing lexicon that now roll on from the ashes of Nine and into Rupert’s FoxSports pantomime. Dripping with sponsor logos and the banality of Australian pay television, cricket as ‘entertainment’ will endure on the whims of another archaic broadcaster buried in Kerry Packer’s bitter shadow.

We retain Warne and co with the comic relief of Skull O’Keefe (in what is personally a crushing blow as an avid and long time ABC Grandstand listener) craftily inserted to remind the boys club that there is a job at hand.

Final condemnation will be reserved till the summer’s conclusion, but the deft movements of Optus to snatch the English Premier League from Fox’s stable reminds one that sport is now firmly a commodity of the masters for the masses.

Shane Warne of Australia (Photo by Hamish Blair/Getty Images)

As Geoff Lemon wrote in 2015 of the Channel Nine broadcast team and cricket commentary more broadly, “There’s no surer path to monotony and a crushingly limited world view – and let’s not even start on the place of women in the game. Cricket needs people whose aptitude as analysts, entertainers and public speakers is tested ahead of batting or bowling.”

It’s a simple cry for respect.

Warne is currently trying to sell what will undoubtedly be a best selling book – Dad’s Christmas stocking filler, if you will.

Australia’s recent capitulation to Pakistan in the UAE has given rise to a plethora of ‘new’ Australian XI’s, Warne’s most notably catching the media’s attention.

Change is always an easy and clear route when such a Test series has eventuated, but to disregard the inexperience of Marnus Labuschange, Travis Head, Aaron Finch and co in a batting line up devoid of confidence and class for more change is a slippery slope.

Pakistan in the UAE has always been a tricky assignment for Australian teams, even when fully strengthened, and against the growing prowess of Mohammed Abbas, the Australian top order was exposed.

Justin Langer will rightly persist with the debutants and so he should. The Marsh brothers are more intriguing: superb recent Australian summers and now catapulted into the senior ranks, they will be under immense pressure to retain their spots.

Justin Langer (Photo by Scott Barbour/Getty Images)

Mitchell Marsh is most definitely not a top five Test batsman and that experiment must be deemed a failure.

More so, his contribution with the ball will not save him if Marcus Stoinis finds the ODI form that announced his international arrival in New Zealand.

Comparatively, older brother Shaun’s nomadic travels in and out of the side must surely be over with Khawaja’s injury and the inexperience of the remaining top order.

A superb batsman on his day, his persistence and mental fortitude to forge on against the moniker of batting scapegoat – bestowed upon by the ravenous Australian public – suggests a man whose desire to play cricket goes far deeper than credited.

It is within this intriguing paradigm of team selection in the new Langer era that Warne now finds himself.

Billed regularly as one of the greatest cricketing minds, it is thus so disappointing that his moments of cricketing clarity and insight are so tediously enveloped by monologues of boastful indulgence. You can be a cricketing genius, but you also need to know when to shut up and let others find their voice.

The Crowd Says:

2018-10-27T11:10:48+00:00

Bill

Guest


I donno, I get your point when you explain, but I felt your article comes across as self-serving and click bait, it’s not really necessary to bait the conversation with tones of accusations of sexism and racism as you’ve almost underhandedly suggested. Why not constructively suggest some alternatives without making this yet another attack on “white males”. Popular today as it is, why not rise above that and stay positive and constructive. I quite likely many of the commentators, at least in measured doses others here appear to take issue with, I’d continue to appreciate their professional game insight over a smoother, so call professional commentator who knows nothing about the game. It’s the current trend now across most sports sadly, just because there’s. more equal mix in the commentary teams I’m not sure it’s worth it. Anyway as others have accused me of being wrong and knowing nothing about cricket, I’ll withdraw here and leave you to it, perhaps Im in the minority here with my views. I also seem to be in the minority thinking the appalling public overreaction to the cheating scandal and bans handed down was way too harsh, everyone else seems to relish righteousness of it all, I just don’t get it, but perhaps it’s just me. Good luck with the articles, I suppose at least your having a go, can’t knock that! thanks for listening anyway. Bill

2018-10-27T11:08:35+00:00

Fred

Guest


What's him being a white male got to do with anything? Are you an 18 year old studying first year sociology?

2018-10-27T10:56:06+00:00

Fred

Guest


Didn't you get the memo? Being a white male is a an outrageous sin in 2018.

AUTHOR

2018-10-26T01:02:45+00:00

JoePhillips

Roar Rookie


Hi Bill, my article challenges the 'boy's club' establishment that existed at Channel 9 and now has the potential to transfer itself to Fox and Seven - in this respect I am seeking to improve the sport by arguing for commentators to have the requisite analysis, narration and media skills, rather than a commentary position based purely on past playing success. This does not diminish their playing careers or achievements. There are plenty of superb commentators who haven't excelled in their chosen sport - Jim Maxwell, Alison Mitchell, Harsha Bogle, Gerard Whateley, John Arlott, Geoff Lemon et al. Jonathan Agnew and Alan McGilvray are two others that have arguably exceeded their sporting achievements when in the commentary box. I believe that in the case of Channel 9 there was too little an opportunity for those with the broadcast skills to be positioned alongside former players. Perhaps 7 and Fox will do a better job with a clean slate.

2018-10-25T23:30:00+00:00

JamesH

Roar Guru


Bill, where is the lie???

2018-10-25T23:03:39+00:00

Spanner

Roar Rookie


Sadly Bill - I believe you really dont understand cricket or it's commentators - great cricketers dont necessarily make great (or even good) commentators or journalists ! If the "existing establishment" is rubbish, it needs to be called out . Sad !

2018-10-25T13:08:28+00:00

Cos1

Guest


I get what you say about commentary (not sure what being 'white' and 'male' has to do with it - please don't bring identity politics into Roar). Of course, it costs TV stations a fortune to buy broadcast rights and their major concern is selling a product and getting a return on their investment. This is not the ideal but it is the reality. The commentators are cricket celebrities and are a part of the product, as are the players that play. But the commentators are also people who can open a window into the world of international cricketers - into the mindsets of those on the field. They may not create great narratives and grasp moments as well as other professional commentators or writers but, at the least, we expect them to be informed. In this sense, Warney has his (many) faults but he knows his stuff. I think both Marsh's are in a pretty precarious position but the fact that there are so few experienced players in the side may save their bacon (yet again). That being said, another poor series and the selectors will probably feel they have little choice but to give someone else a go.

2018-10-25T12:34:27+00:00

Bill

Guest


Wow, to the author what a miserable, bitter and twisted viewpoint you paint, I’ve no idea what’s led you to sledge some of the cricket greats both on the pitch and the commentary team. Yet you offer no alternative. In fact, this attention seeking post of yours here mirrors what you falsely call out in others, what a shocking hipocracy. Let’s stop take shots at those successful and do something yourself to make it better, get in there and improve cricket TV (if you can), oh tearing into the existing establishment is much easier isn’t it. Sad.

2018-10-25T07:51:41+00:00

Geoffo

Guest


Pick on Michael Hussey at your own peril. I was once a devout cricket follower, who would never entertain the notion of T20 cricket. One day I turned on the box and the BBL was on. Mike Hussey came in at the fall of a wicket. Shaun Tait was STEAMING in. First ball bouncer, 155kph, right on Huss's nose. One of the fastest bouncers I have ever seen bowled. Bang. Six runs. The greatest shot I have ever seen. I haven't missed a BBL game since. (if anyone has a recording of this shot I would love to see it again)

2018-10-25T02:48:11+00:00

Paul D

Roar Guru


I thought this was gonna be an article bagging out Mike Hussey - that would have been interesting, if only because I wasn't sure how he's ever demonstrated enough of a personality for someone to form that view. Warney is fast becoming the Tony Abbott of Australian cricket

2018-10-25T01:48:13+00:00

peeeko

Roar Guru


i dont know what their skin colour has to do with it?

AUTHOR

2018-10-25T01:41:04+00:00

JoePhillips

Roar Rookie


You've got to let it all hang out sometimes

AUTHOR

2018-10-25T01:40:33+00:00

JoePhillips

Roar Rookie


A few very good criticisms in regards to language clarity - my fault entirely when submitting rage pieces immediately. Shaun Marsh definitely deserves to remain in the team as an experienced head, I just wasn't particularly clear in hindsight. Thanks for reading and more importantly, engaging though.

2018-10-24T22:32:19+00:00

Andre Leslie

Roar Guru


Golly... don't hold back.

2018-10-24T19:49:54+00:00

Trebla

Guest


The point you make is good, but not always clear. And what Do you mean that Shaun Marshs time in the team must be over with Khawaja injury and the inexperienced players? Surely those reasons make it more likely Marsh will be picked. My opinion could be worthless, but I think your points are good and language is entertaining, but a bit flowery at times. Be more direct with your important points. And I agree with most of what you said, particularly about the commentators.

Read more at The Roar