NRL: The end of contracts, and of characters

By Shane / Roar Pro

The past week has seen a frenzy of player movement in the NRL, which is not unusual for the modern game, but the timing of the announcements does pose a few questions.

Coming into December, squads have just completed their third or fourth week of pre-season and it’s normally a time when strong bonds are starting to form within a playing group, and coaches are beginning to get an understanding of the quality of the group they will be working with in the new year.

The first big news this week was the confirmed move of David Klemmer, affectionately known as ‘Klem’, from the Bulldogs to the Newcastle Knights. His signing was widely tipped in the media as early as October, but the official announcement this week had some commentators comparing his potential impact in Newcastle to Paul ‘The Chief’ Harragon.

I think even David Klemmer would admit that he has a long way to go to validate such a bold statement, both on and off the field.

Next, we were met with the news that long time New Zealand Warriors half-back Shaun Johnson had requested a release from the final year of his contract and he is now tipped to end up in the halves at the Cronulla Sharks.

Shaun has footwork and skills like few other rugby league stars and will likely fill a jersey that has been ably worn in the past by such household names as Brett ‘Noddy’ Kimmorley and Matty ‘Joey’s brother’ Johns.

I don’t need to remind you that ‘Joey’s brother’ also goes by a number of different monikers made famous during his illustrious television career since he retired from the game in 2002.

Some examples include his alter-egos, former 1980s rugby league hard-man Reg Regan and gardening guru Don Kirk. There is no doubt Shaun has remarkable talent on the field, but he will need to step up his game to match the entertainment value of the men who went before him in the Shire.

Shaun Johnson is set to leave the Warriors (AAP Image/SNPA, Martin Hunter)

To cap off a crazy week, we woke to rumours that English pivot Gareth Widdop had come down with a bout of homesickness and craved a return to the Old Dart.

Gareth has had a very successful career in the NRL at Melbourne and the Dragons and after putting together a very consistent couple of seasons, there is no doubt – if the rumours are true – he will be a big loss to the NRL.

Gareth played some brilliant football for the team famous for the red V in a number six jersey previously worn by a number of high profile players. The ones that spring to mind immediately are Anthony ‘Choc’ Mundine and the ‘boy from Temora’, who has had his own share of media lately, Trent Barrett.

Both Dragons halves who preceded Widdop had a tendency to divide opinion, but they no doubt had more of a cult following than Widdop did within the Dragons army.

There are numerous stories like this throughout an NRL season but these ones stood out because of a common theme. Here we have three examples in the space of a week, of very good NRL players who have decided to change clubs when they are entering the prime of their careers.

It is a stark reflection of the business that is the NRL in 2018-19. The fact is the players and clubs will move on quickly, and so will the fans.

All of the stakeholders are so accustomed to the lack of loyalty that is now a reality in the game, that these player transfers will hardly be discussed after the customary office banter has taken place.

But what is the real cost? I don’t know if you noticed in the narrative above that I wrote about men who were once truly idolised by fans – Noddy, Choc, the Chief, Joey and the kid from Temora. These players have been replaced by men known to fans only by their birth names. And the players who replace them will soon be replaced too, without much fanfare. Rugby League crowds and TV ratings are declining each year, and administrators wonder why.

Footy fans don’t give their heroes nicknames anymore and the reason for that is simple. It’s hard to settle on a hero when he probably won’t see out his current two-year deal.

The Crowd Says:

2018-11-29T23:10:29+00:00

BA Sports

Roar Guru


"Noddy" "Choc" and "Baz" played for multiple clubs - what has nicknames got to do with switching clubs?

2018-11-29T14:19:39+00:00

Josh Beckett

Roar Rookie


Ignoring that crowds and ratings aren't really dropping, interesting article. Definitely rose-tinted in relation to the old days though.

2018-11-29T09:28:07+00:00

Louis McIntyre

Roar Guru


You're looking way too into it. The nicknames in my friendship group are mostly name related, maybe more an indication of current society than anything else. Regardless of this, if i said Turbo, Jurbo, LeiPana you would know what players (or pair of players) I was referring to.

AUTHOR

2018-11-29T06:54:04+00:00

Shane

Roar Pro


Definitely agree that society isn’t as fun anymore. I don’t think the common bloke on the street can relate to a full-time pro athlete as they did in the days of Alfie, Spud, Chief, Blocker, Cement etc

AUTHOR

2018-11-29T06:49:00+00:00

Shane

Roar Pro


Totally agree Shaun is a better player than Noddy and Matty were. So why doesn’t he have a nickname we all refer to him by? And why don’t so many other current stars? I believe fans and players don’t have the same connection they once did - not so long ago.

2018-11-29T03:25:39+00:00

Sam Sparrow

Guest


Its an easy Solution. Start a fund for development of grassroots country RL . Fine the club ( the club that held any early terminated contract) 20% of the total lifetime value of that contract for either a coach or player who's contract is terminated early. and Let them have the option of collecting that from the player or coach concerned or from the new club from their salary cap. So lets say a player has a 5 year contract for 400k pa cancelled in the final year, then his club pays 400 x 5=$2m x 20% = $400K for early cancellation to the the CRL in the state his club resides i.e. NSW CRL. I can assure you this would mean most high profile players would wiat out their contracts before moving. You could have a minimum amount when the NRL commission reviewed a particular situation and let them off with a minimum fine for exceptional circumstances.

2018-11-29T02:03:34+00:00

Randy

Roar Rookie


what a bizarre article, especially this part: " There is no doubt Shaun has remarkable talent on the field, but he will need to step up his game to match the entertainment value of the men who went before him in the Shire" what entertainment value did noddy and matt johns bring to the Sharks exactly? lol Johnson is not only a more talented player than those two, he is far more entertaining to watch. No disrespect to Kimmorley who was a great half and won a premiership with the Storm.

2018-11-29T01:51:16+00:00

Matt H

Roar Guru


Cronk is 'cyborg' Smith is 'the referee whisperer' or 'the accountant' Although highly respected, are those two loved in the same way as JT, Locky, Slammin Sam, Thumper, Billy the Kid? Or further back Jacko, Rowdy, Snoz, Choppy, Beaver, Alfie, Dishead and The Turtle?

2018-11-29T00:44:54+00:00

Zavjalova

Roar Rookie


Cooper "Robot" Cronk and Cameron "Hairy" or "refs boss" Smith.

2018-11-29T00:11:14+00:00

Nat

Roar Guru


I think I understand your point but players, good, great and ok have traded around since money became involved. Everyone loathes Manly for their poaching efforts in the 70s/80s to buy a premiership. Same could be said for the Roosters today. As a result players swap clubs quite regularly and who can blame them to maximise their options. To use your example, Noddy, a novacastrian junior behind Joey, lost to Melbourne and onto Sharks. Sticky is synonymous with Canberra but finished at the Dogs. The fact we have over 350 players each season looking to make their mark, it more special that a player remains with only one club and that's why we remember them. Nothing has changed for 30 years and not likely too.

2018-11-28T22:36:12+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


What a strange article. Just a question; what are the nicknames of Cooper Cronk and Cameron Smith? Just to clarify as well, Whiddop isn't going to leave the Dragons in 2019. H simply told the Club that when the time comes, he wants to finish out his career in UK Super League.

2018-11-28T21:44:15+00:00

Ants Pants

Guest


I don’t really think the two are connected. A lot a nicknames in the past were associated with some kind of rebellious behaviour , some kind of unique trait or a humorous word association. Imagine the meltdown now if Brad Fittler was called Adolf, the do gooders ( whingers ) would be “ triggered” into a frenzy. Humour is frowned upon , especially if some pathetic weak person considers it to be “ offensive “ , and then howls loud enough. Society is being dumbed down and silenced , so as to be more easily controlled. Imagination is almost a thing of the past , that’s why the best being offered up these days is something outrageous like , Teddy or Klem.

Read more at The Roar