While confusion reigns, Sri Lanka could knock off Australia at home

By Geoff Lemon / Expert

Chew on this: Kusal Mendis has made three Test centuries in the past year. Australia’s entire cricket team has made one.

If you’ve never heard of him, the batsman is 23 years old and floats around the order for a Sri Lankan team that’s a genuine chance of winning a Test series in Australia.

Those aren’t words I anticipated typing in my lifetime, but with India having just become the first Asian team to win on these shores, what’s to say another can’t follow while Australian men’s cricket is a shambles across all formats?

Throw in some near-misses for Mendis and his last year produced five Test scores above 85. Australia managed two.

Mendis rattled up 1023 runs in twelve months, while the specialist batsmen in Australia’s current squad collectively made 1387.

All of Mendis’ hundreds were made away from home, the pick of them in New Zealand in December to turn a hopeless situation into a draw.

The thing is, it’s not like Mendis is a prodigy. He’s just a good Test player doing his job in a way that Australia’s counterparts have not.

In Australia, Travis Head is treated as a teen sensation at the age of 25, having been nursed to six career Tests. In Sri Lanka, Mendis at two years younger is treated as an old hand, having played 37 Tests and debuted in 2015.

Head, with his inexperience and his string of dicey dismissals and not a Test hundred to his name, is now the vice-captain of this Australian side. So is Patrick Cummins, sharing the role in awkward footy-club style.

Travis Head of Australia (Photo by Ryan Pierse/Getty Images)

It’s only a few months since CA’s hierarchy picked Mitchell Marsh as vice-captain even though he hadn’t nailed down a place in the side. He made it through two more Tests before they had to drop him.

Despite that backfire, now another player one or two games away from the axe is in a formal leadership role. Captain Tim Paine said that the decision was about sharing opportunities to develop younger players. But if Paine rolls his ankle before day one, Head could be Australia’s 47th Test captain.

In the meantime, the most experienced players in Nathan Lyon, Usman Khawaja and Mitchell Starc would watch on bemused.

There’s little in the way of clarity in Australian cricket at the moment, whether in communication or intent. Like selectors picking a Test squad before the warm-up match against Sri Lanka, then having the best performance in that match come from a player who wasn’t in the squad.

After his twin hundreds in the warm-up, suddenly Kurtis Patterson was added to the squad. Which makes one wonder why it was picked before the match at all.

That created a squeeze in the middle order. Young gun Will Pucovksi had been all but locked in for number six, with selectors wanting to see whether his impressive first-class returns could be replicated.

Will Pucovski. (Photo: Paul Kane/Getty Images)

He would have been brimming with excitement as Paine wrote a promotional column in a major newspaper the day before the game on how Pucovski was ready for Test cricket, then doubled down on that in his press conference. A few hours later, however, Pucovski was punted with Patterson taking number six.

Logic would suggest that Patterson should bat at four, given his work for New South Wales, but that place has been reserved for Marnus Labuschagne, the player with the least compelling case for inclusion but who is a favourite of the coach and selectors for vibe-based reasons that defy the ability of human language to convey.

A similar game of leapfrog has been played in the bowling ranks. Peter Siddle was the spare bowler throughout four Tests against India, meaning he was the immediate inclusion should an injury befall one of the incumbents.

Chris Tremain was next in line, having excelled in the Sheffield Shield for several seasons on the trot. But after a couple of impressive one-day games, Jhye Richardson has suddenly jumped them both to land in the starting XI.

Richardson looks a great prospect, but his selection raises the same kind of questions. If Siddle and Tremain were the fourth and fifth best bowlers in the country when the India squad was named, how has that changed without a game of first-class cricket played in the interim?

It’s no wonder players like Matthew Wade are venting frustration publicly. Never mind that Wade leads the Shield runs list at the halfway point of the season and can’t get a sniff at Test cricket. He’s also second on the Big Bash list and can’t get a sniff at Australia’s other teams.

Wade could have had a century for Hobart a few nights ago if his partner D’Arcy Short hadn’t lacked awareness and gobbled a few late boundaries. In the meantime, Alex Carey as Australia’s wicketkeeper in the white-ball formats is yet to make a half-century in his 22 innings, and for a notionally attacking player his ODI strike rate is in a slump at 76.

Matthew Wade has made his frustrations clear. (Photo by Paul Kane/Getty Images)

Every decision about selection or captaincy has its merits and demerit points, and this isn’t to say that every call is wrong. The issue is more the confusion and inconsistency permeating the national setup.

Times of confusion mean vulnerability. Of course any Australian side should have too much firepower for Sri Lanka, especially starting on the Gabba where bounce should be a factor. But it’s a day-night Test in a frazzled era.

Don’t forget Mendis was the player who turned the ignition on the wrecking ball when Australia toured Sri Lanka in 2016. His 176 at Pallekele flipped a match that looked gone, and a much more settled Australian team was demolished 3-0.

The magnitude of that defeat was never digested at home. Australia lost the second Test in Galle by lunch on the third day. Then got trounced in the third despite a huge partnership between Steve Smith and Shaun Marsh.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

A series can hinge on one standout performance. Kusal Mendis got that hundred, his first, in his seventh Test match. Travis Head will play his seventh Test in Brisbane, and would do his team a great service if he could do the same.

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2019-01-25T16:22:40+00:00

Geoff Lemon

Expert


G'day Bushy. I meant Liebke, not me.

2019-01-25T05:21:59+00:00

Simoc

Guest


Well maybe you should check out Langers cynical knocking the bail off cheating against Pakistan, and Langer failed to come clean until sprung by the match referee. And now this little grub is talking elite honesty. He is out of the gutter. And just check out WAs Shield wins under Langers decade in charge (0). He was put as coach by the previous pathetic administration of Sutherland who only knew more dollars in his pocket was progress. Sutherland also appointed the selectors, Chappell most internationally known for ordering an underarm ball be bowled to win a game, but also a great classical test batsman and hopeless at everything since, Hohns an average Shield leggie plus Sutherland put in Howard who gave us the high performance we see now from our Australian team. We need a fresh start from a new CA administration.

2019-01-24T22:01:20+00:00

The Bush

Roar Guru


I like your stuff Geoff, but I must admit, I didn't realise this was satire... My bad obviously.

2019-01-24T10:35:13+00:00

Leebola

Roar Rookie


Yep, Billy as full-time coach and DK to add the polish a la Mitch Johnson.

2019-01-24T10:07:10+00:00

Spanner

Roar Rookie


Agree, Sarge and Matt - no coincidence, our bowlers were penetrating while he was the guru !

2019-01-24T10:02:44+00:00

Spanner

Roar Rookie


Bingo, Baz ! I can vouch for that, I can't believe how sharp I am these days - and my cricket fundamentals are the same as they were in 1974 - pick your best 3 quicks, best spinner, best wicky and make one captain ! As long as the Sheffield Shield comp. is strong, this system shall prove to be foolproof !

2019-01-24T08:56:20+00:00

Virgil Starkwell

Guest


“It’s ludicrous, completely lacking in logic!”

2019-01-24T05:38:01+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


If it's satire it's sometimes fun. When it is tall poppy put downs, it is never successful as satire and only funny to bullies.

2019-01-24T05:34:49+00:00

Gurlivleen Grewal

Roar Pro


Yes, Selection, the roadmap hasn't been great. Yes, the young players haven't set the stage on fire. But the thesis Srl could beat Aus here is outlandish. It shouldn't even be close no matter the flat pitches, on swing under lights, and if you are so inclined to think otherwise, then surely you should take a bet on Srl - the punters are giving very healthy odds - even if they turn out to be competitive you could make a lot by cashing out early. Yes, Srl have a couple of young players who have played tough inn - Mendis, DSilva, might as well add Karunratne but talented batsman tend to that. Marsh has done that many a time, so have many subcontinent teams but it doesn't translate into results unless the whole batting unit is solid and the bowling is better than good. Exhibit Ind during 2003-15. Lumping the result of India to predict future is like saying Oh, SA beat us at home, we are the worst team, any team can beat us at home. Ind are a pretty good team, don't have the pace attack of SA but not that behind either. Srl, on the other hand, were thrashed at home by Ind and beaten soundly by Eng, so not really a team which is batting pretty well even with Mathews. Consistent fast bowling, once the sheen is off the ball, has never been the forte of sub-continent teams lately (barring India ofc).

2019-01-24T05:20:18+00:00

bigbaz

Roar Guru


Go easy on the advanced years bit mate , the sixties are the new 30s.

2019-01-24T04:14:54+00:00

Rob

Guest


I find it really interesting how batsmen are always considered to have a more intelligent cricket brain than bowlers and to a lesser extent wicket keepers when choosing the Captain. I don’t think VC holds any significants but surely Lyon would fill the position until Cummins , Head or Maxwell locked a spot down. Maybe Maxwell not being selected was to avoid him succeeding and becoming a leader in Smith and Warner’s absence?

2019-01-24T04:06:31+00:00

zatoo77

Guest


My point was on the process that should be adopted not on Wade not selection. I am unsure if he is a long term option. He played most of his career being a keeper who only had to contribute with the bat. As a batsman he will have to score centuries and far more runs, however we could do worse than someone who gets out before he gets a hundred to often.

2019-01-24T04:04:51+00:00

Matt H

Roar Guru


It's a situation isn't it. My take is that Labuschagne should never have been selected in the first place. However, once he was the selectors are obliged to give him a decent run. In fact he has improved each test so far, which is another reason he should be retained for now. We criticise the selectors when they don;t give players a decent run (Ferguson, Burns, Maxwell), so we can;t have it both ways.

2019-01-24T04:02:04+00:00

Matt H

Roar Guru


He is elitely honest.

2019-01-24T03:57:43+00:00

Matt H

Roar Guru


McDermott has had two stints as bowling coach and we have looked the goods each time.

2019-01-24T03:56:06+00:00

Matt H

Roar Guru


So only all rounders can coach? And only champion all rounders, given you've dismissed Langer's test record. I've had my fair share of fun criticising the man, but that's just silly.

AUTHOR

2019-01-24T03:52:08+00:00

Geoff Lemon

Expert


My only takeaway from this is that you're annoyed at a satirist for making fun of things.

AUTHOR

2019-01-24T03:48:53+00:00

Geoff Lemon

Expert


The schedule wasn't to do with India not wanting to play at the Gabba, it was to do with India not wanting to play a day-nighter, and CA wanting to schedule India at Adelaide regardless as a marquee game. Brisbane was the only day-night option so had to be reserved for Sri Lanka, and Brisbane draws poor crowds whatever the schedule.

AUTHOR

2019-01-24T03:46:19+00:00

Geoff Lemon

Expert


G'day Troy. My take: Head was second-highest scorer in a very low-scoring series. It flattered him. And at least half his dismissals were to horrible loose shots - caught twice in a Test at third man? That sort of approach won't fly in England, and he can't be retained if he doesn't show he's learned from it. I like him as a player, but he's a long long way from having nailed down a spot.

2019-01-24T03:33:48+00:00

JamesH

Roar Guru


Agreed on the plans. They clearly didn't work.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar