Western United take first steps towards becoming a real club, but questions remain

By Matthew Galea / Expert

The A-League’s newest franchise made the slow start to become the competition’s newest club this week and made quite a statement in doing so.

The franchise formerly known as Western Melbourne Group officially unveiled their new name, new colours and first Socceroo.

Western United, which will wear green and black, announced the signing of right-back Josh Risdon – surely one of the hottest properties on the A-League free agency market.

Risdon joins former Greece international Panagiotis Kone as the club’s second player.

Yet, while the introduction of a new club will always spark intrigue, many questions remain over the ownership, financial backing, direction and future of the Wyndham outfit.

For starters, how much did the group pay for their license? Was the price they were willing to pay the ultimate factor in the decision to give them the nod? How firm was the commitment to a brand new stadium and how reliant are those plans on the investment of supporting infrastructure from the Victorian government?

There remains no announcement on where the club will play games in their debut season, and doubts over whether or not the club is in fact part-owned by the owners of English Championship outfit Birmingham City, BSH.

An online report from Almajir.net linked BSH with the club, despite the group repeatedly asserting the investment is Australian-based.

Almajir’s report does suggest that BSH is no longer funding the project, which may mean the claims of the club’s ownership being Australian may be true, but if such significant funding has indeed been removed from the bid, will the club will be able to deliver on some of its biggest promises – especially a new stadium?

Of course, how much clarity the public can expect to get around these questions is another matter altogether.

It’s clear the club is unwilling to disclose a lot of detail about their ownership structures and financial capacity, so perhaps, in these early stages, Western United’s player recruitment will provide the clearest indication of how serious the new boys are.

In that respect, the club – fronted by super agent Lou Sticca and former Socceroo Steve Horvat – is off to a fantastic start.

Kone brings real international flair, while Risdon is the best Australian right-back going around, and one would expect any offer to keep him in Australia must have been a pretty good, given overseas interest.

Sticca pulled no punches on what to expect from the next few weeks, either.

“People might not like it, but we’ll be very aggressive in the marketplace both locally and overseas. We’ll abide by A-League protocols but we won’t be timid, we need to have a competitive team,” he told the Herald Sun.

Any new team involving Sticca is always going to be linked with plenty of players, but it will be interesting to see how the Western United squad forms.

Should the new outfit genuinely add to the league’s ability to draw genuine marquee talent, like cross-town rivals Melbourne Victory and Sydney FC regularly do, they will certainly be a welcome addition.

Of course, to deliver on that promise they will need to build on their first foray into the marquee market. Kone is a great start for a brand new club, but it’s not the heights some might expect from Sticca and Co.

Regardless, their real benefit could be in the greater opportunities they potentially give to up-and-coming talent from the National Premier Leagues and the National Youth League.

Signing up assistant coaches John Anastasiadis and John Hutchison will potentially go a long way to doing that.

Anastasiadis has enjoyed immense success in Victoria with the Bentleigh Greens in recent seasons and his near unrivalled knowledge of the NPL Victoria competition will give Western United a real edge when it comes to recruiting fresh talent from that particular competition.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Victory’s recent forays into that market, with the signings of Kenny Athiu and Elvis Kamsoba, prove there is exciting potential to be unearthed in the nation’s semi-professional second tier.

If Western United can get the mix right between a compelling combination of visa players, established local quality (I’m thinking more along the lines of Luke Brattan rather than Jacob Pepper) and the best the NPL and NYL have to offer, they will promise an exciting debut season.

Football Federation Australia for one will hope Western United can deliver on the great promise they offer the competition and that public uncertainty about how well the wheels are turning behind the scenes are no more than rumours.

The Crowd Says:

2019-02-17T01:40:07+00:00

Football is Life

Roar Rookie


Actually AU are owned by a dutch consortium

2019-02-16T13:07:16+00:00

Glorious

Roar Rookie


Correct … Nemesis and Fuss are the same person … an MV supporter. It’s a pity he has left. MF won’t be missed.

2019-02-14T08:51:23+00:00

callumgasowski

Roar Rookie


Great Article :)

2019-02-14T07:02:57+00:00

Jordan Klingsporn

Roar Guru


I'm pretty sure Nemesis is Fuss. Or have I mucked it up? And what does me being 14 have to do with anything?

2019-02-14T03:02:07+00:00

Fadida

Roar Rookie


Choosing 1 round to analyse LH? Sydney and WSW haven't even got a home ground. No fans are quicker to jump on/off than those in Brisbane

2019-02-14T01:28:08+00:00

chris

Guest


JK who's fuss? Arent you only 14? lol

2019-02-14T01:27:38+00:00

rolly

Guest


the newest club the dumbest name it means nothing identifies nothing no area it purports to represent and wow 19 million they paid for their license .how corrupt is the FFA to base the winning bid on who can pay the most that's why the fact they have no home ground and they got away with it when it was a clear criteria.

2019-02-14T00:22:08+00:00

Ben of Phnom Penh

Roar Guru


Who did Newton Heath merge with in 1902? Asking for a friend.

2019-02-14T00:11:36+00:00

Ben of Phnom Penh

Roar Guru


Nice try, but Adelaide United adopted the name at the end of the NSL as they pulled together the different communities that used to support Adelaide City & West Adelaide (and those who didn't like either of the older NSL clubs) before they both withdrew from the national comp.

2019-02-13T23:17:31+00:00

Franko

Guest


I've still no idea who own Adelaide United. One thing with both WU and AU is that I'm sure if you chase the money back far enough it ends up in China.

2019-02-13T22:45:23+00:00

Yobbo

Guest


What a dumb name for a club.

2019-02-13T21:46:42+00:00

Waz

Roar Rookie


Panic over, ownership details removed: https://amp.smh.com.au/sport/soccer/melbourne-cup-winning-owner-backs-new-a-league-club-western-united-20190213-p50xgc.html?__twitter_impression=true

2019-02-13T18:45:34+00:00

NUFCMVFC

Guest


My guess is that it is something of a Geelong team, but doing a Wollongong into southern Sydney or CCM into northern Sydney and attempting to lean into western Melbourne At least I hope that's it because it's the only way this bid makes sense If they split their games out of Kardinia Park and some West Melbourne based Stadium or even AAMI Park maybe it will work, but I'm generally sceptical and reckon there was other bids that should have gotten up

2019-02-13T14:08:05+00:00

Blue

Guest


What Athletic competitions will they be joining? Aping foreign teams is what brought us to Adelaide United, who are not the product of a merger, and Sydney FC Football Club. It would have been nearly as comical as Sporting Western Melbourne, as was also foolishly mooted.

2019-02-13T11:47:56+00:00

EJ

Roar Pro


I think the reason why warriors didn't get picked is that I heard that North Geelong Warriors which I believe is an State League 2 side (please correct me if Im wrong) had a problem with it and the fact that the West Melbourne team will play their first seasons in geelong. Not 100% sure but I read that somewhere on the internet. Geelong Advertiser had this stated (I can't access full article due to needing to pay a subscription to access it) "NORTH Geelong Warriors legend Josip Skoko has defended his club’s decision to protect its nickname from incoming A-League franchise Western Melbourne.The NPL2 club filed a trademark application with IP Australia on Monday, four days after Western Melbourne..."

2019-02-13T10:10:10+00:00

Waz

Roar Rookie


Good on ya. I’d support this mob over Vuck and Kindergarten FC

2019-02-13T10:09:20+00:00

Waz

Roar Rookie


Bahahahahahahaha ...

2019-02-13T09:36:03+00:00

Luke Karapetsas

Roar Pro


I am considering supporting WU, mostly because I moved to melbourne a few years ago, and I’m biased against City and Victory. But that name is just plain awful. Maybe it’ll grow on me, hopefully they’ll change it. The colours could be nice though, especially if it’s something like Celtic’s away kit from 2006 or Shalke’s away kit from 2015/16

2019-02-13T08:48:50+00:00

R2k

Guest


What are the odds they've reached out to Western Union for a sponsorship deal?

2019-02-13T08:47:42+00:00

Football is Life

Roar Rookie


Personally I think that Western Athletic, which was what was communicated recently as the result of the polling orocess, shoukd learn from Dave Gallop's ineptitude and communicate to their region, to the wider football community If they did that they are showing respect to their region, creating an inclusive football community and culture and doing what everyone is begging for. Making football belong to tbe people.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar