English Ashes bolters: The batsmen

By Cheers / Roar Rookie

The English batting line-up is in a state of flux. For some time a deep lower-middle order has papered over the cracks of a frail top three, and most of the obvious candidates have been tried and discarded.

The early start to the County Championship season often leads to low scores and impacts overall averages in addition to creating a culture where the best top-order players have half an eye on securing a more comfortable middle-order berth. That said, with crisis comes opportunity, and there is no doubt that consistent scoring throughout the English summer will be rewarded with serious Ashes consideration.

In a similar vein to the last article, let’s take a look at some of the names that are looking to force their way into the side.

Jason Roy (Surrey)

Age: 28
Style: Right-hand bat
First-class record: 81 matches, 4645 runs at 38.38, 9 hundreds, 22 fifties, a highest score of 143

What does he do?
A bludgeoning opening batsman in one-day cricket, Roy has found some success in the longer form of the game, where he has predominantly operated in the middle order. His first-class strike rate of 82 is near unprecedented and is indicative of his swashbuckling approach, which is based on strong driving down the ground and scything front foot pull shots.

Due to a packed middle order calls for Roy’s selection have centred around a berth at the top of the order, which would surely test the technique of such a free-flowing player.

Who is he like?
While the obvious suggestion may be David Warner, Roy currently lacks Australian’s compact technique and temperament. He can, however, be compared to another big-hitting Australian opener in Aaron Finch.

Will he get a game?
Roy barely played a county match last season, but this has not quelled calls for his addition, and with the inclusion of Jos Buttler the selectors have shown that county appearances are not necessarily a prerequisite for Test selection. A productive World Cup will certainly keep his name front and centre come The Ashes.

Jason Roy in his Sydney Sixers kit (AAP Image/Paul Miller)

Ollie Pope (Surrey)

Age: 21
Style: Right-hand bat
First-class record: 26 matches, 1732 runs at 54.12, 6 hundredss, 4 fifties, a highest score of 251

What does he do?
An attractive, free-flowing player, Pope appears a sparkling prospect. He cuts ferociously and, like many modern players, scores quickly all around the ground.

Thrown in at No. 4 against India in 2018, his lack of experience was evident and resulted in some soft dismissals. This led to a swift removal from the Test side but did not appear to impact his confidence too much, as he finished the county season with 986 runs at 70.42.

Who is he like?
The game is filled with players who have briefly shone before being hit by injury or a loss of form, but at this point Pope is riding high. His slashing cut shot is reminiscent of Brendon McCullum and his offside driving has echoes of Ian Bell.

Will he get a game?
This is potentially a series too early for Pope, who should really be given more time to mature and refine his game. That said, if he scores heavily and others fail, he is the player with the recent record most deserving of selection.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

James Hildreth (Somerset)

Age: 34
Style: Right-hand bat
First-class record: 249 matches, 16605 runs at 43.81, 45 hundreds, 74 fifties, a highest score of 303*

What does he do?
Calm and uncomplicated at the crease, Hildreth has become one of English crickets nearly men. When in full flight it is difficult to understand why he hasn’t played a significant amount of Test cricket, but fierce top-five competition during the first decade of his career has led to him only truly being considered for Test selection in recent years.

Hildreth can be punishing against spin. In addition to driving well on both sides of the wicket, he is an intelligent runner and has an elegance at the crease which can make batting look easy. He had another productive season in 2018 and would bring some much-needed stability to a flaky English top order.

Who is he like?
He’s an attractive player without excessive flourish or foot movement. There are elements of fellow first-class stalwarts Adam Voges’s onside play and Callum Ferguson’s offside driving within his game.

Will he get a game?
He probably should have but, as Australian fans well know, the allure of youth can cost these types of consistent, over-30 players. He has been a part of England Lions squads for years and would be deserving of a call up if it came.

Other names to look out for

Haseeb Hameed (Lancashire)
He looked every inch a Test cricketer throughout his appearances against India in 2016 but has struggled since. Hameed could as easily be in the second XI for Lancashire come the first Ashes test, as he could be walking out to face the Australians.

Will Rhodes (Warwickshire)
He had a terrific 2018 under the watchful eye of Jason Gillespie. Rhodes is a talented young player who will have to demonstrate that he can deliver on a consistent basis. He’s one for the future.

Ian Bell (Warwickshire)
It is hard to believe but Bell is still going strong on the domestic circuit, putting together a 2018 season which included five centuries and over 1000 runs. He is injured at the moment and this has surely put an end to any potential discussion of Ashes selection. County cricket fans are lucky to still be able to watch him play.

The Crowd Says:

2019-04-15T05:28:56+00:00

Josh H

Roar Rookie


Yeah definitely, there's been a constant revolving door for the 2nd English opening spot since Strauss retired, with Duckett, Hameed, Lyth and obviously Carberry and Stoneman being tried and failed, and that problem has doubled now with Cook retiring. I really like Keaton Jennings, he's a lot like our Kurtis Patterson, and his debut century really impressed me. Since then he's been a bit inconsistent, much like R Burns. Hameed's knocked on the door again just this week with another county century, so I can't help but think that uncertainty at the top of the order may continue...

AUTHOR

2019-04-14T05:29:44+00:00

Cheers

Roar Rookie


There's definitely a chance that he will be found out and as you mentioned he hasn't been convincing for England so far. Having watched him a bit at county level I don't think that his technique is quite as bad as it initially appears, it's mostly a trigger and he generally gets into a good position come impact. He really needs to convert his opportunities (which is a bit of a weakness for him), as there will likely only be a few chances for him to get in against the Australian attack, this is something that has hurt the likes of Carberry and Stoneman in the past.

2019-04-14T01:21:04+00:00

Josh H

Roar Rookie


Late response Daniel, but what do you think are the odds of R Burns being found out in the Ashes? You're right, he's got the figures from County to back up his selection but his technique looked extremely flawed against even mediocre attacks in Sri Lanka and West Indies. I can't help but think that quality bowlers like what Australia has will be able to counter that reasonably easily.

AUTHOR

2019-04-13T00:23:54+00:00

Cheers

Roar Rookie


Vince is always a great watch and who knows what might have happened if he hadn't run himself out for 80 odd in the first test. If he makes big runs then he obviously deserves his spot, I do have my doubts at the moment though. Looks like Hameed is finally finding some form, he might just be a guy who could carry the obdurate English opening batsman mantle at some point!

2019-04-12T23:22:41+00:00

James Butcher

Roar Rookie


Daniel, I wouldn’t discount James Vince from opening the batting for England come the first test of the Ashes. He has moved up to the top of the order for Hampshire in order to advance his England case. I haven’t seen any player in recent times look so much like they belong in Test cricket, only to have a glaring flaw in his temperament. He’s unquestionably got the skill and if he improves his concentration and tightens up outside off, he’s a good shout. Unfortunately for England, they have a plethora of dashers and not any obdurate over my dead body types and all of the potential England players are best suited to 4567 in the order. I’m backing Australia for the Ashes...especially if they play Cummins, Pattinson and Richardson as their fast bowling attack.

2019-04-12T00:39:07+00:00

Riccardo

Roar Rookie


Great read Daniel...

2019-04-11T01:24:56+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


I can see your point for sure Daniel, but I go back to that last Test series in England when they played India. Both sides were regularly 2 down for not many and behind a batting 8 ball. We'll obviously never know, but one down and Kohli or Root coming in, has to be a lot better than 2 down for under 20, bowlers REALLY got their tail up and the sides basically sacrificed a wicket.

2019-04-11T00:55:57+00:00

dungerBob

Roar Rookie


The one who used to annoy me the most was Shane Watson. He used to insist on opening the batting but more often than not that massive pad of his would get in between the ball and the stumps if there was any swing around. He was an obvious # 6 in both the longer formats but didn't play there nearly enough for my liking.

AUTHOR

2019-04-11T00:50:52+00:00

Cheers

Roar Rookie


Yeh, I think if you pick a young player and put them up the order then you really should be taking a long term view. Look at a guy like Kane Williamson, he was thrown in for New Zealand and initially struggled, but they stuck with him and now he is obviously a superstar; only averaged 36 after his first 30 test matches...

AUTHOR

2019-04-11T00:40:02+00:00

Cheers

Roar Rookie


Tell you what, if Bell hadn't picked up his injury and had piled on the runs again, he would have been half a chance, love it when older players go back into Domestic cricket after their international careers are over and show the youngsters how it's done.

AUTHOR

2019-04-11T00:38:29+00:00

Cheers

Roar Rookie


I have some sympathy for guys like Root, Kholi and even Clarke in the past as they deliver massive runs from their spot of choice. I have issues with the likes of Bairstow beginning to dictate where they bat as they do not have the runs behind them.

AUTHOR

2019-04-11T00:35:41+00:00

Cheers

Roar Rookie


The crazy thing is the side could end up with a situation where Foakes is batting in the top four without the gloves and Bairstow is down at seven! Not a bad squad, however I think that the bowling attack needs some pop with a Wood/Overton/Stone type.

2019-04-10T22:15:40+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


I don't get it these days. Blokes seem to think they can dig in their heels and tell selectors & Boards exactly where they're going to bat in the order - and these others roll over and let them get away with it. Root & Kohli are two who seem to have gotten away with this and I think it may have cost their teams dearly. I'd be thankful I was getting a game and offer to bat where ever I was put.

2019-04-10T22:10:13+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


would you have Stokes batting at 5, George? He averages only 34 with the bat? I was thinking maybe your two openers, Root, Pope, Bairstow, Butler/Foakes, Stokes and the 4 bowlers.

2019-04-10T22:06:33+00:00

George

Guest


Maybe. Should have been at #6 though. Older players should be stepping up at 4 and 5.

2019-04-10T22:03:31+00:00

George

Guest


Bairstow is a strong option. But Foakes easily has him covered. Jonny should bat in top six (with Burns, Root, Hildreth, Stokes, and Pope/Northeast/Clarke/Buttler). Ali, Woakes/Curran, Broad and Anderson to follow. Wood, Leach and Roland-Jones in reserve.

2019-04-10T13:12:26+00:00

Sgt Pepperoni

Roar Rookie


Great to hear that the sherminator is still going at 36 years young. Get the old boys back out there. Did someone say Cook?

2019-04-10T05:02:54+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


I got the impression Pope's inclusion was as much about the press demanding he be chosen as well as a lack of contestants for his batting spot. That said, I don't understand why they didn't persist with him? That was a low scoring series where he faced some high quality bowling. It would have done him the world of good to play all 5 games. Still that's a loss for England and good news for Australia, as he's a class act IMO.

AUTHOR

2019-04-10T03:10:29+00:00

Cheers

Roar Rookie


The Pope situation was a strange one, he was picked too early and thrown in against what we know is a quality Indian attack and then discarded almost immediately. Fortunately, it doesn't seem to have damaged his game, but if he was to be picked and dropped again during The Ashes then this would surely create some scarring. Hildreth is a guy who in hindsight should have played a few years ago, but a bit like when Khawaja and Hughes were picked in front of Rogers and Voges, picking the younger guys seemed a clear decision for the selectors at the time.

2019-04-09T22:32:44+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


Foakes for mine - sorry, couldn't help myself, Daniel!!

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar