No Ponga? No Klemmer? No problem for Newcastle

By Stuart Thomas / Expert

In a fiery encounter at ANZ Stadium, the Newcastle Knights have defeated the South Sydney Rabbitohs 20-12, in the opening game of Round 13.

Late changes to both sides made it difficult to get any sort of read on the potential winner, with the wet weather throwing a further spanner in the works.

It can’t be good to see matches robbed of its stars thanks to injury and fatigue off the back of representative fixtures, yet that is the reality of June in the NRL and the Bunnies took to the field without Cody Walker and Adam Reynolds.

Mercifully for fans of the cardinal and myrtle, Maroons hero Dane Gagai and Blues hooker Damien Cook did back up. The Knights copped a fair whack as well, with Kalyn Ponga rested and their forward power looking a little light on after David Klemmer’s late withdrawal with a wrist injury that will keep him sidelined for some time.

On a wet and slippery night after lingering showers had hosed Sydney throughout much of the day, the smart money was on a low scoring and dour affair between two sides desperate to maintain the momentum they had built early in the season.

However, it took just four minutes for the opening Knights try to Hymel Hunt. The Rabbitohs responded when new recruit James Roberts scored a lovely try from an Adam Doueihi kick just five minutes later.

Mason Lino then extended Newcastle’s lead with a penalty goal, before Mitchell Pearce laid on a deft pass for Mitchell Barnett to score after 26 minutes. As the arm wrestle began to develop late in the half and both sides looked to eliminate errors from their game, tensions grew.

On the stroke of half time, the match exploded. Tom Burgess blatantly head butted Daniel Saifiti in back play before the troops came from all quarters. Brother Sam wasn’t backward in coming forward and appeared to deliver his own Liverpool kiss on Lachlan Fitzgibbon, as the two became locked in a grapple among the throng.

Referee Grant Atkins dealt with the melee by sending both Burgess boys, as well as Fitzgibbon and Saifiti to the sin bin.

Frankly, Tom Burgess should have been marched for the remainder of the match and will undoubtedly serve weeks for the way in which he led with his head. Captain Pearce was infuriated, demanding Atkins award a penalty to the Knights, based on the fact that Burgess had indeed instigated the violence.

Sam Burgess had a shocker against the Knights. (Photo by Will Russell/Getty Images)

Atkins appeared to be in a world of his own and gave the Rabbitohs the penalty. Dane Gagai’s conversion saw the Knights take a slim 12-6 lead into the sheds at the break.

With just 11 on 11 to start the second half, there were paddocks of space available. It looked a little like a drop-off game of touch football as Connor Watson made life a misery for the Bunnies defenders.

He crossed in the 46th minute and the conversion sent the Knights well clear by 18-6. When the sin binned players returned, everyone held their breath. Round 2 looked likely.

It didn’t take long. When Tom Burgess erred in the play the ball after 53 minutes, he stood toe to toe with Saifiti once again; this time managing to resist the urge to snot the big man with a cheap head butt.

Despite Sam Burgess’ rather bizarre complaints of inequality in decision making to Atkins soon after, another penalty conversion to Lino and Sam’s arguably late hit on Mitchell Pearce, the Englishman kept trying until the end.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

He even managed a late try that was converted by Gagai in the 75th minute.

However, the contest was well and truly won. The Knights were better, faster and more intense than South Sydney and could potentially have won by a greater margin had the Bunnies been rightfully forced to play a man down for the final 30 minutes.

There was no Ponga nor Klemmer, yet the Knights showed tonight that they are the sum of a broad array of parts and now look likely to play finals’ football in 2019.
Won’t the Knights’ fans be cock-a-hoop at the thought of that?

I repeat what I said a few weeks back. Nathan Brown can indeed coach.

The Crowd Says:

2019-06-09T11:01:26+00:00

Morshead

Roar Rookie


Steve who are your nine, count em, nine players that would have made that Souths top 17 on Friday that weren't there? After you've listed em, take a looks at the Knights roster. Who are your two players, Klemmer and Ponga. Now add Slade Griffin, who was incumbent NZ hooker when he did his knee last year. Add Danny Levi who has been there hooker all year. Add Aidan Guerra who would have been on the bench. It's more than two. Nobody, from Nathan Brown on down has claimed a great victory against a full-strength Souths team. But we'll take the two points either way. Thanks. See you in September.

2019-06-08T15:00:14+00:00

stevesyd

Roar Rookie


Yes, I can see what you mean. Hope you haven't shrunk too much.

2019-06-08T07:32:05+00:00

Insider

Roar Rookie


Captain hot head

2019-06-08T07:13:42+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


It’s pretty strange. Both Tom and Sam clearly head butted opponents and they’ll get one week between them. Waddell did the same thing last week and got two games.

2019-06-08T05:39:23+00:00

stevesyd

Roar Rookie


Most will tell you the best leadership comes from the effort shown. Sam gives 100% every time which is why he is captain.

2019-06-08T05:20:59+00:00

Forty Twenty

Roar Rookie


Plenty of twists and turns still to come this season. Plenty of teams could win it I reckon and if one of these teams has a stellar run with injuries then that could be the difference.

2019-06-08T05:15:20+00:00

Forty Twenty

Roar Rookie


As a Manly fan I know how great it is to watch a team emerge from some very dark days and win a couple of titles and it beats all the other titles hands down. I've always admired how well Brown carries himself under adversity and I'd be happy for him to land a title.

2019-06-08T04:50:48+00:00

DP Schaefer

Roar Rookie


He might be suggesting, but likely dreaming. Mitchell clearly has other things on his mind but I don't think leaving chooks is one of them. Could be wrong, but time for Steve to spill the beans....

2019-06-08T04:46:58+00:00

DP Schaefer

Roar Rookie


Con - add he gets a recall to SOO and leads a NSW resurgence to 2-1 victory. Double redemption...

2019-06-08T04:45:34+00:00

DP Schaefer

Roar Rookie


That would be a GF worth watching.

2019-06-08T04:38:48+00:00

Insider

Roar Rookie


Steve, it’s banter, if you let it get to you only one outcome You will shrink, turn blue and walk around saying “ Choo Choo outa my way I’m mad” Souths will play semis in 2019 but that’s about it Choo Choo outa my way

2019-06-08T04:35:07+00:00

stevesyd

Roar Rookie


It might but I respectfully prefer the club to disclose whoever or whatever the issue is.

2019-06-08T03:50:45+00:00

Ian_

Roar Rookie


Not much at all. Headbutts clearly are no big deal. Just what does someone have to do to get sent off now?

2019-06-08T03:44:09+00:00

Emcie

Roar Guru


Not many teams have

2019-06-08T02:36:01+00:00

db

Guest


Steve, are you suggesting the impending bad news involves Latrell Mitchell?

2019-06-08T02:34:34+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


Prior to the Knights winning run, they were on a losing run and Brown probably WAS facing the sack. Good on him and the Knights for turning it around

2019-06-08T02:29:00+00:00

Insider

Roar Rookie


He hasn’t achieved anything, his spoon tally and percentages suggest he’s not a very good coach

2019-06-08T02:08:35+00:00

stevesyd

Roar Rookie


Knights are absolutely no hope unless every team has 8-9 players out like last night. All teams near full strength will be a Souths v Raiders GF. Roosters are busted and more bad news coming from their camp very shortly.

2019-06-08T02:05:16+00:00

stevesyd

Roar Rookie


Love the payout at Souths, hilarious. Most Souths supporters also gave them little chance given 9 injuries and origin players backing up after 2 days, not to mention no bye before origin was a big ask and it showed. Knights 2 players out, fresh after a bye and win by 8 pts. Amazing. LOL. Let's see how you narrow minded knockers stack up when Souths have returning players and back to near full strength in the next 5-6 weeks. Presume you might hide for a while.

2019-06-08T01:58:19+00:00

Sideline Eye

Guest


Prior to the Knights winning run, "experts" said Brown couldn't coach & was probably facing the sack. Where are those "experts" now? Probably working at the Bureau of Meteorology.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar