Fittler doesn't need Latrell, but the Roosters sure do!

By Stuart Thomas / Expert

Call them what you will. The masters of salary cap management, sombrero wearers extraordinaire or the most professional and well run NRL club; the Roosters are the story on every other day of the week in Sydney.

Once again they will be the talk of the town, after a classy 24-16 comeback victory over the Tigers on Friday night.

2019 had been increasingly looking like something of a challenge for them. After a convincing start to the season, their State of Origin and injury-affected train had derailed, with four losses from five and an awkward clash looming against the Tigers at Bankwest Stadium.

Off the back of consecutive victories against the Rabbitohs and Cowboys, Wests had grafted their way to the fringes of the top eight and last night’s match provided the perfect opportunity for them to stamp their semi-final claims.

It loomed as a telling clash for both clubs, with another loss bringing the Roosters’ credentials into serious question and a win for the Tigers adding another layer of complexity to the composition of the top eight come season’s end.

In short, a Wests win would see more and more people believing they were the real deal in 2019 and the Roosters beginning to look increasingly fragile.

The match began in a flurry when Nat Butcher crashed over for the visitors in the fourth minute and the subsequent conversion from Latrell Mitchell built an early lead for the Tricolours.

Ryan Matterson answered almost immediately and, when Esan Marsters converted his bustling try in the tenth minute, the Tigers had made a stern statement to the Roosters that their night was not to be an easy one.

A 13th minute Marsters penalty goal gave Wests an 8-6 lead before an appalling decision impacted what was fast becoming a compelling contest. A Rooster clearly charged down a Tigers’ kick, yet the goofballs in green failed to restart the tackle count.

Moments later and, as if to script, Daniel Tupou scored after brilliant vision from Luke Keary saw him hurl the ball into open spaces for the winger to cross untouched.

It was as atrocious a decision as I have seen all season and Benji Marshall found it difficult to contain his anger when the try was eventually awarded. For how long the best rugby league competition in the world can put up with sheer refereeing incompetence is tough to measure, but the Tigers can take little solace from the officials’ lack of feel for the game.

Wests entered the sheds in deficit 8-12, when they potentially deserved a skinny lead.

Some sense of justice saw the Tigers score after just four minutes of the second half when a cracking Benji Marshall pass found Paul Momirovski on the left wing.

Just minutes later, Marsters’ outstretched right hand added another four pointer after a pin-point Benji Marshall kick into the Roosters in-goal area. The Tigers were rampant.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Unfortunately, both tries were unconverted and Marsters stood to rue the misses with the Tigers leading 16-12.

He did. The champs were back within minutes when Mitchell and Keary sent Victor Radley under the sticks for the Roosters’ third try in the 61st minute.

Then at 18-16, Mitchell did what Mitchell does so well. The Origin reject hopped, stepped and jumped his way through the Tigers’ defensive line in the 55th minute to score a brilliant try. His conversion sent the Roosters to a 24-16 lead and killed off any hope the black and gold had of securing the two points.

With 20 minutes remaining on the clock, things looked like getting ugly for the Tigers.

To their credit, Wests probably created the best of the late chances in the match, as the Roosters shut up shop and went into game management mode in the final minutes.

There was to be no addition to the score.

The Tigers will walk away knowing they threw all they had at the champions and were within a conversion or two of putting their foot on the Roosters’ throat. The Chooks will welcome back Boyd Cordner and James Tedesco next week, once their Origin commitments are done, and feel the ship has finally been righted.

With Mitchell and Keary striking some form, it all points to another tilt at the title for the Roosters and another Tigers season of what could have been.

The Crowd Says:

2019-07-06T23:25:44+00:00

Farkurnell

Guest


I sympathise with you .Those 2 decisions last night against NZ really got to me,as you'll see in my posts.

2019-07-06T22:46:03+00:00

Superspud

Roar Rookie


Yeah I get that we live in an age of extremes and we aren't happy unless we have something to be outraged about, but to isolate that particular decision and brush over other far more important ones was a bit strange. The Roar Jury seem to concur from I have read.

2019-07-06T22:21:04+00:00

farkurnell

Guest


Spud "the most appalling decision ever" is the standard jorno phase inserted while reviewing each game.It soon gets replaced with the next howler(s) after the next game.There are 2 basic standards in NRL - a team will win and a howler will be reported.On the bright side " I'm told standards are improving"

2019-07-06T09:45:37+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


Haha...you’re on

2019-07-06T06:42:33+00:00

Big Daddy

Guest


He needs an income while taking a well earned rest. To be fair it was probably filmed weeks ago. Hope the proceeds are going to Fred Hollows.

AUTHOR

2019-07-06T06:21:55+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


I challenge you to a duel with wet lettuce leaves at ten paces!

AUTHOR

2019-07-06T06:18:43+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Looks that way!

2019-07-06T05:44:30+00:00

Superspud

Roar Rookie


"as atrocious a decision as I have seen all season”. Shaun Johnson try last week. Fusitua try last week? No? It's not that on it's own it's the way you give that decision so much column space and importance yet brush over the dodgy try awarded to the Tigers. I think the doubt on the Tigers try deserves a mention doesn't it? If Thompson caught the bomb the charge down is a non factor.

2019-07-06T05:42:10+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


You can pressure a kicker without playing at the ball. Have another look at it. Radley doesn’t play at the ball at all and actually turns away from the ball. It’s not a Rambo Ronnie Gibbs or Steve Price charge down at all. It certainly wasn’t atrocious. Definitely not a 100/0 call and wasn’t even the worst call of that game.

2019-07-06T05:38:45+00:00

Dutski

Roar Guru


Run at the kicker, realise you can’t get there, turn so you don’t get a ball in the face.

AUTHOR

2019-07-06T05:20:13+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Run at the ball and then attempt to avoid it?

AUTHOR

2019-07-06T05:19:36+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Charge 100% for me but happy to disagree on this one.

AUTHOR

2019-07-06T05:18:29+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


I did not say there was anything wrong with the scoring of the try, in fact, I alluded to the brilliant work to get the ball to him.

AUTHOR

2019-07-06T05:17:09+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


I DID NOT ask whether the Roosters were a well run club or taking advantage of the 'salary sombrero. I was alluding to many of the labels people give to them and specifically said, "call them what you will".

AUTHOR

2019-07-06T05:14:01+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Let me explain to you the way quotation marks are used. What is usually included between them are the actual words you are referencing, not what you thought you read. I wrote "as atrocious a decision as I have seen all season". In my view it was a 100/0 call. I support neither side as well and therefore just as balanced as you.

2019-07-06T04:55:12+00:00

Papi Smurf

Roar Rookie


Hardly imaginative "Big D". You need to raise the bar a little. How about this? Little George Burgess Tried to play surgeon, And tickle poor Robbie's eye; He stuck in his thumb, And pulled out an eyeball, And said, "I swear on my kid's lives!" No, that doesn't rhyme at all. But you get the idea. ;-)

2019-07-06T04:25:45+00:00

Big Daddy

Guest


Don't worry about Gorgeous George. Got a gig on Ch9 doing the Full Monty.

2019-07-06T04:13:51+00:00

Papi Smurf

Roar Rookie


Pickett fence are you still trying to run circles around me with your sledgehammer wit trying to invent a new variation of my handle that won't get your post removed? Knock yourself out sunshine. "BTW, thanks for Nat Butcher" Yeah, but like Angus Crichton and Luke Keary he would have developed MUCH, MUCH faster at the Rabbitohs. Speaking of the grand "Roosters development program", what have you done to poor Angus's career? Souths developed him from an NRL rookie into a NSW Origin rep player in just 1 year! Now they won't even pick him in the squad anymore along with Latrell Mitchell. And they arw BOTH Roosters! Roosters development plan? What an oxymoron! Bahahahahahaha

2019-07-06T04:11:07+00:00

Superspud

Roar Rookie


Sorry John i should have read your comments before posting mine. You are 100% correct. Also re the salary cap thing. I’m not a Roosters supporter but I do get amused at the coverage the Roosters get. The other 15 clubs sign a player and it’s recruitment but the Roosters sign a player and it’s poaching.

2019-07-06T04:07:59+00:00

Superspud

Roar Rookie


What a biased account. "The most appalling decision ever" really!!? It was a 50 50 call that I've seen go both ways. That decision gets plenty of coverage as if the entire game swung on it. However the Marsters try decision doesn't rate a mention!! That was 50 50 at best AT BEST! and had a much more definitive impact. I don't support either side but but I do like a bit of balance.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar