With the Rugby Championship about to start, here's what Michael Cheika can learn from the Junior Wallabies

By Nicholas Bishop / Expert

They say that it is the young who should sit at the foot of the elderly, and learn from the wisdom accumulated over the span of a lifetime. In Australian rugby right now, it may just be the other way around.

It is time for Michael Cheika and his coaches to look at the recent success of the under 20ss at the World Junior Championship, and take on board some of the reasons why they reached the final of the tournament. There is no question that they were good enough to have taken the biggest prize back home with them to Australia.

Under the stewardship of ex-Queensland Reds’ assistant coach Jason Gilmore, the Wallaby under 20s showed immediate signs of a revival in 2019. Firstly, they won the Oceania Championship, conceding only 14 points in three games and finishing the tournament on a high, with a resounding 24-0 rout of New Zealand.

At the World Championship itself, the Junior Wallabies achieved their best result since finishing third in the 2011 event behind England and New Zealand. They beat Ireland and Italy decisively in the pool stages, Argentina in the semi-final, and were edged out by a single point, 23 points to 24, in the final game against reigning champions France.

(Photo by Amilcar Orfali/Getty Images)

There were unmistakeable signs of a new seriousness applied to the development of the age group game. Gilmore attempted to recruit established Super Rugby players like the Reds’ Harry Hockings, Hamish Stewart, Tate McDermott and Isaac Lucas to the under 20s.

Although none of the first three was made available, Lucas was released for age group duty along with Nick Frost, a recent transfer from the Crusaders academy to the Brumbies.

Frost provides an instructive example of how Australia can embrace multiple paths of player development, including spells in cutting-edge environments in New Zealand. He cut short his three years in the Crusaders’ outstanding youth academy to return to Canberra, but was in no doubt of the value of his experience across the Tasman:

“I learned a lot about structure and about how New Zealanders play rugby. It took me a while to learn, but once I got it, it came easily. It was a very enjoyable time. It certainly suited my style as a player but now I’m excited by the prospects on offer here.”

Take a look at his spectacular individual try against Ireland – the indelible stamp of a mobile second rower in the finest Kiwi transition is staring you in the face:

In the course of his run, Frost even remembers to transfer the ball twice to the opposite arm to keep it away from potential tacklers and engage them with the fend!

Above all, Jason Gilmore understood that the aim of age-group football is to develop the most important skill of all – a mentality which expects to win and knows how to achieve it:

“We definitely want to develop the guys as young men and footy players, but we want to develop them to be successful. There’s no point coming into the program and just being happy with being in it.

“The boys will pick their kit up and that’s something to celebrate, but you’ve actually got to do something at this level as well.”

Developing the winning habit at a young age, and knowing which core skills are most relevant to that habit, is everything. This is especially important in the context of Australian Super Rugby franchises which have been struggling to succeed in recent years.

Gilmore’s charges showed a level of cohesion unusual in teams at this stage of their development. A few weeks ago, I wrote an article on The Rugby Site illustrating the ‘joined-up’ thinking behind the Junior Wallabies’ play in various parts of the field.

Right from the very beginning of the final against the French, Australia showed an excellent understanding of just how to use the twin play-maker system (Will Harrison at 10 and Lucas at 15) and manipulate the defence to advantage. That in itself should be enough to interest Michael Cheika.

At the first ruck, France already have three backs on their left (numbers 12, 13 and 11) and are trying to balance their defensive line by shifting their 10 (in the red box) over to the far side to join the right winger (in the white hat). This is the same area that Lucas (circled) will be looking to probe later in the sequence:

The ball duly travels over to the Australian left, where the France outside-half Louis Carbonel makes a tackle on Wallaby second rower Michael Wood. What happens next becomes an urgent topic of interest for Lucas, because Carbonel starts running all the way back to the openside:

As the screenshot illustrates, it does not escape Lucas’s notice that he is now opposed by forwards rather than a back. The twin playmaker system has created a mismatch on one side of the field, one he exploits on the very next phase:

Lucas runs straight into the hole between two French forwards opposite to set up a superb try for left winger Mark Nawaqanitawase in the corner.

The Junior Wallabies’ attitude to defence at the breakdown was even more impressive than their attack. Unlike the seniors, who depend so heavily on David Pocock and Michael Hooper to win turnovers after the tackle has been made, for the juniors it was a team effort.

Despite the presence of an outstanding young number 7 in Reds’ Fraser McReight, no fewer than nine different players participated in the eight Wallaby turnovers at the breakdown, and four of them were backs.

So, although defence at the breakdown began (rightly) with McReight, it did not end with him. The Australian number 7 won two jackalling turnovers by himself, and shared a choke tackle turnover with number 5 Trevor Hosea:

McReight’s win on the ground is an excellent example of how defensive teams will strive, under the new rules, to keep their best jackals away from the tackle itself:

McReight is ‘refused’, positioned slightly behind the second and third defenders so that he can swoop in and pick over the bones after the tackle has been completed.

There is a hidden danger with on-ball flankers as good David Pocock, that teams become too dependent on their skills and neglect their development in other positions on the field.

This was emphatically not the case with Jason Gilmore’s side. The outside backs, with inside centre Noah Lolesio and right winger Triston Reilly to the fore, were more than capable of pulling their own weight in this area:

In the first example, Reilly and outside centre Semisi Tupou show the appetite for contact situations which has fast become an essential part of the outside back’s arsenal in the modern game. In the second instance, Reilly wins the battle at the post-tackle battle all by himself in a dangerous situation after a French line-break has been made near the Australian 22.

Reilly’s turnovers are a reminder of just how important the presence of a Waisake Naholo or a Henry Speight can be to a defensive team’s success in the wide zones. It makes the exclusion of Speight from an otherwise sensibly-selected Wallaby squad all the more difficult to understand.

At junior level, the Wallaby forwards and backs combined effortlessly to win turnover across the full width of the field:

This time it is number 12 Lolesio who drives huge French number 8 Jordan Joseph off his cleanout, enabling hooker Lachlan Lonergan to pick up the ball behind him and move it away on the counter.

Summary
The success of the Junior Wallabies at the recent 2019 World Championship is a tremendous filip to Australian rugby as a whole. The new seriousness with which Jason Gilmore approached the task of recruiting and coaching the group has helped re-establish age-group rugby as an essential stepping stone to success at senior level.

Of the French 2018 Under 20s World Championship-winning squad, the likes of Romain N’tamack, Lucas Tauzin and Guillaume Marchand have all achieved senior success at Stade Toulousain immediately, winning the Bouclier de Brennus with their club in the 2018-19 Top 14 season.

Demba Bamba has started for the full national side at tighthead prop at the tender age of 21, while outstanding number 8 Jordan Joseph is already being projected as a future captain of his country. Right there, you have the core group of France’s future as a Test nation.

Players like Nick Frost, Harry Wilson, Fraser McReight, Michael McDonald, Isaac Lucas and Lolesio and Tupou in the centres can do the same for Australia, because they are acquiring winning habits in their early stages of their development.

Frost trained in probably the finest youth development program in the world, and has given himself a chance to fulfil ex-Wallaby coach Matt Williams’ prophecy that he is “the most talented 20-year-old lock since John Eales”. Lucas has already cut his Super Rugby teeth with the Reds this season. That continuity between age group and senior rugby needs to not only continue, but amplify in future.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

The under 20s head coaching role also represents a terrific opportunity for young coaches to learn the ropes: to learn how to assemble and organise different departments of the team within a single vision, and achieve coherence across all areas of the field.

It is an opportunity Gilmore has taken with both hands, and in the process highlighted those areas where the senior team also needs to bring additional focus: the accurate use of the twin playmaker system, the consistency of game-planning up and down the field; a collective, rather than ‘personality’-oriented attitude towards defence at the breakdown.

If it is a stimulating time to be an Australian rugby fan, that is largely because those operating at junior, grassroots level have opened a window for supporters to breathe in some fresh air.

Now, it is up to Michael Cheika and his fellow coaches and selectors to push open the door.

The Crowd Says:

2019-07-23T09:11:54+00:00

Phil Peake

Guest


Hi Nick hope you can comment on the first try to the Springboks v Wallabies. Wingers not staying on their winger resulting in a try again!! Reece Hodge comes in to take the second last attacker leaving his wing wide open and with too much speed for the cover defence. Yet another example of this type of defence not working. If he stayed on his man the result of this play could have been different. Yet they persist with this. I would prefer to lose a bit of ground but stop the try any day.

2019-07-19T23:56:37+00:00

sheek

Roar Guru


Thanks Nick, I could be unkind & also suggest the reason why the current junior Wallabies are successful, & the senior Wallabies have been unsuccessful for so long now, is that they have talent, & the seniors, not so much. Talent can be described in terms more than just natural ability. It also requires sound application of basic skills & situational awareness of how rugby is played. Too many of the seniors lack these skills. Maybe they were let by the coaching system, throughout their progression. But whatever it is, they don't have what the junior Wallabies have. Eventually, you get exposed for what you are. You can dress a pig up in satin & lace, but it is still a pig.

AUTHOR

2019-07-19T06:09:02+00:00

Nicholas Bishop

Expert


Talent development is a passion of mine and we have discussed it here before. You even encouraged me to write an article before NB but I worry that it will not be any good. There is only one way to find out B - go ahead and take the plunge. I am sure you will enjoy the experience!

2019-07-18T16:18:54+00:00

Blessing

Roar Rookie


I agree with everything you have said in your response NB. Rieko Ioane never played for the u20's. He was brought through the 7s program. Niko Jones was the best schoolboy player in Auckland last year. He's the son of the great Michael Jones and is a talented number 8. He's also decided to go the 7s route. He might not play u20 rugby but I would wager that he will probably go on to play for the ABs. Australia do indeed need the U20 program to be successful. Talent development is a passion of mine and we have discussed it here before. You even encouraged me to write an article before NB but I worry that it will not be any good. The two groups I mentioned earlier (Wales 2008 and NZ 2011) were an anomaly. My research has mostly been on NZ u20 squads over the years and on average, about 4 to 5 go on to be ABs. The Wales team that produced that clutch of seniors lost their semi to NZ and got slaughtered by SA in the third place play off. 10 Welsh players went on to be great full internationals, NZ had four, Crotty, Nuggy Smith, Zac Guildford and Sam Whitelock and SA had one, Francois Hougaard. NZ and SA have got the luxury of having Mitre 10 and the Currie Cup, both are top class competitions.

2019-07-18T15:23:43+00:00

Conor Wilson

Roar Pro


I remember reading an article where Leinster played Clermont, and the Clermont players knew that Play was coming due to Joe’s previous job with them. But they still couldn’t stop it! Depends on a lot of “shepherding” as a lot of Joe Schmidt specials do. But i have to admit it looks a lovely move. I must also thank you for keeping us ahead of them those years Mr Bishop. You made many an England fan happy in those years! Particularly me. It is quite interesting actually. I’ve seen quite a few JS plays that were Identical to the Moves used by the Wallabies when you would’ve studied them in the MacQueen era for Wales and the Lions. Written an article about it for a little fine tuning, but X Runs to target dog legs, the Shielding of the ball behind the pass, the Dummy loop inside plays involving the back 3 and the Lineout variations for the inside pass from 9. I saw a lot of those things from the Wallabies against the Lions in 2001 and seen during the 2013-2017 years of Ireland in particular. Saw an Irish try against Scotland in 2018 come from a scissors move to an inside pass off set piece. It was identical to what the Wallabies ran in 1999 against the Boks in the WC QF’S. I could be wrong. But i was amazed when i saw the similarities in the moves used!

2019-07-18T13:30:34+00:00

Derek Murray

Roar Rookie


MC’s strength of will must be a huge plus. Made him a ruthless opponent for Randwick and made him a success at business. But in the current situation it’s perhaps his biggest weakness. Wish/hope he can see past himself (or Snoz and co can make him)

2019-07-18T12:49:10+00:00

Fin

Guest


Hi Nick, On the local coaching front or lack thereof David Campese made an interesting observation recently. He said that too much Australian rugby IQ is lost simply because its former players go on to have "real" jobs, in financial services, banking, the law and so forth. The reasons they end up in those well-paid, non-rugby professions are obvious but the outcome has been damaging to the game in Australia. David Giffin is a prime example of this.

AUTHOR

2019-07-18T12:36:00+00:00

Nicholas Bishop

Expert


Yes the u 20's are really there to generate clear and obvious talent for the full national team and the pro sides beneath it. If you can do it in other ways, you don't need to emphasize the age groups so much. But it's a very useful tool for Australia right now because they need to identify potential WB talent so urgently.

AUTHOR

2019-07-18T12:32:20+00:00

Nicholas Bishop

Expert


That's fair enough.

AUTHOR

2019-07-18T12:31:27+00:00

Nicholas Bishop

Expert


Australia were good with Jim McKay as their offence coach, we didn't have so many problems with Ireland (hence Stuart's 3-1 record against Joe Schmidt). The Rob Kearney try was galling, because we had all of their short-side variations off 9 worked out, so we were expecting that play! But we still won that game, so what the heck....

2019-07-18T11:37:47+00:00

Blessing

Roar Rookie


The whole declining thing is a bit of a myth really, isn't it? They won the competition as recently as 2 years ago and before that they won it 4 years ago. These things go around in cycles, England had a bit if a purple patch and seem to have tapered off. U20 success does not necessarily translate to success with the seniors. That's a very simplistic way to look at things. Once in a while there is a special group at U20 level that goes on to produce quality Test football cattle like the Wales team in 2008 and the NZ team in 2011. If anything, the NZ team from 2017 did look special and I believe they will go on to produce great ABs. Dalton Papali'i, Luke Jacobson and Aumua are ABs already. Ennor should be by the end of the week, Will Jordan should be an AB by next season. Josh McKay had a great season at the Landers. Marino Mikaele-Tuu really excites me as a number 8. Luke Whitelock's departure should give him a chance. Tana's nephews have also had great Super Rugby seasons despite dealing with injuries. Isaia Walker-Leawere is coming along nicely at the Canes and Maori ABs. Still believe Axe Fidow will go on to become a hell of a TH. Ere Enari had that gruesome injury but has just finished his first season under Razor at the Saders and started a couple of matches. Not forgetting Caleb Clarke, Perofeta and Tiaan Falcon. They've also been unlucky with injuries. It was a loaded group in terms of talent. The idea that NZ rugby is struggling for talent is a bit fanciful. They will be fine.

2019-07-18T11:04:37+00:00

Bentnuc

Roar Pro


Can't agree more with you Nick, another great article. The breakdown is the most important part of rugby so why doesn't Cheika even consider it? The starting lineup picked today is very very weak in the breakdown. Just a few additions of quality players could make all the difference. Speight as you said could do a similar job to Nadolo. Would love to see Meakes in place of Kurandrani. I know its out of position and Kurandrani is a solid player but with Meakes you get breakdown skills and a passing game. With a Kerevi/Kurandrani centre pairing you can forget about your wingers getting ball. McCafrey, Samu, Wright, Johnson-Holmes, Rangi; these are top quality players with skills comparable to their counterparts but with the added bonus of being real breakdown menaces! It's too late to coach anything into players for the RC or WC so we just have to be wise with selections and think outside the box and we can have a real crack at winning both.

2019-07-18T10:23:25+00:00

Oblonsky‘s Other Pun

Roar Guru


And yet Launchbury has sadly been, in my eyes, criminally undervalued by English and BI Lions coaches since.

2019-07-18T10:12:04+00:00

Fin

Guest


I think it was a case of Stiles always enjoying coaching as much as he did playing. Rugby was his life.

2019-07-18T09:52:36+00:00

Conor Wilson

Roar Pro


Agreed mate. The England D was pretty damn good as a whole. I just was curious as to how much work had to go into stopping teams like Oz under McKenzie (Who i really think could be the next England coach) and Ireland and the like. Especially Schmidt's Ireland. I still remember Kearney's try against us in 2014 via the inside pass from Heaslip and being absolutely livid that they hadn't caught O'Connell yanking on Launchbury to prevent him folding round. Can't be helped now, but the detail in moves like that was unbelievable. Hence being pretty curious.

AUTHOR

2019-07-18T09:44:33+00:00

Nicholas Bishop

Expert


If you look back at the stats for that period, you'll see that the ABs were the only team we struggled to contain defensively for the whole 80 minutes!

2019-07-18T09:41:37+00:00

Conor Wilson

Roar Pro


Appreciate if you can’t necessarily say mate, especially on here. But when you were with England, which team was the hardest to prepare for besides the All Blacks in terms of variety of attack?

AUTHOR

2019-07-18T09:29:15+00:00

Nicholas Bishop

Expert


Fascinating stuff - thanks Fin: "Nick Stiles: the reluctant Wallaby" :D

AUTHOR

2019-07-18T09:28:00+00:00

Nicholas Bishop

Expert


Yes I think that is the natural level for SJ, his vision is prob the strongest element - perhaps more so than the detail. We never found the Scotland sides prepared by he and Dean Ryan hard to prepare for back in the day - though that may be for the reasons you describe.

2019-07-18T09:22:33+00:00

Conor Wilson

Roar Pro


Agreed again. I think Johnson has found his natural home at Directorship level. I think in terms of putting the infrastructure and processes in, he's the go to guy. He even said that whilst he was coaching Scotland. His focus was on developing their development and support systems. If Gilmore is hired to work with U20's who are nearing senior honours, and starts sending them up when ready, hopefully the head coach who's picked for the Senior setup shares Gilmore's ethos and standards and culture of a team. That way all of the good things developed in the U20's system are nurtured and developed throughout the players senior career, rather then simply thrown aside. I feel Johnson would be very important in ensuring thats established between the two, as for the long term game that continuity is the way Oz gets competitive again. The u20's style could be the Australian way for the future in an area where the Wallabies are so clearly lacking clarity.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar