Southern dominance and other World Cup facts

By Istanbul Wingman / Roar Guru

One question that has certainly been settled in the World Cup era is that of hemispheric dominance.

Those of us of sufficient vintage will recall that this remained very much up for debate during the epoch prior to 1987, and that the accolades of the greatest teams and players were attributed as often as not to the north.

The first World Cup put paid to that, in spite of French heroics in Sydney. The All Blacks not only won the final in a canter, they had got there by crushing the Welsh in a gallop. Things were not so easy in Europe four years later, but in the end it was Australia who emerged victorious, having themselves vanquished the defending champions in the semis.

In 1995 the tournament produced an epic final between the two most successful Test teams in history, South Africa halting the New Zealand juggernaut in extra time. It was their first appearance at the event, which they hosted. Australia prevailed again in 1999 before a northern hemisphere team finally got its hands on the cup – for the first and only time – in 2003.

It took arguably the greatest northern hemisphere team ever to achieve this feat, and it did so only with a Jonny Wilkinson drop goal in extra time. But nobody could deny England were deserved winners. They lifted the trophy in the southern hemisphere, after all, having edged host nation Australia in the final.

(David Davies / PA via AP, FILE)

Since then it has been all southern hemisphere with South Africa grabbing a second title and New Zealand two more. The All Blacks not only became the first three-time winners in 2015, they were also the first team to successfully defend the title.

The 2015 semi-finals were an all-southern hemisphere affair, and this occurred in Britain. In fact, if we compare match-ups between Rugby Championship teams and their Six Nations counterparts at the World Cup, the results are overwhelmingly in the former’s favour, with 54 wins to 16. Of the 24 head-to-head records, the north leads on only two counts – England and Wales against Argentina.

New Zealand have won 22 of 24 encounters with Six Nations teams, South Africa eight of nine, Australia 14 of 20 and Argentina eight of 15. Meanwhile, England have managed to win six of their 16 clashes with Rugby Championship teams, France four of 13, Wales three of 12, Ireland two of 10, Italy one of eight and Scotland none of 11.

Ireland have never reached the semi-finals, nor won a single play-off game at the tournament, having lost six quarter-finals and a repechage play-off in 1999. Italy are the lone tier-one nation never to have reached the quarter-finals, despite having played at every tournament. Fiji and Samoa have both reached that stage twice, while Canada have done so once – way back in 1991.

Canada and Japan are the only tier-two nations to have played at every World Cup. Japan had won just a single game prior to 2015 (against Zimbabwe in 1991), but became the first team to win three matches without reaching the quarter-finals when they stunned South Africa four years ago and followed up with wins over Samoa and the USA.

France, Australia and New Zealand are the only nations to have emerged from the group stages at every World Cup so far, while South Africa have done so since first qualifying in 1995. New Zealand are alone in having won all of their group stage matches, but that record will certainly come under threat when they face arch-foes South Africa in Japan.

(Photo by Anthony Au-Yeung/Getty Images)

New Zealand and France have met an incredible seven times at the World Cup (there have only been eight tournaments), while Australia has met both England and Wales six times each. There are no debutants for the second straight tournament, and in fact there have only been three since the turn of the century – Georgia, Portugal and Russia. First-time meetings will include Russia against Japan, Samoa and Scotland, Georgia against Australia, Wales and Fiji, South Africa against Italy and Argentina against the USA.

Tonga will have the most foreign-born players in their squad at this year’s World Cup with 17, followed by Japan and Samoa (16), Scotland (14) and Australia (12). Only the South Americans – Argentina and Uruguay – are 100% home-grown. New Zealand will be by far the main supplier, with a total of 43 Kiwis lining up for other national teams. Interesting birth places include Algeria, Azerbaijan, Korea, New Guinea and Germany.

Uruguay are the only tier-three team to have won a match at the tournament and have done so twice, beating Spain in 1999 and Georgia in 2003. Namibia have all the negative records with 19 straight losses, three last-place finishes, and the biggest defeat ever – 142-0 vs Australia in 2003. Their last tournament was their best, however, and produced their closest result – a one-point loss to Georgia. They will fancy their chances this year against struggling Canada, who had to qualify through the repechages.

Last but not least, Japan’s Wimpie van der Walt is perhaps an early front-runner for most unusual name of the tournament, although he faces strong competition from Samoan winger Belgium Tuatagaloa and kilted Kiwi Blade Thomson.

Team New Zealand (22-2) South Africa (8-1) Australia (14-6) Argentina (8-7)
England (6-9)
0-3 1-3 3-3 2-0
France (4-9)
2-5 0-1 1-1 1-2
Wales (3-10)
0-3 0-2 1-5 2-0
Scotland (0-11)
0-5 0-2 0-2 0-2
Ireland (2-8)
0-1 0-0 1-4 1-3
Italy (1-7)
0-5 0-0 0-1 1-1

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2019-09-10T18:46:21+00:00

Istanbul Wingman

Roar Guru


RWC best winning and worst losing streaks New Zealand: Winning 14, Losing 2 Australia: W 12, L 2 South Africa: W 11, L 2 England: W 8, L 2 France: W 6, L 3 Argentina: W 5, L 8 Wales: W 4, L 2 Ireland: W 4, L 3 Scotland: W 4, L 3 Italy: W 2, L 4 Canada: W 2, L 5 Samoa: W 2, L 5 Tonga: W 2, L 5 Fiji: W 2, L 6 Japan: W 2, L 13 Uruguay: W 1, L 5 Georgia: W 1, L 6 Romania: W 1, L 7 USA: W 1, L 10 Ivory Coast: W 0, L 3 Spain: W 0, L 3 Portugal: W 0, L 4 Russia: W 0, L 4 Zimbabwe: W 0, L 6 Namibia: W 0, L 19

2019-09-10T12:10:01+00:00

Tutema

Roar Rookie


Thanks Wingo!!!! very interesting reading (I love the stats pieces). Didn't realize that Argentina was above 50% against 6N countries. I did know that the 3 times Argentina beat Ireland it costed Ireland the qualification for the next fase (99 the knock off for QF, in 2007 Group Stage and in 2015 QF). Lets hope that Argentina's record against France incresases this year!!!!

2019-09-10T11:56:53+00:00

Sjngub

Guest


We might see a Springboks vs All blacks final (1995 rematch). Cant wait!!

AUTHOR

2019-09-10T10:11:16+00:00

Istanbul Wingman

Roar Guru


Rounding off the foreign-born players per squad: 5. USA – 13 Dylan Fawsitt (Ireland): Residency (2017) James Hilterbrand (Australia): Parent Paul Mullen (Ireland): Grandparent Greg Peterson (Australia): Parent Hanco Germishuys (South Africa): Residency (2007) Tony Lamborn (New Zealand): Parent John Quill (Ireland): Parent Shaun Davies (South Africa): Residency (2012) Ruben du Haas (South Africa): Residency (2012) Will Hooley (England): Grandparent AJ MacGinty (Ireland): Residency (2015) Will Magie (England): Parent Paul Lasike (New Zealand): Residency 2012

2019-09-10T05:44:31+00:00

piru

Roar Rookie


The Smaugh? I always felt that Australia played their final against NZ, I'll never forget the sinking feeling as that game went on and the NZ comeback just never materialised.

2019-09-09T20:36:32+00:00

rebel

Roar Guru


I've got no idea what you are babbling on about. You seem a little obsessed.

2019-09-09T17:40:23+00:00

FunBus

Roar Rookie


I’m off to have my dinner now, ‘rebel.’ It will probably be tomorrow before I read the site again. Try and find another ‘friend’ to keep you occupied. :laughing: :laughing:

2019-09-09T12:34:54+00:00

rebel

Roar Guru


Why so upset, I'm just doing what you have taught us all, pointing out your faults and insecurities. It's 'Fun' remember. You know, you're the 'Funbus' and I 'rebel' against faux intelligence and humour. Come on, we're a team. Do that one about the sat nav again, that was awesome. Soooooo funny. But that would only be about me, I know, make it about a whole country not being able to use sat nav. That's the wit your famous for.

2019-09-09T11:31:47+00:00

FunBus

Roar Rookie


I suppose, ‘rebel’, I should be flattered that you’re following me around the site like a needy puppy, but some might think it a little creepy. It’s certainly not very ‘rebellious.’ :laughing: :laughing:

2019-09-09T10:54:49+00:00

rebel

Roar Guru


Well done, I knew you had it in you. Have a biscuit.

2019-09-09T10:40:52+00:00

rebel

Roar Guru


Nearly there, still not up to your usual wit though. Think big, bring the 'Fun'

2019-09-09T10:32:05+00:00

Paulo

Roar Rookie


You should know not to take what is said on an online thread for how society as a whole feels or reacts. Forums are typically the most overtly loud and attention seeking whingers, when they are complaining that is, a lot of fair discussion can happen too. I'm on the Rugby Forum too, the UK one, and there is ALOT of self righteous whinging there too. Haka and Maori/Pacifika culture are quite separate from Rugby, but Rugby is a vehicle by which it gains the most global exposure. In England, there isn't really a comparable equivalent, but given the nature of colonization and the marginalization of indigenous peoples around the world, I'm sure you can appreciate the significance of Haka and what it means to have a globally recognized sporting team representing one facet of Maori culture. Most people who understand Haka don't get up in arms about how you want to react to it, twitch, twinge, dance, or pull a campo and kick the ball around your own posts. As for values, I think you may find the ABs have tried to emulate Kiwi values, as that is who they represent. Much like the Black Caps have done too. Or how the Silver Ferns did around Maria. Wouldn't you want a team that represents your own countries values? Its part of why NZ embraces the ABs so much, as they are seen as representing us. It certainly is a double edged sword though, as you are right, sometimes they do become too intrinsically linked.

2019-09-09T10:22:20+00:00

FunBus

Roar Rookie


Calm down 'rebel'. You're going to spontaneously combust. :laughing:

2019-09-09T10:17:49+00:00

rebel

Roar Guru


Oh no, Sadbus. Maybe I went too far. Quick generalise something, make something up, act superior, anything, we need the Fun back.

2019-09-09T09:55:32+00:00

FunBus

Roar Rookie


May well be something in that. I'm still struggling, though, to think of a comparable international example. The nearest might be the Brazilian football team, but I don't think even that compares. It's the narrative connection between the ABs and 'Kiwi values' and the cultural sensitivities around the Haka, for example, that take it to a level I don't think exists elsewhere. Partly, the media's to blame. Sometimes I have a read of sites like 'Stuff NZ', the articles and particularly the comment threads, and feel like I'm a fly on the wall of a group therapy session.

2019-09-09T09:48:01+00:00

FunBus

Roar Rookie


Yes, 'rebel' of course. :unhappy:

2019-09-09T09:39:42+00:00

rebel

Roar Guru


Wow, even emotions confuse you, no wonder you struggle with your mode of transport. Now sit around kiddies, today we are going to learn about laughing. :laughing: This is what we do when narcissists constantly trip up over their own narrative. :laughing:

2019-09-09T09:00:20+00:00

FunBus

Roar Rookie


I make that 14 from England, but no matter. The problem with these sort of stats (good research, by the way, though) is that they don't differentiate. 'Foreign-born' covers a multitude of life-stories and relative 'problems.' Sam Underhill, for example, is 'born in America.' True, but that was because his English RAF officer parents happened to be on a 3 year military tour of the US when he was born. They came home when the tour was over. That's as about as different from the Willi Heinz case as you can get.

2019-09-09T08:53:24+00:00

FunBus

Roar Rookie


Spot-on, Fionn. Eddie's got the choice of a really strong lineout, or playing two '7's'. He can't have both, because you need a fork-lift truck to lift Billy.

2019-09-09T08:50:39+00:00

FunBus

Roar Rookie


Temper, temper, 'rebel.'

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar