Typhoon Hagibis has everyone stirred up at the RWC

By Will Knight / Expert

Did anyone ask for Ben Skeen’s advice on whether they should cancel Rugby World Cup games this weekend because of the approaching typhoon?

What he’d propose would be as unpredictable as his TMO work at the tournament so far, but one thing is certain – he wouldn’t mind getting involved.

Skeen would make Mother Nature accountable. Don’t think that she can go throwing her weight around in the form of Typhoon Hagibis.

A Category 5 typhoon expected to deliver heavy rain and brutal winds of up to 270km/h and hitting Japan’s southern island of Honshu over the weekend?

He wouldn’t stand for that. Never mind that it’s what’s been happening for hundreds of years.

Leave it to Ben. He’ll fix it. Like Samu Kerevi had to pay the price for having the audacity to bump Rhys Patchell out of the way at Tokyo Stadium, Typhoon Hagibis needs to know it can’t be getting so aggressive.

Even though it is typhoon season in Japan, World Rugby’s announcement that two of Saturday’s Rugby World Cup games – England against France in Yokohama and New Zealand’s clash with Italy in Toyota City – had been cancelled because of the approaching typhoon was still stunning.

World Rugby called it “regrettable”, which was mild compared to the general feeling among fans exasperated that there’s no compromise from cancellation.

What about games shifted to the indoor stadiums? To prefectures that weren’t going to be badly affected by the typhoon? Hong Kong? World Rugby gambled that the six-week tournament wouldn’t be weather-hit, but they’ve lost.

It is the first time in World Cup history that a match has been cancelled.

Japan might qualify for the Rugby World Cup quarter-finals for the first time if their final pool match against Scotland in Yokohama on Sunday is scrapped. It feels like Typhoon Hagibis might have timed its run nicely to look after the host nation.

Japan players celebrate victory (WILLIAM WEST/AFP/Getty Images)

A pool-deciding abandonment would also feel like Karate Kid II, when the Okinawa storm stops the village-deciding showdown between Miyagi and Sato.

However, that did heap the pressure on Daniel-San, who had to duel with Sato’s fearsome nephew – a bit like what would happen if Japan lined up against the All Blacks in the quarters.

The typhoon, called “violent” by the Japan Meteorological Agency, will have a significant impact on the World Cup’s quarter-final permutations, with the cancelled games to be registered as scoreless draws.

England will progress as Pool C winners and they will almost certainly face Australia, whose match tonight against Georgia in Shizuoka – 200km southwest of Tokyo – will go ahead as scheduled.

A Wallabies win will ensure they finish runner-up in Pool D, as long as Wales knock over Uruguay. Even a cancellation there would result in the Welsh topping the pool.

Then we’d have the Wallabies to face England and France to tackle Wales.

So how has the typhoon affected the Wallabies?

It was very likely that Australia, following their loss to Wales, would take on England anyway as Eddie Jones’s team would’ve probably been too strong for Les Bleus.

(Photo by Mark Kolbe/Getty Images)

Are England underdone, or is fresher better compared to the Wallabies?

In the pool of death that was meant to push them hard – drain them – they’ve only really been tested by a 14-man Argentina. Tonga and the United States weren’t too arduous.

So the way it’s panned out, and through no fault of their own, England have gone from facing one of the tougher draws to sitting pretty with one of the easiest.

England are leaving Tokyo for Miyazaki on the southern island of Kyushu to avoid Typhoon Hagibis.

Miyazaki hosted England’s pre-tournament training camp. It’s also not far from Oita, where their quarter-final is scheduled to be played next week.

“We’ll have a short camp in Miyazaki and then we’re off to Oita,” Jones said yesterday.

“We have an exceptional record in two-week preparations.”

Selection-wise, England seem pretty well settled so they probably didn’t need another game to make those calls.

They seem set on starting George Ford at flyhalf, moving Owen Farrell to No.12. Their back-row of Sam Underhill, Billy Vunipola and Tom Curry looks set. Jamie George looks to have beaten Luke Cowan-Dickie as hooker. If anything they would’ve liked to get more minutes into Mako Vunipola and Jack Nowell, who have only recently returned from injuries.

Meanwhile, the Wallabies will get to play all four pool games as they continue to search for the right combinations and discover the rhythm missing in their attack so far.

One thing they will want to improve against Georgia is their starts, which have been especially sluggish against Fiji and Wales. Their ball control was poor early and their defence clumsy.

Matt Toomua gets an opportunity to seal the No.10 jersey for the quarter-finals. It’s deflating that it’s taken this long to settle on the key playmaking spot, while Nic White gets the nod at scrumhalf.

Of significant interest will be the balance of the back-row with Michael Hooper being rested – or whatever “general soreness” means – and David Pocock starting at openside flanker in a back-row alongside Jack Dempsey and Isi Naisarani.

There’s the chance that the sight of Pocock back in the No.7 jersey for the first time in a long time might stir thoughts that the relatively lightweight Hooper isn’t the right fit to face England.

David Pocock of the Wallabies (Photo by Jason McCawley/Getty Images)

Rory Arnold has been below his best so far – a far cry from his Bledisloe form. He could do with some more carries and more pace around the field.

In fact, the burly Georgian forwards will provide a decent hit-out for the Wallabies as their biggest frailty against England will be facing their powerful pack.

The Wallabies need the workout and need the opportunity to build more cohesion and urgency. The worry is that given the microscope by match officials on collisions so far at this World Cup and the inconsistencies and delays that make viewing often infuriating, one more game means a chance to get red carded or cited with the knockout stages about to start.

Tolu Latu, Kerevi, Dempsey and Arnold are the ones that might need to temper their aggression against Georgia to ensure they are available next week. At least Ben Skeen isn’t the TMO.

The Crowd Says:

2019-10-12T12:46:58+00:00

Nick

Roar Guru


They had control over their own performance against Ireland, and it was shocking. Face it, Japan have turned up for their three games, Scotland haven't. At full time they looked as if they were ok with conceding 1st place to avoid NZ down the line. Then Ireland lost to Japan and blew the group open. All teams knew typhoon season coincided with the RWC. The smart strategy was to win.

2019-10-12T04:40:18+00:00

jcmasher

Roar Rookie


Yeah maybe but I said I’m pretty comfortable making it. France do have a habit of pulling something out of the bag at a RWC but this year I thought they’ve looked pretty ordinary to be honest and I’m not sure they could have done it. If they could have then no reason why they can’t in their first qtr final match, if they can’t do it for that match then they probably wouldn’t have been able to do it for this one

2019-10-12T03:23:53+00:00

GWSingapore

Guest


Why weren't the canceled games played the day before? The teams and officials would have already been in the locations. The stadia ready for the next day. The organizers had time because they canceled the games 56 hours ahead.

2019-10-11T23:33:52+00:00

Davico

Roar Pro


Your comparing Cricket and Rugby being played due to weather? That will do me

2019-10-11T23:29:23+00:00

Davico

Roar Pro


So what if Jpn v Ire of been the last game and Sco had beaten Jpn earlier? If it was Jpn that would go out would you be saying the same thing? And Sergio is right when he says if NZ needed the points the game would be played. Hansen's head would have exploded by now!

2019-10-11T23:14:08+00:00

Davico

Roar Pro


If you believe what World Rugby says then I am sure you are also a true believer in the ICC??!! :laughing:

2019-10-11T23:14:02+00:00

Ken Catchpole's Other Leg

Roar Guru


In service of consistency the cyclone has been renamed ‘Joubert’.

2019-10-11T23:10:00+00:00

Davico

Roar Pro


Sorry so the Scots had control of the Japan performance against Ireland did they??

2019-10-11T23:09:06+00:00

Davico

Roar Pro


I think that's a pretty arrogant statement considering England's injuries.

2019-10-11T23:05:53+00:00

Davico

Roar Pro


Surely a 4 or 5 day turnaround is better than not giving someone an opportunity no matter how remote that may have been. Now we are going to have some teams playing on 14 days vs 7 days. Is that fair???

2019-10-11T09:54:02+00:00

ChuckP

Roar Rookie


Nz herald republishing telegraph nonsense.

2019-10-11T09:51:11+00:00

ChuckP

Roar Rookie


McCaw is God.

2019-10-11T09:47:11+00:00

ChuckP

Roar Rookie


Yeah. Because Scotland were definitely going to win it :laughing: :laughing: :laughing:

2019-10-11T08:49:33+00:00

Nick

Roar Guru


He controls the weather from an offside position

2019-10-11T08:48:58+00:00

Nick

Roar Guru


It will be a shame, but the Scots can only blame themselves. Japan played a blunder against Ireland, while Scotland against the same opposition were utterly insipid.

2019-10-11T07:46:08+00:00

Double Agent

Guest


Pfffft....Russia played two games in three days. 5 day turnarounds are for weak western imperialist sissy boys. .

2019-10-11T07:16:00+00:00

RugbyLover

Roar Rookie


This is getting out of hand. The same things were spouted about the cricket WC in England. More games were cancelled in that WC than in ALL the World Cups previously put together. Did they have the ability to move games? No - same issues with venues, fans, broadcasts, etc etc. Did it impact on my enjoyment? Not at all. It was still good to watch. And people saying the two cancelled games here are unfair.... unfair to whom? The true fans only get to see 46 games now instead of 48? Give me a break. IF the Jap-Scotland game is cancelled as well I feel for the Scots but in reality they are in the position they are in becasue of previous games they lost - not because of this game being cancelled. They only have a slim chance of making the 1/4s. They have to win and they have to win by more than 7 points. Japan will go through even if they lose - as long as it is by less than 7 points. Where is your money?

2019-10-11T06:53:13+00:00

RugbyLover

Roar Rookie


and typhoons like all weather dont follow the path they are meant to... could go anywhere or end up being nothing

2019-10-11T06:51:32+00:00

RugbyLover

Roar Rookie


Exactly.. McCaw is God's man and Skeene belongs to the devil...

2019-10-11T06:29:19+00:00

MikeJ

Roar Rookie


Scotland gonna fight tooth and nails to make that match happen. They already talking about taking legal action against World Rugby if the match is cancelled completely. Any other team in a similar situation would've done the same. That match with Japan is 50/50 to me. I can see Scotland beat Japan, and advanced over them. Scotland aint gonna back down, they are going all the way to make this match happen, one way or another. This World Cup dramas keeps coming..

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar