Australia to face the best Kiwi XI ever to tour the country

By Nick / Roar Guru

It is almost a cliche to say it, but New Zealand will really never have a better chance to beat Australia when they start their three-Test tour of the country next week.

Yes, people said this last time they came over and the time before that too – when, in fairness, they drew the series. But this time, they really will never have had a better chance.

No matter what version of Australia you get – the kind that hit 600 against Pakistan or the kind that get bowled out for double figures against South Africa – winning a series in Australia is one of the great prizes of Test cricket. The Black Caps covet this more than anywhere else.

New Zealand are riding the crest of a wave of a golden generation of talent. For once they don’t have just one elite player in the batting or bowling order on whom they pin all their hopes and dreams; this time they have several elite players across multiple positions in the starting XI.

And that’s before you mention Kane Williamson, who is a couple of steps above elite. He’s a rightly vaunted member of the big three – formerly the fab four when Joe Root was in form. The man will eventually own nearly every batting record a Kiwi can own. He owns most already.

We’ll get a bit more on Williamson later. Let’s start at the top.

Tom Latham
This man is a contender to slot into one of the World XI openers slots for 2019, with three centuries and a 65 average to show for the year. He has previously battled against Australia in the past, but he was a young man then. At 27 he’s entering the most productive years of a batsman. Expect him to be able to play against the Australians more confidently this time. He doesn’t match David Warner, but he would be a solid match-up against Joe Burns.

(Photo by Gareth Copley/Getty Images)

Jeetan Ravel
Ravel is New Zealand’s other opener. Frankly, he’s not in form, and even when in form he’s probably not up to this challenge. He’s the chink the chain at the moment. Sadly there’s no other top-order option busting to get into the side either. New Zealand will be hoping beyond hope that he can just stick around long enough to take some shine off the new ball before Kane Williamson comes in.

Kane Williamson
Speaking of Williamson, he’s the prized wicket and the start of a very strong middle order. He’s the one Australia will concentrate most of their firepower on. Absurdly gifted, he’s not as run-hungry as Steve Smith, he’s not as visibly passionate as Virat Kohli, but he makes up for that by supreme discipline and technique. He’s unflappably calm.

(AP Photo/Tertius Pickard)

Of the three he’s aesthetically the most gorgeous player to watch. He’s also got a great record away from home. He’s hit a century against all teams. He’s hit a century everywhere except South Africa – and more chances will come to do that. He’s confident on all pitches. If New Zealand are to win the series, he’ll need to hit a big score in at least one match. Back him in to do it.

Ross Taylor
Elite. Class. This will likely be his last tour of Australia. He more than most will be desperate to fly home with the trophy. While it’s not the WACA, he’ll be happy to start in Perth. He flogged 290 chanceless runs last time and was able to turn the final day of the English series into a training run, chalking up a cheeky ton to boost his confidence across the Tasman.

Henry Nicholls
When he’s in form he’s very good. He’s better than the No. 5 options for Australia. He was quiet against England, but Australia need to keep an eye on him.

BJ Watling
Enter into a staring contest with this man at your own peril. He is the shoo-in pick for the World XI keeper position this year. A keeper-batsman or a batsman-keeper, it doesn’t matter – he’s good at both. He bats at No. 6 but could comfortably bat higher. I can think of no-one in world cricket who values his wicket so highly. He won’t give it away, and it will take a good piece of bowling to get him out.

(AP Photo/Kamran Jebreili)

Colin de Grandhomme
A quality all-rounder, De Grandhomme was part of a triumvirate that turned it around in the first Test against England. Spirited with the ball. He will try his best. He probably won’t be able to dislodge the wickets of a Dave Warner or Steve Smith, but he’ll make runs hard to come by for others.

Mitchell Santner
He’s not the greatest spinner out there. Serviceable would be the best word for him – Nathan Lyon is clearly the better spinner – but the century he scored against England was not a surprise to those who have followed him. He can bat. It was only a matter of time until he got one. He’ll get more. Unlike Pakistan, where the tail began at No. 8, Santner is the continuation of a strong lower-middle order. He will provide valuable lower-order runs.

Tim Southee
When he’s on song he’s a quality bowler. He can be a little like Mitchell Starc in that he goes through some unplayable moments, but he can also bowl some tripe. For New Zealand to win he needs to be in unplayable mode. But that’s not to diminish his abilities – he’s a world-class paceman and has been for a while. Like Mitchell Starc, he can also hit some lusty lower-order sixes. Lots of them. He hits so many there’s no other current international cricketer who’s hit more in Test cricket.

Trent Boult
Elite. He’s part of a bowling attack that is much like Australia’s. One of a triumvirate. He can bowl a lethal swinging delivery. He’s consistent. He probably sits behind Richard Hadlee and Shane Bond as New Zealand’s best fast bowler. Elite company. Only now does the tail begin. New Zealand will be hoping he can recover from his injury in time for the first Test. He’ll be needed for all three if New Zealand are to win.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Neil Wagner
Wagner was late to Test cricket, and even when he made his debut he took a while to get into it. But he’s now in terrific form, with 13 wickets across two Tests against England. He never gives up and shows tremendous spirit no matter what the score. He’s world No. 3 for good reason. The last player of this dynamic pace trio.

Except position 1, that is a world-class Test XI. That is a Test XI you take to Australia to win.

In the past a New Zealand team would have a dusting of talent. A Richard Hadlee, Martin Crowe, Stephen Fleming, Daniel Vettori, Shane Bond, Brendon McCullum or Chris Cairns. New Zealand also didn’t have much luck. Cairns missed more Tests than he played, Shane Bond’s frame just couldn’t cope with his talent, Hadlee was a lone voice for a long time, ditto Crowe. Fleming and Vettori held teams together through sheer grit, McCullum through sheer spirit.

But New Zealand have struck gold this time. Latham, Williamson, Taylor, Watling, Southee and Boult are world-class and in the same team. Wagner, De Grandhomme and Nicholls would be prize selections in almost all international teams too.

On balance Australia probably just edge New Zealand out in the openers department, and largely due to Warner’s return to Australian pitches. New Zealand have the edge over Australia in the middle order. Marnus Labuschagne is quality, but Williamson is something else. Smith obviously has top billing ahead of Taylor in position 4. Nicholls is a better cricketer than Travis Head. Watling is not a flamboyant as Matthew Wade, but he’s so much more dependable. De Grandhomme probably just edges ahead of Tim Paine in position 7.

Among the bowlers Nathan Lyon is better than Santner, but Santner provides valuable lower-order runs. The pace batteries of both teams will be exciting to watch. All are in good form and all a smart bowlers. I’d say because it’s being played in Australia, Mitchell Starc-Patrick Cummins-Josh Hazlewood have the nod over Southee-Boult-Wagner. If it were being played in NZ, I’d say the reverse.

This is a golden generation without compare in New Zealand cricket. But it’s a once-in-a-generation alignment. New Zealand cricket doesn’t have a production line of talent like Australia does. There’s rare depth, but it won’t last. This is like the Socceroos in 2006-10, when over half the starting XI were from top-tier European league clubs.

I can’t wait.

The Crowd Says:

2020-01-02T04:12:41+00:00

Dunning Kruger

Roar Rookie


Gee this didn't age well, and not many are surprised.

2019-12-08T22:02:45+00:00

JamesH

Roar Guru


I can't see de Grandhomme being a big wicket taker here. I think his value will lie in tying down an end to allow them to rotate the quicks at the other.

2019-12-08T08:59:09+00:00

Republican

Guest


NZ batting will be far more diuscipled and consistent than ours. We tend to rely on one or two big innings from a player ie Smith in that respect. We will again depend massively on our bowlers and hope fo some exceptional fielding, to ensure a competitive series ensues. NZ I believe, will take the spoils with relative ease.

2019-12-08T03:55:32+00:00

Gurlivleen Grewal

Roar Pro


To be honest, I am not worried about their batting. Batting units with similar attitude and skills have done well against this trio - patience and to make them bowl with the second new ball with only 4-5 wickets down will test their resolve. And if history is any prediction - Starc especially struggles. One bowler down in a 4 man attack will take its toll with back to back tests like it did vs India. But all that comes to naught if the bowlers don't back it up. If a team is fielding 130+ overs on average then the batsmen will also struggle. Here I think will face their sternest test.

2019-12-08T02:25:54+00:00

fabian gulino

Roar Rookie


aust vs nz a should very tight series.

2019-12-07T23:40:03+00:00

Geoff from Bruce Stadium

Roar Rookie


When was the last time Grandhomme bowled in Australia? Its already been a hot dry Spring in Australia and Summer won't be any different. I have a feeling that the Kiwi bowlers may really struggle.

2019-12-07T23:29:59+00:00

Geoff from Bruce Stadium

Roar Rookie


Can't see the Kiwi bowlers matching the Aussies though spruce

2019-12-07T23:24:05+00:00

Geoff from Bruce Stadium

Roar Rookie


My thoughts as well GG. Boult and Southee are very good when the conditions suit but if there is less in the wicket I think the Aussie fast bowlers will get more out of it. Lachie Ferguson could be their surprise packet for the Kiwis. I think you need more speed to make the most of conditions in Australia. Will be interesting to see how the NZ batsman handle the three Aussie quicks who have made the England and Pakistan batsmen look pretty average in the past 6 months. Plus Lyon looks as though he has his mojo back. Latham, Williamson, Taylor and Watling have performed very well in NZ but this will be a sterner test.

2019-12-07T04:16:35+00:00

Simoc

Guest


As an ex Kiwi I don't fancy their chances at all. Mostly they do well everywhere but Australia. I reckon the in form Mitchell Starc is to good for the NZ top order bar Williamson. But they will do better than Pakistan and it's great to finally see NZ get Boxing Day / New Years test rather than being sent to Darwin or Townsville. Like Sendind the Bledisloe Cup to Stewart Island or Wellington.

2019-12-05T12:20:29+00:00

ojp

Guest


Can we 'claim' Clarrie Grimmett as the NZ spinner... ?

2019-12-05T12:15:46+00:00

Bobbo7

Guest


Totally agree re the spinner. Vettori was more a great all round player than a super spin bowler. I saw in the recent NZ series that only 1 out of the last 101 Test wickets in NZ Tests had been from a spinner. Speaks volumes about spin in NZ.

2019-12-05T10:43:12+00:00

Nudge

Roar Rookie


That’s him, thanks Targa

2019-12-05T08:57:52+00:00

Tight-Head

Roar Rookie


Interestingly, on ICC player rankings both Cummins and starc are better all rounders than de Grandhomme – they sit 7th and 6th in the world when it comes to all rounders, and give the Aussie tail plenty of wag. Especially with Pattinson in reserve.

2019-12-05T08:56:21+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


Well sure Targa, that wouldn't surprise me since this is the weakest generation of aussie batsmen I've personally seen. There's been a major slump in quality batsmen here for a few years which is widely acknowledged.

2019-12-05T08:51:57+00:00

Targa

Roar Rookie


Hamish (son of Ken) Rutherford. Scored 170 on debut vs England but is a bit loose outside off stump. Might get a recall vs India in March as has done well in English county cricket in the last couple of seasons.

2019-12-05T08:49:46+00:00

Targa

Roar Rookie


I'd have 4 of the current side in an all time NZ XI: Dempster Turner WILLIAMSON Crowe TAYLOR WATLING (wk) Cairns Vettori Hadlee WAGNER Bond/Cowie (hard choice) I would pick Wagner ahead of Boult as there are already lots of new ball bowlers, but need an old ball bowler. Latham needs to do more to be picked ahead of Dempster and Turner.

2019-12-05T07:02:23+00:00

Nudge

Roar Rookie


Don’t New Zealand have another opener who’s Dad has played test cricket for the kiwis as well? I thought he was going to be good but haven’t seen him in a New Zealand team for a year or two. Can anyone help?

2019-12-05T06:55:46+00:00

Nudge

Guest


Isn’t their another guy who has opened for New Zealand, who’s father had also played test cricket? I thought he was going to be good, but haven’t seen him around for a year or two. Just can’t think of who it is if anyone can help ?

2019-12-05T05:41:15+00:00

Targa

Roar Rookie


You wrote: "I don’t see why that offends you? Southee & Wagner would struggle to make Shield teams here as they lack variety and would get found out pretty quick in a tough competition where fast bowling is often difficult. If the conditions aren’t conducive to swing then Southee is a sitting duck." Tbh, Wade, Head and Paine would struggle to make Plunket Shield teams in NZ as we have lots of decent middle order bats and wicketkeepers.

2019-12-05T04:48:52+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


And CDG is essentially a carbon copy of Southee: a fast-medium swing bowler with not a great amount of variety of deliveries to trouble batsman. On flat aussie wickets with a dead kookaburra that's not swinging or seaming he's completely lost his edge.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar