Has anyone asked Markus Babbel if he's okay?

By Stuart Thomas / Expert

When a tweet announcing the Western Sydney Wanderers’ intention to part ways with Markus Babbel appeared on Sunday night the worst kept secret in the A-League was well and truly let out of the bag.

The 47-year-old German was subsequently told he was surplus to requirements somewhere between the Wanderers 1-0 loss to Perth Glory and the official announcement that followed early Monday morning.

Frankly, the club had little other possible course of action without appearing to be sitting on its hands and doing nothing about what is fast becoming another wasted season.

The Western Sydney Wanderers exploded into the A-League in 2012, became a force and won an Asian Champions League title soon after. This perhaps set a benchmark that fuels much of the current dissatisfaction and disappointment felt by fans of the red and black.

(Nigel Owen/Action Plus via Getty Images)

In short, the Wanderers were too good too quickly. Sadly, the loyal fans’ passion and attendance has waned since 2015-16 after a third grand final loss.

Through no fault of their own, the Wanderers lost their foundation coach Tony Popovic as well as a stadium that had served them well through the early years, and they experienced the always problematic challenge of finding the right man to take the reins as manager.

What the club that refers to itself as the ‘pride of Western Sydney’ was able to do in those years was build something special, something we had arguably never seen in Australian domestic football previously.

Now, midway through the 2019-20 A-League season and with the challenge of finding a short-term managerial solution to mount a still more than realistic charge at the top six, the team appears on the brink of implosion.

The season began with three straight wins, a derby triumph over their greatest foe and a draw in Round 4 against the Roar. Since then the Wanderers have won just once, a 3-2 victory in Adelaide, and the ladder tells the full story.

First to ninth is a dramatic capitulation, and Babbel has taken the majority of the blame square in the face. A winning percentage of 29 will do that to a coach, and when all is said and done the German lasted just a year and a half in the top job at Western Sydney, having lost matches far more often than he’d won them.

I hope he is okay.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Professional life dishes out its fair share of humiliating blows to us all. I’ve lived it and so have you. However, managing a football team that lacks the quality needed to appease those who employed you and deliver the wins and trophies that the fans demand could be the most difficult job of all.

For every Alex Ferguson, Jose Mourinho, Jurgen Klopp or Pep Guardiola – men given the tools and resources required to turn potential into success – there are hundreds of Markus Babbels attempting to craft quality artefacts from materials just not up to the required standard.

In his mid-40s Babbel took a leap of faith and travelled more than half way around the world to manage a struggling team in a B-grade league. That is what both footballers and managers do in order to stay involved in the game they love.

It is a recipe for emotional turmoil, loneliness and doubt bred of communication and cultural issues that must be incredibly difficult to overcome for anyone other than the most resilient of characters.

Sadly, any credit accumulated by a manager thanks to a well-respected and long playing career at the highest level dries up pretty quickly when results turn against them. Babbel had 355 games in the bank before stepping into a managerial role.

No doubt he has enjoyed many top moments during his five-club, 13-year career. However, a tear or two would most likely have been shed late last night, with a three-year deal torn up and an indecisive future his immediate reality.

If rumour does become fact in Newcastle and an announcement on Ernie Merrick’s successor is imminent, Babbel will be out of the loop for an A-League coaching gig in the short term. In fact it would be fair to suggest that nine clubs are actually quite pleased with their current mentor.

Whether he heads home, takes on an assistant role or walks away from the game entirely is his call, but here’s hoping that Markus Babbel’s entire Down Under experience does not become a permanent scar.

Watching his downfall over the last few months has urged me to always remember that the machine of world football consists mostly of talented, well-meaning and decent people, some of whom succeed but many of whom receive the sack when their performance demands it.

The Crowd Says:

2020-01-22T03:37:15+00:00

Nick Symonds

Guest


Almost sounds like the scene from The Life Of Brian. - FRANCIS: "Whatever happened to the popular front, Reg?" REG: "He's over there." - I take it the Blacktown City active support group is a new one then.

2020-01-21T22:08:13+00:00

AndyAdelaide

Roar Rookie


would not be surprised to see him take on some technical role with bayern munich, they tend to look after there former players nicely

2020-01-21T09:01:37+00:00

pacman

Roar Rookie


We definitely do not know the full story Stu, but it would appear the dressing room was unhappy. The reasons?

AUTHOR

2020-01-21T08:17:22+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


I'm in the process of applying for membership of the Blacktown City active support group. It has one member and I hope to be the second for this season.

AUTHOR

2020-01-21T08:15:50+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


I socialise with four distinctively German people and they are dear friends with a sense of decorum and class that I really appreciate. They cook a mean wiener schnitzel and kindly enjoy a gluten free beer with me out of social kindness. A lovely country, as we all know, and wonderful people.

2020-01-21T07:59:42+00:00

Lionheart

Roar Rookie


Germans are all class Stuart. We could do with more of them in our game.

2020-01-21T07:58:47+00:00

Lionheart

Roar Rookie


indeed, can't say the Penrith or Blacktown lads having any affiliation whatsoever with Macarthur. It'd be almost as bad as SFC for them.

2020-01-21T05:59:30+00:00

Redondo

Roar Rookie


At the very least, Babbel will need to leak details somehow or he'll struggle to get his next decent-paying coaching job.

2020-01-21T04:36:07+00:00

HR

Roar Rookie


It has also gone from a 35 match season to a 61 match season over that time, so average attendance isn’t necessarily a perfect indicator (there are probably a lot of families that will go to a few matches a season, regardless of how many matches are actually being played). The fixture also means that there are some matches played at less-than-ideal times for attendance (the two midweek afternoon matches in Adelaide were 10K down in attendance compared to a comparable weekend afternoon match, for example).

2020-01-21T04:23:33+00:00

AndyAdelaide

Roar Rookie


hey don’t get me wrong Stu, i liked babbel as a player and he has good personality/charisma as a coach. Australia is just such a hard place to come to as a European coach, because you cant buy your way out of trouble ( i actually think he would’ve done well with a small club that responds well to that style of coaching, adelaide for example). I’m always very interested when ‘passionate’ coaches get the sack. Im still waiting for mourinho to launch about man utd, im assuming his NDA is a lot longer than babbles though with a few extra zeros on the severance pay lol

AUTHOR

2020-01-21T04:22:56+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Interesting angle but I'd like to think Wanderland is a little more loyal than that.

AUTHOR

2020-01-21T04:21:54+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Sacking a coach extends the tenure of a board each and every time it happens. They will talk of new beginnings, directions and opportunities. Many of the fans will believe it and sadly, at some clubs, the cycle continues. Hopefully the Wanderers get things right now.

AUTHOR

2020-01-21T04:20:06+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Cheers Mid, as a Bulldog myself, it is sad to see Tim really struggling. One of the greats of the club and a decent man to boot.

AUTHOR

2020-01-21T04:18:21+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


By the sounds of things he really loves the country. Wouldn't surprise to see him pop up on FOX and do something similar to what Muscat did a few months back. I really enjoyed his tactical commentary.

AUTHOR

2020-01-21T04:16:27+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


I keep these stats every year, have already tossed it in to a piece or two and will be doing so again as the season draws to a close.

AUTHOR

2020-01-21T04:15:43+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Agreed Chris.

AUTHOR

2020-01-21T04:15:02+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Be interesting to collate those 50/50's that really cost them over the last 18 months. There were some appalling decisions.

AUTHOR

2020-01-21T04:14:05+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


I agree. Given the right tools, he may well be able to succeed elsewhere. His manner and experience suggest that quite strongly.

AUTHOR

2020-01-21T04:12:13+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Will his class prevent him from doing that? I'm not sure. He really showed some with his final words.

AUTHOR

2020-01-21T04:11:24+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Thanks Johan, I always ask the fundamental question when a club is struggling. "Why are the Western Sydney Wanderers not playing well? The answer would be a list containing a number of things. Babbel may well have been able to improve his performance as mentor, but sacking him dumps far too much of the blame on one person in my view. Then again, do we know the full story?

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar